Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why is it a taboo to ‘ benefit bash ‘ on mn ?. See below for context.

300 replies

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 10:21

To be clear , am not talking about people on low wages / those wiith caring commitments/ Mental health or physical difficulties . Am talking about work avoidant people who expect benefits as a lifestyle on the back of others .

Yes it is harder now . Yes its a small group of the population .

But .. why is it taboo to discuss this on mn ?

Yes there are businesses who massively tax avoid , but two wrongs dont make a right.

Its a view I know is held in rl … is it that no one dare say these things on mn .. or is it something else. ???

To be clear -I am only talking about those who abuse the system, make it a ‘ my benefits’ way of being .

In my career ( in part with the benefits system) I have been told by some , the small group I am talking about ,that they wouldn't get out of bed for my wage . ( assuming they know what i got paid ! )

I realise it is much much harder to do this now , thats a good thing I just want to know why it seems to be a taboo subject specially on mn .

Yes -know some people will see this as goading.. however , I feel that the perceived majority of opinion dominates , and there is nothing wrong with discussing subjects that appear to be defined as taboo . ?

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 28/04/2023 11:48

Viviennemary · 28/04/2023 11:25

It annoys me that some people do well on benefits and others really struggle. Whole system needs to be overhauled. Pay nothing in get nothing out. Thats the system in some countries.

Yes indeed. There's a graph showing how other countries pay much higher "out of work" benefits, some up to 70/80% of wages prior to unemployment. Which makes them look good, but it's based on the "prior employment". Those who had low wages (or no wages), got very low amounts, if anything! The time of such largesse was also limited, with some countries drastically reducing the benefits after 2 years, and some down to virtually nothing after 5 years.

Perhaps that's where we should be heading in the UK. Benefits based on what you earned whilst you were working, and time limited, just so people can "live" during temporary period of unemployment rather than benefits for life.

Porkandbeans1 · 28/04/2023 11:49

Because it's hard to know who is genuine and who is not. I know people who play on their issues and could do a lot more. I have a relative who has never had a job, lives with his parents and has a list of medical issues. Well he did until meeting his girlfriend and now wants to have a child with her. Now he claims he's well enough to look after a child whilst she works, but before couldn't be left alone incase he had a "flare up" or self harmed.

And on the flip side I know someone who had a life changing back injury and has had to fight every step of the way to get the little money they receive.

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 11:49

orangegato · 28/04/2023 11:39

I’ve worked administering them and I can tell you they make up a large proportion of claimants. Able bodied, choose not to work cause pop out a couple of kids and get a house, council tax and spends for free.

Bleeding hearts folk don’t like to acknowledge it’s a lifestyle choice for MOST claimants. If you aren’t disabled or have lost your job and are using it as a safety net while getting back on your feet, you should be working.

Thank god you are not still working in benefit admin is all I can say.

Camablanca · 28/04/2023 11:50

privileged · 28/04/2023 11:48

I don't like people benefit bashing because those that have done this around me have usually been very privileged or fortunate themselves. Ex sil married at 23, humongous flat handed to her and husband on a plate by daddy and in laws- think 3 super king size bedrooms with family size en-suite bathrooms for each, drawing room with bathroom, living room, kitchen and a room where the live in help slept. A daily cleaner and ironing lady and a girl who looked after the children as well as a live in driver/ man Friday. She didn't want to give the kids hand me downs to the servants as they didn't deserve it. Those families are not likely to be able to pull themselves out of their situations.

She now lives here and that lifestyle has gone but she would slag off her customers ( bank branch employee) who she knew were on benefits and therefore automatically lazy and the English should do something about that. Hard to hear from someone so privileged. Meanwhile her wage for several years was pure pocket money as it was DH's job to provide for every need and solely his problem if he couldn't meet what she deemed were there needs. When he couldn't live up to it they didn't need benefits because daddy stepped in and sent several hundred a month.

Having said all that I was very surprised to be told by a school mum that they get UC top ups as they wanted her to be at home while kids small. The husband does work and a lot but surprised it was an option.

R.e the final paragraph childcare can cost a lot more so if you have one under 3 that makes sense. Not if they're both schoolgoing though

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 11:50

Trinity65 i most definitely would .

OP posts:
Enncee · 28/04/2023 11:50

kittensinthekitchen · 28/04/2023 11:42

So did these people not have to provide the evidence of disability that you presumably did? Including the couple that your mum gossips about?

I don't know, but I can see you're just having a dig with the gossiping part. Perhaps just read where I say she is a close friend of hers to this day.
We didn't question them on the paperwork needed, no. She mentioned that claiming for it meant they wouldn't ask her to find work, mum wished she could stay at home too. That was it... Gossiping would likely have had her sanctioned with 2 young children if it ended up being reported and - shock horror - we like her and didn't want that to happen. 🙄

Bringonthesunshineporfavor · 28/04/2023 11:51

TeaKitten · 28/04/2023 10:31

It never stays about just bashing those people though does it, everyone ventured out into slagging off those who don’t manage to get higher paid jobs or dare to have children without being high earners. So it’s bound to result in people wanting to shut it down because it never sticks to what you are talking about.

I was just going to say exactly this !

Mrsjayy · 28/04/2023 11:52

It is taboo because once you start talking about "the family down the street " being lazy blah blah it turns into a free for all,

there is nothing to be achieved starting a thread about the "family down the street" but I think op you know that but started the thread anyway.

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 11:52

Porkandbeans1 · 28/04/2023 11:49

Because it's hard to know who is genuine and who is not. I know people who play on their issues and could do a lot more. I have a relative who has never had a job, lives with his parents and has a list of medical issues. Well he did until meeting his girlfriend and now wants to have a child with her. Now he claims he's well enough to look after a child whilst she works, but before couldn't be left alone incase he had a "flare up" or self harmed.

And on the flip side I know someone who had a life changing back injury and has had to fight every step of the way to get the little money they receive.

God forbid that someone might want to try and overcome their mental health issues and move on with their life, eh?

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 28/04/2023 11:52

Why do you feel like you can't talk about it? Noones stopping you. A lot will probably have a different opinion to you but that's what having a discussion is all about.

I don't understand why you think it's taboo and that you're banned from talking about it?

Takemehome7 · 28/04/2023 11:54

Loooads of subjects are taboo on mn that aren't in real life.

Thelnebriati · 28/04/2023 11:55

Because it's hard to know who is genuine and who is not.

You think its your place to judge, but in fact people don't have to discuss the ins and outs of their lives with you. Especially not after they realise you are using the information against them.

Beginningless · 28/04/2023 11:56

I think it’s ok to discuss your views, so YANBU in that sense, but to expect to discuss them without robust disagreement would be U. I have also worked with people probably fitting the profile you describe, but I don’t frame it the way you do. I think people who have grown up through generations of poverty/addiction/violence and being looked at as the underclass of society (possibly by people like you) are quite likely to internalise that, think ‘I can’t have that life’ and decide to have a ‘fuck you’ attitude to a society that has never really given a fuck about them. You can’t discuss the individual attitudes without considering the cultural and structural forces that shape these attitudes.

kittensinthekitchen · 28/04/2023 11:56

Viviennemary · 28/04/2023 11:25

It annoys me that some people do well on benefits and others really struggle. Whole system needs to be overhauled. Pay nothing in get nothing out. Thats the system in some countries.

And what about those who can't pay in? Or who will never be able to pay in enough?

SerendipityJane · 28/04/2023 11:57

Camablanca · 28/04/2023 11:33

How is anybody supposed to answer anything with a couple of colourful, out of context circles?
Provide the full report and justification, then maybe we can comment.
You also don't have to focus on only one thing

Because it is a fucking simple question, not a request for the standard deviation to 4 decimal places adjusted for seasonal variations around the TV viewing habits of San Salvador.

Any halfway sane person would suspect that chasing the tax avoided, evaded and uncollected would be a far better usage of resources than chasing benefit fraud.

By all means, feel free to question the numbers, their source, and presentation. But none of that in and of itself changes what the graphic is telling you. If you are listening.

We all know the real reason no one ever answers it is because to do so would reveal their agenda. Which is never about saving money and all about punishing the poor the ill the sick and the vulnerable. The same way the bedroom tax has cost far more to operate than it ever saved.

Resilience · 28/04/2023 12:00

I'll bite.Wink

I think this comes down to your underlying philosophy on life. If you believe that most physically and psychologically healthy adults need a self view of themselves as being worthy of respect, it answers the question.

Most people on benefits hate it. Governments and society encourage others to look down on it and there's this constant niggling anxiety that it can be taken away at any time. It's a precarious way to live and if you're a single person without dependents it's barely at subsistence level. It's a lot more generous when children are involved but far from luxurious and certainly hasn't kept pace with the COL. Plus children grow up.

I don't blame people for choosing not to take work if it's not paid more than benefits. Despite the promises about always being better off in work, this simply isn't true. The comparison is based on income and ignores the additional outgoings of things like travel to work, which often leaves people on NMW work worse off. If you're barely getting by on benefits you'll go under if you take that job.

Many people will take work when it's a marginal improvement as it improves their self esteem. Work is about more than money (even for those with jobs rather than careers) and the anxiety associated with benefits.

Anyone who is happy to live off a subsistence amount week in, week out, year in, year out, is someone whose life has not gone the way they hoped. Despite what might be interpreted as arrogance, laziness or even aggression, underlying that is a belief that they probably couldn't hold down a decent job anyway.

Which brings us to the next point. If all benefits were scrapped, who exacted would be employing these 'scroungers' who may now want to work but might also lack any kind of employment skills, be barely literate, have terrible organisation skills... Do we just let them starve?

The real crime is that we have a society that consistently produces people like this through underfunding education and social care and placing little value on supporting families.

I've met benefit 'scroungers' and cheats. Many are actively dislikable. However, not in a million years would I change position with them which tells me everything I need to know about how genuine a 'choice' their 'choice' to live like that is. It's a symptom not a cause.

ShowUs · 28/04/2023 12:01

There was a thread on here not so long ago about a woman claiming to be single to claim benefits & council tax reduction etc but her partner was living with her and the majority of posters said it was absolutely fine and the OP should keep her nose out.

I think it just shows how many people do commit benefit fraud as I’d assume the majority of the posters saying it was ok also commit benefit fraud.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 28/04/2023 12:01

When the world economy is being run as a capitalist pyramid scheme designed to keep wealth and power in the hands of a very few, with copious amounts of brainwashing that by taking enough personal responsibility anyone can succeed, society will remain forever dysfunctional.

The devil really is in the detail here - the "bashing" of a proven by research to be a vanishingly small group by those also struggling is engineered to deflect ire away from the profiteers at the top of the pyramid.

As industrialisation and the two world wars devastated Europe do you really think the state provided infrastructure and welfare state was all concocted out of pure altruism? No - it was a direct result of realising that if the masses didn't get some semblance of bread and circuses they might turn on their masters.... the Russian Revolution was a good lesson for other world leaders.

In addition state support partly guarantees a healthier, fitter army and workforce to keep filling the coffers of those at the top of the tree.

So this picking over people who allegedly make bad choices, when actually we are now being rendered all but obsolete by the march of technology is a desired activity because the future is going to be dystopian, and it will be engineered, and blamed on anyone but the actual perpetrators.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 28/04/2023 12:03

@Resilience

Your post is excellent.

CareBearScare123 · 28/04/2023 12:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Porkandbeans1 · 28/04/2023 12:05

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 11:52

God forbid that someone might want to try and overcome their mental health issues and move on with their life, eh?

Then he should work on his issues and get his life sorted before having a child.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/04/2023 12:07

MN is a big forum, OP, so inevitably there'll be some who fit the demographic you meant - and not unnaturally, given the anonymity, they're likely to be noisy in insisting you're a judgemental b*tch, etc, etc.

I do get the point about steretypes being unhelpful to all the genuine claimants, but in RL I suspect most have the sense to be able to tell the difference, especially if it's thrust in their faces

Gemma2003 · 28/04/2023 12:09

Because all it achieves is making some people feel worse about their already challenging lives. Those who are lazy or feckless won't care or change their ways. Those who have been dealt a bad hand will feel bad.

daisymoonlight · 28/04/2023 12:09

user1497207191 · 28/04/2023 10:28

YANBU, same as tax evasion when MN'ers seem to think it's fine for tradesmen to do "cash in hand" work and not declare it "because of Starbucks", likewise they condone pop stars, footballers, and other slebs who play the system by using tax avoidance schemes, "living" in tax havens, etc "because of Amazon".

I agree with this 100%. Either tax evasion is wrong or it isnt. Yes, the amounts are different for a tradesman or amazon obviously but the act is exactly the same. Thats like saying stealing is wrong but only if its over a certain amount of £ or assault is wrong but not if it only causes a small red mark rather than a broken bone. Who made them judge and jury to say what amount of stealing or tax evasion makes it "ok" because everyone will have different opinions on that amount! Either something is wrong or it isnt, you cant gymnastic your way out of it based on the amount of money involved.

I wonder if those same people would be ok about a friend stealing from them as long as it was only a tenner and not thousands?

feellikeanalien · 28/04/2023 12:12

Resilience · 28/04/2023 12:00

I'll bite.Wink

I think this comes down to your underlying philosophy on life. If you believe that most physically and psychologically healthy adults need a self view of themselves as being worthy of respect, it answers the question.

Most people on benefits hate it. Governments and society encourage others to look down on it and there's this constant niggling anxiety that it can be taken away at any time. It's a precarious way to live and if you're a single person without dependents it's barely at subsistence level. It's a lot more generous when children are involved but far from luxurious and certainly hasn't kept pace with the COL. Plus children grow up.

I don't blame people for choosing not to take work if it's not paid more than benefits. Despite the promises about always being better off in work, this simply isn't true. The comparison is based on income and ignores the additional outgoings of things like travel to work, which often leaves people on NMW work worse off. If you're barely getting by on benefits you'll go under if you take that job.

Many people will take work when it's a marginal improvement as it improves their self esteem. Work is about more than money (even for those with jobs rather than careers) and the anxiety associated with benefits.

Anyone who is happy to live off a subsistence amount week in, week out, year in, year out, is someone whose life has not gone the way they hoped. Despite what might be interpreted as arrogance, laziness or even aggression, underlying that is a belief that they probably couldn't hold down a decent job anyway.

Which brings us to the next point. If all benefits were scrapped, who exacted would be employing these 'scroungers' who may now want to work but might also lack any kind of employment skills, be barely literate, have terrible organisation skills... Do we just let them starve?

The real crime is that we have a society that consistently produces people like this through underfunding education and social care and placing little value on supporting families.

I've met benefit 'scroungers' and cheats. Many are actively dislikable. However, not in a million years would I change position with them which tells me everything I need to know about how genuine a 'choice' their 'choice' to live like that is. It's a symptom not a cause.

Excellent post.