Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel I can't see my friend in the same light anymore?

345 replies

annanbw · 02/07/2023 09:49

Me and a very close friend had a baby the same sort of time. Our children are now 4 and about to start school. My friend has announced that her child will be going to a private school. My friend was privately educated and I met her years later. She has become more open minded as the years have gone on (her words!) and I really really didn’t think she would put her dc in the private sector so this is a surprise to me. She is a v good friend and we get on so well but this decision has made me feel weird and I don’t know why?! We couldn’t afford it for our child but even if we could I don’t agree with it. I feel like our children will now grow up very differently and I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. I don’t know what I am asking really. Just feel like I am not as close to her since she told me and I also feel bad for our child that this is allowed to happen.

OP posts:
5128gap · 02/07/2023 16:56

Londisc · 02/07/2023 15:53

Why are you projecting guilt onto people?
I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. The OP is jealous. She is feeling personally wounded because her friend is choosing to take an option that is not available to the OP. She can lose a friendship or she can talk it through with a therapist. Either way, she is likely to pass this chip onto her child's shoulders if she doesn't address it. The OP has started this thread because she is not enjoying feeling the way that she does.

No. To interpret that statement as jealousy is to misunderstand. Taking the OPs post at face value, she isn't jealous, because she doesn't covet a private education for her own child, as that would be against her principles. What she wants is for her friend and others not to have chosen one either, as she believes the private education system disadvantages children who are state educated. She is disappointed because she has now discovered someone who she believed to share her values is in fact part of the problem.
Obviously people will cry jealousy, as it's the go to response when anyone has a moral or ethical objection to something that costs money.

ElleMD80 · 02/07/2023 17:00

If your kid works hard, there is no reason there should be a disadvantage. If it bugs you so much, yóú work harder and send yours to private school too. Being annoyed at a parent for doing their best for their child? Would she look down on you for going public? This sounds like a ‘you’ inferiority complex.

rockpoolingtogether · 02/07/2023 17:01

My child goes to private school on a massive bursary. If someone can afford it, they should. Would hate to think I'm judged by others (who don't know about our bursary).

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 17:10

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 16:09

Much like education, there is both state and private provision when it comes to medicine.

I doubt there’s a single social or political system that is ever going to be universally ‘fair’, despite the best of intentions. Life isn’t fair, and in many ways it can’t be, whatever force a government may employ. Is it fair to deny freedoms, in the name of fairness? If the answer is yes, then what are the consequences of that, both intended and unintended? Are the results of that decision going to be a net positive, or in fact a negative?

What unfairness is acceptable, and what fairness isn’t? And to whom? What group should be advantaged, and what group disadvantaged?

People pay a lot of lip service to notions of ‘fairness’, as if it’s ever that simple, or simple to achieve.

Without going on and on, because I feel like I have a bit... No system is fair - that is true. But we can make a choice to move closer to or further away from fairness. The UK is becoming a more and more unequal society, and this is a political choice. It is not simple to achieve, but inequality can be measured and addressed. Plenty of other high income countries are doing a much better job than the UK in reducing inequality. Regarding your ethical questions, I suppose we all exist on a spectrum that spans collectivism to individualism - my take is that we are too individualistic in this country and we don't sufficiently acknowledge the extent to which our wellbeing is interconnected.

HeartBrokenWife · 02/07/2023 17:11

Diversity is good, no? So the OP’s child and her friend’s child are getting diverse educations if one is privately and one is state educated. What’s the problem with diversity?

Being kind is also good, no? The OP isn’t being kind to her friend whose opinion on education differs from her own. Is living in a bubble or an echo chamber where there is no diversity something to aim for? Surely not.

There’s no ideal world where everyone is equal because some people have different capabilities, both practical and intellectual. Cookie cutter world will never exist outside an Edward Scissorhands type dystopia. What about those, like myself, with physical disabilities that have been present since childhood? Should everyone be forced to limit themselves to what I can physically achieve? Not on my watch they shouldn’t. I’m happy that fit, healthy people exist. I’d like to join their ranks (obviously that’s impossible) but I don’t want to impose limits on them.

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 17:11

ElleMD80 · 02/07/2023 17:00

If your kid works hard, there is no reason there should be a disadvantage. If it bugs you so much, yóú work harder and send yours to private school too. Being annoyed at a parent for doing their best for their child? Would she look down on you for going public? This sounds like a ‘you’ inferiority complex.

All right Therese!!!

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 17:12

5128gap · 02/07/2023 16:56

No. To interpret that statement as jealousy is to misunderstand. Taking the OPs post at face value, she isn't jealous, because she doesn't covet a private education for her own child, as that would be against her principles. What she wants is for her friend and others not to have chosen one either, as she believes the private education system disadvantages children who are state educated. She is disappointed because she has now discovered someone who she believed to share her values is in fact part of the problem.
Obviously people will cry jealousy, as it's the go to response when anyone has a moral or ethical objection to something that costs money.

Probably because jealousy has a habit of wearing virtue’s mask. Very few people admit their dislike of something is motivated by jealousy, but that doesn’t change the fact that it absolutely can be.

Sure, some people genuinely are against private school because of moral principle, but there are also those against it because it’s not an option for them.

moonlitwalks · 02/07/2023 17:17

Probably because jealousy has a habit of wearing virtue’s mask. Very few people admit their dislike of something is motivated by jealousy, but that doesn’t change the fact that it absolutely can be

Couldnt agree more with this. I know of people who claimed vehemently they were against certain expensive lifestyle things when they were broke for "moral reasons". Strange how when they did eventually have the money they then got them/did them. Cognitive dissonance- its a very common self defence mechanism and not rare at all. We all do it to varying degrees.

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 17:18

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 17:10

Without going on and on, because I feel like I have a bit... No system is fair - that is true. But we can make a choice to move closer to or further away from fairness. The UK is becoming a more and more unequal society, and this is a political choice. It is not simple to achieve, but inequality can be measured and addressed. Plenty of other high income countries are doing a much better job than the UK in reducing inequality. Regarding your ethical questions, I suppose we all exist on a spectrum that spans collectivism to individualism - my take is that we are too individualistic in this country and we don't sufficiently acknowledge the extent to which our wellbeing is interconnected.

But that depends on your definition of fairness (as well as what you consider to be an acceptable level of unfairness), and what you consider to be more valuable when two things stand in opposition.

like I said earlier, both my parents grew up in collectivist, socialist, countries. There was most definitely still a class system in operation, and a divide between desirable and undesirable schools. People still purchased advantage for their children: those that could used their positions, connections, and money to buy their children access to the best schools. They just did it under the table.

FAFO · 02/07/2023 17:20

Of course it has a bearing on OPs child. Just be ause this child is known to her doesn't mitigate the fact that thousands of children have an enormous advantage over the rest of our children.

Private schooling is abhorrent to me. There would be better equality if all schools were equal, and those able to pay for education did so to improve education for all.

FAFO · 02/07/2023 17:22

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 17:10

Without going on and on, because I feel like I have a bit... No system is fair - that is true. But we can make a choice to move closer to or further away from fairness. The UK is becoming a more and more unequal society, and this is a political choice. It is not simple to achieve, but inequality can be measured and addressed. Plenty of other high income countries are doing a much better job than the UK in reducing inequality. Regarding your ethical questions, I suppose we all exist on a spectrum that spans collectivism to individualism - my take is that we are too individualistic in this country and we don't sufficiently acknowledge the extent to which our wellbeing is interconnected.

Exactly. Very well said.

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 17:24

moonlitwalks · 02/07/2023 17:17

Probably because jealousy has a habit of wearing virtue’s mask. Very few people admit their dislike of something is motivated by jealousy, but that doesn’t change the fact that it absolutely can be

Couldnt agree more with this. I know of people who claimed vehemently they were against certain expensive lifestyle things when they were broke for "moral reasons". Strange how when they did eventually have the money they then got them/did them. Cognitive dissonance- its a very common self defence mechanism and not rare at all. We all do it to varying degrees.

We do - but we couldn't accuse OP (OP...hello? Are you still here??) of this - OP said she wouldn't send her child to private school if she could afford it. It is perhaps the cognitive dissonance in OPs friend that has made the OP feel "weird". But we'll never know because she's not coming back to see the mess she made!!! 😁I jest, I've enjoyed this thread.

Londisc · 02/07/2023 17:26

5128gap · 02/07/2023 16:56

No. To interpret that statement as jealousy is to misunderstand. Taking the OPs post at face value, she isn't jealous, because she doesn't covet a private education for her own child, as that would be against her principles. What she wants is for her friend and others not to have chosen one either, as she believes the private education system disadvantages children who are state educated. She is disappointed because she has now discovered someone who she believed to share her values is in fact part of the problem.
Obviously people will cry jealousy, as it's the go to response when anyone has a moral or ethical objection to something that costs money.

I disagree. Taking the post at face value, the OP says she is angry and feels bad that her child will now be disadvantaged by her friend's decision. Nothing has in fact changed for her child. The anger is jealousy and it is a perfectly normal reaction. People are resisting the word because they interpret it as petty and/or nasty. It's not. It is natural instinct to want "the best" for your child and feeling bad if you can't provide that. It is why the OP also included the information that she could not afford to privately educate her child The OP feels bad about not being able to give her child the same opportunity. The problem is her feeling of wanting to bin a "very good" friendship over it. It's easy to talk 'principles' when you are dealing with hypotheticals. If this friend is someone you get on "so well" with then the friendship should be able to withstand this issue but the OP has to be completely honest with herself about what she is feeling and why before talking to her friend.

ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 17:26

5128gap · 02/07/2023 16:56

No. To interpret that statement as jealousy is to misunderstand. Taking the OPs post at face value, she isn't jealous, because she doesn't covet a private education for her own child, as that would be against her principles. What she wants is for her friend and others not to have chosen one either, as she believes the private education system disadvantages children who are state educated. She is disappointed because she has now discovered someone who she believed to share her values is in fact part of the problem.
Obviously people will cry jealousy, as it's the go to response when anyone has a moral or ethical objection to something that costs money.

To say if Op won’t use private school it can’t be jealousy is naive. I think she is jealous because it’s the first time she has realised her friends wealth could make a huge difference in their child’s lives. But even if the child went to a state school, that would happen. The friend is likely to have more disposable income for holiday, hobbies, day trips and so on and so forth. As the kids get older the friend may be able to help their child with house deposits and uni costs and so on. All giving their child more opportunities.

You can be jealous of someone even if it you wouldn’t make the same choices. Especially when you realise there’s such a big wealth gap between you.

If op thinks the private school system is directly damaging her child, I might agree. But this child going is not causing any additional harm. So why is the Op so upset. private education in general will still happen even if the friends child doesn’t go.

But people who can’t afford private school (like me) saying ‘I wouldn’t send mine even if I could afford it’ doesn’t make it a fact.

You don’t know what decision you would make until you are in that situation. For a start having that amount of money may change your outlook. But For example if op only had really poor states schools to pick from but was wealthy. I very much doubt she would accept a very poor education for her child.

She would either move to an area with better schools or go private. By moving to a house in a better area with better schools, where lots of families are priced out of buying she would also be participating in the same behaviours. Using her money to give her child a better education. Or she would go private.

I very much doubt there’s many families that have other options but still choose to send their child to a poor performing school.

Personally, I think the house buying situation is more, directly, damaging to state school pupils.

and if all children should have to have a state education, would home schooling have to be banned too?

JayAlfredPrufrock · 02/07/2023 17:36

Her money. Her choice.

StaunchMomma · 02/07/2023 17:36

You sound jealous and more than a tad batshit, OP.

The state education is in currently, I wouldn't blame anyone for putting their kids in private, if they can.

GirlOfTudor · 02/07/2023 17:39

It sounds like you feel inferior to your friend.

Greenpin · 02/07/2023 17:41

You thought your friend was similar to you and that your daughters would have the same experiences and way of life. Finding out that they will not has thrown you off balance.
I understand that feeling.

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 17:41

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 17:24

We do - but we couldn't accuse OP (OP...hello? Are you still here??) of this - OP said she wouldn't send her child to private school if she could afford it. It is perhaps the cognitive dissonance in OPs friend that has made the OP feel "weird". But we'll never know because she's not coming back to see the mess she made!!! 😁I jest, I've enjoyed this thread.

Plenty of people will say they wouldn’t even if they could, precisely because they can’t. It’s very easy to say you wouldn’t do something when it’s not an option for you. It’s not unusual for stances to change when circumstances do and options become available, however.

SweetStrawberrie · 02/07/2023 17:49

I haven't seen anyone on this thread acknowledge the few posts, including my own, that have pointed out the statistics on why it's problematic and why you get a direct advantage from being privately educated.

It's far easier to do a bemused 'what's the problem?' or call someone 'crazy/bonkers' for questioning a friends moral by contributing to a system that continues to allow the class gap to get bigger.

Whether or not we would 'all' do it is debatable - depends really on how strong your moral stance on it is.

OP has said she is fully against it and wouldn't - i take it at face value and thus, on that basis, it is understandable why she feels uncomfortable at her friends decision.

I'm not sure I would totally cut a friend off for this decision but we set our own line.

moonlitwalks · 02/07/2023 18:03

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 17:41

Plenty of people will say they wouldn’t even if they could, precisely because they can’t. It’s very easy to say you wouldn’t do something when it’s not an option for you. It’s not unusual for stances to change when circumstances do and options become available, however.

Basically this.

JudgeAnderson · 02/07/2023 18:08

I haven't seen anyone on this thread acknowledge the few posts, including my own, that have pointed out the statistics on why it's problematic and why you get a direct advantage from being privately educated.

I'm sure there are indeed many advantages to a private education as I doubt parents would go to the expense otherwise. But that's life - people with resources will obviously use them to give their child the best outcome possible. I don't think it's a judgeable offense.

Thehop · 02/07/2023 18:08

I don't see how it's any different to any other choice a parent makes to buy their child a better advantage?

betyer car seat equals improved chances in a crash
private music lessons
swimming lessons
turor
all sorts of opportunities to buy opportunities for children. This is no different at all. Good for her.

Londisc · 02/07/2023 18:15

The OP said : We couldn’t afford it for our child but even if we could I don’t agree with it.

That is the extent of her expression of being "fully against" private education. The rest of the post is an expression of narcissistic injury. No, I'm not saying the OP has NPD.

happyfoot · 02/07/2023 18:16

I haven't seen anyone on this thread acknowledge the few posts, including my own, that have pointed out the statistics on why it's problematic and why you get a direct advantage from being privately educated

With the NHS waiting times and the state of it currently, I know many people using private health care. Should I judge them for that too? One of my friends was recently diagnosed with breast cancer and went private for her operation, should I un friend her because of it?- after all, she is using her privilege that many others dont have and surely that is problematic too