Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Anyone else get annoyed by the phrase ‘not all men, but always a man’?

398 replies

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 13:15

I’ve seen countless comments saying ‘not all men, but always a man’ underneath news articles and videos detailing a murder, child abuse, stalking or rape case. I guess what annoys me about it is that none of these crimes are just committed by men. If they were, then fair enough.
Over the last week I’ve seen an article about a woman who sexually assaulted a male taxi driver after groping his genitals and exposing herself (the comments were not kind to the man and he was called ‘gay’ for rejecting her, many of which were wrote by women). I’ve seen several articles about women who have killed or harmed young children. I’ve seen two news articles on female teachers who sexually abused/raped their male students, etc. I do wonder what sort of message these types of comments send out to young boys (who are being taught that they are the problem) and girls (who are being taught that only men can commit these crimes).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 12:18

Poppingby · 03/11/2026 11:43

I don't think it's appropriate to ask people's opinions on this sort of thing. If the evidence is there yes of course a woman should be charged for whatever crime has been committed. I don't think anyone would say otherwise. This case doesn't support your argument about victims feeling embarrassed to come forward but the fact you think it is appropriate to bring it up for discussion makes me think something really awful has happened to you and for that I am sorry.

If you think the law should be changed that's fine but really canvassing people's opinions on a website is not the way to do it. Women are angry that men commit violence against us because they are tacitly given societal permission to do it, shown by how many men perpetrate violence against women in real and proportionate terms. You can feel that and also feel horrified about sexual violence perpetrated by women, which is likely to have a different root cause.

It shows that female perpetrators of sexual violence, like males, are very often not held to account. Anyone reading what happened to that little boy would think that she should be charged with sexual violence against a minor, but wasn’t. It supports my argument that just because women don’t appear in the data doesn’t mean that they aren’t committing these sorts of crimes. So absolutely it is appropriate. So far on this Thread we’ve had people making excuses for women who kill their own children (mothers kill their own children at the same rate as men do), we’ve had people saying that women should not be charged with rape, we’ve had people inflating the data claiming that 98% of violent crime is committed by men in the UK, etc. So I will absolutely stand for the victims and point out where women should’ve been held to account but weren’t.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 12:25

Poppingby · 03/11/2026 11:43

I don't think it's appropriate to ask people's opinions on this sort of thing. If the evidence is there yes of course a woman should be charged for whatever crime has been committed. I don't think anyone would say otherwise. This case doesn't support your argument about victims feeling embarrassed to come forward but the fact you think it is appropriate to bring it up for discussion makes me think something really awful has happened to you and for that I am sorry.

If you think the law should be changed that's fine but really canvassing people's opinions on a website is not the way to do it. Women are angry that men commit violence against us because they are tacitly given societal permission to do it, shown by how many men perpetrate violence against women in real and proportionate terms. You can feel that and also feel horrified about sexual violence perpetrated by women, which is likely to have a different root cause.

Also, interested to know what you mean by female perpetrators of sexual violence having a different ‘root cause’? In the instance I mentioned, the woman had no cause other than the fact she had a compulsion to hurt children. So she carefully planned it out purely because she sought enjoyment from hurting an
infant. She openly expressed that.

OP posts:
Enterthewolves · 03/11/2026 12:43

LivelyAquaPoster · 03/11/2026 11:41

Under the Accessories and Abettors Act 1961, anyone, explicitly including women, who sets up, assists, holds down a victim, or coerces a man into penetrating someone else, is indicted and convicted of the crime of Rape itself.

The court, the judge's sentencing, and her criminal record will explicitly state "Rape".

Not True

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 12:48

Enterthewolves · 03/11/2026 12:43

Not True

It is true. Are you dense?

OP posts:
Emilesgran · 03/11/2026 13:03

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 10:59

On paper they can carry the same sentence, but rarely do. Personally I think a man or woman who is drugged and forcefully penetrated with a dildo against their will has experienced rape. What I’m suggesting actually would protect MORE women, not less. So unless you’re a woman who has plans to force yourself on someone I hardly see why on earth you’d have an issue with it.

Doesn’t matter what you think, that’s not what U.K. law says.

LivelyAquaPoster · 03/11/2026 13:08

It would be helpful to quote or refer to specific sections of the law instead of pouty statements like "not true" and "that's not what UK law says".

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 13:17

Emilesgran · 03/11/2026 13:03

Doesn’t matter what you think, that’s not what U.K. law says.

I’ve repeatedly said that’s not what the UK law says. But to say that universally a woman has not been charged with rape is untrue. Women have been charged with rape and therefore can be rapists.

OP posts:
MoistVonL · 03/11/2026 14:11

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 10:35

In the UK about 80% of violent crime is committed by males, yet people on this Thread are making shit up saying it’s 98% but I don’t see you calling that out.

No, the 98% is sexual violence, 80% is overall violent crime.

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 14:13

MoistVonL · 03/11/2026 14:11

No, the 98% is sexual violence, 80% is overall violent crime.

And that’s exactly what I said.

OP posts:
Enterthewolves · 03/11/2026 20:07

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 12:48

It is true. Are you dense?

