Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel I can't see my friend in the same light anymore?

345 replies

annanbw · 02/07/2023 09:49

Me and a very close friend had a baby the same sort of time. Our children are now 4 and about to start school. My friend has announced that her child will be going to a private school. My friend was privately educated and I met her years later. She has become more open minded as the years have gone on (her words!) and I really really didn’t think she would put her dc in the private sector so this is a surprise to me. She is a v good friend and we get on so well but this decision has made me feel weird and I don’t know why?! We couldn’t afford it for our child but even if we could I don’t agree with it. I feel like our children will now grow up very differently and I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. I don’t know what I am asking really. Just feel like I am not as close to her since she told me and I also feel bad for our child that this is allowed to happen.

OP posts:
MinimalistMe · 02/07/2023 13:51

Good on her, if I could afford to put my child through private education, I absolutely would. YABVU

Ghosttofu99 · 02/07/2023 13:59

Whataretheodds · 02/07/2023 10:00

Because it's not a choice open to all children?

Exactly.

A two tier education system is what led us to one of the all-time worst governments led by Boris Johnson but op is going to get ripped because lots of people think it’s their right to use their money to advantage their children over others.

Its still a massively class based system in this country it’s just much better hidden now.

TheOGCCL · 02/07/2023 14:04

I get what you're saying. You tend to gravitate to people who you think share the same sort of ideals and principles and when you discover they don't it can be a bit disappointing. This is quite a fundamental principle, its not like she's just put up some curtains you don't like.

Ghosttofu99 · 02/07/2023 14:05

YouAreNotBatman · 02/07/2023 13:03

This can’t be serious!
No one is this level of crazy!!

Some people can see the systems that advantage/disadvantage certain sections of society and some can’t, or choose not to. It’s much easier not to think about these things and just live with the status quo. Op maybe slightly over the top and looking for perspective but many of these comments are even more of an over reaction to challenging the accepted system.

whumpthereitis · 02/07/2023 14:10

I think it’s simplistic in the extreme to think that banning private schools would result in a levelling of the playing field. It wouldn’t. The playing field already isn’t level across the state sector.

There would still be desirable and undesirable schools, with a number of the desirable ones becoming elite enclaves that are essentially private schools, yet paid for by the state. Other parents would send their children abroad, home educate by themselves or with tutors, or set up educational cooperatives with other parents in the same position.

I said this in the other thread but it’s relevant here too: both my parents grew up in socialist countries, and in those ‘classless societies’ there was still a considerable difference between desirable (gymnasia) and undesirable (vocational) schools. Of course those able to did not legally buy their children access to the good schools, instead it was typical to use one’s connections and employ bribery to do so. It was endemic.

venusandmars · 02/07/2023 14:10

I understand. We have a group of very long term friends from university. Whatever their backgrounds, at the time, everyone expressed common values with respect to private schooling, private health care etc. Over the years several have changed their minds for a variety of reasons (GPS paying school fees, one child who didn't thrive in local comp etc). That is all fine, and we are still a good bunch of friends. However, probably the most well off of the group (family money plus excellently paid careers) managed - with the benefit of private, music, French, sports lessons - to get scholarships for all 3 kids. I did feel differently about that, it was depriving some less well-off families of financial support, whereas for them it was a way saving money.

Years on we are still friends, but I don't see them in quite the same light, and I see their inherent 'penny pinching' played out in other ways. But I like them in other ways and we have a long shared history.

MollysBrolly · 02/07/2023 14:15

Your child isn't disadvantaged.
You have issue with private vs state not your friend. It's up to her how she chooses to educate her child.
Are you jealous because she has the choose of private school because she can afford it?

ProfessorXtra · 02/07/2023 14:18

Ghosttofu99 · 02/07/2023 14:05

Some people can see the systems that advantage/disadvantage certain sections of society and some can’t, or choose not to. It’s much easier not to think about these things and just live with the status quo. Op maybe slightly over the top and looking for perspective but many of these comments are even more of an over reaction to challenging the accepted system.

In which case sending your kids to a half decent state school should be an issue too?

