Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why is it a taboo to ‘ benefit bash ‘ on mn ?. See below for context.

300 replies

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 10:21

To be clear , am not talking about people on low wages / those wiith caring commitments/ Mental health or physical difficulties . Am talking about work avoidant people who expect benefits as a lifestyle on the back of others .

Yes it is harder now . Yes its a small group of the population .

But .. why is it taboo to discuss this on mn ?

Yes there are businesses who massively tax avoid , but two wrongs dont make a right.

Its a view I know is held in rl … is it that no one dare say these things on mn .. or is it something else. ???

To be clear -I am only talking about those who abuse the system, make it a ‘ my benefits’ way of being .

In my career ( in part with the benefits system) I have been told by some , the small group I am talking about ,that they wouldn't get out of bed for my wage . ( assuming they know what i got paid ! )

I realise it is much much harder to do this now , thats a good thing I just want to know why it seems to be a taboo subject specially on mn .

Yes -know some people will see this as goading.. however , I feel that the perceived majority of opinion dominates , and there is nothing wrong with discussing subjects that appear to be defined as taboo . ?

OP posts:
Busybody2022 · 28/04/2023 20:28

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 20:15

I see what you mean but not everyone can do a masters to elevate themselves from a low paid job, for a multitude of reasons. So it can’t be a standalone option available to everyone. How did you fund the fees out of interest, was it a government loan?

Not everyone is capable of completing a degree or a masters. Those who are can better their lives for it and reduce their reliance in the long run.

You could replace an MA with an apprenticeship or other forms of training. Short term high level of cost but pays in the long run

Busybody2022 · 28/04/2023 20:32

My course fees were covered by student finance, which all students are eligible for. Despite being a loan you pay back, the matinence loans are deducted from any benefit payment. Essentially in the long run you pay twice.

Arginalia · 28/04/2023 20:35

Busybody2022 · 28/04/2023 20:28

Not everyone is capable of completing a degree or a masters. Those who are can better their lives for it and reduce their reliance in the long run.

You could replace an MA with an apprenticeship or other forms of training. Short term high level of cost but pays in the long run

Yep - short term-ism plus keep the plebs in their box. One more person with a Masters, one fewer person available to do care work at min wage <insert any other low-paid, high stress job>. If we carry on like that we might actually have to offer decent wages for shitty unskilled jobs, and then where would the shareholders be?

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 21:00

Not only is that paranoid rubbish, you’re forgetting the enormous number of people that work full time and would like to do a masters but can’t because… they’re working full time. For not much money, 24k maybe. If you think they’re ‘keeping plebs in their box’ then you have no idea how most people live.

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 21:17

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 19:13

Re higher education and benefits . If you are 60 / 59 tou dont have to pat the fees back . Hence , my friend is work part time , plus do the degree of his dreams .. actively because he gets paid more than he would to work full time minimum wage . He openly sates this .

Could you please repost this in a way that makes sense, because I cannot understand what you are trying to say.

albapunk · 28/04/2023 23:00

Beezknees · 28/04/2023 15:01

The 16 hour thing is NOT TRUE at all. That was the case on the old tax credits system, UC is a whole different kettle of fish. The more hours you work, the better off you are.

I can only go by what they tell me unfortunately. But benefits is the reason stated my many as only wanting 16 hour contracts. Unsure of their circumstances though.

Whammyyammy · 28/04/2023 23:21

The cheats and scroungers tarnish the whole benefits system for the genuine that ate actually on need.

izimbra · 28/04/2023 23:45

"as the lazy entitled low lives who are just scum." Do you feel that way about really wealthy people who could absolutely afford to pay the same rate of tax as people on PAYE, but who use legal tax avoidance schemes to pay as little as possible?

Because they know they're depriving the exchequer of much needed funds - in the case of rich people because they can never be rich enough, and in the case of very poor people on benefits, because working means they'll still be living in poverty, just with vastly less time and energy than they had when they were unemployed.

Maverickess · 29/04/2023 01:15

berksandbeyond · 28/04/2023 16:30

I’d rather that. And yes, men should be made to pay for their own children but that’s a different debate really isn’t it?

Why though, if the amount of money spent is the same? Surely if both things cost around the same then there's no real difference to the tax payer if the single parent works full time and has a fair whack in childcare paid, or works part time and has the same amount in top ups?

