Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

814 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
MagnoliaParks · 12/11/2026 11:55

Grammarnut · 12/11/2026 11:49

One has no right to police how others refer to you.

I KNOW!

I was pointing out the flaw in the TRA’s logic!

Because further than having no right to compel the speech of others, it’s entirely illogical to say one should respect pronouns and my brother will always be my brother. Both statements can’t be true as you can’t know that your brother will never want to be a sister.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 11:55

Grammarnut · 12/11/2026 11:49

One has no right to police how others refer to you.

Yes but this is TPA, a highly trans affirming person. I think it was a perfectly reasonable comment by @MagnoliaParks in the context.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2026 11:55

Datun · 12/11/2026 11:54

Yes, The Script. All utterly predictable.

There's a reason why some men really don't like women talking together, comparing notes, giving advice, offering support. It's incredibly powerful.

I'm told that at first feminism will piss you off, and then it will set you free.

I'm still at the pissed off stage.

I've doubled back to pissed off again. It seems like someone's decided 'OK women, you've had rights for 100 years, that's enough.'

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2026 11:58

Let me help you.
The qualifying criteria for age depends on chronology.

You could help by posting something that makes sense. And 'qualifying criteria' sounds like something DWP or HMRC come out with.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/11/2026 12:01

Datun · 12/11/2026 11:42

caprioska

Also, based entirely on pattern recognition, I predict that this poster will argue that you can't generalise, but neither can you individualise.

They will attempt to dismantle every argument, in order to be the only man on the planet to have the individual, highly specific criteria necessary to enter women's private spaces.

And they'll use every word in the English dictionary to avoid telling you exactly what that criteria is.

Quoting to put my chips on that bet as well.

All in.

Poker GIF by AllIn
GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/11/2026 12:03

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2026 11:55

I've doubled back to pissed off again. It seems like someone's decided 'OK women, you've had rights for 100 years, that's enough.'

I agree. It's a serious point. I think many younger women believe life has always been like this, with equal rights for women and equal participation in society. It hasn't. These things were fought bloody hard for. What has been gained can be taken away.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/11/2026 12:06

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2026 11:47

You can notice sexism your whole life long, without having the analysis afforded by feminism to process it.
I'm very fond of pattern recognition, and boy, once you've got the key, it's bloody everywhere.
The number of lightbulb moments I've had are never-ending. From the rules of misogyny, to DARVO, the true meaning of gaslighting, the lot.

It's really interesting you say that, because MN wasn't around when my marriage was breaking up because of ex's affair, but when I'm on the relationships board I'm nodding along with 'yep, recognise that, yep, recognise that.' And not just in personal relationships either, I've spotted someone using DARVO on me at work and not been taken in by it as they hoped. This site and this board is so educational for me.

once you've got the key, it's bloody everywhere.

Isn't it just.

There's a reason second wave Feminism called it Consciousness Raising.

"Woke" used to be an anti-racism term for the same process.

Fish starting to understand the water in which we swim.

BackToLurk · 12/11/2026 12:10

Imdunfer · 12/11/2026 11:40

He'll still be her brother.

Not according to TPA’s own logic. In fact they will retrospectively never have been their brother. That’s how bonkers it all is.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/11/2026 12:11

Datun · 12/11/2026 11:54

Yes, The Script. All utterly predictable.

There's a reason why some men really don't like women talking together, comparing notes, giving advice, offering support. It's incredibly powerful.

I'm told that at first feminism will piss you off, and then it will set you free.

I'm still at the pissed off stage.

And there's a reason men (and male defined social mores) have always sought to separate young women from older, to encourage them to dismiss our voices and perspectives as "bitter", "jealous", "dried up" so we can't tell them how we have seen all this shit and flannel the mean shower them with happen before, and we know how it really plays out.

"Trans" is often just another package for the same old sexist shit.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2026 12:11

GreyskySexRealistsky · 12/11/2026 12:03

I agree. It's a serious point. I think many younger women believe life has always been like this, with equal rights for women and equal participation in society. It hasn't. These things were fought bloody hard for. What has been gained can be taken away.

I can recall 25 years ago telling younger women at work about women not being able to get mortgages and needing a male guarantor if you wanted a loan, and they looked at me as if I were talking Sanskrit. As a young woman I had female relatives who did not as young women have the right to vote.

JuliaAgrippina · 12/11/2026 12:12

At its worse for us I did wonder if this was a small taste of what East germany felt like under communist rule.

That sounds OTT - but sat at my own kitchen table with DH trying to shush me as I oh so carefully crafted a sentence to gently question what school, youth group and peers were telling my bi/gay ND teens without starting a fight or pushing them away.

DH only just gone from be kind to actually seeing problem when they hit him personally - but in an environmnet where saying anything was costing jobs.

I remember another mother gentle sounding my views out stood outside GG - and me being oh so careful what I said back. Being told on here something helping my ND DDs and broadening the eldest social grousp away from toxic school freindship group I should have the courage to stop - as I disagreed with GG stance.

