Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Well done, FWS, and women everywhere. There are no men in women's jails in Scotland.

404 replies

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 20:08

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c962p8217zxdo

'All transgender inmates have been moved out of women's prisons, according to the Scottish Prison Service (SPS).
SPS deputy chief executive Adam Jobson told Holyrood's Equalities Committee that a small number of transgender prisoners had been moved. He said that trans women - biological males who identify as women - were now held in men's prisons.
The move was to comply with a judge's ruling in June, that sex segregation in prisons must be based on biological sex rather than gender identity.'

An image of a series of security gates in a prison - with floor-to-ceiling white metal bars. Above the first set it says "E/F Wing" and a prison officer - a bald man in a white shirt and black trousers - is opening the gate. We see him from behind.

No biological males in women's prisons, Scottish Prison Service confirms

All transgender women - biological males who identify as women - have now been moved into men's jails to comply with a legal ruling.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c962p8217zxdo

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/11/2026 23:20

Feminism is for women, not men.

And there you have it @Transperson

It's unanswerable.

turquoiseshell · 12/11/2026 23:26

Transperson · 12/11/2026 20:21

I don't think most had any impact by trans people being there or not.

I'm sure it must be lovely, living and communal showering with sadistic male killers. Just what female prisoners, most of whom have suffered from domestic violence, need to help with their rehabilitation.
Here's one of those vicious male murderers, who stabbed his victim (a man he lured to his flat for sex) 16 times, and then decided he was a woman and until he was charged with sexually assaulting a female inmate was housed in the women's prison.
Trans prisoner charged with sexual assault in women's jail - BBC News

A general view of the entrace to HMP Greenock. A small, dark stone wall sits in front of the main building with the name of the prison on a white panel.

Trans prisoner charged with sexual assault in women's jail

Alexandra Stewart, previously known as Alan Baker, was charged over an alleged attack at HMP Greenock.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4glne43101o

itstoolateforsnacks · 12/11/2026 23:33

alcovecupboards · 12/11/2026 21:01

They do, I'm afraid, frequently on here. I think it's disgusting that a gender critical paedophile child abuser was sentenced to just three years for her vile crimes. On here she's described as 'vulnerable'. The children she sexually abused were vulnerable, not her.

So when these vulnerable child victims grow up and a few replicate and perpetrate the crimes they experienced - no longer vulnerable? Where does the vulnerable line stop when you’ve had multiple adverse experiences as a child? Is there an age limit?

Saying someone is vulnerable does not mean they are not culpable, their crimes not terrible, or they do not need to be stopped from harming others. But it does mean in the case of female prisoners, that they are particularly at risk of being harmed by others - in this case men who believe or say they are women.

Dictionary def of vulnerable, in case helpful: capable of being easily physically, mentally, or emotionally hurt, attacked, or influenced.

Manyanamanyana · 12/11/2026 23:35

Transperson · 12/11/2026 20:17

Wow you managed to cause hell to a whole 20 people, well done.

Honestly, you're just cranky because it's another nail in the coffin for your delusional belief that gender identities trump sex-reality. I have to be honest and say I feel nothing for the decietful and selfish men who took advantage of this and placed women in the position they were in. Only a truly despicable person would do that.

Well done Women of Scotland!! 💚💜
Legends, every single one of you (who supported this most obvious correction).

It is a travesty that it ever happened in the first place, and that it continues to happen in other countries, including the super-progressive Australia.

JanesLittleGirl · 12/11/2026 23:41

Transperson · 12/11/2026 22:06

European court of human rights would have a field day to squash this transohobia

Please feel free to bring a case to the ECtHR having exhausted your appeals to your domestic courts.

Hedgehogforshort · 12/11/2026 23:46

I think transperson might be identifying as an AI bot or is one.

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/11/2026 23:49

Hedgehogforshort · 12/11/2026 23:46

I think transperson might be identifying as an AI bot or is one.

AI bots can construct coherent sentences.

murasaki · 12/11/2026 23:52

I think we decided he is real as AI would know the difference between affect and effect.

Although I got the distinct impression he didn't like me correcting him..

murasaki · 12/11/2026 23:53

JanesLittleGirl · 12/11/2026 23:41

Please feel free to bring a case to the ECtHR having exhausted your appeals to your domestic courts.

He can get the Good Laugh Project on board. That always goes well.

MarieDeGournay · 12/11/2026 23:58

It looks like Transperson has left the thread before I had a chance to ask them if they had actually read the FWS v Scottish Prisons rulings?

It would appear not, because the concerns for the well-being of trans-IDing male prisoners being housed in male prisons is specifically addressed,
[112] The existing Prisons Guidance recognises that there is a need to make special provision for trans prisoners.
2026csoh59-petition-of-for-women-scotland-for-judicial-review.pdf

There are already arrangements in place for the safety of trans prisoners, so Transperson's fears of them being thrown to the wolves is misplaced.

I've been very tempted to use the parliamentary formula of saying 'I refer the honourable member to the answer...' when posters like TP bring up objections that were already and thoroughly dealt with in the ruling.

RareGoalsVerge · 13/11/2026 00:14

Transperson · 12/11/2026 20:17

Wow you managed to cause hell to a whole 20 people, well done.

Correction. The 350ish female prisoners who have had their human rights ignored, imprisoning them without due regard to their rights, are now being properly protected.

Bit main-character-energy to centre the males in this story. I expect a nice safe all-transwomen unit has been set up somewhere (in the male estate)

Assuming your figure of 20 is correct, how come there are so many transwomen in prisons? - 20 prisoners would be 6% of the womens prison population. If transwomen offended at the same rates as actual female women the number would be about 0.2 transwomen prisoners in scotland, so scottish transwomen offend at approximately 100 times the rate of actual female women. Any thoughts on why that is? My guess is "because they are male" but do feel free to speculate on alternate explanations.

Transperson · 13/11/2026 00:56

RareGoalsVerge · 13/11/2026 00:14

Correction. The 350ish female prisoners who have had their human rights ignored, imprisoning them without due regard to their rights, are now being properly protected.

Bit main-character-energy to centre the males in this story. I expect a nice safe all-transwomen unit has been set up somewhere (in the male estate)

Assuming your figure of 20 is correct, how come there are so many transwomen in prisons? - 20 prisoners would be 6% of the womens prison population. If transwomen offended at the same rates as actual female women the number would be about 0.2 transwomen prisoners in scotland, so scottish transwomen offend at approximately 100 times the rate of actual female women. Any thoughts on why that is? My guess is "because they are male" but do feel free to speculate on alternate explanations.

It's 20 for all trans people, I don't remember the FOI request breakdown

IwantToRetire · 13/11/2026 01:03

Sadly whilst not wanting to detract from the great work of FWS and others, this endless intervening (and responding which I accept I did on this occasion) means that FWR is forever prioritising trans politics.

However dangerous it is that TW and their TRA terrorists are, they are not the totality of issues for women.

And sadly, as many have made me aware, makes what were once the valuable threads for those not on FWR but would check in to read FWRers thoughts on latest issues, of little interest or use to other women.

Its actually turned FWR on its head. The split (crudely put in place by MNHQ admittedly) was to allow those on FWR to discuss sex based rights without constantly being made to go back to square 1 by deliberate interventionists. Although dressed up as we weren't being "kind" enough, so Feminism Chat would be the safe be kind forum, so had to be sent of to the naughty corner to have our terfy exchanges, the exact opposite has happened.

Most threads are now held to ransom by TRA wreckers.

What a sad state of affairs.

TakingMyChancesWithTheRabbits · 13/11/2026 01:45

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/11/2026 23:15

@Transperson I wish you'd proofread your posts, because a lot of them don't make sense.

I don't think that's purely a proofreading issue.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 05:37

Transperson · 12/11/2026 22:00

So respectful and dignified

Such respect, such wow.

Respect is earned…. If im not showing your opinions respect, think about why.

Unimpressed Monday Night Raw GIF by WWE
TheMarbleRun · 13/11/2026 07:03

I remember that, two days ago, Transperson was justifying his access in women toilets and changing rooms because he passed so well, that his presence wouldn't harm anyone. And there he is, oblivious to the harm this trans prisoners have done to women. The pretence that he cares is totally gone.

I'm glad for the win, FWS!!

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 13/11/2026 08:25

IwantToRetire · 13/11/2026 01:03

Sadly whilst not wanting to detract from the great work of FWS and others, this endless intervening (and responding which I accept I did on this occasion) means that FWR is forever prioritising trans politics.

However dangerous it is that TW and their TRA terrorists are, they are not the totality of issues for women.

And sadly, as many have made me aware, makes what were once the valuable threads for those not on FWR but would check in to read FWRers thoughts on latest issues, of little interest or use to other women.

Its actually turned FWR on its head. The split (crudely put in place by MNHQ admittedly) was to allow those on FWR to discuss sex based rights without constantly being made to go back to square 1 by deliberate interventionists. Although dressed up as we weren't being "kind" enough, so Feminism Chat would be the safe be kind forum, so had to be sent of to the naughty corner to have our terfy exchanges, the exact opposite has happened.

Most threads are now held to ransom by TRA wreckers.

What a sad state of affairs.

It is a bit of a shame, however I was expecting this. Once the so-called "legal" arguments have been shut down, one by one, all the activists will have will be baseless bickering and meaningless statements/insults. Most of which, I believe, come from a place of self-hatred and serious insecurities, as well as non-UK countries that have different laws to us.

I understand the drive to set these posters straight on the law, but I do wish we here on FWR would remember who we are trying to argue with, the increasing use of AI on MN, and the uselessness of it all.

And remember that all these derailing posters might actually be the same person (it's possible to have more than one account, as shown recently on the Jo Phoenix post).

It's also needless. Nothing the Interrupterons say will change UK law.