No but I am capable of understanding the law and its application, as I am of reading research papers, both things you seem to be struggling with. I’m teeing out now, you are not acting in good faith. I’m sorry that you were hurt, that a woman sexually assaulted you, but that doesn’t mean we should ignore the fact that men are enormously more likely to cause sexual harm to women than other women are.

gokartdillydilly · 04/11/2026 00:15

My amazing partner champions women and calls out shitty misogynistic behaviour. Over many years prior to him, I was subjected to a rape, physical abuse, a couple of violent unprovoked attacks in the street, stalking, being followed by strangers at night, coercive control, gaslighting, ghosting, groping, upskirting, catcalling, sexual innuendo, sex discrimination... ALL by (all different) men. So yes, it's not all men, but it is always men. Partner agrees.

FantasyFoodhall · 04/11/2026 02:27

I wonder why you didn’t enable voting.

KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 09:54

Enterthewolves · 03/11/2026 20:07

No but I am capable of understanding the law and its application, as I am of reading research papers, both things you seem to be struggling with. I’m teeing out now, you are not acting in good faith. I’m sorry that you were hurt, that a woman sexually assaulted you, but that doesn’t mean we should ignore the fact that men are enormously more likely to cause sexual harm to women than other women are.

I nowhere said we should ignore male
violence against women. I’m saying that we shouldn’t make up factually incorrect statements in response to it. It doesn’t help women as many victims of female perpetrated violence are other women.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 09:55

FantasyFoodhall · 04/11/2026 02:27

I wonder why you didn’t enable voting.

Because it wasn’t relevant

OP posts:
Emilesgran · 05/11/2026 10:03

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 10:35

In the UK about 80% of violent crime is committed by males, yet people on this Thread are making shit up saying it’s 98% but I don’t see you calling that out.

Why would I “call out” something I haven’t seen? You’re the OP, your posts show up more - I don’t necessarily read all the others.

Thing is, I’m not here as a proof reader - I don’t have to point out everyone else’s mistakes. It’s like being caught speeding: the cops, and the court, would take a dim view of a defence that was “Lots of others were speeding too and you didn’t stop them!” What you post here stands or falls on its own merits, and not on your claim that someone else did something just as bad.

The truth is that men commit the vast majority of violent crime, and the vast VAST majority of sexual crime. And someone obsessing over the tiny number of women who do so is just resorting to the old trick of minimising male crimes by finding ways to blame women for stuff. In this case by making out that women are just getting away with crimes that poor men would be punished for.

KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 10:30

Emilesgran · 05/11/2026 10:03

Why would I “call out” something I haven’t seen? You’re the OP, your posts show up more - I don’t necessarily read all the others.

Thing is, I’m not here as a proof reader - I don’t have to point out everyone else’s mistakes. It’s like being caught speeding: the cops, and the court, would take a dim view of a defence that was “Lots of others were speeding too and you didn’t stop them!” What you post here stands or falls on its own merits, and not on your claim that someone else did something just as bad.

The truth is that men commit the vast majority of violent crime, and the vast VAST majority of sexual crime. And someone obsessing over the tiny number of women who do so is just resorting to the old trick of minimising male crimes by finding ways to blame women for stuff. In this case by making out that women are just getting away with crimes that poor men would be punished for.

The majority is not all. Therefore the statement ‘always a man’ is factually incorrect and actually harmful to women. Lesbian women are far less likely to report domestic violence by a female partner, is the phrase ‘always a man’ helpful to them? Recently a lesbian author wrote that when she was being abused by her female partner she did not understand it as domestic violence as she didn’t think women could commit domestic violence. What message do you think ‘always a man’ sends out to people like her?

OP posts:
Emilesgran · 05/11/2026 10:37

KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 10:30

The majority is not all. Therefore the statement ‘always a man’ is factually incorrect and actually harmful to women. Lesbian women are far less likely to report domestic violence by a female partner, is the phrase ‘always a man’ helpful to them? Recently a lesbian author wrote that when she was being abused by her female partner she did not understand it as domestic violence as she didn’t think women could commit domestic violence. What message do you think ‘always a man’ sends out to people like her?

That unless she’s educationally challenged, it clearly doesn’t apply to her because it clearly refers to heterosexual relationships 🙄

She was able to work out that sexual relationships can also exist between people of the same sex, and I bet she’d have known that even when lesbianism was kept hidden. I’m finding it a stretch to think she reallycouldn’t work out that the concept of male violence didn’t apply to her situation. FFS

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 05/11/2026 11:53

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:27

Of course Im not going to response to everyone. If people keep regurgitating the same point why would I respond to each person individually? Yet none of you can answer the question of how the phrase benefits either women or men.

I don’t understand why you seem to think we believe this phrase “helps the cause “? I don’t think anyone uses it to try and do that?

or are you saying that a feminist I should be policing my language to make it clear that it’s not always men but more often it is?

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 05/11/2026 11:54

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:40

No you don't. Nor can you find a gender-flipped version of the Pelicot case and all the other similar cases now coming to court. There simply are not networks of women online sharing tips on how to rape men and arranging with each other to come and assault one another's husbands. There is not a widespread campus issue of male students fearing to enter sorority houses and being gang-raped by the sisters who high five each other and send text messages advertising their crimes and inviting other girls to join in. When men walk home alone, it's not the threat of female violence that they fear. We know, and you know, the reality of the world we live in. You can't come on forums, piss on women's heads and convince them it's raining. We can see what you're doing and it doesn't work. No one denies the existence of female violence; everyone knows it is overwhelmingly dwarfed by male violence. Not all men, but 98% of the time it's a man.

👏

KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 14:22

Emilesgran · 05/11/2026 10:37

That unless she’s educationally challenged, it clearly doesn’t apply to her because it clearly refers to heterosexual relationships 🙄

She was able to work out that sexual relationships can also exist between people of the same sex, and I bet she’d have known that even when lesbianism was kept hidden. I’m finding it a stretch to think she reallycouldn’t work out that the concept of male violence didn’t apply to her situation. FFS

Edited

Wait, so you think ‘all men’ just applies to people in heterosexual relationships? That makes zero sense. You’re just making stuff up
now.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 14:23

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 05/11/2026 11:53

I don’t understand why you seem to think we believe this phrase “helps the cause “? I don’t think anyone uses it to try and do that?

or are you saying that a feminist I should be policing my language to make it clear that it’s not always men but more often it is?

So if it’s unhelpful and inaccurate, why use it?

OP posts:
4timesthefun · 05/11/2026 14:31

You’re 100% correct, OP. It should read ‘not all men but almost always a man’. It’s not actually always just ALMOST always. Although you are technically right, I can’t get myself worked up over it. Most sayings like that have a bit of hyperbole added in for good measure. It is almost always though, so add the additional word in if you ever use the phrase and you will be accurate :)

Neverrinse · 05/11/2026 15:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WillowWindWitch · 05/11/2026 16:47

So sorry OP, popped back in and saw that I have been taken to task for my use of stats. I was focusing on sexual crime but I did bring up violent crime. So I am now happy to say that I fully support the slogan 'not all men but 80-90% of the time a man if it's violent crime and 98% of the time when it's a sex crime'. I think that is a massive own goal for MRAs and also hilarious for feminists everywhere if we concede on that point and are forced to spell it out in that much detail. It also allows us to recognise the 10-20% of violent crime perpetrated by women and 2% of sexual crime also so victims of that can feel fully recognised. Most importantly, it does not obfuscate the overwhelming problem of male violence the way that 'just not saying it all' would - which was, I believe, your preferred suggestion. So I think it works out for everyone except, alas, apologists for male violence.

I know you'll complain about under-reporting but that applies across the board and is in no way unique to female-perpetrated crime. Victims of male violence are routinely disbelieved, humiliated through the reporting process and dragged across the coals in court so an enormous number do not put themselves through it in the first place. As recognition and with it condemnation of these sorts of crimes grows, I hope we see much better treatment of all victims throughout the justice system thus leading to better reporting and conviction rates across the board. We won't get there by trying to shut women up, so in the meantime please feel free to offer accurate amendments to the slogan but don't tell women they shouldn't say it at all. No one who cares about victims agrees with silencing them.

KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 19:02

WillowWindWitch · 05/11/2026 16:47

So sorry OP, popped back in and saw that I have been taken to task for my use of stats. I was focusing on sexual crime but I did bring up violent crime. So I am now happy to say that I fully support the slogan 'not all men but 80-90% of the time a man if it's violent crime and 98% of the time when it's a sex crime'. I think that is a massive own goal for MRAs and also hilarious for feminists everywhere if we concede on that point and are forced to spell it out in that much detail. It also allows us to recognise the 10-20% of violent crime perpetrated by women and 2% of sexual crime also so victims of that can feel fully recognised. Most importantly, it does not obfuscate the overwhelming problem of male violence the way that 'just not saying it all' would - which was, I believe, your preferred suggestion. So I think it works out for everyone except, alas, apologists for male violence.

I know you'll complain about under-reporting but that applies across the board and is in no way unique to female-perpetrated crime. Victims of male violence are routinely disbelieved, humiliated through the reporting process and dragged across the coals in court so an enormous number do not put themselves through it in the first place. As recognition and with it condemnation of these sorts of crimes grows, I hope we see much better treatment of all victims throughout the justice system thus leading to better reporting and conviction rates across the board. We won't get there by trying to shut women up, so in the meantime please feel free to offer accurate amendments to the slogan but don't tell women they shouldn't say it at all. No one who cares about victims agrees with silencing them.

For me, the saying just is not helpful. Plenty of famous feminists would agree. I agree that sexual violence is massively underreported as a whole, regardless of whether the perpetrator is male or female. I don’t think the saying helps anyone. I’m all for reforms to help address the issue, but meaningless inaccurate slogans do nothing for me. And even if ‘only’ 20% of violent crimes are caused by women, that’s still enough in my mind to show it is far from just a male issue. I think also, with growing issues like cyber-bullying, in which girls are largely the perpetrators (with other girls very often being the targets) I do think we need to reframe how we think about abuse.

OP posts: