From TT
they have gone to to make the decision.
DS conts, [reading out excerpts from decision], speaks to the context of a JR, how much scope does the authority have to second guess the authority of those running the ponds. There are five factors here:
1st decision, decision was made by D in exercise of its statutory authority to run leisure facilities, 2nd expertise of stewards and management used in decision, 3rd decision took place after consultation, user association and focus group, that is enough
and overwhelming support for current arrangements. 4th the feelings aroused by the issue are strong,
J strong feelings on both sides
DS yes, lots of people for strong feelings on both sides, all the more reason for the D to rely on the expertise of its officials and 5th
there was no individual claimant, that's a further reason to take a deferential approach.
We rely upon proportionality as set out in our skeleton,
J you want me to have that in front of me
DS struggling to find it, but the factors are there, in summary the privacy of the
changing arrangements are mitigations of the additional arrangements. Been in place for a long time and have worked well, the fact that bio sex option would cause TP to use other facilities where they do not feel comfortable or safe, not using facilities of lived gender
TP are a small minority, but the disadvantage they would suffer would be high. Strong support in user groups, strong support in consultation from women many of whom see the policy as an advantage and also the ease of enforceability. ML asked me about Option 5 and why a
balance would have been struck.
J yes, why not
DS it was seen as an option that combined the worst aspects and indeed, C did not suggest. 90% of those surveyed opposed this. Why did they oppose? Active discrimination and segregation. Regarded by those consulted as more
intrusive then any other option (the timed options)
J I can see the statistics but the reasoning doesn't make sense
DS well you might say they got it wrong,
J it doesn't make sense
DS it would be very different from say a women's swimming evening where men aren't allowed, one
is protecting a vulnerable minority, giving them their own time, not stigmatising men, what's proposed here by having non-trans people
J well that's just women
DS its a period of time when the vulnerable minority is excluded
J along with all other men
DS TP are a uniquely
vulnerable group
J they are vulnerable in a particular way, as women are vulnerable in a different way
DS it's not the same thing at all to exclude TP, as it is to exclude men
J It doesn't make sense to me to be in favour of segregated swimming and then say not having
segregated evening.
DS TP just want to live their lives and forcing them to use the facility at specific times, forces them to confront their exclusion from the facility
J I've got your point but why does exclusion at some points seem worse than complete exclusion.
DS just
trying to find passage I was relying on.
J could we move on,
DS the point I was on is this, strong belief that scheduled ss times, singled out tp, and created windows of exclusion and stigmatised tp. By highlighting them
J I see it's not complicated but still doesn't explain
why segregation every day of the week isn't worse.
DS let's say you have a cafe that excludes Jewish people but allows them to come for an hour a day, how much more humiliating is that policy, it simple serves to reinforce the exclusion and draw attention to them, would attract
anti-semitic people. That's the point. There's nothing illogical about that, reflects the humiliation of being there temporarily rather than not at all.
DS moving on, MLF says proportionality is a numbers game, more women who want SS spaces than TW who want inclusion.