Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Anyone else get annoyed by the phrase ‘not all men, but always a man’?

398 replies

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 13:15

I’ve seen countless comments saying ‘not all men, but always a man’ underneath news articles and videos detailing a murder, child abuse, stalking or rape case. I guess what annoys me about it is that none of these crimes are just committed by men. If they were, then fair enough.
Over the last week I’ve seen an article about a woman who sexually assaulted a male taxi driver after groping his genitals and exposing herself (the comments were not kind to the man and he was called ‘gay’ for rejecting her, many of which were wrote by women). I’ve seen several articles about women who have killed or harmed young children. I’ve seen two news articles on female teachers who sexually abused/raped their male students, etc. I do wonder what sort of message these types of comments send out to young boys (who are being taught that they are the problem) and girls (who are being taught that only men can commit these crimes).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 02/11/2026 16:52

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 02/11/2026 16:51

Are you getting post and thread muddled up? Because you making quite a few posts on this topic here https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5587564-to-feel-uncomfortable-by-these-type-of-posts-as-a-mum-of-a-boy?page=10

Made, not making.
Bloody autocorrect.

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:56

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 02/11/2026 16:51

Are you getting post and thread muddled up? Because you making quite a few posts on this topic here https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5587564-to-feel-uncomfortable-by-these-type-of-posts-as-a-mum-of-a-boy?page=10

Yes, I commented under someone else’s Thread a month ago that male crime rates is a systemic issue that requires a systemic response. If that’s considered persistent…

OP posts:
LetMeGoogleThat · 02/11/2026 16:58

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:46

Many feminists do hate the phrase. Could you explain to me why saying ‘not all men, but always a man’ is helpful to either women or men? Because I don’t see it. If you’re rightly worried about sexual violence and male criminality, why not focus your attention on helping them? We know that male criminals are vastly more likely to come from families without a father or come from an unstable home (an issue that’s often brushed over and it’s blamed on them just having a penis) so why not focus attention on getting men into early years and primary school settings and support initiatives to have men mentor boys who don’t have a good male figure at home? Can you imagine, as a girl, growing up without a mother and all your friends grew up without a mother, and the first time you see a positive female figure is in secondary school? I imagine the female crime rates would shoot up. But instead of helping girls men were just churning out useless phrases like ‘not all women, but always a woman’. It’s like idiocracy.

Omg, you have no idea of what I do and have done for a living, and i'm not about to add it here. What a whole load of assumptions you made, and some are pretty insensitive if you knew me.

You're right, bickering with people on MN about about your dislike of a phrase, and self appointing yourself as head feminist is going to make such a massive difference to victims.

You know, its not all men.....but it nearly always is! Better?

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 17:01

LetMeGoogleThat · 02/11/2026 16:58

Omg, you have no idea of what I do and have done for a living, and i'm not about to add it here. What a whole load of assumptions you made, and some are pretty insensitive if you knew me.

You're right, bickering with people on MN about about your dislike of a phrase, and self appointing yourself as head feminist is going to make such a massive difference to victims.

You know, its not all men.....but it nearly always is! Better?

I think it would be better to say nothing and acknowledge that abuse and violence can be committed by anyone so that people feel safe to come forward.

OP posts:
whiteroseredrose · 02/11/2026 17:05

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 13:33

But females cannot be labeled as rapists under UK law. It’s baffling, but it can only be considered rape if the perpetrator penetrates the victim with a natural appendage. The law needs to change there. It’s not that no female rapists exists, it’s that they legally cannot be charged with rape.

The statistic is for sexual assaults which is not male-specific.

AmnesiacDream · 02/11/2026 17:32

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 13:22

Studies show time and again that victims of female perpetrated crime are less likely to report it due to fears of not being taken seriously. So it’s already having huge consequences.

Female perpetrated violence is far less likely to be reported mainly because it's far less likely to result in serious injury or fear of serious injury.

When serious injury is involved, data shows little difference in report rates based on sex of attacker and victim. But attackers are far more likely to be men. And in domestic settings when women commit serious assault on a male partner there is frequently a significant history of the man assaulting the woman. This is almost never the case when men cause severe injury in domestic assault.

The Not All Men claim has been used to try and deflect away from the reality that men and male culture are cause of the vast majority of violence. The affect of violence on men and woman is asymmetrical. And men are almost always the perpetrators and instigators of significant harm.

It's right to highlight it.

AliasGrape · 02/11/2026 17:47

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:16

So women in same sex relationships are abused to the same extent as women in heterosexual relationships and are far less likely to report it. Saying it’s ‘always a man’ is fundamentally anti-feminist and doesn’t protect women at all: https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/92715/html/

Edited

You’re being disingenuous again.

That claim misinterprets lifetime statistics. Most broad studies (like the CDC or ONS) track lifetime prevalence based on the victim’s current identity, not the gender of the abuser. UK and international data show that roughly one-third of lesbians who experienced abuse were actually abused by former male partners earlier in life. When you isolate same-sex relationships, the rate of female-to-female domestic abuse is significantly lower than male-to-female abuse.

LivelyAquaPoster · 02/11/2026 18:02

blacksax · 02/11/2026 14:54

Women absolutely cannot commit rape. It is a physical impossibility.

By 'women' I mean biologically female women.

Merriam-Webster defining rape - very much ungendered:

  1. unlawful sexual activity and usually sexual intercourse carried out forcibly or under threat of injury against a person's will or with a person who is beneath a certain age or incapable of valid consent because of mental illness, mental deficiency, intoxication, unconsciousness, or deception.
  1. an outrageous violation
  1. an act or instance of robbing or despoiling or carrying away a person by force
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:12

AmnesiacDream · 02/11/2026 17:32

Female perpetrated violence is far less likely to be reported mainly because it's far less likely to result in serious injury or fear of serious injury.

When serious injury is involved, data shows little difference in report rates based on sex of attacker and victim. But attackers are far more likely to be men. And in domestic settings when women commit serious assault on a male partner there is frequently a significant history of the man assaulting the woman. This is almost never the case when men cause severe injury in domestic assault.

The Not All Men claim has been used to try and deflect away from the reality that men and male culture are cause of the vast majority of violence. The affect of violence on men and woman is asymmetrical. And men are almost always the perpetrators and instigators of significant harm.

It's right to highlight it.

What’s male culture exactly? Because I see
a lot of issues stem from deep rooted societal issues as whole. Male criminals are much more likely to come from households without a father figure (about 80% of violent male criminals). That’s not necessary male culture. That’s an issue with society as a whole when there’s so many boys growing up without a positive male role model and society does nothing to try and get men into early years education or primary school settings. It’s not right that many boys are growing up and their first experience of a positive male role model is in secondary school. We are letting boys down.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:14

LivelyAquaPoster · 02/11/2026 18:02

Merriam-Webster defining rape - very much ungendered:

  1. unlawful sexual activity and usually sexual intercourse carried out forcibly or under threat of injury against a person's will or with a person who is beneath a certain age or incapable of valid consent because of mental illness, mental deficiency, intoxication, unconsciousness, or deception.
  1. an outrageous violation
  1. an act or instance of robbing or despoiling or carrying away a person by force

It’s bizarre to me that people are claiming that a woman cannot rape. To have sex with a minor or with someone without their consent should automatically make you a rapist. The fact that some women are defending female rapists is shocking.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:15

AliasGrape · 02/11/2026 17:47

You’re being disingenuous again.

That claim misinterprets lifetime statistics. Most broad studies (like the CDC or ONS) track lifetime prevalence based on the victim’s current identity, not the gender of the abuser. UK and international data show that roughly one-third of lesbians who experienced abuse were actually abused by former male partners earlier in life. When you isolate same-sex relationships, the rate of female-to-female domestic abuse is significantly lower than male-to-female abuse.

But then they can’t be victims because it’s ’always a man’, right?

OP posts:
Waitingforthistopass75 · 02/11/2026 18:17

Hoppinggreen · 02/11/2026 13:16

No, that phrase doesn't annoy me
But listing female crimes to mitigate male ones? - that pisses me right off

Nailed it!

AliasGrape · 02/11/2026 18:23

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:15

But then they can’t be victims because it’s ’always a man’, right?

Of course they can. But you claimed that women in lesbian relationships experience DV at the same rate as women in heterosexual ones, and the data simply doesn’t show that.

Again, the ‘always a man’ phrase came up in respond to ‘not all men’ which gets trotted out by male apologists every time women try to discuss the systemic culture of violence against women and girls. In that context, it’s perfectly fine to use and to claim it’s what is stopping victims of female criminals coming forward is more deflection and whataboutism. I call bullshit, sorry.

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:36

AliasGrape · 02/11/2026 18:23

Of course they can. But you claimed that women in lesbian relationships experience DV at the same rate as women in heterosexual ones, and the data simply doesn’t show that.

Again, the ‘always a man’ phrase came up in respond to ‘not all men’ which gets trotted out by male apologists every time women try to discuss the systemic culture of violence against women and girls. In that context, it’s perfectly fine to use and to claim it’s what is stopping victims of female criminals coming forward is more deflection and whataboutism. I call bullshit, sorry.

Two thirds of domestic violence towards lesbian women is committed by female partners: https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/49219/html/

that is significant.

OP posts:
WillowWindWitch · 02/11/2026 18:46

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:12

What’s male culture exactly? Because I see
a lot of issues stem from deep rooted societal issues as whole. Male criminals are much more likely to come from households without a father figure (about 80% of violent male criminals). That’s not necessary male culture. That’s an issue with society as a whole when there’s so many boys growing up without a positive male role model and society does nothing to try and get men into early years education or primary school settings. It’s not right that many boys are growing up and their first experience of a positive male role model is in secondary school. We are letting boys down.

Who's letting boys down?

The fathers who abandon them...ie men.

And presumably as many girls are abandoned by absentee fathers as boys? So why does not having a father make boys violent and dangerous, but a girl without a father does not react that way?

And why are the majority of absent parents men, not women? You could almost say 'not all men abandon their families...but it's always a man'. It's far less common for a mother to walk away than a father, just as it's far more common for men to commit violent and sexual crime than women.

There are always outliers. But exceptions prove the rule, rather than invalidating it.

AliasGrape · 02/11/2026 19:01

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:36

Two thirds of domestic violence towards lesbian women is committed by female partners: https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/49219/html/

that is significant.

Which isn’t even close to your earlier claim that So women in same sex relationships are abused to the same extent as women in heterosexual relationships and are far less likely to report it.

So according to your link, out of 100 lesbian and bisexual women, 25 will experience domestic abuse in their lifetime. But according to that stat, two-thirds of them were abused by a woman, while the other third were actually abused by a man earlier in life.

That means the real rate of female-to-female abuse is only about 17%. When you compare that to the 25% of heterosexual women who face abuse from men, the math shows that women are still statistically much safer with a female partner.

It’s also a self-selecting sample.

Im not saying women can’t be perpetrators of domestic violence, or that their victims don’t matter. Im saying that the phrase ‘always a man’ is -

  • Not the reason these victims don’t come forward
  • Used specifically in the context of countering the ‘not all men’ claim which is used to minimise and wave away the very real, systemic issue that is male violence
  • Usually used in contexts where the crime being discussed is overwhelmingly committed by men, and generally more ‘extreme’ than domestic violence (which I’ve experienced and am not minimising). Also in every case I’ve ever seen it used the crime was indeed committed by a man.

Policing the language women use to describe and talk about the absolute epidemic of male violence against women and girls is not the way to help any victims honestly. If your motivation really is to support victims of female crime, I’m sure there are better ways to spend your energy.

Snugglebear · 02/11/2026 19:07

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:36

Two thirds of domestic violence towards lesbian women is committed by female partners: https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/49219/html/

that is significant.

Erm. Well of course it would be as their partners are women! They don’t have male partners. That doesn’t mean that they experience it equally to women in hetero relationships in any way!

Error404FucksNotFound · 02/11/2026 19:12

Well im ok to start saying "not all men but almost always a man and in disturbingly large numbers because male violence is a huge problem globally and women and girls are at great risk from NAMBAAAM" if thats better for you.

Tweeply · 02/11/2026 19:13

When [mostly] men stop doing harm to women, I will stop saying it.

AmnesiacDream · 02/11/2026 19:13

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:12

What’s male culture exactly? Because I see
a lot of issues stem from deep rooted societal issues as whole. Male criminals are much more likely to come from households without a father figure (about 80% of violent male criminals). That’s not necessary male culture. That’s an issue with society as a whole when there’s so many boys growing up without a positive male role model and society does nothing to try and get men into early years education or primary school settings. It’s not right that many boys are growing up and their first experience of a positive male role model is in secondary school. We are letting boys down.

Male culture isn't a single mono-culture, it's pretty varied, so there is no "exactly" (there's no exactly about culture in general, it's always changing). But where men have a culture (values, behaviours, traditions, social expectations, etc.) that differ from the women they live amoung it tends to include less expectation to take responsibility for contraception and children, greater acceptance of violence to settle arguments, greater reliance on dry or cutting humour to deal with difficult or unwanted incidents or conditions, stronger support for a might is right mindset, and greater acceptance of sexual objectification of women.

Those young boys growing up without a positive male role model are already victim to this male culture, in many cases doe to domestic abuse by the father towards their mother, but in any case to the tendency of men to be less committed to their children. That isn't simply a societal problem. It's specifically a problem with male culture and the way men let them (and their daughters) down.

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 19:17

AmnesiacDream · 02/11/2026 19:13

Male culture isn't a single mono-culture, it's pretty varied, so there is no "exactly" (there's no exactly about culture in general, it's always changing). But where men have a culture (values, behaviours, traditions, social expectations, etc.) that differ from the women they live amoung it tends to include less expectation to take responsibility for contraception and children, greater acceptance of violence to settle arguments, greater reliance on dry or cutting humour to deal with difficult or unwanted incidents or conditions, stronger support for a might is right mindset, and greater acceptance of sexual objectification of women.

Those young boys growing up without a positive male role model are already victim to this male culture, in many cases doe to domestic abuse by the father towards their mother, but in any case to the tendency of men to be less committed to their children. That isn't simply a societal problem. It's specifically a problem with male culture and the way men let them (and their daughters) down.

So I had a look and Denmark has the lowest recorded male violence towards women. Interestingly, it also has a high rate of present, active fathers. This is made easier by the fact that paternity leave is so much better there than in the UK and there’s more equality in general. Surely this would indicate that how society is set up is the greatest influence on boys and men.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 19:19

AliasGrape · 02/11/2026 19:01

Which isn’t even close to your earlier claim that So women in same sex relationships are abused to the same extent as women in heterosexual relationships and are far less likely to report it.

So according to your link, out of 100 lesbian and bisexual women, 25 will experience domestic abuse in their lifetime. But according to that stat, two-thirds of them were abused by a woman, while the other third were actually abused by a man earlier in life.

That means the real rate of female-to-female abuse is only about 17%. When you compare that to the 25% of heterosexual women who face abuse from men, the math shows that women are still statistically much safer with a female partner.

It’s also a self-selecting sample.

Im not saying women can’t be perpetrators of domestic violence, or that their victims don’t matter. Im saying that the phrase ‘always a man’ is -

  • Not the reason these victims don’t come forward
  • Used specifically in the context of countering the ‘not all men’ claim which is used to minimise and wave away the very real, systemic issue that is male violence
  • Usually used in contexts where the crime being discussed is overwhelmingly committed by men, and generally more ‘extreme’ than domestic violence (which I’ve experienced and am not minimising). Also in every case I’ve ever seen it used the crime was indeed committed by a man.

Policing the language women use to describe and talk about the absolute epidemic of male violence against women and girls is not the way to help any victims honestly. If your motivation really is to support victims of female crime, I’m sure there are better ways to spend your energy.

As a victim of female perpetuated sexual violence, I was absolutely put off from reporting it due to comments (mostly from women) that minimised my experience. So, yes, that phrase isn’t helpful.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 19:23

WillowWindWitch · 02/11/2026 18:46

Who's letting boys down?

The fathers who abandon them...ie men.

And presumably as many girls are abandoned by absentee fathers as boys? So why does not having a father make boys violent and dangerous, but a girl without a father does not react that way?

And why are the majority of absent parents men, not women? You could almost say 'not all men abandon their families...but it's always a man'. It's far less common for a mother to walk away than a father, just as it's far more common for men to commit violent and sexual crime than women.

There are always outliers. But exceptions prove the rule, rather than invalidating it.

Because a mother can teach a son about respecting women, but she cannot model that behaviour for him. When a boy grows up witnessing a man respecting his mother, that has a much greater impact. There’s a reason why Denmark has the lowest rates of recorded male violence against women and high rates of present, active fathers.

OP posts:
AccidentallyWesAnderson · 02/11/2026 19:25

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 18:14

It’s bizarre to me that people are claiming that a woman cannot rape. To have sex with a minor or with someone without their consent should automatically make you a rapist. The fact that some women are defending female rapists is shocking.

God the comprehension (or lack of 🙄).

The legal definition of rape is penetration by a penis. As women don’t have penises (unless you’ve drunk the trans Kool Aid), they cannot be rapists. Women can be charged with rape if they aid in a rape (like holding someone down) but a penis has to be present in the act. Women having sex with minors or with someone against their will would be sexual assault.

Correct facts are important, and don’t equate to ‘defending female rapists’ as you do put it.

MerryAquaKoala · 02/11/2026 19:25

WorkingItOutAsIGo · 02/11/2026 13:16

When men stop committing 99% of such crimes I will have energy to spare to worry about the phrase. Till then....all out of fucks to give.

Quite.