On the other hand, as I said, I have been expecting this to happen, and am actually looking forward to the day when there is absolutely nothing left to say except "I know I am, but what are you?" type playground sniping, and FWR is no longer needed. Wouldn't that be great?

Because we will have reached a point when all women's rights would be respected.

However, we're not there yet.

nutmeg7 · 13/11/2026 08:49

Transperson · 12/11/2026 21:34

How do we protect them though? Men will lie to get sent to the trans women unit?

Well that’s the problem with self ID isn’t it?

Which is what women have been fighting against.

But the trans community oppose “gatekeeping” because “you are who you say you are”.

nutmeg7 · 13/11/2026 08:53

Transperson · 12/11/2026 21:43

I was using Ur own points, I didn't say that trans people do that.

Again few bad apples don't categorise the entire group. Cis women can sexually assault too!

Is that some sort of attempt at a “gotcha”?

You do know that 97% of sexual crime is committed by male people, don’t you?

nutmeg7 · 13/11/2026 09:00

Transperson · 12/11/2026 21:58

Andy is planning on devolving powers DW DW soon GC groups won't be able to use the court systems as a humans rights circus.

Are you suggesting women shouldn’t be allowed to use the courts to enforce our hard-won rights that were already written into law?

If you don’t like the law, you will have to lobby parliament to get it changed.

Not whine on about court cases that didn’t go the way you wanted. It seems clear you don’t want females as a sex class to have any legal meaning or protection.

TheKeatingFive · 13/11/2026 09:01

TheMarbleRun · 13/11/2026 07:03

I remember that, two days ago, Transperson was justifying his access in women toilets and changing rooms because he passed so well, that his presence wouldn't harm anyone. And there he is, oblivious to the harm this trans prisoners have done to women. The pretence that he cares is totally gone.

I'm glad for the win, FWS!!

I am gobsmacked that TP has so little consideration for women impacted by being incarcerated with men. I genuinely thought he was (a bit) better than that.

But the lack of care/consideration/interest in the women’s plight he shows here is revolting.

fromorbit · 13/11/2026 09:21

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 13/11/2026 08:25

It is a bit of a shame, however I was expecting this. Once the so-called "legal" arguments have been shut down, one by one, all the activists will have will be baseless bickering and meaningless statements/insults. Most of which, I believe, come from a place of self-hatred and serious insecurities, as well as non-UK countries that have different laws to us.

I understand the drive to set these posters straight on the law, but I do wish we here on FWR would remember who we are trying to argue with, the increasing use of AI on MN, and the uselessness of it all.

And remember that all these derailing posters might actually be the same person (it's possible to have more than one account, as shown recently on the Jo Phoenix post).

It's also needless. Nothing the Interrupterons say will change UK law.

On the other hand, as I said, I have been expecting this to happen, and am actually looking forward to the day when there is absolutely nothing left to say except "I know I am, but what are you?" type playground sniping, and FWR is no longer needed. Wouldn't that be great?

Because we will have reached a point when all women's rights would be respected.

However, we're not there yet.

Trolls have their upsides. It is one of the ways we got this win.

The TAs who hate open debate were very right from their perspective. As soon as you start to argue about this openly one side always loses - it is not the pro women side. The Trolls are useful. The Trolls have been "derailing" threads here for almost a decade and achieved nothing, and have only helped. It has only made our side stronger and they make Mumsnet money every time they post. Yes it is infuriating, but being upset is only painful if you don't channel it into motivation which is what generally happens.

I am not saying you have to argue with the Trolls - you can opt to ignore them. The thing is on Mumsnet there will always be people to refute and laugh at them.

As I said on the troll discussion thread Trolls have their uses:

If Troll posting was a real problem then the pro-women side would have lost long ago. If you think about it though there are way way worse and more effective things Trolls could be doing. Instead they are here making the pro-women side money, pushing engagement with the site, advertising Mumsnet's ideas, making Mumsnetters laugh and infuriating them in equal measure and serving as perfect practice dummies.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5598622-a-heartfelt-thank-you-to-the-reddit-trolls-of-mn

A heartfelt thank you to the Reddit trolls of MN | Mumsnet

On a recent thread there was link to some Redditors discussing how they troll MN and FWR. It was deleted before I saw it, but another poster mentione...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5598622-a-heartfelt-thank-you-to-the-reddit-trolls-of-mn

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/11/2026 09:26

murasaki · 12/11/2026 23:52

I think we decided he is real as AI would know the difference between affect and effect.

Although I got the distinct impression he didn't like me correcting him..

And mortality and morality

teawamutu · 13/11/2026 09:27

TheKeatingFive · 13/11/2026 09:01

I am gobsmacked that TP has so little consideration for women impacted by being incarcerated with men. I genuinely thought he was (a bit) better than that.

But the lack of care/consideration/interest in the women’s plight he shows here is revolting.

Having read his posts on the previous thread, I expected nothing more from him.

Don't think I've used this meme in a while, but it seems apposite.

Well done, FWS, and women everywhere. There are no men in women's jails in Scotland.
OP posts: