Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why is it a taboo to ‘ benefit bash ‘ on mn ?. See below for context.

300 replies

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 10:21

To be clear , am not talking about people on low wages / those wiith caring commitments/ Mental health or physical difficulties . Am talking about work avoidant people who expect benefits as a lifestyle on the back of others .

Yes it is harder now . Yes its a small group of the population .

But .. why is it taboo to discuss this on mn ?

Yes there are businesses who massively tax avoid , but two wrongs dont make a right.

Its a view I know is held in rl … is it that no one dare say these things on mn .. or is it something else. ???

To be clear -I am only talking about those who abuse the system, make it a ‘ my benefits’ way of being .

In my career ( in part with the benefits system) I have been told by some , the small group I am talking about ,that they wouldn't get out of bed for my wage . ( assuming they know what i got paid ! )

I realise it is much much harder to do this now , thats a good thing I just want to know why it seems to be a taboo subject specially on mn .

Yes -know some people will see this as goading.. however , I feel that the perceived majority of opinion dominates , and there is nothing wrong with discussing subjects that appear to be defined as taboo . ?

OP posts:
Whiteroomjoy · 28/04/2023 12:33

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 10:37

So you would prefer they didn't work at all? Because many people work part time for legitimate reasons.

Exactly, part timers are usually people who are parents, maybe with kids with special needs, or even with long term illnesses requiring lots of hospital appointments. They may be carer for other adults or partner. They may be recovering from major illness like cancer, well enough to work some hours but not full time. A large portion of them will have mental health problems which mean the same..people with mental illness often can’t work at all (my ex being one that didn’t work for 13 years - no benefits though as I earnt “too” much.
they may be people who are studying to improve their carer prospects .
people who are freelancers who have a random part time job to get regular hours/wage but then have periods where they can’t get the work that is their professional job (eg professional classical musicians a lot of whom are freelance )
I think the amount of people working part time have a reason. Again the number sitting round on their arses “sponging” off the state is very small. Even some of those sat on their arses doing not a lot and not motivated could also have undiagnosed mental health issues causing the loss of motivation

5128gap · 28/04/2023 12:34

Resilience · 28/04/2023 12:00

I'll bite.Wink

I think this comes down to your underlying philosophy on life. If you believe that most physically and psychologically healthy adults need a self view of themselves as being worthy of respect, it answers the question.

Most people on benefits hate it. Governments and society encourage others to look down on it and there's this constant niggling anxiety that it can be taken away at any time. It's a precarious way to live and if you're a single person without dependents it's barely at subsistence level. It's a lot more generous when children are involved but far from luxurious and certainly hasn't kept pace with the COL. Plus children grow up.

I don't blame people for choosing not to take work if it's not paid more than benefits. Despite the promises about always being better off in work, this simply isn't true. The comparison is based on income and ignores the additional outgoings of things like travel to work, which often leaves people on NMW work worse off. If you're barely getting by on benefits you'll go under if you take that job.

Many people will take work when it's a marginal improvement as it improves their self esteem. Work is about more than money (even for those with jobs rather than careers) and the anxiety associated with benefits.

Anyone who is happy to live off a subsistence amount week in, week out, year in, year out, is someone whose life has not gone the way they hoped. Despite what might be interpreted as arrogance, laziness or even aggression, underlying that is a belief that they probably couldn't hold down a decent job anyway.

Which brings us to the next point. If all benefits were scrapped, who exacted would be employing these 'scroungers' who may now want to work but might also lack any kind of employment skills, be barely literate, have terrible organisation skills... Do we just let them starve?

The real crime is that we have a society that consistently produces people like this through underfunding education and social care and placing little value on supporting families.

I've met benefit 'scroungers' and cheats. Many are actively dislikable. However, not in a million years would I change position with them which tells me everything I need to know about how genuine a 'choice' their 'choice' to live like that is. It's a symptom not a cause.

Excellent post.

Arginalia · 28/04/2023 12:35

Take Joe down the road who has never worked because no one in his family and few people in his neighbourhood have ever worked; he has grown up with no prospects on a bleak and lawless estate, is poorly educated and so used to living hand-to-mouth on benefits that he can simply envisage no other life.

Then take Joseph who lives in a London mansion flat paid for by his father. He's never worked and will never need to work because his family have vast inherited wealth that has passed down over hundreds of years, amassed at the cost of slave labour and human exploitation.

Which one is more morally reprehensible? Answer - neither. It's our capitalist system and acceptance of immense wealth inequality as normal, that is to blame.

autienotnaught · 28/04/2023 12:36

Sapphire387 · 28/04/2023 10:33

Because it perpetuates unhelpful stereotypes and leads to people lumping all benefit claimants into a group and calling them scroungers.

Why do you feel the need to do this anyway, what's lacking in your life?

👏👏👏👏👏👏

Spendonsend · 28/04/2023 12:37

Because I dont think there is much to discuss about it when benefits come up in threads as normally they are about someone struggling on carers allowance or trying to leave an abusive relationship.

Even in broader political debate most people support the idea of benefits for a range of scenarios and it seems obvious that no one thinks its ok to exploit things so its taken as read that we can discuss the other stuff.

Doggymummar · 28/04/2023 12:38

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 11:20

Which European countries have a system that pays no benefits at all after a certain time?

Ours! I was told my benefits would end on July 14 th if I didn't have a job. I signed on on 14th March. So that's 16 weeks. Then nothing. Hence I am doing 15 hours.

nidgey · 28/04/2023 12:41

LakieLady · 28/04/2023 12:14

I've done welfare rights work for 23 years. I don't think I'm in anyway "blinded" about what actually goes on.

In that time, the number of clients who've been getting benefits they're not entitled to is gobsmackingly tiny. And the vast majority of the time, that's due to oversight or the client not understanding the rules rather than deliberately playing the system. But around 20%-40% of cases aren't getting all the benefits they're entitled to.

In my team of 6, 4 of whom are part-time, we got gains for our clients of nearly £500k last year. That's £500k that was going unclaimed. And all the results for last year's work aren't in yet, because the wait for decisions and appeals is such a long one. That's an awful lot of people not getting an awful lot of money that the law says they should get.

I represented someone at a tribunal yesterday. His claim started in the financial year before last. If he succeeds, which I'm confident he will, he will get an arrears payment of £18k - £20k, probably a fair bit more by the time he gets the money. He's been living like an utter pauper, at considerable cost to his mental and physical health, for nearly 2 years, thanks to the benefit system being stacked against claimants.

I'd rather 10 people got a few quid more than they're entitled than have some poor soul go through what that man has been through, frankly.

I think this provides concrete insight into the system, and that benefit fraudsters are a tiny minority. As such, maybe it’s ‘taboo’ because it just isn’t a reflection of reality and MN is dedicated to truth and enlightened debate 😀

Tekkentime · 28/04/2023 12:42

Doggymummar · 28/04/2023 12:38

Ours! I was told my benefits would end on July 14 th if I didn't have a job. I signed on on 14th March. So that's 16 weeks. Then nothing. Hence I am doing 15 hours.

Same, you have to have contributed and then you get a maximum timeframe that you can claim before you can't get unemployment benefit anymore, usually 4 months.

KittyAlfred · 28/04/2023 12:43

I’ve been a GP in the same surgery for nearly 30 years, and obviously my job means I’m closely involved with issuing sick notes, PIP reports, etc. I’ve looked after families through several generations now, and I can say with absolute certainty that there are plenty of people for whom benefits are a lifestyle choice.

Their grandparents parents never worked, their parents never worked, and they don’t expect to work. They suffer with various minor ailments, which basically all result from having fairly crappy lives, poor support systems and coping strategies. They’re fit enough to work but they don’t think they are, and they don’t really know how to work, so they never do. Working is an alien world to them, whereas benefits are familiar. They fit their ailments around their benefits - not wilfully deceiving as such, just doing what they have to do. It’s their form of “work”. Occasionally they try and break the cycle by doing a bit of voluntary work or casual part time work, but then one of their neighbours might report them and their benefit get stopped, so they don’t risk it.

Greenfairydust · 28/04/2023 12:44

Because most people have better things to do with their life?

Because most of us can the difference between Daily Mail type propaganda and real life?

The reality is that benefits are far from generous in the UK (much less than what people can get in many EU countries) and the levels of fraud is tiny.

If you want to hyperventilate about ''scroungers'' focus your attention on MPS., ministers and our most recent Prime Ministers....

More tax payer money was wasted on a pointless track and trace system, consultants, MP/ministers expenses and government awarding contracts to mates who could not deliver (PPE and so on), than will ever be claimed fraudulently by people who receive benefits.

Frankly, inform yourself and get a life.

CareBearScare123 · 28/04/2023 12:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Maverickess · 28/04/2023 12:46

A lot of it is based on supposition and filling in gaps with imagination presented as facts, rather than actual facts, and people who do this do not like it challenged.
They are trying to claim the moral high ground and when their 'facts' are exposed as supposition and imagination, that moral high ground is at risk, and so anyone who challenges them is accused of trying to make the discussion taboo, or shut it down, to divert away from the fact they got it wrong and are trying to beat people down based on complete fantasy because it makes them feel better.

I've had this type of thing in RL, I once got 'confronted' by neighbours who told me it was disgusting that I laid in bed all day with the curtains closed and had 'been seen' in my PJ's at all times of day and clearly I was playing the system (I have a HA property) because I rode a horse and walked my dogs and did my garden and as my DD was a teen, I was clearly claiming stuff I wasn't entitled to and they were paying for it and were going to report me. We don't have 'your sort' around here.

The reality was that I worked ft nights, and that had never occurred to these people because they knew what they knew, based on supposition of my circumstances (I moved into a HA property) was obviously a single parent due to lack of another person there, and had my curtains closed/was in my PJ's during the day and did normal things on my days off. And they'd seen me riding a horse they assumed was mine, when in fact wasn't.

I got a small amount of tax credits and a HA property to make up for the piss poor wage I earned as a care assistant - a job that society relies on but does not value in the slightest, and because DD's father never paid a penny maintenance and although was ordered to, had all the arrears written off (without any consultation with me) so I could keep a roof over our heads and food on the table.

But those people knew what they knew and the actual facts didn't matter, I was a target for their dissatisfaction in life, based on a their wrong interpretation of what they saw and their imagination filling in the gaps and running away with them.

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 12:49

KittyAlfred · 28/04/2023 12:43

I’ve been a GP in the same surgery for nearly 30 years, and obviously my job means I’m closely involved with issuing sick notes, PIP reports, etc. I’ve looked after families through several generations now, and I can say with absolute certainty that there are plenty of people for whom benefits are a lifestyle choice.

Their grandparents parents never worked, their parents never worked, and they don’t expect to work. They suffer with various minor ailments, which basically all result from having fairly crappy lives, poor support systems and coping strategies. They’re fit enough to work but they don’t think they are, and they don’t really know how to work, so they never do. Working is an alien world to them, whereas benefits are familiar. They fit their ailments around their benefits - not wilfully deceiving as such, just doing what they have to do. It’s their form of “work”. Occasionally they try and break the cycle by doing a bit of voluntary work or casual part time work, but then one of their neighbours might report them and their benefit get stopped, so they don’t risk it.

Anyone care to comment on this? Are GPs (hated by the daily Mail) peddling right wing propaganda now as well?

slowquickstep · 28/04/2023 12:49

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 10:43

Like what?

We all want to be the one to pick our kids up from school, have time to catch up on housework, have a bit of ‘me’ time. But if we all went part time and relied on UC then the whole system would blow up

Like what ? Because their health won't allow them to work FT or there is no childcare available to enable them to work FT.

nidgey · 28/04/2023 12:52

Maverickess · 28/04/2023 12:46

A lot of it is based on supposition and filling in gaps with imagination presented as facts, rather than actual facts, and people who do this do not like it challenged.
They are trying to claim the moral high ground and when their 'facts' are exposed as supposition and imagination, that moral high ground is at risk, and so anyone who challenges them is accused of trying to make the discussion taboo, or shut it down, to divert away from the fact they got it wrong and are trying to beat people down based on complete fantasy because it makes them feel better.

I've had this type of thing in RL, I once got 'confronted' by neighbours who told me it was disgusting that I laid in bed all day with the curtains closed and had 'been seen' in my PJ's at all times of day and clearly I was playing the system (I have a HA property) because I rode a horse and walked my dogs and did my garden and as my DD was a teen, I was clearly claiming stuff I wasn't entitled to and they were paying for it and were going to report me. We don't have 'your sort' around here.

The reality was that I worked ft nights, and that had never occurred to these people because they knew what they knew, based on supposition of my circumstances (I moved into a HA property) was obviously a single parent due to lack of another person there, and had my curtains closed/was in my PJ's during the day and did normal things on my days off. And they'd seen me riding a horse they assumed was mine, when in fact wasn't.

I got a small amount of tax credits and a HA property to make up for the piss poor wage I earned as a care assistant - a job that society relies on but does not value in the slightest, and because DD's father never paid a penny maintenance and although was ordered to, had all the arrears written off (without any consultation with me) so I could keep a roof over our heads and food on the table.

But those people knew what they knew and the actual facts didn't matter, I was a target for their dissatisfaction in life, based on a their wrong interpretation of what they saw and their imagination filling in the gaps and running away with them.

That’s awful, solidarity. People can be so appalling.

Sleepydaffodil · 28/04/2023 12:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

It’s mind boggling to me that you’re so hellbent on seeing your own narrative as truth that you have misconstrued almost everything in the post you’ve quoted. The most well thought out post on this thread in my opinion, might I add.
They didn’t say “everyone claiming benefits in the UK is doing so out of desperation”. They said most and many.
You’ve then replied with some examples, which you yourself say isn’t the norm, to argue that their post is wrong.
Why is it so hard to believe that most people on benefits don’t want that life? I grew up on a deprived council estate with lots of unemployment. I’m fortunate that I did reasonably well in school and was able to go onto university and carve out a better life for myself. Many children I grew up with did not fare so well, through no fault of their own, for many of the reasons the poster you’ve quoted talks about. They didn’t choose to be born into the area they were, but by being born there their chances of having a good life were snatched from them. They didn’t choose to have a substandard education. They didn’t choose to grow up in a home without heating. They didn’t choose to grow up in an area with high rates of crime. Two young men I grew up with have been murdered. They didn’t choose that. Their lives unfortunately were mapped out for them by a terrible system that leaves people growing up in deprived areas so ill equipped for life that often being on benefits is the only option.

YouCouldHaveKnockedMeDownWithAFeather · 28/04/2023 12:59

I can only assume that most of the bashing comes from those who have misunderstood on MN and have assumed that all people ( low wages, disabled, carets ) are being criticised and lumped into the same category as those who can’t be bothered to work.

Do MN really avoid criticising the work shy

PollyAmour · 28/04/2023 13:01

Are you a disability assessor for PIP or something along those lines, OP? Do you get a bonus if you manage to get someone's benefits stopped because you have deemed them fit to work?

CareBearScare123 · 28/04/2023 13:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Busybody2022 · 28/04/2023 13:06

People seem to think everyone in the system is in the milking it category and not the genuine in need.

FWIW though I live in a HA after a non-fault eviction. When I moved in to my house I was (and Still am) a single parent of two. Both kids do have disabilities and receive DLA so we do get support.

When I moved in I was in my second and final year of my masters. This was during covid so all home based. I've been working ever since. I hit the jack pot with jobs and work from home, term time only for the Local Authority. We went on holiday in October and my camera picked up my neighbours commenting on how they clearly need to quit their jobs so they can go on holiday too and a few other derogatory remarks. They had (and still have) no idea I do actually work, I have worked consistently and I'm a sole carer of two disabled children. What they think they know and what they actually know are two very different things. I'm almost certain they could be one of these posters who knows their neighbour is living the life of Riley not working on benefits.

KittyAlfred · 28/04/2023 13:06

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 12:49

Anyone care to comment on this? Are GPs (hated by the daily Mail) peddling right wing propaganda now as well?

It’s not right wing propaganda at all. I’m simply stating facts based on my experience. Obviously I have far more patients who claim various benefits that could never be questioned in any way. And I have patients who I have campaigned on behalf of, because they were unjustly deemed fit to work. But there is a small minority who behave in the way that I outlined, and it’s wrong to claim that these people don’t exist.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 28/04/2023 13:11

LadyMuckingabout · 28/04/2023 11:09

There is a group of people, it cannot be denied, who work in the black economy. A few years ago I was claiming unemployment benefit and every fortnight round the corner from the job centre were blokes in vans getting out of overalls and going in to sign on.

This is nonsense. "Signing on" weekly or fortnightly at the jobcentre is no longer how it's done.

You absolutely made this up.

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 13:14

KittyAlfred · 28/04/2023 13:06

It’s not right wing propaganda at all. I’m simply stating facts based on my experience. Obviously I have far more patients who claim various benefits that could never be questioned in any way. And I have patients who I have campaigned on behalf of, because they were unjustly deemed fit to work. But there is a small minority who behave in the way that I outlined, and it’s wrong to claim that these people don’t exist.

I was agreeing with you. When I shared your opinion posters accused me of gobbling up propaganda by the right wing media. So I was asking if you (as a GP that such media despises!) are also peddling right wing propaganda, because clearly you’re not.

But nobody will comment on your post as it’s e inconvenient truth stated by somebody who has lived experience of this and has no affinity (presumably) with the daily Mail that they can blame your views on

izimbra · 28/04/2023 13:19

"For example my neighbour with six children who never intends to work, and who pops out a new kid with whichever local drug dealer will shag her about once a year. Her children all have varying degrees of disability so she does actually rake it in. The older children look after the younger ones while she focuses on the new boy/baby.

These types absolutely exist, but we’re supposed to pretend they don’t."

They exist - I know a couple. Both very poorly educated, from troubled backgrounds, who have emotionally abusive or absent partners, started having kids when they were very young. I see these women and their children as victims of very poor decision making at a very young age, and they have nothing but my pity. It makes me depressed that they're the focus of so much anger and resentment from the Daily Mail reading cohort, who also tend to be the sort of people who are stolidly against the state doing anything serious and meaningful about low wages, insecure jobs, unmanageable childcare and housing costs which are the biggest barriers to single parents being able to escape the benefits trap.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 28/04/2023 13:22

Why cant it be discussed.

But it IS being discussed. We’re onto page 7 of said discussion. What you mean is that you want it to be discussed without you being accused of benefit bashing. Well tough. A discussion isn’t you getting to have your say without criticism. “I hate benefit bashing” is just as valid a part of the discussion as your point .