Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sex Matters - Hampstead Heath Ponds -

1000 replies

SexRealismBeliefs · 15/12/2025 18:42

Sex Matters, a charity that campaigns for single-sex rights, will argue that the City of London Corporation is breaching equality law by allowing trans women to use Kenwood Ladies’ Pond on Hampstead Heath.

Hearing this Wednesday.

https://www.thetimes.com/article/cceca8ca-4167-4b04-875a-40ddacfea782?shareToken=e9fe25a546d20835f1a5a66564cbf27b

Hampstead women’s pond sued over transgender access

Sex Matters claims that the City of London Corporation is defending a policy that defies the Supreme Court ruling on single-sex services

https://www.thetimes.com/article/cceca8ca-4167-4b04-875a-40ddacfea782?shareToken=e9fe25a546d20835f1a5a66564cbf27b

OP posts:
Thread gallery
42
Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 12:50

From TT

It permits positive action where a person reasonably believes people with a protected characteristic face disadvantage, different needs, or under-representation.
Any measure taken must be proportionate way of addressing issue.

There is not a right to receive SS services nor a duty to provide them, Sched 3 contains permissive provisions if its terms are fulfilled. Does not cut back the application of sec 158 by use of the Sched 3.

DS conts I will come back to that in more details but want to move on to Goodwin and rights of tp. Want to go to 'I in the Uk' because it mentions service provision, [reading out very rapidly] we if we go through this para 44, the applicant makes a series of complaints about the

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 12:52

From TT

difficulties that had not been put before the court before; prisons, being accommodated in a male ward in hospital, we see gov response, agreed that sometime treatment of tp may be a violation of human rights, denied that applicant faced any real difficulties, the gov said she

was able to live a female social role, get documents in new name etc. Likely to be placed on a female ward because of presentation and birth certificate. Court's analysis, must be rec'd that, conflict between social role and society creates problems, court is struck by fact

gender reassignment should be recognised in law. And then at para 70, we see that on page 82, in the 21st century it is an unsatisfactory situation for transsexuals to live in an intermediate zone, not one or the other. No conflict is likely to be expected from this, and

society should accommodate.
J and all of that talking about people with the pc of GRA
DS yes people who had gender reassignment services, also in our authorities, C vs DWP, recognised the deep need for TP to live in assumed gender. Strong recognition of the rights of TP not

just to get a piece of paper but to live fully in acquired gender. Now on to the Gender Recognition Act - GR Act., It is in the authorities. It is fair to say that acquisition of a GRC is a complex and lengthy one, which is why most TP do not have a GRC.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 12:52

From TT

But if one does go through the process, if the GRC is issued to a person, the gender becomes for all purposes the acquired gender. It is limited
J we covered that yesterday
DS will not belabour, in addition to the Strasbourg authorities, gra discrim was first prohitied in 1999

and then incorporated in EA as a pc.
Pausing there, we note that art 8 rights of TP are not a matter for debate, the D is a public authority, needs to act in accordance HRA, needs to act in accordance with that right.
I want next to go to my 4th heading which FWS

FWS explored the interaction of the GR Act and EA, it was a very narrow question. Was the definition of sex in the EA modified by the GRA. It has been widely misrepresented. We see the caution of the SC in the first two paras. End of para 1,
J I have that

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 12:54

From TT

DS [reads out para 2] you have that point
J that's the easiest point, TC is not attempting to argue that
DS the key problem that the SC grappled with was that nobody was arguing that people with the pc of GRA who did not have a GRC should not be accepted as their lived gender.

