Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel I can't see my friend in the same light anymore?

345 replies

annanbw · 02/07/2023 09:49

Me and a very close friend had a baby the same sort of time. Our children are now 4 and about to start school. My friend has announced that her child will be going to a private school. My friend was privately educated and I met her years later. She has become more open minded as the years have gone on (her words!) and I really really didn’t think she would put her dc in the private sector so this is a surprise to me. She is a v good friend and we get on so well but this decision has made me feel weird and I don’t know why?! We couldn’t afford it for our child but even if we could I don’t agree with it. I feel like our children will now grow up very differently and I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. I don’t know what I am asking really. Just feel like I am not as close to her since she told me and I also feel bad for our child that this is allowed to happen.

OP posts:
babbscrabbs · 02/07/2023 15:08

SoupDragon · 02/07/2023 10:11

Neither is excellent state education.

This is a really good point, and why we are considering private (even though we can't really afford it). The state schools we would get into round here are shocking. Catchments have changed since we moved here, and we can't afford to move into the "naice" catchments.

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 15:09

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 14:57

Really????

It doesn't offend anyone but can you really not see that you got to make a decision that you feel was in the best interests of your child that most people don't get to make? That makes you very privileged and that's great for you! Can you not see how there are probably thousands of children with the same traits your child has and yet this isn't an option?

Some people don’t get to make that decision no, but that doesn’t mean that she shouldn’t. Indeed, she did.

If parents were to provide for their children only what every other child had access to, they’d find themselves quite limited.

SybilWrites · 02/07/2023 15:13

It seems to be a glib answer to posts like this to state you must be jealous of her. Only you will know if that's the case.

For my part, I do not agree with private schools and don't agree that they have no impact on me personally or as a society. Anything that perpetuates inequality in such a way has an impact on me. I could have afforded private school and chose not to do it. I do judge people who send their children there, particularly those who don't acknowledge that they are making a decision that is not an option for most people (and then claim its because they care so much about their children's education or its because their child has some special attribute that means they need to go there). But I wouldn't end a friendship on this basis.

And, as others have said, there are many other inequalities in education that exist outside of the private/state discussion- outstanding state schools and the ways the richer of us play the system to get into them, - grammars, expensive catchment areas, ability to pay for extra curricular activities, church schools etc. Many things that middle class parents do which less well off parents just can't. If you feel so strongly about it, you can do a lot as a parent in the state system.

Anyotherdude · 02/07/2023 15:24

You do realise that by putting her DC into a private school, she is not withdrawing any funds from your DC’s state school, right? In fact, by choosing to pay for a private school, she is paying both for a state and private education. I don’t have any DC at school, but I’m also paying out of my taxes for state education. By your logic, I should be kicking up a fuss over my taxes paying for education given that nobody in my family is getting anything out of it right now!
Honestly, I think you need to give your head a wobble over this, OP!

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 15:37

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 15:09

Some people don’t get to make that decision no, but that doesn’t mean that she shouldn’t. Indeed, she did.

If parents were to provide for their children only what every other child had access to, they’d find themselves quite limited.

True, but that wasn't the point I was trying to make. The PP mentioned that they didn't know why anyone would have a problem with private education. The point I was making was that many children would benefit from this type of education but it is not available to them - it is inherently unfair. I don't think this is a good thing - much like most people wouldn't like to see a predominantly private healthcare system in this country. The premise of healthcare in this country is that it is provided based on need NOT the ability to pay - we ALL benefit as a result of nationalised healthcare. I won't get into the issues of chronic underfunding in healthcare or education but the basic philosophical principle is justice - that's what we are discussing here.

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 15:41

Vivi0120 · 02/07/2023 15:01

@ISpyNoPlumPie I agree with you, but in my experience and in my surroundings there have been a lot of people who can afford the fee and still judge me and make fun of my decision. I'm mostly referring to those people. I understand not everyone has the option no matter how hard they work etc.

This is a strange and slightly cruel stance for these people to take and I wouldn't pay them any mind. You have made a decision that you feel is best for your family. The system is unfair, but of course I can understand why you would want the best for your child (and that we can all have a nuanced understanding of these issues e.g. I think the system is bad but I don't want to make an example of my child when they are struggling/unhappy etc.).

BathroomOnTheRight · 02/07/2023 15:43

Vivi0120 · 02/07/2023 14:51

I never understood what is the issue with private education?

My DC goes to private school. It cost a lot. We definitely can put the money towards our mortgage or something else but we chose to do this for her.