Now everyone over it - they are polite when dealing with trans people in RL but everyone so over it - and greatful the mix toilets seem to be on decline.

Aposterhasnoname · 12/11/2026 12:27

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:37

There is no such thing as

You could say the same about belief in god & yet people base their whole identities around it. This is no different.

You mean its a religion, that makes no sense to anyone who doesn't follow it, has many inconsistencies that are never explained, but followers are told to just have faith, and are threatened with dire punishments such as excommunication, burning in hell for eternity, or being banished from their communities if they dont, and a that a great many people think is utter tosh and are perfectly within their rights to say so?

Yeah, I think we can agree on this comparison.

TheHereticalOne · 12/11/2026 12:34

PriOn1 · 12/11/2026 09:42

I feel like Cassandra or like watching an ongoing, multi-car pile up that never seems to come to an end.

I guess many of us now understand how it feels to live through an episode of mass psychosis. Much easier for those who believe, than for those watching all the harms piling up, without having any power to stop it.

100% this, for me.

Significant psychosis plus psychological/social pressure as the dark underbelly of the human need for community.

I have acquired a newfound appreciation for The Crucible, in particular. I do sometimes wonder how much I was primed for rejecting all this by reading that sort of literary warning early in life.

Either way: 'More weight'.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 12:37

TheHereticalOne · 12/11/2026 12:34

100% this, for me.

Significant psychosis plus psychological/social pressure as the dark underbelly of the human need for community.

I have acquired a newfound appreciation for The Crucible, in particular. I do sometimes wonder how much I was primed for rejecting all this by reading that sort of literary warning early in life.

Either way: 'More weight'.

Yes I went to see a school production of the Crucible a couple of years ago and it was very much on my mind!

Grammarnut · 12/11/2026 13:32

MagnoliaParks · 12/11/2026 11:55

I KNOW!

I was pointing out the flaw in the TRA’s logic!

Because further than having no right to compel the speech of others, it’s entirely illogical to say one should respect pronouns and my brother will always be my brother. Both statements can’t be true as you can’t know that your brother will never want to be a sister.

Brother can want all he likes, though, you can't change sex!

Toseland · 12/11/2026 13:33

I feel exactly like I did when I was 10 and spent a lot of time outdoors, camping and hiking. I told my classmates not to stand under the huge tree at the top of the hill during a thunderstorm as it was dangerous. They all fell about laughing, I tried to explain over and over but they cut me off and laughed even more, some spent the entire year mocking me about it and calling me names.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/11/2026 13:53

When I was growing up, Sci Fi bad guys were typically totalitarian dictators and regimes. Big Brother. Brave New World. Tron, and hundreds of lesser known imitators. You can see a clear parallel between post war 20th century geopolitics and the villains of our stories.

When I was a kid, individual Nazis in TV and films were pathetic, beaten, a figure of fun. The horror of Nazism and the Holocaust was not just that they dehumanised and hated a group of people they judged their enemy or unworthy of being part of their society, but also that they had the totalitarian control to implement government approved destruction of these humans they considered unwanted and do it on an industrial scale.

And I wonder whether part of the reason more of our generation has rejected Genderism is that we still fear top down social control in a way that younger generations who didn't have the shadow of actual totalitarian regimes in their childhood but did grow up with the knowledge that LGB rights had only just been achieved, and in a "it's the job of teachers and schools, and then government, laws and institutions, to ensure people's feelings are not hurt or judged" culture, do not.

Pallisers · 12/11/2026 14:00

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/11/2026 07:46

It's really simple.

Trans people exist. And if you know them and accept them, using their correct name and pronouns is incredibly easy. Because that's just who they are.

Doesn't matter what they look like. My son is my son, regardless of whether he has visible boobs or not.

My stepdad is my dad., same as my half-brother will always be my brother, despite us all looking nothing alike.

It's really easy to see beyond a difference you don't share to the person. All you have to do is be a decent human being who values respect, and keeps an open mind.

Same as it's easy to accept people of different races than your own as equals, gay marriage as equal to straight and, say, women pilots as equal to male in ability.

People different to you all bleed the same, live the same, feel the same. Did no one ever teach you that?

This post kind of captures the issue really. Everyone exists and people can see them as they wish but at some point biological reality bumps up against feelings.

Your stepdad may be your dad to you but you don't give his medical history to your doctor. That matters.

I'm adopted. I feel exactly about my parents as someone who is not adopted does. They have a lot of influence on me and my values. But their biology is irrelevant to my health.

The whole thing felt very like religion to me - right down to the doctrine of transubstantiation.

Prekoc2 · 12/11/2026 14:49

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 12/11/2026 07:46

It's really simple.

Trans people exist. And if you know them and accept them, using their correct name and pronouns is incredibly easy. Because that's just who they are.

Doesn't matter what they look like. My son is my son, regardless of whether he has visible boobs or not.

My stepdad is my dad., same as my half-brother will always be my brother, despite us all looking nothing alike.

It's really easy to see beyond a difference you don't share to the person. All you have to do is be a decent human being who values respect, and keeps an open mind.

Same as it's easy to accept people of different races than your own as equals, gay marriage as equal to straight and, say, women pilots as equal to male in ability.

People different to you all bleed the same, live the same, feel the same. Did no one ever teach you that?

Same as it's easy to accept people of different races than your own as equals...

It's not the same at all. I don't pretend to be black and expect everyone to go along with it.

TheHereticalOne · 12/11/2026 14:53

FlirtsWithRhinos · 12/11/2026 13:53

When I was growing up, Sci Fi bad guys were typically totalitarian dictators and regimes. Big Brother. Brave New World. Tron, and hundreds of lesser known imitators. You can see a clear parallel between post war 20th century geopolitics and the villains of our stories.

When I was a kid, individual Nazis in TV and films were pathetic, beaten, a figure of fun. The horror of Nazism and the Holocaust was not just that they dehumanised and hated a group of people they judged their enemy or unworthy of being part of their society, but also that they had the totalitarian control to implement government approved destruction of these humans they considered unwanted and do it on an industrial scale.

And I wonder whether part of the reason more of our generation has rejected Genderism is that we still fear top down social control in a way that younger generations who didn't have the shadow of actual totalitarian regimes in their childhood but did grow up with the knowledge that LGB rights had only just been achieved, and in a "it's the job of teachers and schools, and then government, laws and institutions, to ensure people's feelings are not hurt or judged" culture, do not.

Could be, although I've been heartened to see prominent younger women (Maeve Halligan springs to mind) pick up the mantle too (and I suspect I'd also fall outside the age bracket you're thinking of).

Like you, I do wonder what is the common trait or experience that causes some people to reject this sort of attempt at authoritarian enforcement of patent nonsense. It has been suggested to me that they would all score lower than average on the trait of agreeableness, which may well be right, but I don't expect that can be the whole story (and even if it were, what causes that?)

The phenomenon of Terf Island is another interesting angle. Why have we had a more successful pushback than Australia and Canada so far, for example? Is it purely structural or is it linked to the types or volume of people with the necessary traitsto resist it? There are a few books on my shelf waiting to be read on that topic!

TheHereticalOne · 12/11/2026 14:56

Toseland · 12/11/2026 13:33

I feel exactly like I did when I was 10 and spent a lot of time outdoors, camping and hiking. I told my classmates not to stand under the huge tree at the top of the hill during a thunderstorm as it was dangerous. They all fell about laughing, I tried to explain over and over but they cut me off and laughed even more, some spent the entire year mocking me about it and calling me names.

Those who will not hear must feel, as the saying goes! Ground current and falling branches will be less gentle teachers than you!

Giggorata · 12/11/2026 14:57

MrsOvertonsWindow · 12/11/2026 07:28

Indeed. Gaslighting, lies and untruths are at the core of transactivism. With a side order of intimidation, threats and bullying to enforce the lies.

It hasn't worked and has now blown up in their faces. Hence the tedious stream of blokes and others sharing their fantasies and disordered thinking with us on here. 🙄

This, exactly.

And in answer to your question, being gender critical feels normal, justified and quietly sane.

ScrollingLeaves · 12/11/2026 14:58

caprioska · 12/11/2026 06:55

Did you ever consider that you might be experiencing the "Everyone But Me" dynamic aka the spotlight effect (overestimating how much others are paying attention to or judging you) or missing a blind spot in your own behaviour while others are reacting to a pattern you haven't noticed?

Edited

Sure.

ScrollingLeaves · 12/11/2026 15:01

Pallisers · 12/11/2026 14:00

This post kind of captures the issue really. Everyone exists and people can see them as they wish but at some point biological reality bumps up against feelings.

Your stepdad may be your dad to you but you don't give his medical history to your doctor. That matters.

I'm adopted. I feel exactly about my parents as someone who is not adopted does. They have a lot of influence on me and my values. But their biology is irrelevant to my health.

The whole thing felt very like religion to me - right down to the doctrine of transubstantiation.

Except in religion it is not all about the self.

ChequerToRed · 12/11/2026 15:03

For me, I think it comes from the same place as my atheism.
I just can’t be doing with the metaphysical. It all seems completely batshit and nothing I’ve seen in half a century of life has convinced me otherwise. I don’t believe in souls, I don’t believe in the inexplicable or the spiritual.
Gender is no different, where others insist on some mysterious essence that makes them other than what they appear I see a lot of wishful thinking propped up by some shallow stereotypes, and tbh those stereotypes are picked and chosen as convenient. After all, who among us (apart from the obvious) has failed to notice that a great many men who adopt a ‘woman’ look happily retain all the worst of their male qualities? Often the qualities, such as entitlement, a misogynistic sense of superiority, aggression, that benefit only them.

I live in the Emerald City. Lots of people say how great the wizard is, but I’ve seen behind the curtain and it’s just some old dude pulling levers.