Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

817 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/11/2026 15:03

Crazy to think someone might not be always asking themselves "but what if I'm wrong?"

I certainly do. All the time.

But I haven't been able to disprove the significance of sex in practical terms as much as I try. (And frankly I make a better attempt than most of the Genderists manage!)

Prekoc2 · 12/11/2026 15:11

ChequerToRed · 12/11/2026 15:03

For me, I think it comes from the same place as my atheism.
I just can’t be doing with the metaphysical. It all seems completely batshit and nothing I’ve seen in half a century of life has convinced me otherwise. I don’t believe in souls, I don’t believe in the inexplicable or the spiritual.
Gender is no different, where others insist on some mysterious essence that makes them other than what they appear I see a lot of wishful thinking propped up by some shallow stereotypes, and tbh those stereotypes are picked and chosen as convenient. After all, who among us (apart from the obvious) has failed to notice that a great many men who adopt a ‘woman’ look happily retain all the worst of their male qualities? Often the qualities, such as entitlement, a misogynistic sense of superiority, aggression, that benefit only them.

I live in the Emerald City. Lots of people say how great the wizard is, but I’ve seen behind the curtain and it’s just some old dude pulling levers.

I'd love to ask someone who believes souls can be born in the wrong body to tell me how many trans women there are in Afghanistan.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/11/2026 15:15

Prekoc2 · 12/11/2026 14:49

Same as it's easy to accept people of different races than your own as equals...

It's not the same at all. I don't pretend to be black and expect everyone to go along with it.

Exactly.

Anti-racism doesn't say some Black people are really White. I don't think I need to highlight how racist that statement would be!

Anti-racism is the recognition that ones race has no impact on the qualities that make one an equal human.

Genderism however does not say ones sex has no impact on the qualities that make one an equal human, it says that some men are really women. And yes, that is just as sexist as the previous statement is racist.

Feminism is the radical notion that woman are human beings, while Genderism basically boils down to the incoherent notion that ones sex has no impact on ones sex 😂

tobee · 12/11/2026 15:16

I mean it can often be exhausting. But surely not as exhausting as being a TRA and trying to believe in the interminable bullshit you must spout .

BobbleBear · 12/11/2026 15:20

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:15

You don't believe in introspection just in case its your priors are off the mark? Reactionary oversimplified perspectives are made in such ways.

Can you trans-late that word soup into English please?

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 12/11/2026 15:23

I'm always reminded about the black female trans ally journalist who's interviewed Rachel Dolezal twice, both very bad tempered affairs.
Being black, she's offended beyond belief that a white woman like Rachel IDs as black (now actually African American).
Yet when it's pointed out to her she has no issues with men who ID as women, she goes off on a tantrum about transphobia in society.
There isn't enough time remaining in the life of the universe to reconcile her total inconsistency.
No non black can become black.
But non women can become women.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2026 15:24

BobbleBear · 12/11/2026 15:20

Can you trans-late that word soup into English please?

It;s like Alphabetti spaghetti, Pick the letters out and make a sensible sentence.

ChequerToRed · 12/11/2026 15:38

Prekoc2 · 12/11/2026 15:11

I'd love to ask someone who believes souls can be born in the wrong body to tell me how many trans women there are in Afghanistan.

Ah, a question for the ages, that.
You can even flip it and ask why Afghan women don’t identify their way out of their brutal, sex based, oppression?
You won’t get a satisfactory answer out of them, because there isn’t one.
I can give an answer, though. It’s that the contemporary trans movement is a First World luxury belief that bases an identity on what you can purchase, which is why we have the vociferous insistence that what actually makes a woman a woman isn’t ‘being a woman’, because it’s the bits you can’t swallow/inject/have sliced about/ buy off the shelf.
If we were plunged into a post apocalyptic hellscape there’d be a mass detransition.

Maaate · 12/11/2026 18:33

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 12/11/2026 15:23

I'm always reminded about the black female trans ally journalist who's interviewed Rachel Dolezal twice, both very bad tempered affairs.
Being black, she's offended beyond belief that a white woman like Rachel IDs as black (now actually African American).
Yet when it's pointed out to her she has no issues with men who ID as women, she goes off on a tantrum about transphobia in society.
There isn't enough time remaining in the life of the universe to reconcile her total inconsistency.
No non black can become black.
But non women can become women.

The irony being that it is indeed possible to be mixed race and then identify more with one race than the other. The same can't be said for your sex

JanesLittleGirl · 12/11/2026 18:44

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:26

Let me help you.

The qualifying criteria for age depends on chronology.
The qualifying criteria for gender depends on the socially constructed roles, behaviours , expression, and identities that societies consider typical for women, men, and gender-diverse people.

I completely agree with you.

Gender is a social construct that applies roles, behaviours and responsibilities to people purely based on their reproductive capacity. The effect of this is to prevent women from achieving their full social, political and economic potential.

This is why I am a Gender Critical Radical Feminist. It has nothing to do with transgenderism.

My objection to transgenderism at a political level is that it perpetuates the very social construct that I oppose.

My objection to transgenderism at a personal or social level is twofold. It's totally unreasonable to grant any man or boy access to the spaces, services and sports reasonably reserved for women and girls and it's indefensible to even suggest to a young person that it's possible to change your sex.

2021x · 12/11/2026 18:48

OldCrone · 12/11/2026 08:35

And the qualifying criteria for sex?

Sex is the criterion.

OP posts:
OP posts:
TheHereticalOne · 12/11/2026 20:20

2021x · 12/11/2026 18:52

To help everyone who doesn't know :)

Outstanding.

I think this needs more frequent airing on these boards in lieu of yet another round of Let's State The Bleeding Obvious For You.

It's aimed at about the right educational level too. Doesn't even require reading skills.

A triumph.

caprioska · 12/11/2026 21:02

Babyboomtastic · 12/11/2026 11:38

Absolutely. People are free to believe what they wish, but we are equally free not to believe.

A man can believe he's a woman, a frog, an alien, or anything else asich as he wants. To us he's still a man, and we do not have to share in his illusion.

We've had enough of men telling us what we should do, how we should behave, what we should say and what we should think.

But that's not what the OP is complaining about:

"I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity"

Their grievance is because they don't share other people's understanding of the world they shouldn’t validate it as an identity & implies there’s something wrong in doing so.

Identity being the unique combination of your individual traits, personal values & life experiences as a self concept. Validation of another's self concept is not agreement to it. You can recognise and respect that someone has a distinct internal experience or feeling without agreeing with their perspective or endorsing their behaviour.

And while its true atheists think theists are delusional, they generally don't reject their right to their own individual self concept as theists don't of them. Nor do atheists declare others who respect religious identity as pretending to agree with them.

Why the invalidation of identity particularly when it involves competing rights?
Here's some interesting insight:

"When people deny the validity of another group's identity because they view their rights as competing, it is most commonly described as identity invalidation driven by a zero-sum mindset (or zero-sum bias).
Depending on the context—whether psychological, sociological, or political—several specific terms capture different layers of this behavior:

1. Core Psychological Concepts
Zero-Sum Mindset (or Zero-Sum Bias): The belief that rights, status, or resources are strictly limited. In this view, granting recognition or rights to one group automatically takes something away from another, creating a perceived threat that motivates the denial of the out-group's identity.
Identity Invalidation (or Identity Denial): The active refusal to recognize, accept, or legitimize another person's or group's self-defined identity, lived experience, or existence.
Competitive Victimhood: A dynamic where groups compete to prove they have suffered more or are the "true" marginalized group. To protect their own claim to victimhood or resources, one group may invalidate the oppression or identity of the other.

2. Sociological & Political Concepts
Gatekeeping: Controlling who gets access to a particular identity, community, or set of rights. Groups may rigidly define criteria to exclude others whom they see as competitors for legal protections or social support.
Erasure: The systematic ignoring, removing, or denying of a specific group's existence, history, or identity. When driven by competing rights, erasure serves to remove the "rival" group from the political or legal conversation entirely.
Ontological Security Threat: A sociological term describing the anxiety people feel when their worldview or social standing is challenged. Denying a competing group's validity is often a defense mechanism to protect one's own sense of place and entitlement in society.

How These Concepts Work Together
In practice, these terms describe a chain reaction. A group perceives a zero-sum conflict over finite legal protections, social status, or resources. To protect their own standing, they engage in gatekeeping or identity invalidation, framing the other group's identity as illegitimate or fabricated rather than acknowledging a legitimate conflict of interests."

Cattywillow · 12/11/2026 21:15

Oh goodness. That copy paste about zero sum has really opened my eyes. Thank you so much.

LOL….nah. A woman only space with a male person in it is no longer woman only. No matter what his own thoughts on his identity might be. So, you see….

inkymoose · 12/11/2026 21:23

Re the post above by caprioska at 21:02

Despite severe temptation to skim read, or to skip, I read all the "interesting information" wordus saladus extraordinairus.

It doesn't give any interesting information, but if you can decipher the points through the obfuscatory language, it's a long-winded DARVO-type explanation that shows the opposite of what it's trying to show. The sad condition of the trans-rights-activists is that they believe trans people to be "the most marginalised, the most oppressed" - and their attitude towards women is dismissive at best. It's not the other way round.

Trying to redefine the meaning of the word "validation" is unsuccessful. It still means "to confirm, substantiate, verify".

2021x · 12/11/2026 21:27

caprioska · 12/11/2026 21:02

But that's not what the OP is complaining about:

"I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity"

Their grievance is because they don't share other people's understanding of the world they shouldn’t validate it as an identity & implies there’s something wrong in doing so.

Identity being the unique combination of your individual traits, personal values & life experiences as a self concept. Validation of another's self concept is not agreement to it. You can recognise and respect that someone has a distinct internal experience or feeling without agreeing with their perspective or endorsing their behaviour.

And while its true atheists think theists are delusional, they generally don't reject their right to their own individual self concept as theists don't of them. Nor do atheists declare others who respect religious identity as pretending to agree with them.

Why the invalidation of identity particularly when it involves competing rights?
Here's some interesting insight:

"When people deny the validity of another group's identity because they view their rights as competing, it is most commonly described as identity invalidation driven by a zero-sum mindset (or zero-sum bias).
Depending on the context—whether psychological, sociological, or political—several specific terms capture different layers of this behavior:

1. Core Psychological Concepts
Zero-Sum Mindset (or Zero-Sum Bias): The belief that rights, status, or resources are strictly limited. In this view, granting recognition or rights to one group automatically takes something away from another, creating a perceived threat that motivates the denial of the out-group's identity.
Identity Invalidation (or Identity Denial): The active refusal to recognize, accept, or legitimize another person's or group's self-defined identity, lived experience, or existence.
Competitive Victimhood: A dynamic where groups compete to prove they have suffered more or are the "true" marginalized group. To protect their own claim to victimhood or resources, one group may invalidate the oppression or identity of the other.

2. Sociological & Political Concepts
Gatekeeping: Controlling who gets access to a particular identity, community, or set of rights. Groups may rigidly define criteria to exclude others whom they see as competitors for legal protections or social support.
Erasure: The systematic ignoring, removing, or denying of a specific group's existence, history, or identity. When driven by competing rights, erasure serves to remove the "rival" group from the political or legal conversation entirely.
Ontological Security Threat: A sociological term describing the anxiety people feel when their worldview or social standing is challenged. Denying a competing group's validity is often a defense mechanism to protect one's own sense of place and entitlement in society.

How These Concepts Work Together
In practice, these terms describe a chain reaction. A group perceives a zero-sum conflict over finite legal protections, social status, or resources. To protect their own standing, they engage in gatekeeping or identity invalidation, framing the other group's identity as illegitimate or fabricated rather than acknowledging a legitimate conflict of interests."

This is not what I felt at all.

Do not explain how I feel to other people.

OP posts:
caprioska · 12/11/2026 21:35

2021x · 12/11/2026 21:27

This is not what I felt at all.

Do not explain how I feel to other people.

Words have meaning….

2021x · 12/11/2026 21:40

caprioska · 12/11/2026 21:35

Words have meaning….

I read a really interesting book this year called The Social Brain.

They discussed gossip.

They said that the structure and content of gossip between men and other men is the same as gossip between women and other women.

The only time it changes is when women are gossiping with men; men will only speak to women in terms of technicalities.

OP posts:
inkymoose · 12/11/2026 21:45

2021x · 12/11/2026 21:27

This is not what I felt at all.

Do not explain how I feel to other people.

It doesn't explain how anyone feels. Too many words and not enough meaning.

For me, I had no idea I was "gender critical" and had to ask about what it meant when the term first popped up in a Green Party email in 2021. It felt normal to me to understand that women were female from conception and men were male from conception. When I found out that you weren't even allowed to talk about this stuff, I found mumsnet, the only place where any discussion was possible.

JanesLittleGirl · 12/11/2026 22:27

caprioska · 12/11/2026 21:02

But that's not what the OP is complaining about:

"I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity"

Their grievance is because they don't share other people's understanding of the world they shouldn’t validate it as an identity & implies there’s something wrong in doing so.

Identity being the unique combination of your individual traits, personal values & life experiences as a self concept. Validation of another's self concept is not agreement to it. You can recognise and respect that someone has a distinct internal experience or feeling without agreeing with their perspective or endorsing their behaviour.

And while its true atheists think theists are delusional, they generally don't reject their right to their own individual self concept as theists don't of them. Nor do atheists declare others who respect religious identity as pretending to agree with them.

Why the invalidation of identity particularly when it involves competing rights?
Here's some interesting insight:

"When people deny the validity of another group's identity because they view their rights as competing, it is most commonly described as identity invalidation driven by a zero-sum mindset (or zero-sum bias).
Depending on the context—whether psychological, sociological, or political—several specific terms capture different layers of this behavior:

1. Core Psychological Concepts
Zero-Sum Mindset (or Zero-Sum Bias): The belief that rights, status, or resources are strictly limited. In this view, granting recognition or rights to one group automatically takes something away from another, creating a perceived threat that motivates the denial of the out-group's identity.
Identity Invalidation (or Identity Denial): The active refusal to recognize, accept, or legitimize another person's or group's self-defined identity, lived experience, or existence.
Competitive Victimhood: A dynamic where groups compete to prove they have suffered more or are the "true" marginalized group. To protect their own claim to victimhood or resources, one group may invalidate the oppression or identity of the other.

2. Sociological & Political Concepts
Gatekeeping: Controlling who gets access to a particular identity, community, or set of rights. Groups may rigidly define criteria to exclude others whom they see as competitors for legal protections or social support.
Erasure: The systematic ignoring, removing, or denying of a specific group's existence, history, or identity. When driven by competing rights, erasure serves to remove the "rival" group from the political or legal conversation entirely.
Ontological Security Threat: A sociological term describing the anxiety people feel when their worldview or social standing is challenged. Denying a competing group's validity is often a defense mechanism to protect one's own sense of place and entitlement in society.

How These Concepts Work Together
In practice, these terms describe a chain reaction. A group perceives a zero-sum conflict over finite legal protections, social status, or resources. To protect their own standing, they engage in gatekeeping or identity invalidation, framing the other group's identity as illegitimate or fabricated rather than acknowledging a legitimate conflict of interests."

Oh, now that you put it like that it is so obvious. How did I not realise it before?

You couldn't do me a favour by putting your post through an English language translator could you? I might not be as clever as you.

lcakethereforeIam · 12/11/2026 23:07

One of these women is not like the others...🎶

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?
Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 00:53

How it feels to me this week: at work, a job I love and am very good at, we have recently had the "respect at work" framework released, to much drum-rolling and fanfare.
The "gender affirmation guidelines" infuriate me, because, in Australia, men are women if they say they are, and women must simply accept those delusional men in anything that we might quietly want as female-only.
I find myself with very little respect for the people who nod along with this, despite the impacts on women and this feeling does not sit well with me. People who I enjoy working with otherwise and have enormous professional respect for. They will probably never know that I hold something that tastes like contempt, but isn't, because I otherwise genuinely like them.
I have no faith in my government, or any media outlet, organisation or service provider that supports this. I feel politically homeless. I can't believe the scale of the dismissal of womens rights. It has left me feeling deeply distant from huge parts of my cultural environment. In Australia the social, professional and legal threat to people who hold gender critical views is real, and it is depressing.
That's me being as honest as I'm willing to be.

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 01:02

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:09

No one is asking you to pretend anything only respect their right to their own choices & beliefs. Big difference.

Absolutely not true. In Australia I am 100% compelled to accept and validate the delusional identities of sex deniers. I face professional, legal and social consequences if I do not comply.
How does that align with you live and let live philosophy?

caprioska · 13/11/2026 01:24

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 01:02

Absolutely not true. In Australia I am 100% compelled to accept and validate the delusional identities of sex deniers. I face professional, legal and social consequences if I do not comply.
How does that align with you live and let live philosophy?

No you aren't. Respecting people's right to their own identity isn't the same as agreeing with it. The only potential consequences you would face would need to be based on behaviour that rises to the level of harassment or discrimination in the work place as you would for any other group.