Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Well done, FWS, and women everywhere. There are no men in women's jails in Scotland.

404 replies

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 20:08

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c962p8217zxdo

'All transgender inmates have been moved out of women's prisons, according to the Scottish Prison Service (SPS).
SPS deputy chief executive Adam Jobson told Holyrood's Equalities Committee that a small number of transgender prisoners had been moved. He said that trans women - biological males who identify as women - were now held in men's prisons.
The move was to comply with a judge's ruling in June, that sex segregation in prisons must be based on biological sex rather than gender identity.'

An image of a series of security gates in a prison - with floor-to-ceiling white metal bars. Above the first set it says "E/F Wing" and a prison officer - a bald man in a white shirt and black trousers - is opening the gate. We see him from behind.

No biological males in women's prisons, Scottish Prison Service confirms

All transgender women - biological males who identify as women - have now been moved into men's jails to comply with a legal ruling.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c962p8217zxdo

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
WearyAuldWumman · 12/11/2026 22:50

Transperson · 12/11/2026 21:27

That would be better than leaving them to get raped.

I suspect that Paris Green will be quite safe, but I'm not sure that it would be fair to inflict Paris on another transwoman.

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 22:50

Hoardasurass · 12/11/2026 20:35

Scottish Greens MSP blasted over 'false' claims that banning men from female toilets 'drives' lesbians out of public life https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/scottish-greens-msp-blasted-over-37870872
This article has the push back that holly bruce got from fws that is missing from the BBC article

Holly Bruce:

'Ms Bruce also criticised the fact that female prisons no longer house biological men. She said that she had “safeguarding concerns” around trans prisoners. She said: “I do have concerns that there are going to be real risks posed to these women" if they are housed in the male estate.'

I mean. What is there to say to that?

OP posts:
NotAtMyAge · 12/11/2026 22:52

alcovecupboards · 12/11/2026 20:28

Good. But they should be ensured protection within the male estate. I do have to say though I find it curious how female prisoners - murderers, child abusers and the like - are described as 'vulnerable'. They're no such thing - they are criminals, locked up for society's protection. Let's not pretend that these criminals are in any way 'vulnerable'. The sole concern should be for their victims now this situation has come to an end.

I do wish you would do a minimum of research before jumping on your soapbox. A quick search on Google shows that the most common crime of female prisoners in the UK is theft/shoplifting. For male prisoners it's violence against the person.

Only 8% of convicted murderers are female and less than 4% of convicted child abusers are female. On the other hand 60% of trans-identifying male prisoners have been convicted of at least one sex offence.

Even someone so wilfully blind to the rights and needs of women as you should be able to see how inappropriate it has always been to lock up men in women's prisons, however those men present and identify.

NumberTheory · 12/11/2026 22:52

Transperson · 12/11/2026 22:41

It was using the GC trope as I said.

It's not GC to distinguish between men who really think they should be women and men who are lying about really thinking they are women in terms of the risk they present to women (or anyone else). So you can't have been using a GC "trope".

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 22:53

https://www.edinburghlive.co.uk/news/edinburgh-news/womens-wing-edinburgh-jail-now-27823641

"They’re going to use Ratho for the beasts because the beast wing is full. The prisons are overcrowded as it is.
"They’re going to put in some transgender prisoners into Ratho too."

Re the wing at HMP Saughton for vulnerable prisoners. It used to be for women prisoners, has now been repurposed.

Women's wing of Edinburgh jail will now house country's most 'dangerous' sex offenders

HMP Edinburgh's Ratho House wing was previously used as an all-female wing for prisoners from the east of Scotland, before the women were shipped out to other jails.

https://www.edinburghlive.co.uk/news/edinburgh-news/womens-wing-edinburgh-jail-now-27823641

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 22:54

NotAtMyAge · 12/11/2026 22:52

I do wish you would do a minimum of research before jumping on your soapbox. A quick search on Google shows that the most common crime of female prisoners in the UK is theft/shoplifting. For male prisoners it's violence against the person.

Only 8% of convicted murderers are female and less than 4% of convicted child abusers are female. On the other hand 60% of trans-identifying male prisoners have been convicted of at least one sex offence.

Even someone so wilfully blind to the rights and needs of women as you should be able to see how inappropriate it has always been to lock up men in women's prisons, however those men present and identify.

300 women in Scotland in prison. 8000 men. (roughly).

OP posts:
lcakethereforeIam · 12/11/2026 22:54

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 22:32

Or Alexandra Stewart's victims.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4glne43101o

Alexandra Stewart who could have had all the affirming surgeries he wished to change his...phenotype. Decided to just have his madam's apple shaved. He could have had his junk chopped off, Scottish taxpayers would have paid, but he didn't want to. I'm beginning to think he's not taking this trans thing all that seriously 😐

OP posts:
WearyAuldWumman · 12/11/2026 22:57

Glad to hear it. I believe that he was the prisoner who kept oscillating between the male and female estate, mainly because he kept changing his mind - in spite of being vocal about wanting surgery.

NotAtMyAge · 12/11/2026 22:57

Transperson · 12/11/2026 20:50

You don't know that. It's time for Westminster to lose its veto.

The law says otherwise. The devolution settlement specifically excludes equality law. Only Westminster can change that.

murasaki · 12/11/2026 22:58

lcakethereforeIam · 12/11/2026 22:54

Alexandra Stewart who could have had all the affirming surgeries he wished to change his...phenotype. Decided to just have his madam's apple shaved. He could have had his junk chopped off, Scottish taxpayers would have paid, but he didn't want to. I'm beginning to think he's not taking this trans thing all that seriously 😐

About as seriously as TP is, going by what he's said.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 12/11/2026 23:01

Transperson · 12/11/2026 20:21

I don't think most had any impact by trans people being there or not.

Have you asked, rather than assuming, or telling them [the women] there is no impact?

NotAtMyAge · 12/11/2026 23:03

Transperson · 12/11/2026 21:12

Google it.

I did. It's specifically a US practice.

WearyAuldWumman · 12/11/2026 23:04

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 22:50

Holly Bruce:

'Ms Bruce also criticised the fact that female prisons no longer house biological men. She said that she had “safeguarding concerns” around trans prisoners. She said: “I do have concerns that there are going to be real risks posed to these women" if they are housed in the male estate.'

I mean. What is there to say to that?

Maybe introduce her to Paris or Katie and let her see the reality of what she wants to inflict on the female prison estate? The problem is that some people have fooled themselves into believing that trans identified prisoners are harmless souls who have been imprisoned for prostitution etc.

I still find it astonishing that trans activists accepted (and celebrated)Tiffany Scott as trans.

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 23:07

https://www.scottishparliament.tv/meeting/equalities-human-rights-and-civil-justice-committee-november-12-2026

I have only watched this clip so far, looking forward to watching the rest tomorrow.

Susan Smith of FWS , at the Scottish Parliament.

https://www.scottishparliament.tv/meeting/equalities-human-rights-and-civil-justice-committee-november-12-2026?clip_start=11:25:47&clip_end=11:27:45

OP posts:
WearyAuldWumman · 12/11/2026 23:07

socialdilemmawhattodo · 12/11/2026 23:01

Have you asked, rather than assuming, or telling them [the women] there is no impact?

Rhona Hotchkiss spoke eloquently about this:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-scotland-51452489

Rhona Hotchkiss

Concern over trans women in female jails

The former governor of Cornton Vale says that in her experience it is "always an issue to have trans women in with female prisoners”.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-scotland-51452489

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/11/2026 23:07

I don't think most had any impact by transpeople being there or not

How the fuck do you know? You cannot impute feelings on to other people, just because you think that's how they should feel.
The arrogance is astounding.

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 23:08

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/11/2026 23:07

I don't think most had any impact by transpeople being there or not

How the fuck do you know? You cannot impute feelings on to other people, just because you think that's how they should feel.
The arrogance is astounding.

Come on, it's a man telling women he is a woman!

OP posts:
NotAtMyAge · 12/11/2026 23:09

Transperson · 12/11/2026 21:33

People who sexually assault shouldn't share a cell with anyone, anyoneeeee.

Have you any idea how many more prisons we'd need to give all sex offenders their own cell? Among male prisoners in the UK sexual offences, at about 22%, are second only to violence against the person at 35%

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/11/2026 23:10

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 23:08

Come on, it's a man telling women he is a woman!

Oh, so it is.
I stand corrected.
🤣
A man has spoken.

NotAtMyAge · 12/11/2026 23:13

Transperson · 12/11/2026 21:58

Andy is planning on devolving powers DW DW soon GC groups won't be able to use the court systems as a humans rights circus.

I think Andy has far more pressing matters on his plate now than cosying up to John Swinney.

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/11/2026 23:15

@Transperson I wish you'd proofread your posts, because a lot of them don't make sense.

Helleofabore · 12/11/2026 23:15

Transperson · 12/11/2026 20:17

Wow you managed to cause hell to a whole 20 people, well done.

How many additional female people do you consider acceptable to be harmed by including any male person with a transgender identity in a female single sex provision, before all male people above around 8 years old are fully excluded from all single sex provisions?

What is your number? How many female people are ok to be harmed in your opinion?

solerolover · 12/11/2026 23:16

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/female-inmate-threatened-sexual-abuse-transitioning-man-xg35lck28

https://archive.ph/dMSDZ

The woman, referred to in court documents as AA, described unwanted sexual attention from one male prisoner, referred to as MP1, who had “one hell of a big build” and started “transitioning” in jail, wearing “a tight top and jeans and high healed [sic] trainers”.

She said: “MP1 fancied me. I was scared. He saw that. He threatened and intimidated me. He fancied me the way a man fancies a girl. He would expose his body parts, and wear skin tight leggings, so that everyone could see the shape of his penis. That’s sexual assault or indecency.

“I felt unsafe with these men around me. MP1 did threaten me with sexual abuse.”

One one occasion, the woman said MP1, a “lifer”, “battered a lassie when I was there”. “I seen [sic] it with my own eyes,” she said. “So did the officers.”

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/article/female-inmate-threatened-sexual-abuse-transitioning-man-xg35lck28

Manyanamanyana · 12/11/2026 23:18

Transperson · 12/11/2026 20:44

This is a feminism category right? Haven't seen anything in the rules excluding trans women from the definition. Therefore me discussing the issues that concern with trans women is appropriate.

Feel free to disagree but yk

Feminism is for women, not men. I don't include trans identified men as women, as the only prerequisite for being a "trans woman", is to be male.