Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel I can't see my friend in the same light anymore?

345 replies

annanbw · 02/07/2023 09:49

Me and a very close friend had a baby the same sort of time. Our children are now 4 and about to start school. My friend has announced that her child will be going to a private school. My friend was privately educated and I met her years later. She has become more open minded as the years have gone on (her words!) and I really really didn’t think she would put her dc in the private sector so this is a surprise to me. She is a v good friend and we get on so well but this decision has made me feel weird and I don’t know why?! We couldn’t afford it for our child but even if we could I don’t agree with it. I feel like our children will now grow up very differently and I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. I don’t know what I am asking really. Just feel like I am not as close to her since she told me and I also feel bad for our child that this is allowed to happen.

OP posts:
Toohardtofindaproperusername · 02/07/2023 10:09

And for anyone saying you're not open minded and it,had no impact on you... I call that out as middle class denial of class. Its everywhere. That's what you probabky have to deal with posting anything about class privilege on mumsnet. No one wants to see it.
I will now get flamed.. and thats fine, I just didnt want to sit by watching it all go your way.

Isheabastard · 02/07/2023 10:09

This is something I went through when I was much younger (though not about private school).

I used to have an attitude that for me to like/respect someone I had to like the whole of them. Ergo their values would have to synch with mine.

I realised this is messy thinking. We are all so different, that is nearly impossible. We have to learn to like a person but not necessarily agree with them or their actions everytime. In a way it’s self interest, as we will restrict our own pool of friends, if everyone has to jump over our own set bar.

We all have a turning point when another’s behaviour is beyond the pale, mine would be cruelty to animals. Then I would drop that person.

We each have our own limit, some people set it much higher or lower than others. If you set it too high, your friends will find it difficult to make the grade.

Long story short, I agree with the other posters.

mummam28 · 02/07/2023 10:09

YABU!!! It's her child and her decision. Absolutely nothing to do with you.

ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 10:09

Give over reaction.

What do you mean she has become more open minded? I have friends who went to private school, can’t say they aren’t as open minded as friends who didn’t. I grew up with friends who went to private and I didn’t. It didn’t make a huge difference.

I have to be honest, it sounds like the route of this is jealousy that she can afford options for her child that you can’t afford for yours. Wether you would do it or not.

BumpyaDaisyevna · 02/07/2023 10:09

You don't have to have the same views and choices in order to be friends.

Your DCs are going to different schools and of course they will have different experiences. (That would be the case with two different state schools even). It doesn't mean they won't also have things in common. Or that you and your friend won't have things in common.

She must have her reasons for her choice. And it's just a school.

She hasn't signed her DC up to a cult!

Fiddlesticks82 · 02/07/2023 10:10

Please sever links OP.

You will be doing your friend a big favour

MrsSamR · 02/07/2023 10:10

You're being ridiculous. Why shouldn't she put her child through private school if she can afford it and feels it right for her child? How does her decision impact yours? You might choose all kinds of other different ways to parent, why is private school always singled out as some kind of evil choice? If someone else buys organic food or designer clothes for their child but you can't afford to, does that mean they shouldn't be allowed to? You sound judgemental and envious to be honest and it's not a good look.

SoupDragon · 02/07/2023 10:11

Whataretheodds · 02/07/2023 10:00

Because it's not a choice open to all children?

Neither is excellent state education.

Netcam · 02/07/2023 10:11

I think this is a very difficult situation and quite complex, but one I can understand. I am and have always been left wing, life long labour voter (although contemplating defecting to the Greens). In theory I don't support the idea of private schooling or selective schooling.

However, I am also acutely aware from my own experience at a state secondary school, and as a former secondary school teacher, that state school does not suit all children. Some love it, some manage and get something out of it, some find it quite damaging.

If your child is bright, supported, keen and gets on OK at a state school, there is no reason why they can't do really well and go to a good university. It's when state doesn't work out for a particular child that it's problematic.

I wouldn't break off a friendship because of school choices, the decision is probably made in the best interests of the child. But I also know people who have been to private school and had terrible experiences there. It is not all that clear cut and how anyone gets on in school will be how well that particular child fits into a particular environment and whether it suits him/her.

I was a single parent bringing up my children for many years and couldn't have even contemplated sending them to private school. But I wouldn't lose friends if that's what they chose. In fact I'd be more likely to break off a friendship with someone who defected to the Tory party.

BumpyaDaisyevna · 02/07/2023 10:11

Growing up is realising that you can't control everything and everyone around you. Others are different and make their own choices.

If you cut of relationships because people are different then you are being rigid and "my way or the highway".

RenegadeMasterx · 02/07/2023 10:12

Bit dramatic

Fiddlesticks82 · 02/07/2023 10:12

And going by your opening sentence OP, you would have benefited from a better education whether that was state or private

* Me and a very close friend *

A very close friend and I

Trainsplanesandfeet · 02/07/2023 10:12

Your reaction to this is ridiculous and I would suggest you spend some time evaluating your own jealousy and inflexibility.

Tbh she should know how you feel so she can choose whether she still wants to be friends with you. I wouldn’t want you spending time with my child if you think such thoughts about them and me.

Oblomov23 · 02/07/2023 10:15

"I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage."

Oh ffs come on. Your anger is misplaced. What you wrote above makes you look like a prize tit.

XelaM · 02/07/2023 10:15

This has to be wind-up.

My privately-educated kid has loads of friends from various state schools. 3 of her best friends are in different state schools. There is literally zero difference between them, except that the state school parents have more disposable income than me as they aren't spending it all on school fees.

PushmePull · 02/07/2023 10:15

Your turn now to be more open minded.

You are only going to keep friendships if you can see past this sort of thing. If you are only friends with people who think the same as you on everything you'll find your circle getting smaller and smaller.

Holly03 · 02/07/2023 10:16

Private school has and always will provide a better education. Has this made you feel insecure because it shows you are from different classes. I come from a different class to my friends and all of our children are in state school but I do opt to pay privately on certain expenses as this was the way I brought up. I don’t feel it caused any discomfort for them or me as our children are all different and we all do what is in the best interest for our children. Yes I have more advantages then my friends but I’ve never had them become distant or cold like this towards me but that’s merely because we all accept that we have more in common than our limitations of society’s basis on class and wealth

Puppyseahorse · 02/07/2023 10:16

YABU and sound self-righteous and possibly jealous.

she doesn’t share your ideology. How would you feel if a friend felt differently about you because you ate meat or decided to be a SAHM?

continentallentil · 02/07/2023 10:16

In the nicest way you are being entirely nuts.

How she educates her child is up to her, and given you could do the same if you wanted, there is no need to feel bad for yours.

Unless she’s planning on a path that leads to a major boarding school your kids aren’t going to have vastly different experiences, unless the state alternatives are very poor. Even if they did, it wouldn’t mean they couldn’t be friends.

It be understandable that you were a bit put out if the two were lifelong friends and had had decades of conversations about how awful the private sector was. But you haven’t. You can be friends and disagree with each other’s choices.

continentallentil · 02/07/2023 10:18

Fiddlesticks82 · 02/07/2023 10:12

And going by your opening sentence OP, you would have benefited from a better education whether that was state or private

* Me and a very close friend *

A very close friend and I

Well so could you, it might have taught you better manners.

5128gap · 02/07/2023 10:18

Toohardtofindaproperusername · 02/07/2023 10:09

And for anyone saying you're not open minded and it,had no impact on you... I call that out as middle class denial of class. Its everywhere. That's what you probabky have to deal with posting anything about class privilege on mumsnet. No one wants to see it.
I will now get flamed.. and thats fine, I just didnt want to sit by watching it all go your way.

You are entirely correct. Choices that perpetuate inequality are not merely personal.
However, people typically look out for themselves and their own before seeking to redress societal inequality, and I think its a big ask to expect someone to put their social conscience ahead of what they percieve as best for their child.
The problem is systemic and it needs to be addressed at this level. While the opportunity to benefit oneself at the expense of others exists, people will take it, and will find a means to justify it to themselves. Its human nature.

FloweryName · 02/07/2023 10:19

You’re not a very good friend if you can’t be supportive of her perfectly acceptable and valid choice for her child. It’s nothing to do with you and it’s not a reflection of her opinion on your choices for your child. Have you even tried to think about her reasons for choosing private?

Does she have reason to believe her child needs a smaller environment or is she doing it because she has little chance of getting into a good state school near their home, or will it make a difference to her childcare options? There are plenty of reasons why she’s making this choice that aren’t just about wanting to buy her child an advantage over yours.

You need to open your mind some more.

TeaKitten · 02/07/2023 10:20

I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage.

This is so entitled, you are angry for your child because your friend is sending her own child to private school. Ridiculous. YABU

PrueRamsay · 02/07/2023 10:21

Huge overreaction OP.

You sound jealous.

JudgeRudy · 02/07/2023 10:21

annanbw · 02/07/2023 09:49

Me and a very close friend had a baby the same sort of time. Our children are now 4 and about to start school. My friend has announced that her child will be going to a private school. My friend was privately educated and I met her years later. She has become more open minded as the years have gone on (her words!) and I really really didn’t think she would put her dc in the private sector so this is a surprise to me. She is a v good friend and we get on so well but this decision has made me feel weird and I don’t know why?! We couldn’t afford it for our child but even if we could I don’t agree with it. I feel like our children will now grow up very differently and I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. I don’t know what I am asking really. Just feel like I am not as close to her since she told me and I also feel bad for our child that this is allowed to happen.

If your friend has banged on about communism for years and is anti elitist, I can see you'd be shocked/hurt, but it's really not an unreasonable choice for someone (who can afford it) to make.
It's natural for parents to do what they believe is best for their child. You will do the same, even if it disadvantages another child.
When the teacher sits the ADHD kid next to your child because they're a 'calming influence' remain open minded. When they then pair them up for all activities and want them to sit together at lunch so your child isn't with their preferred friends, you mind will close a little. When little Johnny's mum dies reciprocate your play dates, you might stop inviting him...etc....etc
How will you feel if she takes 2 holidays per year or buys a flash car?