Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why is it a taboo to ‘ benefit bash ‘ on mn ?. See below for context.

300 replies

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 10:21

To be clear , am not talking about people on low wages / those wiith caring commitments/ Mental health or physical difficulties . Am talking about work avoidant people who expect benefits as a lifestyle on the back of others .

Yes it is harder now . Yes its a small group of the population .

But .. why is it taboo to discuss this on mn ?

Yes there are businesses who massively tax avoid , but two wrongs dont make a right.

Its a view I know is held in rl … is it that no one dare say these things on mn .. or is it something else. ???

To be clear -I am only talking about those who abuse the system, make it a ‘ my benefits’ way of being .

In my career ( in part with the benefits system) I have been told by some , the small group I am talking about ,that they wouldn't get out of bed for my wage . ( assuming they know what i got paid ! )

I realise it is much much harder to do this now , thats a good thing I just want to know why it seems to be a taboo subject specially on mn .

Yes -know some people will see this as goading.. however , I feel that the perceived majority of opinion dominates , and there is nothing wrong with discussing subjects that appear to be defined as taboo . ?

OP posts:
Bringonthesunshineporfavor · 28/04/2023 12:12

The problem is that people on UC who try and better themselves with a job or further study also get screwed over by UC which I am sure makes people feel reluctant to change their circumstances!
Close relative at Uni studying MA suddenly had 650 month deducted by UC and never got an explanation despite numerous attempts through UC and DWP.
The only way this person still has roof over head and continues her studies was through financial help from us …lucky we have the funds .
Now 8 months later she has suddenly been reimbursed by UC because it was a mistake!
So this is one explanation as to why many of these benefits claimants just probably lack incentive. Bloody shocking!

kittensinthekitchen · 28/04/2023 12:12

@CareBearScare123

So you would report the inaccuracies to the DWP, refuse to back up the claimants statement, and yet (you know) they were still successful at qualifying for PIP?

Theoneandonlyjrae · 28/04/2023 12:14

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 28/04/2023 10:41

See this is literally what I mean!

I’m a single parent to two children (I have two under two). My youngest has a rare genetic disorder which is an intellectual disability. He’s under the care of physio, OT, paediatrician, neurologist, dietician, ophthalmology and is currently waiting to start SALT and portage.

I’m his career so technically don’t have to work. I work three days a week to bring more money into the household because we simply can’t survive on UC. Is that okay with you? Or should we just struggle because you don’t think someone should be able to work PT and claim UC? Not everyone can work full time due to responsibilities. My son has up to three appointments a week and no job would allow me to constantly take time off for his appointments.

And this is a perfect example of why these threads never work. You, OP have spoken about people who take advantage of the system. Another poster comes along putting their two pence in speaking about people who work part time and claim UC. Do you see what I mean? These threads never stay on topic and people who mind their business just end up getting dragged down for no reason

This!!

I'm in the same position single mum, child with disability. I could survive on benefits but I want to keep working, even if it's part time. I don't know what his future might be, he may be an independent adult and I can then increase hours, but if I'm out of work whilst he is young, I will not be in a good position and I will need to start my career from scratch 🤷🏻‍♀️

LakieLady · 28/04/2023 12:14

gettingoldisshit · 28/04/2023 11:16

Op I don't agree that its only a minority that make benefits a lifestyle! Its only a minority that will ADMIT to doing that! In my previous work and in my community the majority are on some form of benefit and openly admit they would rather claim something they are not strictly entitled to rather than work 40 hours a week for the same money! People on MN are blinded to what actually goes on they refuse to accept that the system is very easy to play if you know how and that not everyone who is on benefits is living a hand to mouth existence on rubbish money!

I've done welfare rights work for 23 years. I don't think I'm in anyway "blinded" about what actually goes on.

In that time, the number of clients who've been getting benefits they're not entitled to is gobsmackingly tiny. And the vast majority of the time, that's due to oversight or the client not understanding the rules rather than deliberately playing the system. But around 20%-40% of cases aren't getting all the benefits they're entitled to.

In my team of 6, 4 of whom are part-time, we got gains for our clients of nearly £500k last year. That's £500k that was going unclaimed. And all the results for last year's work aren't in yet, because the wait for decisions and appeals is such a long one. That's an awful lot of people not getting an awful lot of money that the law says they should get.

I represented someone at a tribunal yesterday. His claim started in the financial year before last. If he succeeds, which I'm confident he will, he will get an arrears payment of £18k - £20k, probably a fair bit more by the time he gets the money. He's been living like an utter pauper, at considerable cost to his mental and physical health, for nearly 2 years, thanks to the benefit system being stacked against claimants.

I'd rather 10 people got a few quid more than they're entitled than have some poor soul go through what that man has been through, frankly.

YouTarzan · 28/04/2023 12:15

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 10:46

@ItsBritneyBitchhhh it was obvious from what I wrote!

It really wasn't!

Camablanca · 28/04/2023 12:15

SerendipityJane · 28/04/2023 11:57

Because it is a fucking simple question, not a request for the standard deviation to 4 decimal places adjusted for seasonal variations around the TV viewing habits of San Salvador.

Any halfway sane person would suspect that chasing the tax avoided, evaded and uncollected would be a far better usage of resources than chasing benefit fraud.

By all means, feel free to question the numbers, their source, and presentation. But none of that in and of itself changes what the graphic is telling you. If you are listening.

We all know the real reason no one ever answers it is because to do so would reveal their agenda. Which is never about saving money and all about punishing the poor the ill the sick and the vulnerable. The same way the bedroom tax has cost far more to operate than it ever saved.

Well I'm perfectly happy to agree that the bigger figure should be focused on, but at a fundamental level I'm capable of having multiple perspectives.
Regardless of how much 'tax', money etc you recoup it will never be enough if the government continues to funnel it to their mates.
Equally the benefits and taxation system can also have distorted incentives.

What the OP is trying to say is that any discussion of the latter is immediately shouted down as 'benefits bashing'. Perhaps because it's very difficult to have a reasonable, balanced discussion in general without it turning into an emotive shouting match.

TiredOfCleaning · 28/04/2023 12:16

OneForTheRoadThen · 28/04/2023 10:54

What I have trouble with is people on Mumsnet who earn over £100k are always told to put the extra into their pension so they can still claim benefits such as the 30hours free childcare yet a single mum, working part time and on a UC top up is often subject to vitriol and told to up her hours and stop claiming benefits. It's ok only for high earners it seems.

Yes. I saw pretty much this on a thread this very week and wondered why no-one pointed that out.

user1497207191 · 28/04/2023 12:16

@LakieLady

I'd rather 10 people got a few quid more than they're entitled than have some poor soul go through what that man has been through, frankly.

How does other people getting more than they're entitled to help that man though?

Hobbi · 28/04/2023 12:17

Is there a taboo on correctly formatted punctuation?

Redebs · 28/04/2023 12:17

Sapphire387 · 28/04/2023 10:33

Because it perpetuates unhelpful stereotypes and leads to people lumping all benefit claimants into a group and calling them scroungers.

Why do you feel the need to do this anyway, what's lacking in your life?

This

Cornchip · 28/04/2023 12:18

A lot of posters on Mumsnet are incredibly naive if they think that this happens as little as it supposedly does.

It’s easy to assume it doesn’t happen when you live in a nice leafy green middle class suburb but the reality is actually quite different.

Everyone who knows them knows, it’s not a secret in most cases. People don’t tend to report simply because they don’t want to end up with trouble on their own doorstep because of it. It’s easier to play the system than people think.

Sallyh87 · 28/04/2023 12:18

Not that I am very knowledgeable about benefits but as far as I know it’s a very small amount of money. Yes, I fully believe there will be a small contingent of people living solely on benefits and ‘choosing’ not to work. However, it’s such a small amount of money, I really doubt many would do this.

As for the poster who complained about people working part time and claiming benefits. Why is this an issue? Some people aren’t able to work full time, those with caring responsibilities, single parents etc. Surely supporting them to work part time is a real benefit to society.

Mostly, I wonder why people worry about what others are claiming? It’s not like if one person stops claiming, I wont suddenly get given extra money. I think being bitter about people claiming a meagre amount of money, is no way to live your life.

Ive never had any benefits but I have used the NHS a lot due to many health conditions and I’m sure it has been hugely expensive. I think it’s important for society to look after each other.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 28/04/2023 12:18

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 10:21

To be clear , am not talking about people on low wages / those wiith caring commitments/ Mental health or physical difficulties . Am talking about work avoidant people who expect benefits as a lifestyle on the back of others .

Yes it is harder now . Yes its a small group of the population .

But .. why is it taboo to discuss this on mn ?

Yes there are businesses who massively tax avoid , but two wrongs dont make a right.

Its a view I know is held in rl … is it that no one dare say these things on mn .. or is it something else. ???

To be clear -I am only talking about those who abuse the system, make it a ‘ my benefits’ way of being .

In my career ( in part with the benefits system) I have been told by some , the small group I am talking about ,that they wouldn't get out of bed for my wage . ( assuming they know what i got paid ! )

I realise it is much much harder to do this now , thats a good thing I just want to know why it seems to be a taboo subject specially on mn .

Yes -know some people will see this as goading.. however , I feel that the perceived majority of opinion dominates , and there is nothing wrong with discussing subjects that appear to be defined as taboo . ?

'Yes there are business that massively tax avoid new but two wrongs don't make a right.'

So can that be twisted around "Why is it taboo to bash Tax avoiders"......Yes I know we have feckless lazy bone idle people who won't get off their fat butts and get a job, but two wrongs don't make a right or is it a different set of rules the rich privileged and elite. You can't have things both ways.

Bringonthesunshineporfavor · 28/04/2023 12:19

Resilience · 28/04/2023 12:00

I'll bite.Wink

I think this comes down to your underlying philosophy on life. If you believe that most physically and psychologically healthy adults need a self view of themselves as being worthy of respect, it answers the question.

Most people on benefits hate it. Governments and society encourage others to look down on it and there's this constant niggling anxiety that it can be taken away at any time. It's a precarious way to live and if you're a single person without dependents it's barely at subsistence level. It's a lot more generous when children are involved but far from luxurious and certainly hasn't kept pace with the COL. Plus children grow up.

I don't blame people for choosing not to take work if it's not paid more than benefits. Despite the promises about always being better off in work, this simply isn't true. The comparison is based on income and ignores the additional outgoings of things like travel to work, which often leaves people on NMW work worse off. If you're barely getting by on benefits you'll go under if you take that job.

Many people will take work when it's a marginal improvement as it improves their self esteem. Work is about more than money (even for those with jobs rather than careers) and the anxiety associated with benefits.

Anyone who is happy to live off a subsistence amount week in, week out, year in, year out, is someone whose life has not gone the way they hoped. Despite what might be interpreted as arrogance, laziness or even aggression, underlying that is a belief that they probably couldn't hold down a decent job anyway.

Which brings us to the next point. If all benefits were scrapped, who exacted would be employing these 'scroungers' who may now want to work but might also lack any kind of employment skills, be barely literate, have terrible organisation skills... Do we just let them starve?

The real crime is that we have a society that consistently produces people like this through underfunding education and social care and placing little value on supporting families.

I've met benefit 'scroungers' and cheats. Many are actively dislikable. However, not in a million years would I change position with them which tells me everything I need to know about how genuine a 'choice' their 'choice' to live like that is. It's a symptom not a cause.

Very well thought out post .X

Bedtimemode · 28/04/2023 12:19

I've been involved with hiring for retail work and honestly some people are just completely unemployable. I'm not sure they can so anything other than claim benefits and I think that's fine.

SecretVictoria · 28/04/2023 12:20

I think it’s because there are people like me (a few years ago) and a couple of my work colleagues who earn a low wage but aren’t entitled to anything, apart from the council tax discount (if single). In my case, it worked out to a fiver a week. This is because we don’t have DC/DC don’t live with us all the time.

I am extremely fortunate that DH has a good pension, and wanted to marry me, otherwise I’d be homeless. A colleague is really struggling; he’s applied for better paid jobs but been unsuccessful. He has DC but due to his shifts, they’re with his EXW and he has them EOW.

Then you have my SD who is in her late 30s and has never, ever worked. Nor, until the last few years had her DH.

It’s very, very hard if you are a single adult with no DC. There’s zero help available, even though you still have to pay rent/bills/travel/food and, apart from maybe being able to rent a smaller home (though not many 1-beds around) and maybe a bit more on food (though you can save on multi buy offers if there’s more than 1 of you) the heating/petrol/water/travel is the same.

OneTC · 28/04/2023 12:22

This is like the people that post on here saying that MN is massively pro dogs or massively pro cyclist. It's weird how people perceive the same data so differently.

There's plenty of benefit bashing on here, fill your boots if it's what you want to do.

Sittingonabench · 28/04/2023 12:22

I suspect it’s because of the likelihood of a witch hunt mentality. Perhaps in your work you do come across people who game the system and you can see the ins and outs of their circumstances to know. But the majority of people do not have that information and so it’s a case of making accusations without knowing the circumstances. They also don’t know the statistics and so generalisations can be made without foundation. I don’t think the topic should be shut down but when it is directed to one person I do think it’s in bad taste.

orangegato · 28/04/2023 12:26

kittensinthekitchen · 28/04/2023 11:45

MOST claimants are claiming fraudulently? Gosh, have you informed the Government of your research results?

Not fraudulently, just claiming by choice. I never mentioned fraud. It’s a lifestyle for anyone who doesn’t want to work.

I get some do but many don’t as why would they work their arse off to pay for their accommodation and spending money when taxpayers are currently paying? It’s naive to think this is rare.

No one is committing a crime, the system allows for this and can do nothing about it.

NotQuiteUsual · 28/04/2023 12:26

I don't think anyone who genuinely believes the best life they can have is that of a serial benefits claimant who will never work, is someone who is going to be able manage in the workforce anyway.

People who have had healthy, supportive and safe upbringings, who don't have some kind of trauma or mental health issues diagnosed or not don't grow up to aspire to it. These people were generally raised on benefits and come from generational poverty. What poverty does to a person's brain and development is pretty severe. Plus with a lot of early intervention and community projects scraped due to funding, there's little help for them before the damage is done.

Apairofsparklingeyes · 28/04/2023 12:29

I’d be happier if the government put more resources into chasing fathers who don’t pay CM rather than penalising single mothers who work part time.

habbiespond · 28/04/2023 12:29

What I find interesting is that benefit claimants are shocked that people don't want to go to work to pay for others to not bother.

They're actually angry themselves at the people who pay for their lifestyle. It's bizarre.

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 28/04/2023 12:30

People can't sit on benefits.
There are very very few people playing the system.
The problem is everyone thinks they know everyone's business so just because they see dave down the pub off work with a bad back they assume he's not really got a bad back because otherwise he wouldn't be in the pub. In reality they know nothing about his PRIVATE medical business but like to froth at the mouth claiming he's playing the system, just because it doesn't fit in with what they think he SHOULD be doing to recover.

ToWhitToWhoo · 28/04/2023 12:31

The reason that it's often treated as taboo here is that very often 'people on low wages / those wiith caring commitments/ Mental health or physical difficulties' are assumed to be 'work avoidant people who expect benefits as a lifestyle on the back of others', and who basically need 'tough love' and a good kicking.

It is not possible to claim benefits honestly as a lifestyle choice: goverments make it very difficult to be eligible for benefits. There are certainly benefit cheats, who claim benefits dishonestly, and I have no problems with bashing them! It is the idea that the government is too generous toward genuinely poor or disabled people that I find upsetting.

CareBearScare123 · 28/04/2023 12:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.