Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed up of the phrase 'net contributor'

246 replies

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

OP posts:
topcat2014 · 29/10/2026 13:37

I could have made a similar point during Covid when the entire public sector were "key workers". What were the rest of us supposed to feel like? Scum?

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 29/10/2026 13:38

Thesillysocks · 29/10/2026 13:10

Could our society work if suddenly all the non-net contributors went away? I’m pretty sure it could, either by paying people more to be nurses / teachers / shelves stackers etc or even by attracting people from other countries to do these jobs.
Could our society work if suddenly all the net contributors went away? I don’t see how it could, no salary for teachers / nurses, not even money to keep schools and hospitals open, no police force…

I have used the term net contributor before, usually when people express hatred for high earners but refuse to acknowledge that they benefit from them. Or when people argue that « they pay taxes » without acknowledging that the amount they pay is less than the one they receive.

I don’t think our society could work at all if you took all the non-net-contributors away. Wealth isn’t generated in a vacuum. High earners can only generate their revenues because of the infrastructure built and maintained by everyone else. A CEO can’t generate revenue if there are no roads for their goods, no warehouse staff to pack boxes, no cleaners to clean their offices, no police force to protect their property, no teachers to educate their future workforce, no health care to keep their workers well etc etc etc. The two are interdependent - that’s why it’s such a reductive and unhelpful term.

CraftySquirrel · 29/10/2026 13:38

Come on OP, you’re really reaching with this post. I have never, on here or IRL, heard anyone say that the lives of net contributors are worth more than the lives of others or that they are morally superior. The cold hard reality however is that a relatively small proportion of high earners in the UK pay disproportionately for the majority to enjoy a multitude of benefits that otherwise wouldn’t exist somewhere with a low or flat tax rate and there is nothing wrong with acknowledging that.

Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 13:39

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 13:29

It makes me kind of sick to see people placing value on a human life purely by what they contribute economically

Oh sorry, what I mean is, give me more benefits please I want to spend all the rich people's money on lip filler

Its not placing a value judgement on someone's life, it is a broad economic average of where the crossover point is. Whatever term you use, people will be offended. Look at BMI debates on here. The gymnastics people use about rugby players etc. to dodge that truth that they are obese. Neither makes you worthless or inferior, but on average if your BMI is over 30 you are obese, and if you earn less than £45k, economically, you take from society more than you give.

randomchap · 29/10/2026 13:41

Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 13:39

Its not placing a value judgement on someone's life, it is a broad economic average of where the crossover point is. Whatever term you use, people will be offended. Look at BMI debates on here. The gymnastics people use about rugby players etc. to dodge that truth that they are obese. Neither makes you worthless or inferior, but on average if your BMI is over 30 you are obese, and if you earn less than £45k, economically, you take from society more than you give.

Take more from society?

So a carer who saves the state thousands in care fees takes from society? A nurse takes from society?

Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 13:46

randomchap · 29/10/2026 13:41

Take more from society?

So a carer who saves the state thousands in care fees takes from society? A nurse takes from society?

Its a broad economic definition. You're doing the equivalent of yapping on about rugby players and body builders to discredit BMI.

Take emotion out it. If you earn less than £45k, broadly, on average, you will take more from the state than you give.

No amount of cuddles and carer rainbows and pixie dust change the economics in broad terms.

Livinglavidaloco · 29/10/2026 13:46

Why can't you value the role of both? You've emphasised the value of public services on this thread but fail to recognise that without contribution those roles are cut. Why can't you value both?

randomchap · 29/10/2026 13:51

Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 13:46

Its a broad economic definition. You're doing the equivalent of yapping on about rugby players and body builders to discredit BMI.

Take emotion out it. If you earn less than £45k, broadly, on average, you will take more from the state than you give.

No amount of cuddles and carer rainbows and pixie dust change the economics in broad terms.

The economic value of someone's labour does not necessarily translate into how much they are paid.

The example of the unpaid carer is a good one. They save the state thousands, and contribute to the economy that way

How much you get paid does not determine how important you are to the economy

CraftySquirrel · 29/10/2026 13:51

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 29/10/2026 13:38

I don’t think our society could work at all if you took all the non-net-contributors away. Wealth isn’t generated in a vacuum. High earners can only generate their revenues because of the infrastructure built and maintained by everyone else. A CEO can’t generate revenue if there are no roads for their goods, no warehouse staff to pack boxes, no cleaners to clean their offices, no police force to protect their property, no teachers to educate their future workforce, no health care to keep their workers well etc etc etc. The two are interdependent - that’s why it’s such a reductive and unhelpful term.

Have you never heard of flat, or less progressive, tax systems? It obviously can work, not by eliminating all the people doing low paid jobs but by flattening the tax rate so everyone is paying the same regardless of income. The difference is you won’t have the huge benefits safety net that exists in the UK, so people who have the option of not working now would need to work. There are winners and losers in such a system, just as there are in the UK’s current system.

Lhori · 29/10/2026 13:53

I think it is partly to combat the constant narrative about free healthcare, free education and the government paying for things.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 29/10/2026 14:03

CraftySquirrel · 29/10/2026 13:51

Have you never heard of flat, or less progressive, tax systems? It obviously can work, not by eliminating all the people doing low paid jobs but by flattening the tax rate so everyone is paying the same regardless of income. The difference is you won’t have the huge benefits safety net that exists in the UK, so people who have the option of not working now would need to work. There are winners and losers in such a system, just as there are in the UK’s current system.

Of course I’ve heard of flat tax systems. But even if you significantly shrink the welfare safety net, and have everyone paying flat taxes you still don’t create a system where everyone contributes the same financially - you still have children and the elderly, whose education and care needs to be provided, and you still have unpaid carers looking after them so that others can make money. Whatever the tax system, net contributors and non net contributors remain reliant on each other. Which is why, to me, whatever the tax system, the term remains reductive and overly simplistic.

Everanewbie · 29/10/2026 14:05

randomchap · 29/10/2026 13:51

The economic value of someone's labour does not necessarily translate into how much they are paid.

The example of the unpaid carer is a good one. They save the state thousands, and contribute to the economy that way

How much you get paid does not determine how important you are to the economy

This phrase is not that deep. It references a tipping point from where what you contribute exceeds what you take, on average.

Carers etc. do a job I couldn't do and I respect their contribution. But if they are an average person, they are statistically likely to take more than they give in terms of tax and spending. That doesn't mean that I think they are unworthy of anything, or should be looked down upon.

A single, healthy person with no kids, no benefits of any kind earning £35k may well be a net contributor, likewise an unhealthy person earning £85k a year with 5 kids, all needing some ongoing care and/or benefits plus state education etc. may is likely to be a net drain. We're talking averages here, and c,£45k is the crossover. I'll hug a carer on the way home if it makes the economics more palatable for you.

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 29/10/2026 14:08

CraftySquirrel · 29/10/2026 13:38

Come on OP, you’re really reaching with this post. I have never, on here or IRL, heard anyone say that the lives of net contributors are worth more than the lives of others or that they are morally superior. The cold hard reality however is that a relatively small proportion of high earners in the UK pay disproportionately for the majority to enjoy a multitude of benefits that otherwise wouldn’t exist somewhere with a low or flat tax rate and there is nothing wrong with acknowledging that.

Sorry, but if you go on any thread on here about disabilities and/or benefits, they reek with assumptions about the value of people who are disadvantaged and/or disabled. Ditto frequent references on news programmes about economic activity and contribution. Granted discussions in real life are not quite as, err, robust as they tend to be online (thankfully!).

Havanananana · 29/10/2026 14:11

@CraftySquirrel "Come on OP, you’re really reaching with this post. I have never, on here or IRL, heard anyone say that the lives of net contributors are worth more than the lives of others or that they are morally superior."

It is a constant theme in the right-wing media. People on benefits are variously described as "takers" and "scroungers" and other less palatable terms, the implication being that they are less valuable to society than the so-called "net contributors" and so by definition, these "net contributors" are being portrayed as being superior.

"The cold hard reality however is that a relatively small proportion of high earners in the UK pay disproportionately for the majority to enjoy a multitude of benefits that otherwise wouldn’t exist somewhere with a low or flat tax rate and there is nothing wrong with acknowledging that."

Why use the term "disproportionally?" High earners pay according to a progressive taxation system that is similar to tax systems across the western world. Far from being taxed disproportionally, high earners engage accountants and tax advisors in order to ensure that they pay as little tax as possible on their income. There is also a moral question - how many houses does one man need when there are millions of homeless people or people living in sub-standard and/or unaffordable housing? How many steaks can one man eat when there are millions going to bed hungry?

A bigger issue is that people seem to think that income tax and National Insurance are the only sources of income that the government has when in fact these only cover around 35% of government revenue. Two-thirds of government revenue comes from elsewhere, including VAT, Excise duties (e.g. on alcohol and tobacco), Corporation Tax and other revenue streams - and the low paid are also paying these taxes every time they shop for clothes or buy fuel. The "multitude of benefits" that citizens enjoy are also paid for by taxes other than income tax, and one area that the UK government could focus on is ensuring that Corporation Tax is paid by businesses operating in the UK. Consumers should also play a role by looking at where companies operating in the UK actually pay their tax (perhaps starting with Boots, Starbucks and Amazon) and shopping accordingly.

Cucurella · 29/10/2026 14:23

I've never heard this phrase used in real life, only on Mumsnet

Ally886 · 29/10/2026 14:38

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 19:59

Surely this depends on how much you 'take' from the system? Eg healthcare

Also surely depends on whether they use the NHS or private health and dental?

ThePerfectStormBird · 29/10/2026 14:44

We have littered our vocabulary with legal and medical terms to add gravitas to our conversations. By saying someone is a Net Contributor you are simplifying the fact that they are paying in to a struggling system. People with ill health might find saying the medical term for the symptoms they are struggling with conveys they aren’t just moaning and shirking work, they have a diagnosis.

We are in an age where being unable to work is pretty common, so you’ll have those who want to be seen to be ‘paying in’ and those who want people to know they would pay in if they weren’t sick.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 29/10/2026 14:47

Ally886 · 29/10/2026 14:38

Also surely depends on whether they use the NHS or private health and dental?

And even more than that - if a 'net contributer' is an employer, it also depends on whether they've benefitted from an educated and healthy workforce, if they're someone who sells things it depends on whether they've benefitted from consumers being able to get to them via public transport etc etc.

It's surely very difficult to quantify exactly what someone has 'got out' of the system, in relation to what they have put in.

Differentforgirls · 29/10/2026 15:46

Minasama · 28/10/2026 20:07

As a very big net contributor I have no problem with the phrase. I think it’s good we are thinking about such things and it doesn’t stop me holding teaching assistants in high regard.

There’s a huge difference between a teaching assistant and an able-bodied person of 19 or 20 who is claiming benefits. These people should be supported by their families and (hopefully) working. It’s the type of families that don’t support these kids that I find to be problematic.

Edited

If you're 19 or 20 and not claiming the job seeking element of UC, your parents are doing you no favours.

Tideturn · 29/10/2026 16:21

The majority of very high earners have not chosen their job to benefit society, to contribute in some way (though some certainly have). Rather, their work was more often chosen out of self interest. Their (involuntary) contribution to society is financial. Perhaps this may redress the balance, but it does not make them net contributors to society. You could argue they are net financial contributors, but Raidersofthelostbattenburg and others have illustrated how this may not be the case. Still, the absence of the words ‘financial’ or ‘economic’ is what people often find insulting about the term.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 16:49

Tideturn · 29/10/2026 16:21

The majority of very high earners have not chosen their job to benefit society, to contribute in some way (though some certainly have). Rather, their work was more often chosen out of self interest. Their (involuntary) contribution to society is financial. Perhaps this may redress the balance, but it does not make them net contributors to society. You could argue they are net financial contributors, but Raidersofthelostbattenburg and others have illustrated how this may not be the case. Still, the absence of the words ‘financial’ or ‘economic’ is what people often find insulting about the term.

I think that's a good point that it's an involuntary contribution.

And also the quite telling the amount of high earners obviously MN who have said they would move to a different country if taxes increased. They're not interested in contributing anything to society

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 29/10/2026 17:20

Tideturn · 29/10/2026 16:21

The majority of very high earners have not chosen their job to benefit society, to contribute in some way (though some certainly have). Rather, their work was more often chosen out of self interest. Their (involuntary) contribution to society is financial. Perhaps this may redress the balance, but it does not make them net contributors to society. You could argue they are net financial contributors, but Raidersofthelostbattenburg and others have illustrated how this may not be the case. Still, the absence of the words ‘financial’ or ‘economic’ is what people often find insulting about the term.

I’m not sure why motivation matters. Money is money - it isn’t worth more because it came from someone that acted against their own self interest in order to make it. Someone making it for their own benefit doesn’t negate the fact that they are a net contributor.

InterIgnis · 29/10/2026 17:26

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 16:49

I think that's a good point that it's an involuntary contribution.

And also the quite telling the amount of high earners obviously MN who have said they would move to a different country if taxes increased. They're not interested in contributing anything to society

Edited

Some of us already have, and are instead contributing towards societies that offer us a better deal in return.

It’s not about not wanting to contribute, as it’s not all or nothing.

Tinofspoons · 29/10/2026 17:26

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 16:49

I think that's a good point that it's an involuntary contribution.

And also the quite telling the amount of high earners obviously MN who have said they would move to a different country if taxes increased. They're not interested in contributing anything to society

Edited

I’m pretty sure parents don’t have children purely to benefit society either. They do it because they selfishly want them. (I’m not saying that in a mean way. Just that it is to serve their own self wants). Yet I’ve seen many threads with parents telling childfree people that they should be grateful to their “contribution” to society with their children. So surely whether your contribution is involuntary or not it still matters the same?

XenoBitch · 29/10/2026 17:38

@glitterpaperchain I just caught up with the thread, and it seems a few posters are just proving your point.

Swipe left for the next trending thread