Amuseaboosh · 02/07/2023 14:22

annanbw · 02/07/2023 09:49

Me and a very close friend had a baby the same sort of time. Our children are now 4 and about to start school. My friend has announced that her child will be going to a private school. My friend was privately educated and I met her years later. She has become more open minded as the years have gone on (her words!) and I really really didn’t think she would put her dc in the private sector so this is a surprise to me. She is a v good friend and we get on so well but this decision has made me feel weird and I don’t know why?! We couldn’t afford it for our child but even if we could I don’t agree with it. I feel like our children will now grow up very differently and I almost feel angry on my child’s behalf that my friend’s decision is what makes children like my own be at a disadvantage. I don’t know what I am asking really. Just feel like I am not as close to her since she told me and I also feel bad for our child that this is allowed to happen.

So in other words you're feeling insecure and jealous?

honeyandfizz · 02/07/2023 14:26

DD is at a top Uni and is room mates with a lad who went to our local boarding school which is circa 45k a year. DD went to state comp and college and both ended up at the same place. It will not disadvantage your child.

Hadjab · 02/07/2023 14:30

Your friend is doing what’s best for her child - sometimes you have to set aside your principles for your kids.

I was anti private education for years, until it came to actually getting my kids in to a decent secondary school, because there are very few in our area, and we were outside of the catchment area for the ones that are. Moving wasn’t an option as we would have needed a five bedroom house, which we couldn’t afford - we’d converted the loft to get the two extra bedrooms we needed, which was a far cheaper option, even factoring in school fees.

Private education doesn’t always guarantee your child a better start in life. At the end of the day, it’s up to your child to put the work in, wherever they end up.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 02/07/2023 14:33

Yabvu.

This post is very dramatic considering it has no bearing on your life or that of your dc at all. Your friend has taken a decision about their dc and you are trying to make it all about you. You seem over invested in her life and your post it quite an uncomfortable read if I’m honest.

I very much hope this reaction is out of character because if you behave like this every time someone makes a choice that you aren’t able to do or don’t 100% agree with, I’d imagine it would be very draining for everyone concerned.

Notjustabrunette · 02/07/2023 14:34

The schools in my town are very good with several rated as outstanding. Someone I know who lived in the catchment area of an outstanding school choose to send her child to a private school. She wasn’t happy with this school and after reception moved them
to a different private school 30 mins drive away. This school has just received a damming ofsted report. So she’s basically driving for 2 hours a day to send her child to a failing school rather than the excellent state school round the corner. I can’t see her decision as giving her child any sort of advantage to be honest.

BumpyaDaisyevna · 02/07/2023 14:35

You can go through life thinking that the reason I haven't got what I would like is cos someone else has taken up space or resources that should be mine if life were fair. Unfortunately though this locates the problem in the external world.

The real skill is to be someone who can really make best use of the opportunities that you in reality actually have.

Envy and jealousy only undermines that creative capacity unfortunately and makes you feel like a slave to a system rather than the agent of your own life.

BumpyaDaisyevna · 02/07/2023 14:38

So, no your son will not have the undoubted advantages of private school that your friends son will have.

But what can he do, where can he go, with the education that IS available to him, and how can you support him in making best possible use of that.

You can't make good use of something if you are feeling permanently aggrieved about that something not being as good as someone else's thing.

Hobnobswantshernameback · 02/07/2023 14:39

PMSL at the op dropping their little bomb and vanishing....

BlackSwan · 02/07/2023 14:47

Misplaced anger really. Look a little deeper.

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 02/07/2023 14:48

You’re clearly very jealous

Vivi0120 · 02/07/2023 14:51

I never understood what is the issue with private education?

My DC goes to private school. It cost a lot. We definitely can put the money towards our mortgage or something else but we chose to do this for her.

She was very shy and very closed child. She is also august born kid so she was really littlebwhen she started. She is extremely gentle and kind. She would have struggled so much in a class with 30+ kids.

She also has severe allergies and we don't trust a public school to handle her allergies as well I'm afraid.

We don't send her there because it's posh or because it gives her something academically it was just a decision based on her health and personality. As I said we need to be quite careful financially so we can afford it as well.

With this in mind, I don't see why this would offend anyone?

I just don't get why someone would judge people because they chose a private school for their child? Especially if you don't know the reason.

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 14:53

honeyandfizz · 02/07/2023 14:26

DD is at a top Uni and is room mates with a lad who went to our local boarding school which is circa 45k a year. DD went to state comp and college and both ended up at the same place. It will not disadvantage your child.

Your anecdotal evidence with a sample size of two is very compelling... What about the fact that at a population level, 7% are privately educated and yet 65% of senior judges are privately educated, 57% of the House of Lords are privately educated, and 65% of Rishi's cabinet were privately educated. Class inequality and elitism are rampant. You're living in denial. Your DD is the exception, not the rule.

Sunsetandsunrise · 02/07/2023 14:57

“I think it’s simplistic in the extreme to think that banning private schools would result in a levelling of the playing field. It wouldn’t. The playing field already isn’t level across the state sector.”

exactly, it tends to be middle class parents who say things like this knowing full well if everyone went to state schools they’d pull out all the stops for private tuition and enrich their child’s cultural education through travel and weekend visits to museums etc plus moving to the rich catchment areas to ensure they get the good state schools . Are they also going to not financially support their kid in uni because if they do it’s unfair their child doesn’t have to work throughout uni while other kids do? Will they pull back from helping their kid to get their door in a competitive industry by refusing to support them if they get an unpaid or low paid internship in London which they can only accept if their parents financially help them ? Where does it end if you’re genuinely so keen not to have an “advantage” over other kids.

I used to teach in an East Asian country where most kids went to state school but there were so many private after school academies and Rich kids going on travel abroad to learn English that there was a clear divide. Plus I don’t know why people are pretending they wouldn’t want to give their kids an advantage? There are so many people on mumsnet and beyond who literally stay in unhappy marriages because they know the stats show kids from two parent families typically do better. It’s literally what parents do…make sacrifices to give their kids an advantage.

ISpyNoPlumPie · 02/07/2023 14:57

Vivi0120 · 02/07/2023 14:51

I never understood what is the issue with private education?

My DC goes to private school. It cost a lot. We definitely can put the money towards our mortgage or something else but we chose to do this for her.

She was very shy and very closed child. She is also august born kid so she was really littlebwhen she started. She is extremely gentle and kind. She would have struggled so much in a class with 30+ kids.

She also has severe allergies and we don't trust a public school to handle her allergies as well I'm afraid.

We don't send her there because it's posh or because it gives her something academically it was just a decision based on her health and personality. As I said we need to be quite careful financially so we can afford it as well.

With this in mind, I don't see why this would offend anyone?

I just don't get why someone would judge people because they chose a private school for their child? Especially if you don't know the reason.

Really????

It doesn't offend anyone but can you really not see that you got to make a decision that you feel was in the best interests of your child that most people don't get to make? That makes you very privileged and that's great for you! Can you not see how there are probably thousands of children with the same traits your child has and yet this isn't an option?

chopc · 02/07/2023 14:58

OP the emotion you are feeling is jealousy

Just own it, see if you can deal with it and if you can't then I think your friendship is over

Vivi0120 · 02/07/2023 15:01

@ISpyNoPlumPie I agree with you, but in my experience and in my surroundings there have been a lot of people who can afford the fee and still judge me and make fun of my decision. I'm mostly referring to those people. I understand not everyone has the option no matter how hard they work etc.

Sunsetandsunrise · 02/07/2023 15:02

Ghosttofu99 · 02/07/2023 13:59

Exactly.

A two tier education system is what led us to one of the all-time worst governments led by Boris Johnson but op is going to get ripped because lots of people think it’s their right to use their money to advantage their children over others.

Its still a massively class based system in this country it’s just much better hidden now.

I don’t see the issue most parents uses their money to the best of their ability to provide benefits to their kids, which some Other parents of children can’t afford private academic tuition, music lessons, sports clubs or other extra curricular activities which can all benefit the children in the long term when it comes to uni or job applications. Should every parent pull out of all these extras so as not to give their child an “advantage”?

OP, you’re being very unreasonable btw and I’m glad that’s the general consensus here. If you disapprove move on from this friendship - your friend and her kids deserve better.