There's probably advantages and disadvantages to both around long term prospects Vs stability for the child(ren), money flowing through the economy, creating jobs etc (although atm there's a shortage of childcare workers I believe) but regardless of that, if the costs are the same then it just comes down to other people feeling entitled to decide who's deserving and undeserving really - and in all likelihood doing so having zero insight into individual circumstances that lead to working part time, so like I said in a pp, based on supposition and imagination.

And I think the question of children being supported by their own parents is the very thing being discussed here - so yes men supporting their own children (and being enforced to do so) is very relevant here because if that support were a given and non negotiable, then perhaps we wouldn't need to be paying out so much in benefits to single parents.
But as ever it's more popular to say the mother with caring responsibility should be working ft and supporting her own children but ignore (or say it's a different discussion) that men should be doing the same.

Coyoacan · 29/04/2023 02:02

For example my neighbour with six children who never intends to work, and who pops out a new kid with whichever local drug dealer will shag her about once a year. Her children all have varying degrees of disability so she does actually rake it in. The older children look after the younger ones while she focuses on the new boyf/baby.

I just wanted to say that these types of people still have children they cannot provide for even in countries where there are no benefits. This isn't a situation created by benefits.

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 04:42

izimbra · 28/04/2023 23:45

"as the lazy entitled low lives who are just scum." Do you feel that way about really wealthy people who could absolutely afford to pay the same rate of tax as people on PAYE, but who use legal tax avoidance schemes to pay as little as possible?

Because they know they're depriving the exchequer of much needed funds - in the case of rich people because they can never be rich enough, and in the case of very poor people on benefits, because working means they'll still be living in poverty, just with vastly less time and energy than they had when they were unemployed.

But they’re not depriving if what they’re doing is legal are they? They’re just not paying as much as some people would like them to.

When it’s benefit claimants you’re saying they’re ‘entitled’, they’re ‘not gaming the system if what they’re doing is legal’ and we should butt out. But it’s different for businesses who are doing the same thing?

Like I said before the optics are not as galling for some if you have someone paying £15 rather than £20, than somebody taking out £1 but paying nothing.

HollyBerri · 29/04/2023 04:43

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 10:43

Like what?

We all want to be the one to pick our kids up from school, have time to catch up on housework, have a bit of ‘me’ time. But if we all went part time and relied on UC then the whole system would blow up

So you don’t think anyone has a legitimate reason to work part time? This is exactly the way these threads go. Someone a few posts earlier gave a reason she works part time - is that acceptable to you ?

Yerroblemom1923 · 29/04/2023 08:01

What @sst1234 said! The defensiveness on this thread speaks volumes!
I am intrigued as to how the MA works as I did my degree part time while working full time (no benefits). I'd love to further my education but can't imagine what benefits I'd be eligible if I gave up work to do a full time MA. Yes, I could do it part time but further education is expensive and to study after a 10 hour day at work seems impossible. Surely further education is a luxury rather than a right and even kids at uni have jobs to pay for their education/living costs etc.
I do think benefits are much harder to get than they were in the 90s. I recall a friend being indefinitely signed off for mental health reasons and only having to attend a meeting every so many years to check her circumstances hadn't changed.
I also have a GP friend who has worked as a sickness benefits assessor and he knows who is/isn't milking the system. Sadly it's people that are that make it hard for genuine claimants. I guess that's why everyone is so defensive on here.
I do think that sometimes people are scared to get a job as they know the benefits stop as soon as you tell them you've found work but also that you won't get paid from work for another 4 weeks!

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 08:10

HollyBerri · 29/04/2023 04:43

So you don’t think anyone has a legitimate reason to work part time? This is exactly the way these threads go. Someone a few posts earlier gave a reason she works part time - is that acceptable to you ?

Of course they do, but not a benefits-worthy reason to my mind. If people don’t need the state to finance it they can work as few hours as they like

angela99999 · 29/04/2023 08:53

Yerroblemom1923 · 29/04/2023 08:01

What @sst1234 said! The defensiveness on this thread speaks volumes!
I am intrigued as to how the MA works as I did my degree part time while working full time (no benefits). I'd love to further my education but can't imagine what benefits I'd be eligible if I gave up work to do a full time MA. Yes, I could do it part time but further education is expensive and to study after a 10 hour day at work seems impossible. Surely further education is a luxury rather than a right and even kids at uni have jobs to pay for their education/living costs etc.
I do think benefits are much harder to get than they were in the 90s. I recall a friend being indefinitely signed off for mental health reasons and only having to attend a meeting every so many years to check her circumstances hadn't changed.
I also have a GP friend who has worked as a sickness benefits assessor and he knows who is/isn't milking the system. Sadly it's people that are that make it hard for genuine claimants. I guess that's why everyone is so defensive on here.
I do think that sometimes people are scared to get a job as they know the benefits stop as soon as you tell them you've found work but also that you won't get paid from work for another 4 weeks!

Sorry, but I know that people are simply not "signed off indefinitely for mental health reasons" since I have a relative with a permanent mental health condition who is virtually harrassed with interviews, medicals, requests for (chargeable) doctor's letters and so on.

Yerroblemom1923 · 29/04/2023 09:39

@angela99999 this was mid nineties, it may have changed now. It made no sense as surely with the right medication/counselling depression etc can be temporary. Also many people hold down jobs while struggling with mental health issues.

defi · 29/04/2023 10:06

Ok so I went to uni whilst claiming benefits. I worked as a carer and was always skint just about getting by. So I worked more, stayed late, did weekends. The difference between working part time with benefits and full time was £100. It just wasn't sustainable. So I went to uni and did a biomedical science degree. I now work for the nhs and earn enough for a decent standard of living for the north west. Cost of living really hasn't helped but if I was on a carers wage I couldn't put the heating on and would probably be at food banks.

RethinkingLife · 29/04/2023 10:57

I also have a GP friend who has worked as a sickness benefits assessor and he knows who is/isn't milking the system.

And yet 72% of PIP denials are overturned on appeal. Do assessors know how many of their decisions are reversed? Are they given additional training if the appeals are successful above a particular threshold?

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has shared “three main reasons” why award decisions for Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) are being overturned in favour of the claimant. New figures released earlier this month revealed that 72 per cent of PIP tribunals result in success for the claimant.

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/lifestyle/money/reasons-benefit-award-decisions-overturned-27297738

DWP shares reasons PIP and ESA award decisions overturned in favour of claimant

Latest figures show 72% of PIP tribunals overturned DWP award decisions.

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/lifestyle/money/reasons-benefit-award-decisions-overturned-27297738

Beezknees · 29/04/2023 11:00

albapunk · 28/04/2023 23:00

I can only go by what they tell me unfortunately. But benefits is the reason stated my many as only wanting 16 hour contracts. Unsure of their circumstances though.

You're being fed a tall tale then. I've been on varying degrees of benefits for 14 years and the whole 16 hour thing changed when UC was introduced.

JazbayGrapes · 29/04/2023 11:13

I can only go by what they tell me unfortunately. But benefits is the reason stated my many as only wanting 16 hour contracts. Unsure of their circumstances though.

Benefits are not easy to obtain, and very easy to lose. An extra shift, a temporary job - won't compensate for what you're going to lose. The system is totally rigged to keep poor people poor. And let's face it - life on benefits is poverty, and there is no pride in it.

Sillysheep · 29/04/2023 11:20

Beezknees · 28/04/2023 14:48

Ah, I see. It's not "gaming" anything then. The DWP sets the rules. They're entitled to do that, whether you agree with it or not. Just like the legal tax loopholes that the very wealthy use. Morally wrong? Sure. Illegal? No.

Thanks. It's not gaming at all. We've never had anything that we weren't entitled to. I'm not going to justify to others as we aren't doing anything illegal no scams and we are now better off as a family in loads of ways.

angela99999 · 29/04/2023 13:58

Yerroblemom1923 · 29/04/2023 09:39

@angela99999 this was mid nineties, it may have changed now. It made no sense as surely with the right medication/counselling depression etc can be temporary. Also many people hold down jobs while struggling with mental health issues.

Yes, I think you're right about depression, and many people think that getting involved in real life can help it too. But in the case of my daughter (not depression) we have always been told that there is absolutely no chance that she would be well enough to work. Yet still she is dragged along for constant assessments, medicals and courses related to her benefits.

Yerroblemom1923 · 29/04/2023 15:02

In which case @angela99999 I have every sympathy for your daughter. I'm not mental health bashing either before anyone starts that, I appreciate it takes time to find the right medication and/or therapist etc etc but people can and do recover. I'm no stranger to mh issues but know leaving the workforce would only exacerbate any existing issues as working is generally considered healthy for both mind and body.

Manyanaish · 30/04/2023 23:06

Interesting debate that didn't deteriorate .. good to see views expressed !

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread