Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Well done, FWS, and women everywhere. There are no men in women's jails in Scotland.

404 replies

ArabellaScott · 12/11/2026 20:08

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c962p8217zxdo

'All transgender inmates have been moved out of women's prisons, according to the Scottish Prison Service (SPS).
SPS deputy chief executive Adam Jobson told Holyrood's Equalities Committee that a small number of transgender prisoners had been moved. He said that trans women - biological males who identify as women - were now held in men's prisons.
The move was to comply with a judge's ruling in June, that sex segregation in prisons must be based on biological sex rather than gender identity.'

An image of a series of security gates in a prison - with floor-to-ceiling white metal bars. Above the first set it says "E/F Wing" and a prison officer - a bald man in a white shirt and black trousers - is opening the gate. We see him from behind.

No biological males in women's prisons, Scottish Prison Service confirms

All transgender women - biological males who identify as women - have now been moved into men's jails to comply with a legal ruling.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c962p8217zxdo

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
SirChenjins · 14/11/2026 15:46

The list of TIMs who have publicly declared their absolute certainty that they pass as women is a very long one.

None of them do.

murasaki · 14/11/2026 16:08

Ereshkigalangcleg · 14/11/2026 15:42

Robin Moira White “somatically female”

Dr Upton “I’m biological and I’m a woman so I’m a biological woman. Biological sex is a nebulous dog whistle.”

neither of these men pass as female

Quite so. I remember RMW on antiques roadshow, and I was in the kitchen, DP was watching and said 'I think this man is the lawyer you keep mentioning'. I popped my head round. Readers, it was.

BlueLegume · 14/11/2026 16:14

Dennis Kavanagh has done a video guide to commenting on the Conversion Practices draft bill. He had it on his X but just notice he has started a thread including the link.

Link to video is here:

Link to thread he started is here: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599461-conversion-practices-video-guide-to-responding-before-deadline-on-monday

Thanks DK.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/pmR1ALMFnrU?si=4hUjZsd1O56efQXa

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 16:23

And on that denial that no female can 'tell', here is one of the gait studies.

Table 2 shows that sex can be identified from gait by the study cohort with 65% accuracy just from dots on the joints over a 3.8 second duration.

To be clear, 65% accuracy from dots over a less than 4 second duration! It was still over 60% accuracy from 0.4 seconds.

This is a fairly handy graphic. It is basic and is not showing q-angles but it communicates the basics.

DETECTING SEX CATEGORY BY GAIT STUDY

www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnhum.2020.00320/full

Abstract
This paper explores in parallel the underlying mechanisms in human perception of biological motion and the best approaches for automatic classification of gait. The experiments tested three different learning paradigms, namely, biological, biomimetic, and non-biomimetic models for gender identification from human gait. Psychophysical experiments with twenty-one observers were conducted along with computational experiments without applying any gender specific modifications to the models or the stimuli. Results demonstrate the utilization of a generic memory based learning system in humans for gait perception, thus reducing ambiguity between two opposing learning systems proposed for biological motion perception. Results also support the biomimetic nature of memory based artificial neural networks (ANN) in their ability to emulate biological neural networks, as opposed to non-biomimetic models. In addition, the comparison between biological and computational learning approaches establishes a memory based biomimetic model as the best candidate for a generic artificial gait classifier (83% accuracy, p < 0.001), compared to human observers (66%, p < 0.005) or non-biomimetic models (83%, p < 0.001) while adhering to human-like sensitivity to gender identification, promising potential for application of the model in any given non-gender based gait perception objective with superhuman performance.

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 16:23

The degree of misinformation that men wish desperately to believe is quite concerning really. As we have seen from a different thread, one poster makes claims that they simply cannot prove and that the evidence disproves, but the poster will just keep on doubling down, and then another male poster will jump in and support that poster.

I think we keep witnessing the result of male people reassuring each other and their supporters joining in but so much of it is based on either falsity. Or it is based on information vapour - that ambiguous claim that in the future x will be proven and therefore you all must believe what I am saying is true now... because it 'might' be proven true in the future.

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 16:26

Here is the image for the study

Well done, FWS, and women everywhere. There are no men in women's jails in Scotland.
Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 16:38

And here is another man who calls himself 'female'.

Maybe the men telling us that they are female because they are 'phenotypically leaning more towards female' can start to understand that we have heard it all before. No man is that special that he can say, 'I am female' and expect any female person to ever believe him.

Because if he says it, and all these other men say it, who the fuck is the arbiter of which man is telling the truth about something that is impossible in any case, and which man is nowhere near 'phenotypically' female?

When you think of it, maybe there is a heirarchy of these men all judging each other and thinking 'nah.... you don't make the female label', while telling each other just how amazingly they pass.

THIS NEEDS A VPN SET TO THE USA TO SEE THE VIDEO

https://news.sky.com/story/trans-cyclist-rachel-mckinnon-defends-her-right-to-race-in-womens-competitions-11838131

Trans cyclist Rachel McKinnon defends her right to race in women's competitions

By Martha Kelner
Sunday 20 October 2019

Trans athlete McKinnon will race to defend her sprint title at the Masters track cycling championships in Manchester on Saturday.

And then

"All my medical records say female," she said. "My doctor treats me as a female person, my racing licence says female, but people who oppose my existence still want to think of me as male."

"There's a stereotype that men are always stronger than women, so people think there is an unfair advantage. By preventing trans women from competing or requiring them to take medication, you're denying their human rights."

Asked if she accepted it is possible that transgender women retained a physical advantage over cis female competitors (the term used to describe someone who identifies as the same gender they were assigned at birth), McKinnon replied: "Is it possible? Yes it is possible. But there are elite track cyclists who are bigger than me."

"There is a range of body sizes and strength, you can be successful with massively different body shapes. To take a British example, look at Victoria Pendleton, an Olympic champion with teeny tiny legs."
"In many Olympic disciplines the gap in performance is bigger between first and eighth in a single sex event than it is between the first man and the first woman."

and then

It is one of the most politically charged and sensitive issues around - but asked whether trans inclusion was more important than retaining a category for women in sport, McKinnon replied: "I think what your asking me is, 'Is it more important that trans people are included, than it is to retain fairness in sport?'

"My point is that trans inclusion is fairness, it is unfair to exclude trans women. This is much bigger than sport, it's a proxy for all of trans inclusion in society. Talk of bathrooms has switched into sport by people who don't care about sport."

__

In the video, McKinnon says "if you think that transwomen are men are men, then you think that there is an unfair advantage."

and my point about the pronouns comes from this quote:

at around 37 seconds into the video: "We care about sport, it is central to society. If you want to say, 'well, I believe you're a woman for all of society, except this massive central part that is sport, then, that is not fair. Fairness is the inclusion of transwomen."

In this video and article, McKinnon uses the:

Unfair to not think of us as female since people 'accept us as female elsewhere'.

The 'I don't always win, therefore I don't have a competitive advantage fallacy'

The 'Phelps Gambit' fallacy - range of body sizes, and shape etc

Elite male's advantage should not be used for all levels to exclude male people

Questions sex categorisation anyway

The 'not many transwomen in the Olympics anyway' fallacy

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 16:43

Just added this here also about the men who use single sex provisions by stealth.

It is not ok for male people to just use female single sex provisions by stealth.

What is the difference between a male person using the provision by stealth and these male people?

Both actions ignore/dismiss/reject female people’s collective consent which cannot be gained.

These videos are a reminder of the other common reaction from men we see to our rejection that they are female people in any way. This is the reaction to being told ‘no, you should respect female people’s needs for single sex provisions’ by a celebrity.

Alexandra Billings self published these videos . This one first I believe.
https://x.com/gaynotqueer1/status/2032811484271817092?s=46

Then the chilling and menacing response to women saying 'no' here stitched into Amy Sousa’s response.

https://x.com/knownheretic/status/2032639781658833142?s=46

The menace is chilling to see. Yet, apparently we are supposed to welcome these same men into provisions designated as single sex for our protection from men threatening and intimidating us.

It becomes so clear that these men hate female people in general when they gloat over not being able to stop them accessing provisions that they should be excluded from and lack the inclination to self exclude from. Just as they gloat over organisational decisions to remove female single sex provisions in response to law changes that exclude male people from those provisions.
At the same time, we are supposed to believe that these men are most vulnerable and marginalised.

This set of tweets is from Daviana. Who started posting videos about how he knew he was a man etc. He was considered to be 'one of the reasonable ones' because of that.

Of course, as he has made more videos more has come out about what and how he really thinks. Including his behaviour towards his ex-wife...

https://x.com/KnownHeretic/status/2031523680136868150?s=20

https://x.com/KnownHeretic/status/2031873045682667588?s=20

https://x.com/KnownHeretic/status/2031975467725832460?s=20

These men are chilling once you see what they really think.

The gloating from this man as he also envisions negative impacts on female people because they rejected his demands seems to be highlighting just how common that reaction is from men who don’t get what they want from women.
Billings and Daviana are just two men who are showing women who they really are. It seems some men really cannot help themselves in showing that these demands are also part of the power dynamic.

It makes those ‘you got what you deserved after you rejected me’ behaviours all so familiar.

Oh... And I believe that Billings also believes that he 'passes'.

Amy E. Sousa, MA Depth Psychology (@KnownHeretic) on X

Amazing news, and an absolute WIN for women. By the power of our collective NO and social pressure, Daviana aka David Memont has agreed to stay out of women’s spaces. He still owes women an apology for ever disrespecting our boundaries. And he acts l...

https://x.com/KnownHeretic/status/2031975467725832460?s=20

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 16:48

And this one too.

AMY SOUSA - INSIGHT INTO MANIPULATION ON CONSENT and LANGUAGE.

I think this is a useful video in that Amy highlights several important things.

One is the nature of the boundary violations of male people, that even a boundary violation by deception is a significant issue.

But she also highlights the tactics and emotional manipulation that underlie the rhetoric people use to demand that male people are treated as if they are female people.

Remembering of course, that this can only ever be premised from a philosophical position. Because there is no material way for male person to change sex and someone’s feelings of gender dysphoria does not mean that they are materially the sex they want to believe they are.

https://x.com/knownheretic/status/2006188958586380420?s=46

Once you can strip away the emotionally manipulative language and behaviour, there is no logic or science that supports the demand that male people should be treated as if they are female

There really are some men who feel that they can just convince female people to consent to their presence or to convince female people that their investment in acquiring breasts which are still 'male breasts' and other treatments gives them a claim to describe themselves as 'female' either explicitly or implicitly by simply using female single sex provisions.

murasaki · 14/11/2026 16:52

Yes, our recent visitor never answered me as to why his opinion of his phenotypical presentation overrode mine.

BlueLegume · 14/11/2026 17:01

BlueLegume · 14/11/2026 16:14

Dennis Kavanagh has done a video guide to commenting on the Conversion Practices draft bill. He had it on his X but just notice he has started a thread including the link.

Link to video is here:

Link to thread he started is here: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599461-conversion-practices-video-guide-to-responding-before-deadline-on-monday

Thanks DK.

Reminder about the Conversion Practices draft bill and guidance as to how we can comment. Only got until Monday

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599461-conversion-practices-video-guide-to-responding-before-deadline-on-monday?reply=155924970

Conversion Practices Video Guide to responding before deadline on Monday | Mumsnet

Hey Mumsnet I've done a video guide with legal help for responding to the pre legislative scrutiny committee's call for evidence which closes Monday...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599461-conversion-practices-video-guide-to-responding-before-deadline-on-monday?reply=155924970

Tallisker · 14/11/2026 17:14

The question asked about why don’t we like transpeople was answered by many, many posts lying, obfuscating, ignoring boundaries, refusal to listen, gloating, needling, scoffing etc. It’s not that I don’t like transpeople, I despise their behaviour and their treatment of me and every other woman. I’ve never met a nice one who wouldn’t trample all over me and my boundaries in a heartbeat and without a second thought. As has been amply and repeatedly ad nauseam demonstrated recently.

Perenelle · 14/11/2026 17:21

Then the chilling and menacing response to women saying 'no' here stitched into Amy Sousa’s response.
https://x.com/knownheretic/status/2032639781658833142?s=46
The menace is chilling to see. Yet, apparently we are supposed to welcome these same men into provisions designated as single sex for our protection from men threatening and intimidating us.

That was intensely creepy. I certainly would not feel safe sharing any space with this man.

Women can be mean and threatening of course, but there is just a different energy. And it diffuses from dominance. Bleurgh.

But Amy is great. Thanks for sharing! These videos prove exactly why there is a need for single sex spaces.

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 17:33

Perenelle · 14/11/2026 17:21

Then the chilling and menacing response to women saying 'no' here stitched into Amy Sousa’s response.
https://x.com/knownheretic/status/2032639781658833142?s=46
The menace is chilling to see. Yet, apparently we are supposed to welcome these same men into provisions designated as single sex for our protection from men threatening and intimidating us.

That was intensely creepy. I certainly would not feel safe sharing any space with this man.

Women can be mean and threatening of course, but there is just a different energy. And it diffuses from dominance. Bleurgh.

But Amy is great. Thanks for sharing! These videos prove exactly why there is a need for single sex spaces.

The thing is, that if any woman's group made a project of collecting men's videos that intimidated female people about those men telling women they are coming in anyway, whether the female people agree or not, I estimate it would now be in hundreds, may even over a thousand.

Because it is just that common.

The reaction videos of male people describing what they want to do to female people who reject their claim to be female would be a thread that would be alarming. I have been tempted to do it in response to all those men who declare that they are 'harmless'. Because, who the fuck also judges which men are 'harmless' and which ones would indeed carry out their threats that they detail on self published video.

But apparently, we must trust the posters who tell us not only do they 'pass' but they are 'harmless', and never ever have their correct sex identified by any female people.

.... then we know there are these videos circulating around the internet and they wonder why no female person will let them know that that male person is easy to identify as being male.

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 18:01

https://x.com/knownheretic/status/2121084034768089122?a=NbWhDZchL87koqifUqY&s=46

A man being honest about fetishising lesbians.

murasaki · 14/11/2026 19:57

Jesus.

Alucard55 · 14/11/2026 21:30

murasaki · 14/11/2026 16:08

Quite so. I remember RMW on antiques roadshow, and I was in the kitchen, DP was watching and said 'I think this man is the lawyer you keep mentioning'. I popped my head round. Readers, it was.

What was he doing on ARS?

murasaki · 14/11/2026 21:35

Alucard55 · 14/11/2026 21:30

What was he doing on ARS?

Something about trains and railway memorabilia if I recall correctly.

JanesLittleGirl · 14/11/2026 21:41

murasaki · 14/11/2026 21:35

Something about trains and railway memorabilia if I recall correctly.

Makes sense. Didn't he work for British Rail back in the day?

murasaki · 14/11/2026 21:42

Yes, I think so. It was illuminating to see him in person as it were. Passing he was not.

murasaki · 14/11/2026 21:47

Dp knew he was a man straight away. And then realised he might be who he is (turns out he does listen!).

Alucard55 · 15/11/2026 10:18

murasaki · 14/11/2026 21:35

Something about trains and railway memorabilia if I recall correctly.

I'll need to Google that one!

Perenelle · 15/11/2026 11:46

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 17:33

The thing is, that if any woman's group made a project of collecting men's videos that intimidated female people about those men telling women they are coming in anyway, whether the female people agree or not, I estimate it would now be in hundreds, may even over a thousand.

Because it is just that common.

The reaction videos of male people describing what they want to do to female people who reject their claim to be female would be a thread that would be alarming. I have been tempted to do it in response to all those men who declare that they are 'harmless'. Because, who the fuck also judges which men are 'harmless' and which ones would indeed carry out their threats that they detail on self published video.

But apparently, we must trust the posters who tell us not only do they 'pass' but they are 'harmless', and never ever have their correct sex identified by any female people.

.... then we know there are these videos circulating around the internet and they wonder why no female person will let them know that that male person is easy to identify as being male.

Exactly, no one can decide who is harmless and who is not - that's why safeguarding rules must include every man.

I am really on the fence about these videos, as I find them really disturbing and hard to watch. On the other hand it sure would be helpful for more people to see what is really going on in this milieu we are supposed to be supportive of. That's why I value people like Amy or Mr Menno and anyone who openly calls out the insanity.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 15/11/2026 14:15

Helleofabore · 14/11/2026 17:33

The thing is, that if any woman's group made a project of collecting men's videos that intimidated female people about those men telling women they are coming in anyway, whether the female people agree or not, I estimate it would now be in hundreds, may even over a thousand.

Because it is just that common.

The reaction videos of male people describing what they want to do to female people who reject their claim to be female would be a thread that would be alarming. I have been tempted to do it in response to all those men who declare that they are 'harmless'. Because, who the fuck also judges which men are 'harmless' and which ones would indeed carry out their threats that they detail on self published video.

But apparently, we must trust the posters who tell us not only do they 'pass' but they are 'harmless', and never ever have their correct sex identified by any female people.

.... then we know there are these videos circulating around the internet and they wonder why no female person will let them know that that male person is easy to identify as being male.

Its mansplaining on steroids.