Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why is it a taboo to ‘ benefit bash ‘ on mn ?. See below for context.

300 replies

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 10:21

To be clear , am not talking about people on low wages / those wiith caring commitments/ Mental health or physical difficulties . Am talking about work avoidant people who expect benefits as a lifestyle on the back of others .

Yes it is harder now . Yes its a small group of the population .

But .. why is it taboo to discuss this on mn ?

Yes there are businesses who massively tax avoid , but two wrongs dont make a right.

Its a view I know is held in rl … is it that no one dare say these things on mn .. or is it something else. ???

To be clear -I am only talking about those who abuse the system, make it a ‘ my benefits’ way of being .

In my career ( in part with the benefits system) I have been told by some , the small group I am talking about ,that they wouldn't get out of bed for my wage . ( assuming they know what i got paid ! )

I realise it is much much harder to do this now , thats a good thing I just want to know why it seems to be a taboo subject specially on mn .

Yes -know some people will see this as goading.. however , I feel that the perceived majority of opinion dominates , and there is nothing wrong with discussing subjects that appear to be defined as taboo . ?

OP posts:
Arginalia · 28/04/2023 18:20

LadyMuckingabout · 28/04/2023 18:16

I think thousands of people would love to do an MA but the cost is prohibitive. Should everyone be entitled to study for one and be supported by benefits while they do? Every young graduate? Every middle-aged mum? Every burnt-out bloke?

Yes - I do think these opportunities should be available to all rather than being the preserve of the wealthy.

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 18:24

If that study leads to a job that gets them off benefits…what then?

Any job could get them off benefits not just one that requires a masters. Do you think anybody should be able to quit work to do a masters and have the taxpayer subsidise it all?

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:25

I just find that needlessly defensive and ungrateful

you know it’s OK for people to not want to discuss their personal circumstances with….anyone at all? That people don’t have to justify their existence to strangers or feel the need to bow down at the feet of tax payers.

I’ve claimed benefits for years. I work full time. I have a disabled child. You knowing that doesn’t change what I’m entitled to, does it? You don’t get to pity me and nor do you get to hold me up as some kind of shining example of what can be achieved if only everyone would stare down the shit hand they have been dealt. My circumstances are my own. They don’t apply to anyone else.

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 18:25

Arginalia · 28/04/2023 18:20

Yes - I do think these opportunities should be available to all rather than being the preserve of the wealthy.

The naivety about how much things cost and the pie-in-the-sky thinking on here is astonishing

ToWhitToWhoo · 28/04/2023 18:26

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 14:07

This confirms my suspicions from speaking to other professionals.

I think what a lot of people forget is that a lot of people who are in work have issues - be it mental health, physical health, or life circumstances. But work anyway, it doesn’t occur to a lot of them to do more than be signed off for a few weeks at the height of whatever it is they’re going through.

It isn’t a case of ‘people in work skip through life with luck and in perfect health, and only people claiming benefits have issues so those in work could never possibly understand’.

Which is why I find it quite offensive when people claiming benefits think people in work are not entitled to an opinion because ‘they have never gone through what I am’. When quite often they have.

But if everyone with depression or a long term health issue or childcare problems just sacked off work and claimed benefits, there would be no money raised to pay anybody’s benefits.

Well, I'm one of those people, who has a number of physical health problems and mostly-invisible disabilities, which have indirectly cost me quite a lot of money over my life, and restricted me in various ways. And who has nevertheless always worked and never claimed benefits.

So I suppose I should be one of the people, who is strongly anti-skiver and in favour of Daily Mail/ IDS- style harshness toward benefit claimants.

Well, that would be half-correct, I suppose. I am anti-skiver. But as far as the rest is concerned, my experiences have made me less, not more, in favour of excessive suspiciousness toward vulnerable people and especially of so-called 'tough love' approaches:

(1) I am aware that I have been LUCKY to be able to manage; there have been numerous times when it seemed like I would go over the edge; and as regards benefit claimants,'there but for the grace of God (family support, educational opportunities, certain abilities that I didn't consciously choose to have; and just sheer luck at certain times) go I'.

(2) When this sort of suspiciousness is encouraged, it very rarely ends up confined just to benefit claimants, or even just to those needing some form of financial help, but often ends up applied to anyone who may need any sort of adaptations. 'Well, if you can do X, why can't you do Y?' An always emotionally damaging and often practically damaging attitude to people with health problems and disabilities, which, if they are in the category capable of work, usually involve difficulties in specific areas, rather than all areas. Of course the system needs to involve careful checks for fraud, but I would rather be occasionally cheated, as an individual or as a taxpayer, than have to deal with increased public harshness toward disabilities and health problems.

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:28

Any job could get them off benefits not just one that requires a masters. Do you think anybody should be able to quit work to do a masters and have the taxpayer subsidise it all?

so….whilst we’re playing hypothetical. One year in minimum wage job, £1k a month paid out in benefits. One year studying, £2.5k a month paid in benefits. Post-MA, £300 a month paid out in benefits for 4 years and then nothing at all when the career ladder is climbed. Why are you trying to keep people down? It makes sense in the medium and long term.

Lwrenagain · 28/04/2023 18:30

I know a loads of people who are as the OP describes and I think when they tell you, "they'd not get out of bed for minimum wage" etc, they're quite possibly just lying to themselves.
Often with these people its lack of education and low self esteem/confidence.

I'm sure not everyone but being from a really shitty place originally, think underclass - lowest social economic area in the UK, but many of the people I grew up with are so disadvantaged, even basics such as personal hygiene are absolutely fucked.
You hear people say "go work in nursing homes/cafes" but as someone who has worked those jobs I tell you now, you'd not want people who struggle to brush their own teeth looking after your grandmother or making you a sausage butty.

I'm sure there are plenty who just don't want to work, but I'd make a guess there's many more who just don't have the basic skills to realistically keep down a job.

Just my opinion but poverty is so complicated and its really tough to drag people out of years and years of believing that a house with a burnt out car and knackered couch in the front garden isn't the be all and end all.

MaryCrawford · 28/04/2023 18:32

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:07

She must have been getting a fair amount if they deducted £650 and for what...sitting on her arse and studying for an M.A. She should get up, get to work and pay to do her M.A part time or do it when she retires...you know, from work. Frankly, I don't give a flying wet fart if she can only have incentive if her benefits keep rolling in. Bollocks to her incentive

see, this is the problem, isn’t it? You know fuck all about a stranger on the internet’s family member. Their circumstances, life chances, the shit that has been thrown at them or indeed, what it is they are studying for. If that study leads to a job that gets them off benefits…what then? You still deny them the opportunity? Better to have poorly educated, low paid people beholden than working and independent?

Well, you can type out any sort of fairy story that you like to justify this woman being paid to sit on her arse and study for an M.A.

However, I'm quite sure that if only one of your scenarios appertained here, then then the cousin would have fallen over herself to include it.

So, the chances are no such scenario exists.

My thoughts on the M.A. student are just as valid as yours and, in fact, more so, as my thought are those formulated after reading the facts presented in the original post and yours have been pulled out of your arse based on fuck all.

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:35

However, I'm quite sure that if only one of your scenarios appertained here, then then the cousin would have fallen over herself to include it.So, the chances are no such scenario exists

why should anyone have to include details of their situation to anyone at all? It’s fuck all to do with anyone. You don’t get to decide who is worthy and who isn’t. Most people will experience adversity at some point in their lives. You have no idea what is around your corner.

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:36

My thoughts on the M.A. student are just as valid as yours and, in fact, more so, as my thought are those formulated after reading the facts presented in the original post and yours have been pulled out of your arse based on fuck all

and just who exactly is entitled now?!

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 18:40

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:25

I just find that needlessly defensive and ungrateful

you know it’s OK for people to not want to discuss their personal circumstances with….anyone at all? That people don’t have to justify their existence to strangers or feel the need to bow down at the feet of tax payers.

I’ve claimed benefits for years. I work full time. I have a disabled child. You knowing that doesn’t change what I’m entitled to, does it? You don’t get to pity me and nor do you get to hold me up as some kind of shining example of what can be achieved if only everyone would stare down the shit hand they have been dealt. My circumstances are my own. They don’t apply to anyone else.

They have to justify them to DWP surely?

And when did I say I pity you?

Not a single person has said they begrudge benefits going to carers or the disabled

ToWhitToWhoo · 28/04/2023 18:42

vodkaredbullgirl · 28/04/2023 10:58

🙄Well it is an option and it will not change.

And if it weren't an option, the taxpayers would probably have to pay a lot more in the end for childcare and adult social care than they do on UC for people who work part-time to enable them to care for their children and/or elderly relatives.

MaryCrawford · 28/04/2023 18:46

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:35

However, I'm quite sure that if only one of your scenarios appertained here, then then the cousin would have fallen over herself to include it.So, the chances are no such scenario exists

why should anyone have to include details of their situation to anyone at all? It’s fuck all to do with anyone. You don’t get to decide who is worthy and who isn’t. Most people will experience adversity at some point in their lives. You have no idea what is around your corner.

Yes. I thought that would be your half baked response.

The poster, entirely of her own volition, gave us the example of her poor cousin studying for her M.A. on benefits and undergoing a harrowing experience when those benefits were temporarily pulled.

We were all invited to join in-as you enthusiastically have- with a Greek chorus of tearing our hair, ripping our clothes and beating our breasts, as we all wailed at the unfairness of it.

So, having gone thus far to tell us about this dreadful situation, she would have included more heart rending facts if they had been available in order to ramp up the outrage.

A cynic would say there are no heart rending details-the poster obviously though what she had written was heart rending enough. She may now, come back with more details-having had time to think of a few-or alternatively, she may just allow rather silly posters to provide completely imaginary details for her.

And lo! Over the hill comes you @Changechangechanging to do just that.

Her cousin should get off her arse and pay for her own M.A. while working. She is not owed an M.A by the state...she could maybe ask an employer to pay-as many do-if her M.A, is in any worthwhile.

MaryCrawford · 28/04/2023 18:47

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:36

My thoughts on the M.A. student are just as valid as yours and, in fact, more so, as my thought are those formulated after reading the facts presented in the original post and yours have been pulled out of your arse based on fuck all

and just who exactly is entitled now?!

I'm certainly entitled to my opinion and surprised that you would deny that, based on your open handed attitude to those entitled to do further degrees while unable to support themselves.

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:48

And there isn’t one fact in the original post. All based on the OP’s opinion.

I sat on benefits as a single mum for a number of years following a traumatising marriage breakdown whilst pregnant. I lost absolutely everything. I later retrained to teach in a shortage subject and have been doing that for the last 15 years. I used to receive a small fortune in benefits - I am no longer entitled to anything and haven’t been for about 8 years now. If I had taken any job in the god forsaken place I live in (industry has been decimated by covid locally, most of what is available is retail/restaurant/retail), I would still be claiming. It made sense to pay me to train at that point in my life.

and to be clear, my child’s condition is such that he receives DLA and I could be sat at home claiming Carer’s Allowance if I wished. We muddle through, although th awfully hospitalisations are far less than they used to be.

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:50

A cynic would say there are no heart rending details-the poster obviously though what she had written was heart rending enough. She may now, come back with more details-having had time to think of a few-or alternatively, she may just allow rather silly posters to provide completely imaginary details for her

I hope she doesn’t. No one owes you an explanation.

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:53

They have to justify them to DWP surely?

sure. Not to anyone else.

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 18:56

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 18:53

They have to justify them to DWP surely?

sure. Not to anyone else.

But nobody’s asked them to. This is a thread, literally nobody has to partake or reply to anything they don’t want to. Other posters can ask, but they don’t have to disclose anything they don’t want to.

5128gap · 28/04/2023 18:56

sst1234 · 28/04/2023 17:32

The staunch defense of benefit fraud on MN points to one thing. That those staunch defenders are themselves on the rob.

Not necessarily. I staunchly defend the right of posters on MN to make themselves look foolish by suggesting ridiculous correlations. That doesn't mean I'm also a fool.

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 19:03

But nobody’s asked them to

you’re right, of course, but it is something that people out in the real world who claim benefits often feel the need to do. And people ask questions - they try to dig into your life and your motives. The second someone hears you don’t currently work, it starts. Question after question after question.

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 19:13

Re higher education and benefits . If you are 60 / 59 tou dont have to pat the fees back . Hence , my friend is work part time , plus do the degree of his dreams .. actively because he gets paid more than he would to work full time minimum wage . He openly sates this .

OP posts:
Busybody2022 · 28/04/2023 20:10

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 18:24

If that study leads to a job that gets them off benefits…what then?

Any job could get them off benefits not just one that requires a masters. Do you think anybody should be able to quit work to do a masters and have the taxpayer subsidise it all?

Okay, so I did my MA whilst on benefits and caring for disabled DC and volunteering to build up experience.

So theoretically a low skilled job makes you more likely to need to do antisocial hours and be lower paid and reliant on benefit top ups long term.

A year supporting someone to further study gives them more prospects, more earning power. Gets them off benefits long term.

Your view is hideously short sighted.

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 20:15

Busybody2022 · 28/04/2023 20:10

Okay, so I did my MA whilst on benefits and caring for disabled DC and volunteering to build up experience.

So theoretically a low skilled job makes you more likely to need to do antisocial hours and be lower paid and reliant on benefit top ups long term.

A year supporting someone to further study gives them more prospects, more earning power. Gets them off benefits long term.

Your view is hideously short sighted.

I see what you mean but not everyone can do a masters to elevate themselves from a low paid job, for a multitude of reasons. So it can’t be a standalone option available to everyone. How did you fund the fees out of interest, was it a government loan?

Changechangechanging · 28/04/2023 20:21

How did you fund the fees out of interest, was it a government loan?

See this is what I mean....questions, questions. Picking shit apaet to try and decide whether someonenis woerhy...or not. Why does it matter? What difference does it make? It has improved her job prospects, ability to earn more, ensure her children are not brought up in poverty. She will be payi gbtax. Why do you need the detail?

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 20:23

Because we’re discussing it? She doesn’t have to be on the thread, and brought up her own situation. So is it really that unreasonable I asked a question?! It’s getting a bit paranoid now. If I wrote a long paragraph about my own life on a thread I would expect people to ask about it if they wanted to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread