Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel I can't see my friend in the same light anymore?

345 replies

annanbw · 02/07/2023 09:49

Me and a very close friend had a baby the same sort of time. Our children are now 4 and about to start school. My friend has announced that her child will be going to a private school. My friend was privately educated and I met her years later. She has become more open minded as the years have gone on (her words!) and I really really didn’t think she would put her dc in the private sector so this is a surprise to me. She is a v good friend and we get on so well but this decision has made me feel weird and I don’t know why?! We couldn’t afford it for our child but even if we could I don’t agree with it. I feel like our children will now grow up very differently and I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. I don’t know what I am asking really. Just feel like I am not as close to her since she told me and I also feel bad for our child that this is allowed to happen.

OP posts:
ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 18:27

SweetStrawberrie · 02/07/2023 17:49

I haven't seen anyone on this thread acknowledge the few posts, including my own, that have pointed out the statistics on why it's problematic and why you get a direct advantage from being privately educated.

It's far easier to do a bemused 'what's the problem?' or call someone 'crazy/bonkers' for questioning a friends moral by contributing to a system that continues to allow the class gap to get bigger.

Whether or not we would 'all' do it is debatable - depends really on how strong your moral stance on it is.

OP has said she is fully against it and wouldn't - i take it at face value and thus, on that basis, it is understandable why she feels uncomfortable at her friends decision.

I'm not sure I would totally cut a friend off for this decision but we set our own line.

Loads of us have. I don’t like the private system but I don’t dislike people who use it. Most people do what they can to give their kids the best start they can afford.

We know it’s gives advantages. Just like going to a really good state school gives you an advantage over kids who can’t access a really good school. But that’s not option for loads of kids. Because there aren’t enough good schools and the catchment areas of really good schools are too expensive for most families. Again, you need a certain level of income to access these.

Homes schooled children of wealthy parents also can have an advantage as they have tutors, 1-2-1 learning and extra time and money for hobbies, travel, day trips etc.

This has all been discussed on this thread. Which I suspect was started just by Op to start the debate.

Crumpleton · 02/07/2023 18:30

happyfoot · 02/07/2023 18:16

I haven't seen anyone on this thread acknowledge the few posts, including my own, that have pointed out the statistics on why it's problematic and why you get a direct advantage from being privately educated

With the NHS waiting times and the state of it currently, I know many people using private health care. Should I judge them for that too? One of my friends was recently diagnosed with breast cancer and went private for her operation, should I un friend her because of it?- after all, she is using her privilege that many others dont have and surely that is problematic too

I look at this as your friend freeing up a NHS space for someone that can't afford to pay.

Like you judging them, or anyone else for that matter, for it would be something that wouldn't even enter my mind...

Teder · 02/07/2023 18:49

SweetStrawberrie · 02/07/2023 17:49

I haven't seen anyone on this thread acknowledge the few posts, including my own, that have pointed out the statistics on why it's problematic and why you get a direct advantage from being privately educated.

It's far easier to do a bemused 'what's the problem?' or call someone 'crazy/bonkers' for questioning a friends moral by contributing to a system that continues to allow the class gap to get bigger.

Whether or not we would 'all' do it is debatable - depends really on how strong your moral stance on it is.

OP has said she is fully against it and wouldn't - i take it at face value and thus, on that basis, it is understandable why she feels uncomfortable at her friends decision.

I'm not sure I would totally cut a friend off for this decision but we set our own line.

Of course being at privately educated gives an advantage and means one has a significant privilege.

My children are not privately educated but they have engaged, highly educated and involved parents. They live in an environment where we can create a quiet space for study and we proactively encourage them to work hard. They are lucky we can afford a home with enough space. We value education and we do this because we are fortunate enough to be well educated ourselves. We are fortunate to not work such long hours that our time with our children is very limited, so one of us can physically be there to support. My children are at an advantage and are privileged just to be born into a family where we are “ok” financially. I know you cannot even out every advantage and disadvantage but it’s naive to assume that private schooling is the be all and end all. It’s often the environment around it that creates the advantages.

happyfoot · 02/07/2023 18:59

Crumpleton · 02/07/2023 18:30

I look at this as your friend freeing up a NHS space for someone that can't afford to pay.

Like you judging them, or anyone else for that matter, for it would be something that wouldn't even enter my mind...

Same could be said for private education! They are paying taxes for a state education they arent actually using so the same principle applies

Singingthesong · 02/07/2023 19:01

I don’t believe you wouldn’t send your child if you could. You are annoyed because she can and you can’t and are taking that out on her - annoyed that she has an advantage you don’t, even tho you may have others over her (bigger house maybe, more holidays?) Maybe she should look at you in a different way?

ATeamsvan · 02/07/2023 19:03

Why don't you believe her? Lots of people wouldn't send their children private even if they could afford to

bluefrog11 · 02/07/2023 19:06

You’re actually jealous - that’s the emotion you are looking for. It’s clear you would do the same if you could and you’re annoyed that her child will have the tools given to them to succeed. It doesn’t necessarily mean they will do better then yours BTW but yes, there’s certainly going to be a difference going forward. I don’t really see why your friend’s choices affect you. The problem is you, not her.

ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 19:10

ATeamsvan · 02/07/2023 19:03

Why don't you believe her? Lots of people wouldn't send their children private even if they could afford to

How do they know?

AllyArty · 02/07/2023 19:11

Maybe you are worried that you and your DC will feel like the poor relations. And that she will mix in different circles from now on. She is only giving her child the same experience that was given to her. Try not to take it personally.

Singingthesong · 02/07/2023 19:28

@ATeamsvan because if she wouldn’t do it herself, it wouldn’t matter if someone else did. Certainly not enough to rethink a friendship

ATeamsvan · 02/07/2023 19:37

ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 19:10

How do they know?

Are you saying literally no one would not choose private if they had the means to?
You don't know anyone wealthy enough to do this, who uses a state school instead? As I certainly do.

SallyWD · 02/07/2023 19:43

ATeamsvan · 02/07/2023 19:37

Are you saying literally no one would not choose private if they had the means to?
You don't know anyone wealthy enough to do this, who uses a state school instead? As I certainly do.

It's true - plenty of people who could afford to send their kids to private school don't as a matter of principle.
For example, I grew up near Paul McCartney (one of the richest men in Britain). His children went to the local comprehensive. Many of my friends went to the same school as Stella and James McCartney.

ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 19:43

ATeamsvan · 02/07/2023 19:37

Are you saying literally no one would not choose private if they had the means to?
You don't know anyone wealthy enough to do this, who uses a state school instead? As I certainly do.

We are talking about the ‘even IF they could afford group.’

People who can afford it aren’t in the ‘IF they could afford it’ group. They are in the ‘can afford it’.

You said plenty of people wouldn’t send their kids even if they could afford it.

But if they can’t afford it, how do they know what decision they would make if they could afford it? If they were wealthy they may have a very different outlook on many things.

And your friends who are rich enough to afford private but don’t…..I assume they send their kids to shit schools? Or are they wealthy enough that they could afford to buy a house in a catchment area for a good school? Driving up house prices in that area and pricing families that aren’t wealthy out of the area. Essentially, using their wealth to get their kids a good education?

GarlicGrace · 02/07/2023 19:46

YANBU to feel the way you do, @annanbw. Your feelings are your feelings.

I agree that for anyone saying you're not open minded and it had no impact on you... I call that out as middle class denial of class. Its everywhere.

The question is whether your political anger at class inequality, your sense of injustice and/or resentment at your friend's wealthier circumstances are stronger than your affection for your friend as a person. This is something only you can know.

Personally, I'd be okay with the difference for as long as she both recognises it and doesn't act superior. But people have varying strengths of belief. You might find you're okay to remain friends but need to back off a bit?

Teder · 02/07/2023 21:27

”And your friends who are rich enough to afford private but don’t…..I assume they send their kids to shit schools? Or are they wealthy enough that they could afford to buy a house in a catchment area for a good school? Driving up house prices in that area and pricing families that aren’t wealthy out of the area. Essentially, using their wealth to get their kids a good education?”

This part gets conveniently ignored. I know a few “could afford private education but don’t on moral grounds” people who have paid a huge premium on a house by a very good school. Or their kids are at faith schools.

Hopingforagreatescape · 02/07/2023 21:41

I understand. It's not actually that the OP is jealous, it's that it feels to her that her friend, by paying for her child to attend a different school, is saying "my child is too good to go to school with yours", and the OP feels that her friend perhaps looks down on her and her child, which she hadn't realised.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 02/07/2023 21:50

Projecting much?

Crumpleton · 02/07/2023 22:07

Me and a very close friend had a baby the same sort of time. Our children are now 4 and about to start school. My friend has announced that her child will be going to a private school. My friend was privately educated and I met her years later.

I can see why your children can't still remain friends and see each other, the same with you and your friend.

OP you say yourself that your friend had a private education yet she is a "very close friend" so clearly her going to a private school hasn't clouded your judgment in the past.

Have you always been dead set against private education?
If so it seems very odd to strike up a close friendship with someone that had the very same education.

SunnyFrost · 02/07/2023 22:19

Hopingforagreatescape · 02/07/2023 21:41

I understand. It's not actually that the OP is jealous, it's that it feels to her that her friend, by paying for her child to attend a different school, is saying "my child is too good to go to school with yours", and the OP feels that her friend perhaps looks down on her and her child, which she hadn't realised.

Or maybe, just maybe, the decision is absolutely nothing to do with the children they will be going to school with. Maybe it’s down to class size, better equipment, extra curricula opportunities, better facilities, better wrap around care, teaching staff that aren’t on the brink of a nervous breakdown.

People are so quick to assume that private school parents are uppity snobs who want their children to be future members of the Bullingdon Club and only associate with millionaires. In the vast majority of cases (certainly where I live) they’re solidly middle class professionals who make a lot of sacrifices to prioritise education because the state secondary schools are almost without exception so shit as to be quite terrifying.

Hopingforagreatescape · 02/07/2023 22:31

SunnyFrost · 02/07/2023 22:19

Or maybe, just maybe, the decision is absolutely nothing to do with the children they will be going to school with. Maybe it’s down to class size, better equipment, extra curricula opportunities, better facilities, better wrap around care, teaching staff that aren’t on the brink of a nervous breakdown.

People are so quick to assume that private school parents are uppity snobs who want their children to be future members of the Bullingdon Club and only associate with millionaires. In the vast majority of cases (certainly where I live) they’re solidly middle class professionals who make a lot of sacrifices to prioritise education because the state secondary schools are almost without exception so shit as to be quite terrifying.

I said "it feels to her", not "it is".

New posts on this thread. Refresh page