It was accepted that even with a GRC, sex remains bio sex. The battle lines were drawn
J what point are you trying to make here
DS the critical reason why it decided what it did, it would be incoherent and unworkable to have TP with a GRC in one set and TP with a GRC in

another set
J and so what does give us
DS TP without a GRC have their sex at birth, whether a subgroup had a different sex, when you look at the problem that way, it's not difficult to see what it had to be decided that
J conversely, a GRC could provide evidence

DS that would be a problem, outing trans people, confidential document
J so are you saying incoherence was GRC vs non GRC
DS the incoherence largely arose from the fact that most people don't have a GRC, difficulty for service providers.
J alright

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 12:56

From TT

DS back to FWS, identifies barriers that have been removed, diminishing relevance of GRA; same sex marriage, pension age, etc. We disagree with that. The SC is recognising the need to avoid discordance in TP and society. FWS is affirming the rights of TP to live in their sense

of identity, not just to do with the state, not just about on your passport or pension records. Key reasoning of SC here -
J I've highlight the para,
DS require distinguishing between people of the basis of whether they hold a confidential certificate. The final point I wish

to take from FWS is SC did not consider they were cutting back TPs rights, not disadvantaging TP with or without a GRC, return to that theme later on in several places.
J yes
DS they make the same point later on, does not diminish important protections for TP with/without GRC

J when they refer to TP what do they mean
DS refer to people with pc of GRA whether or not they have a GRC. Nowhere did the SC say you can't provide a TI service. That interpretation of FWS has been widely propounded. Stewards handbook included instructions not to get into

debates about FWS. An unintended consequence; it is a widespread belief. That's all that I wanted to say about FWS.
Turning next to direct discrim.
It is unsatisfactory to deal with questions of discrimination in the abstract. Dealing with questions of discrim in the

absence of a particular claimant.
J it's not really in the abstract is it
DS we don't have individual claimants who can be cross examined etc, the Cs have taken on a heavy burden of proving discrim in the abstract.
J in a JR we look at the consequences of the rules made

DS For example, in reply, we have evidence from Phoenix Oren (sp) who puts forward reasons they would like to use the LP, one is the warm showers. I'm advised that there are warm showers in MS pond and MP. It goes to the difficulty of trying to deal with this in a JR.

PrettyDamnCosmic · 04/11/2026 12:56

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 11:47

the guy is fucking enraging

Naomi has a very effective critique of Daniel Stilitz's unusual interpretation of FWS & other cases in a podcast he appeared on. She is not impressed with Daniel Stilitz's understanding of the Equality Act

www.legalfeminist.org.uk/2026/03/25/podcasting-and-partisanship/

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 12:58

From TT

It is inherently unsatisfactory to try and deal with these issues in the abstract. Analytically we submit that to establish direct discrim because of sex, been subjected to less favourable treatment, to another and the admission arrangements don't meet 158 criteria.

J I question the burden of proof under 158.
DS the burden is on the Ds, I agree.
J You need to construct a comparator,
DS perhaps I don't need to take ML to that. The reason why then,,,,it's clear that the SC decision in FWS is not a ss service, so not within sched 3.

Admissions policy permits bio men and bio women to use both MP and LP.
J those are 2 different questions, does the rule differentiate on the basis of sex
DS I disagree, if it is on the basis of sex, it does not do that, and so would be discriminatory. Can we turn up JFS judgment

DS conts 2 different sets of why questions, relevant question is why did C receive less favourable treatment,
J isn't two ways of saying discrim on sex
DS we would say it's gender not sex
J Are you confusing the motive with the outcome, it's discrimination for good reasons not

an answer. Lets look at para 52,
DS the relevant criteria for entry are one of lived gender, not biological sex,
J so what does that men, looking at the rule i can see what the decision was, if I'm looking at it in practice, it is more difficult and has consequences further on

PrettyDamnCosmic · 04/11/2026 12:59

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 11:49

Most swimming facilities are mixed sex, so it isn't that outlandish a suggestion.

The ponds aren't just for swimming. All the gay guys hooking up around the Men's Pond would be very upset if the MP became mixed sex.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 13:00

From TT

DS in report framed as allowing people to access ponds in lived gender, I would accept that there is a distinction between the way the policy has been formulated and the practical application of it, what is clear is that the aim as set out in the report is that people should be

able to access according to lived gender rather than bio sex. True to say that the formulation is broader than that in practice, NB can access the ponds of their bio sex even if they don't live in one gender or the other, one of the reasons option 3 was confusing was because

no provision of NB people. The aim was to have 2 ponds, one for female gender, the other for lived gender is male, albeit the way it is formulated is somewhat more inclusive than that.
J are we talking about the same rule, requiring the pc of GRA is quite narrow,
DS I'm not

sure that's right, Option 2 permits NB people to use the pond of their bio sex, and in theory it permits a trans person,
J what do you mean
DS I mean someone with the pc of GRA, they could use the pool of their bio sex. So 2 is broader that 3. It is about lived gender.

J are you saying in reality its option 3,
DS it's option 3 plus, includes NB, TP who could use the pond for their bio sex,
J right
DS it's formulated in that way for the pragmatic reason that people found Option 3 confusing, left NB in an anomalous situation, and couldn't be

distinguished from Option 2.
J yes, so it's lived gender, all right
DS if that analysis is right, then that's the end of the direct discrim case, if its not right then we are into arguments about less favourable treatment, I will go to Coll (sp) to see if segregation

is sufficient. The C relies on that in support of the proposition that not all men would be allowed into LP for direct discrim to be established. So this one is about someone who might be sent to approved accommodation far from their home, much more likely to happen to women

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 13:01

From TT

The exact correspondence test is only relevant when the criteria is not a pc but something else. It is not a requirement that all members of a class experience discrim. The Birmingham case is that - all girls at risk of being excluded despite passing exam.

Back to the women prisoners; women at much higher risk of being placed in approved premises far from home. The exact criterion in our case is gender and that is not a proxy for biological sex. If it was an exact proxy, then we would not be in sec 3.

J lived gender is not a pc,
DS it might be indirect discrim but that is not the argument that the C is making.
End of morning session.
J can we discuss the timetable, I said that TL could intervene, if we had time, I'm putting a market down so that TC has a chance to reply.

DS I'm making good time getting through my subs,
J despite judicial interference
DS with ML's help. I think MLF for TL will have time.
Court rises.
Now end of morning session.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 13:02

Caught up, I think it’s lunch. As an aside, didn’t Stilitz work with the GLP on some challenge or other?

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 13:04

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 12:50

From TT

It permits positive action where a person reasonably believes people with a protected characteristic face disadvantage, different needs, or under-representation.
Any measure taken must be proportionate way of addressing issue.

There is not a right to receive SS services nor a duty to provide them, Sched 3 contains permissive provisions if its terms are fulfilled. Does not cut back the application of sec 158 by use of the Sched 3.

DS conts I will come back to that in more details but want to move on to Goodwin and rights of tp. Want to go to 'I in the Uk' because it mentions service provision, [reading out very rapidly] we if we go through this para 44, the applicant makes a series of complaints about the

"Analytically we submit that to establish direct discrim because of sex, been subjected to less favourable treatment"

Isn't the men's pond bigger?

LadyinPainting · 04/11/2026 13:05

Have I understood correctly that one of their arguments is 'this will be very difficult to impose'?? That is tantamount to saying 'some trans people won't follow instructions/orders' isn't it.

And yet 'there is no evidence that [cis] women want to use the Men's Pond' could just be 'women generally obey the rules'.

So 'women obey the rules but transwomen don't, so we shouldn't put ourselves in a position where the transwomen don't get what they want, as they will make a fuss?'

Transwomen will need to get used to single sex situations, (with mixed sex options but not single gender ones) because that is what FWS has meant needs to be imposed in leisure centres, workplaces, hospitals, etc etc etc.

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 13:06

DS it's option 3 plus, includes NB, TP who could use the pond for their bio sex

Does this mean NB people must use the ponds according to their sex, or that anyone can use either pond as long as they identify as NB?

Datun · 04/11/2026 13:07

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 13:06

DS it's option 3 plus, includes NB, TP who could use the pond for their bio sex

Does this mean NB people must use the ponds according to their sex, or that anyone can use either pond as long as they identify as NB?

I'm not surprised the judge pointed out that the language is ambiguous.

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 13:09

LadyinPainting · 04/11/2026 13:05

Have I understood correctly that one of their arguments is 'this will be very difficult to impose'?? That is tantamount to saying 'some trans people won't follow instructions/orders' isn't it.

And yet 'there is no evidence that [cis] women want to use the Men's Pond' could just be 'women generally obey the rules'.

So 'women obey the rules but transwomen don't, so we shouldn't put ourselves in a position where the transwomen don't get what they want, as they will make a fuss?'

Transwomen will need to get used to single sex situations, (with mixed sex options but not single gender ones) because that is what FWS has meant needs to be imposed in leisure centres, workplaces, hospitals, etc etc etc.

I’m surprised he hasn’t submitted that genital inspections would be required to keep the men out if the rules were sex-based.

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 13:10

'there is no evidence that women want to use the Men's Pond'

And if there were evidence that women wanted to use the larger men's pond and diving board?

Slothtoes · 04/11/2026 13:20

Thank you so much for the updates. Flowers Gin Star

I find it appalling that so much official time and money is being wasted on this self regarding need for validation.
There are only two sexes, gender do whatever you like as an adult, but biological sex has to have primacy because it’s not all about the individual’s experience.
It is also about the collective needs for single sex spaces and about upholding women’s rights in a sexist society. the UK likes to pretend it’s really equal here but the misogyny is very plain to see.

TheDisguiseOfReasonableness · 04/11/2026 13:31

If the stewards' handbook had to include an instruction not to get into a debate about FWS doesn't that rather imply that not all users consider trans inclusion idyllic?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 13:57

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 13:09

I’m surprised he hasn’t submitted that genital inspections would be required to keep the men out if the rules were sex-based.

He did! See upthread

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 13:59

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 10:59

From TT

to gender non-conforming, possibility of genital inspections, must carry documents. These concerns lead the Ds to reject option 1 (sex segregation). In response to Option 2 (keep existing GIP arrangements), majority agreed, closely mirror reasons for rejecting Option 1. Trans

Bumping

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:12

We resume

From TT

We resume.
DS moving on to less favourable treatment, Al Hijra school case. Rely on that - segregation can be less favourable treatment, impact on education of girls. Less fav treatment is correct, not an express finding of LFT, an implicit finding of LFT, for each pupil, both

sexes suffer a detriment. Both a detriment and LFT (less favourable treatment). LFT because of the finding of Ofsted, they are entitled to reach that finding, we do not find that there is discrim merely because of segregation. Not the mere fact of segregation, the impact on

the quality of education. Suffered by both groups. Present case is the opposite. C complains that ponds are not segregated enough. The LFT is because ponds are not identical. This argument runs across Ground 2, which was abandoned by C.
J what was that

DS Ground 2 - direct discrim against women, not against men because of the presence of TW in the LP. But what is being said under G1 is that it is direct discrim not to let men in the LP.
J where does that take us
DS what is not being said is the less fav treatment is now being

J the case is being put differently, the LFT is denying some men access to the LP and some women access to the LP
DS I addressed the error about the hot showers earlier, now a few remarks about the other 2 WS. One witness wants to swim in the MP at regularly scheduled times,

but not at any times. There are times when the MP is available to all, even if only occasional. Another factual error, 'do not believe that I have seen a TiM at the LP', says she swims 5/6 per week since June to Sept, but never knowingly seen a TW, I would be shocked to see a TP

in the LP changing rooms.
J the point here is that the LP has a particular nature and go there as a bio female, for a particular environment, just because sometimes she wants to swim in MP doesn't mean she wants mixed sex provision.
DS now onto another WS.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:15

From TT

DS cont LP has total area of 5300 sqm, MP has a smaller swimming area of 8000 sqm. (What I heard but seems wrong)
J is your argument that women don't know what the circumstances are
DS this is evidence only rec'd in reply and it appears to be problematic.

Signalbox · 04/11/2026 14:16

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 13:57

He did! See upthread

😮😲🤯😱😳

I missed that! Can’t believe they said that out loud in court 😆

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 14:18

From TT

DS when this evidence is circulated in reply and hasn't been subject to scrutiny, it can't be held to evidence of LFT
J because it might not be correct?
DS it serves to underline the difficulty in looking at these points on the hoof
J not sure that's a fair description of the

process
DS only given in reply, not tested
J LFT is a subjective question, not an evidentiary matter
DS back to showers, hot showers, turns out to be wrong
J it's not a matter of law
DS I don't agree it's wholly subjective
J you don't agree? What do you think it is

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.