She was very shy and very closed child. She is also august born kid so she was really littlebwhen she started. She is extremely gentle and kind. She would have struggled so much in a class with 30+ kids.

She also has severe allergies and we don't trust a public school to handle her allergies as well I'm afraid.

We don't send her there because it's posh or because it gives her something academically it was just a decision based on her health and personality. As I said we need to be quite careful financially so we can afford it as well.

With this in mind, I don't see why this would offend anyone?

I just don't get why someone would judge people because they chose a private school for their child? Especially if you don't know the reason.

This is a very fair point! Schools are all different. Check out 150 schools, you'll find 150 different school communities/teaching styles/environment. There is a school out there to suit every child.

I had a hard time at my co-ed state secondary school and I DESPERATELY wished my parents could have sent me to an all girls school where I believe I would have thrived. I've always resented my parents for that, and as I was unhappy at school, I didn't perform well and reach my potential.

Actually, I think my girls would prefer to attend a single sex school, if asked. The boys ruined a lot of things at school.

Every child has a different personality and there are schools to suit every child. No child is homogenous, so why should schools be homogenous?

Banning private schools and only having one homogenous school system won't help anyone except the popular, bright, gifted children. People who want a homogenous state school system are not thinking deeply.

ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 15:47

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 15:37

True, but that wasn't the point I was trying to make. The PP mentioned that they didn't know why anyone would have a problem with private education. The point I was making was that many children would benefit from this type of education but it is not available to them - it is inherently unfair. I don't think this is a good thing - much like most people wouldn't like to see a predominantly private healthcare system in this country. The premise of healthcare in this country is that it is provided based on need NOT the ability to pay - we ALL benefit as a result of nationalised healthcare. I won't get into the issues of chronic underfunding in healthcare or education but the basic philosophical principle is justice - that's what we are discussing here.

The state system isn't fair either. Just as u fair as having a private option for those who can pay.

State schools rely heavily on catchment areas. Catchment area property prices are usually very high if its the catchment of a good school. So parents who can afford to move are the ones who live there.

You can get private health care in the UK and get ahead of waiting lists. You have an advantage if you have money. And no one hates it like they do private schools. Even though we ate talking about peoples lives.

CoffeeCantata · 02/07/2023 15:49

@Bathroomontheright

Guilty as charged! Yes - I missed the important 'couldn't'!

BathroomOnTheRight · 02/07/2023 15:50
  • I think my girls

should be I think many girls

Londisc · 02/07/2023 15:53

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 12:42

All of this "tell your friend so she can ditch you", "get some therapy", "you're probably hypocritical in other ways", "you're so jealous and bitter". Are there some people on this thread feeling guilty about the decisions they have made???? 😆

Why are you projecting guilt onto people?
I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. The OP is jealous. She is feeling personally wounded because her friend is choosing to take an option that is not available to the OP. She can lose a friendship or she can talk it through with a therapist. Either way, she is likely to pass this chip onto her child's shoulders if she doesn't address it. The OP has started this thread because she is not enjoying feeling the way that she does.

jeaux90 · 02/07/2023 15:54

@BathroomOnTheRight so true about single sex school. Treating everyone the same does not create equality.

I was shocked at the statistics on sexual assaults in mixed secondary schools too.

My DD14 is in a small private girls school and thrives.

LauraNicolaides · 02/07/2023 15:55

This is not about the ethics of private education. @annanbw has already made that decision.

It's about whether you'd drop a friend who has different views to you on some issue. I think the obvious answer is yes, if the issue is sufficiently important to you, and only you can decide how important it is.

jeaux90 · 02/07/2023 15:58

School budget cuts- is this normal? http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4839390-school-budget-cuts-is-this-normal?msgid=-4839390#-4839390

And I don't blame the friend either, mine is in private and I'm really glad!

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 15:58

ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 15:47

The state system isn't fair either. Just as u fair as having a private option for those who can pay.

State schools rely heavily on catchment areas. Catchment area property prices are usually very high if its the catchment of a good school. So parents who can afford to move are the ones who live there.

You can get private health care in the UK and get ahead of waiting lists. You have an advantage if you have money. And no one hates it like they do private schools. Even though we ate talking about peoples lives.

You have cited another example of how inequality creates more inequity. This doesn't negate the fact that the private vs. state school system is unfair and suggests you understand the ethics underlying the argument.

I'm not sure I agree with your final paragraph. Many people are opposed to a two tier healthcare system and over 80% of the population wish for healthcare to remain a nationalised service.

WeeOrcadian · 02/07/2023 15:59

"made me feel weird"

Read: jealous

YABU

Vivi0120 · 02/07/2023 16:04

Ha! Yes, the catchment area rule is an interesting one. Especially for Grammar Schools. I simply don't get how you pass an exam and then it doesn't matter what your score is but it matters where you live.

I am not originally from the UK so in my country there are entrance exams for Secondary school and only your mark matters and not your proximity to the school.

There definitely are trends that houses are more expensive near good schools so there even public education is based on privilege I guess.

There was also the comment saying that actually private schools do subsidise public and take some strain out of them which I agree with. Thinking about it our overall taxes would be even higher if there weren't private services.

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 16:09

Londisc · 02/07/2023 15:53

Why are you projecting guilt onto people?
I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. The OP is jealous. She is feeling personally wounded because her friend is choosing to take an option that is not available to the OP. She can lose a friendship or she can talk it through with a therapist. Either way, she is likely to pass this chip onto her child's shoulders if she doesn't address it. The OP has started this thread because she is not enjoying feeling the way that she does.

I can't project guilt onto people - I really can't do that. If people feel uncomfortable when their decisions are called into question that suggests their own underlying cognitive dissonance.

Perhaps OP is jealous - I don't know. Perhaps OP feels like life is very unfair and she is seeing it played out in front of her with two 4 year olds. My take on it is that I wouldn't call it a "chip" that needs therapy, more an awareness that not only do we not have equality of outcomes in this country but we don't even have equality of opportunity.

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 16:09

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 15:37

True, but that wasn't the point I was trying to make. The PP mentioned that they didn't know why anyone would have a problem with private education. The point I was making was that many children would benefit from this type of education but it is not available to them - it is inherently unfair. I don't think this is a good thing - much like most people wouldn't like to see a predominantly private healthcare system in this country. The premise of healthcare in this country is that it is provided based on need NOT the ability to pay - we ALL benefit as a result of nationalised healthcare. I won't get into the issues of chronic underfunding in healthcare or education but the basic philosophical principle is justice - that's what we are discussing here.

Much like education, there is both state and private provision when it comes to medicine.

I doubt there’s a single social or political system that is ever going to be universally ‘fair’, despite the best of intentions. Life isn’t fair, and in many ways it can’t be, whatever force a government may employ. Is it fair to deny freedoms, in the name of fairness? If the answer is yes, then what are the consequences of that, both intended and unintended? Are the results of that decision going to be a net positive, or in fact a negative?

What unfairness is acceptable, and what fairness isn’t? And to whom? What group should be advantaged, and what group disadvantaged?

People pay a lot of lip service to notions of ‘fairness’, as if it’s ever that simple, or simple to achieve.

DemiColon · 02/07/2023 16:13

Why should parents have a moral obligation to give their kids the kinds of education the state deems appropriate, rather than what the parents deem appropriate?

Of course your friend is going to send her child to a school she things will give her a good education, that's the point of going to school.

DinkeyDonkey · 02/07/2023 16:21

Honestly you sound jelous.

DemiColon · 02/07/2023 16:21

Or to put it another way, do we really want to say that parents are legally obligated to give up their kids to the state for 12 or so years?

Because while you might say, private options, like say hiring a tutor, aren't "fair" for all, how far are we going to go in suppressing individual rights in order to accomplish that?

There are countries where private education, including tutors or home education, are illegal. Parental rights around children are not as strong in many ways as the rights of the state.

Lavender14 · 02/07/2023 16:25

Yabu. It's her decision how she parents and educates her child as it is your decision how you will parent and educate yours. There are certain benefits to private education (and certain negatives) and its for your friend to weigh that up. How she educates her child outside of that education will also have a big bearing on who her kid turns out to be. Your own judgement is what is affecting the relationship here. You've probably made choices in your parenting that your friend has silently disagreed with but she was able to put that aside to prioritise your friendship and respect your choices. I think you need to afford her the same courtesy.

Crumpleton · 02/07/2023 16:33

Best to concentrate on your own child's education and leave your friend to do what she feels is best for her DC.

flirtygirl · 02/07/2023 16:36

My only choices with the current UK education over last 15 years would be private or home ed.

I choose to home ed.

I would not send my child to most UK schools.

Everyone is different and this is a silly reason to feel different about your friend. Cheating, lying and cruelty that would make me feel different, as would extreme beliefs. But not private education.