Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Anyone else get annoyed by the phrase ‘not all men, but always a man’?

398 replies

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 13:15

I’ve seen countless comments saying ‘not all men, but always a man’ underneath news articles and videos detailing a murder, child abuse, stalking or rape case. I guess what annoys me about it is that none of these crimes are just committed by men. If they were, then fair enough.
Over the last week I’ve seen an article about a woman who sexually assaulted a male taxi driver after groping his genitals and exposing herself (the comments were not kind to the man and he was called ‘gay’ for rejecting her, many of which were wrote by women). I’ve seen several articles about women who have killed or harmed young children. I’ve seen two news articles on female teachers who sexually abused/raped their male students, etc. I do wonder what sort of message these types of comments send out to young boys (who are being taught that they are the problem) and girls (who are being taught that only men can commit these crimes).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:16

DeftGoldHedgehog · 02/11/2026 14:02

Why are you so determined to find the exceptional cases unless for misogynistic reasons?

Read the statistics on crime and particularly sex and violent crime.

So women in same sex relationships are abused to the same extent as women in heterosexual relationships and are far less likely to report it. Saying it’s ‘always a man’ is fundamentally anti-feminist and doesn’t protect women at all: https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/92715/html/

OP posts:
LetMeGoogleThat · 02/11/2026 16:18

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:08

Oh, I’m all for facts, and the phrase ‘always a man’ is factually incorrect. Not only that, but it plays into anti-feminist notions that women are fundamentally harmless and ‘good’ (interestingly anti-feminists will use these same tropes to try and keep women at home within a nurturing role). Also, men who are victims of female perpetrated violence face extreme stigma. Therefore it’s not helpful to anyone. It’s just stupid and reactionary.

Being uncomfortable with a generalisation doesn't make it an accusation, and certainly doesn't make it anti-feminist.

LancsMa · 02/11/2026 16:19

No, I don't get annoyed by this phrase but I get very annoyed by the daily butchering, raping, strangling, stabbing and general abuse of women and girls.

Laurmolonlabe · 02/11/2026 16:20

I've never heard this phrase before, but the statistics support over 99% of such crimes are committed by men, so it's fair enough really.

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:22

LetMeGoogleThat · 02/11/2026 16:18

Being uncomfortable with a generalisation doesn't make it an accusation, and certainly doesn't make it anti-feminist.

Many feminists hate the phrase because it does oversimplify the issue. Lesbians, for example, experience the same rates of domestic violence as heterosexual couples. By saying ‘always a man’ it ignores their reality. As a consequence they are far less likely to report it. I recently read an article from a lesbian author who said she was abused by her female partner but didn’t understand it as domestic violence as female perpetrated violence isn’t something that’s discussed. She literally said that she didn’t think her being hit qualified as domestic violence as her abuser was female. So, actually, saying ‘always a man’ does have real world consequences. I don’t see how it’s protecting women at all.

OP posts:
FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:22

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 14:42

I suppose most stalkers of men are female, so we could say under these types of crimes ‘not all women, but always a woman’ (even if it is factually incorrect).

It’s not true that most stalkers of men are women. Studies show it’s split quite equally.

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:23

LancsMa · 02/11/2026 16:19

No, I don't get annoyed by this phrase but I get very annoyed by the daily butchering, raping, strangling, stabbing and general abuse of women and girls.

Me too, which is why we shouldn’t oversimplify the issue.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:23

FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:22

It’s not true that most stalkers of men are women. Studies show it’s split quite equally.

Not true.

OP posts:
Snorlaxo · 02/11/2026 16:23

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:08

Oh, I’m all for facts, and the phrase ‘always a man’ is factually incorrect. Not only that, but it plays into anti-feminist notions that women are fundamentally harmless and ‘good’ (interestingly anti-feminists will use these same tropes to try and keep women at home within a nurturing role). Also, men who are victims of female perpetrated violence face extreme stigma. Therefore it’s not helpful to anyone. It’s just stupid and reactionary.

Who do you think is judging a man for being a victim of a woman?

I’ve seen the phrase used when the victim is male - especially when the victim is minor so not sure it’s about women being harmless.

Men commit most violent crime. This is a fact all around the world. The men in our lives are most at risk from other men. This is a fact. The phrase isn’t literal because there’s obviously crimes committed by women but as a general statement about men as a class, it is accurate. When anomalies like a female school shooter happens, it’s not unfair to express surprise but pretending that it happens as much as male violence is outrageously ridiculous.

FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:26

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:23

Not true.

Can you link to studies? All the ones I find show almost an equal split-some find more males, some more females, but overall it’s seems almost 50/50.

MoistVonL · 02/11/2026 16:26

I'm sorry you're a survivor of sexual assault. That's horrible. Sadly, most of us have experienced it.

When male offending rates have dropped the the level of female offending rates, I'd be prepared to take your point.

Currently we have 96-99 male sex offenders per female sex offender. We know who to be most wary of.

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:27

Snorlaxo · 02/11/2026 16:23

Who do you think is judging a man for being a victim of a woman?

I’ve seen the phrase used when the victim is male - especially when the victim is minor so not sure it’s about women being harmless.

Men commit most violent crime. This is a fact all around the world. The men in our lives are most at risk from other men. This is a fact. The phrase isn’t literal because there’s obviously crimes committed by women but as a general statement about men as a class, it is accurate. When anomalies like a female school shooter happens, it’s not unfair to express surprise but pretending that it happens as much as male violence is outrageously ridiculous.

Well, if you want to talk about stats 80% of school shooters had an absentee father. Yet I bet most people would feel uncomfortable saying ‘not everyone without a dad, but always those without a dad’. I don’t think it’s helpful at all. I believe it silences men and women who have been victims of female perpetuated violence. And I believe it oversimplifies a complex issue.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:28

FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:26

Can you link to studies? All the ones I find show almost an equal split-some find more males, some more females, but overall it’s seems almost 50/50.

Edited

Almost 50/50 isn’t 50/50. Statistically, there are more female perpetrators of this type of crime where the victim is male.

OP posts:
FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:29

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:28

Almost 50/50 isn’t 50/50. Statistically, there are more female perpetrators of this type of crime where the victim is male.

Can you show evidence of that?

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:31

FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:29

Can you show evidence of that?

The centre of disease and control reports that 46% are female and 43% are male. The remaining 8% is both a male and female. So statistically it is majority female.

OP posts:
GrandHighPoohbah · 02/11/2026 16:32

I suppose it's shorthand for what ordinary people see in society. The overwhelming majority of criminals are men.

FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:35

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:31

The centre of disease and control reports that 46% are female and 43% are male. The remaining 8% is both a male and female. So statistically it is majority female.

46% is a plurality, not a majority. The 8% experienced stalking by both sexes, so you can’t attribute that entirely to women. These figures concern male victims, not all stalking perpetrators. You’re misrepresenting the statistics to claim women commit the majority of stalking.

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:37

FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:35

46% is a plurality, not a majority. The 8% experienced stalking by both sexes, so you can’t attribute that entirely to women. These figures concern male victims, not all stalking perpetrators. You’re misrepresenting the statistics to claim women commit the majority of stalking.

Sigh. I didn’t say that women commit the most stalking. I said where the victim was male the perpetrator was most likely female. Which they are.

OP posts:
LetMeGoogleThat · 02/11/2026 16:39

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:22

Many feminists hate the phrase because it does oversimplify the issue. Lesbians, for example, experience the same rates of domestic violence as heterosexual couples. By saying ‘always a man’ it ignores their reality. As a consequence they are far less likely to report it. I recently read an article from a lesbian author who said she was abused by her female partner but didn’t understand it as domestic violence as female perpetrated violence isn’t something that’s discussed. She literally said that she didn’t think her being hit qualified as domestic violence as her abuser was female. So, actually, saying ‘always a man’ does have real world consequences. I don’t see how it’s protecting women at all.

Edited

To suggest that many feminists hate the phrase is a generalisation! Which is exactly the same as the saying that you dislike. You can dislike it, and as a feminist I can disagree.
Throwing in exeptions doesn't make the statistics disappear. How many women ended up dead at the hands of their female partners??

CleverlyBeery · 02/11/2026 16:40

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:12

I’m asking if you have an argument to put forward or are you just here to pick up on a grammatical error?

I suggest you read all of my posts on this thread, and if there is anything that's unclear to you after doing so, please quote the text that's unclear and I will try and clarify for you.

And no, I'm not here to pick up on a grammatical error (although if someone types something that seems nonsensical, I consider it more courteous to ask them what they meant rather than assume without question that they got it wrong).
I was here to try and work out whether there's any truth in your claim that the phrase in question is causing a significant difference in the prevalence of reporting of FPSA compared with MPSA, but as you won't engage with fairly simple requests like 'copy the bit of the study you're talking about, so I understand what you mean', I'm not really interested in doing that any more.

I hope your annoyance subsides and you find some peace.

Never2many · 02/11/2026 16:43

No but I hate the phrase “when violence against men is equal to that of women I’ll care.” It’s pathetic and hateful.

all violence is wrong. it’s possible to acknowledge that more men are perpitrators of sexual violence than women, but the reality is that female crimes are excused more often than not.

Man murders someone? He was a thug/a bastard/a man what do you expect?

Woman murders someone, including her own children,? “She must have been mentally ill/a victim of a man in some way.”

And let’s not pretend that doesn’t happen because it absolutely does.

In the past few years I’ve seen far more women who have murdered their children than men, and even in the case of men having done it, the woman has been complicit and has more often than not moved him in within five minutes of getting together, then done absolutely nothing to protect her children.

Let’s be honest, there are some heinous individuals out there, more of one sex committing certain crimes does not diminish the guilt of the crimes committed by the other sex, and we need to stop downplaying female crimes because “when as many women do it as men I’ll care.”

FucksakeMulder · 02/11/2026 16:45

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:37

Sigh. I didn’t say that women commit the most stalking. I said where the victim was male the perpetrator was most likely female. Which they are.

Fair enough, not going to argue that you said something you didn’t.

Im going to grab a cup of tea and dive into all the studies I can find. Much fun!

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:46

LetMeGoogleThat · 02/11/2026 16:39

To suggest that many feminists hate the phrase is a generalisation! Which is exactly the same as the saying that you dislike. You can dislike it, and as a feminist I can disagree.
Throwing in exeptions doesn't make the statistics disappear. How many women ended up dead at the hands of their female partners??

Many feminists do hate the phrase. Could you explain to me why saying ‘not all men, but always a man’ is helpful to either women or men? Because I don’t see it. If you’re rightly worried about sexual violence and male criminality, why not focus your attention on helping them? We know that male criminals are vastly more likely to come from families without a father or come from an unstable home (an issue that’s often brushed over and it’s blamed on them just having a penis) so why not focus attention on getting men into early years and primary school settings and support initiatives to have men mentor boys who don’t have a good male figure at home? Can you imagine, as a girl, growing up without a mother and all your friends grew up without a mother, and the first time you see a positive female figure is in secondary school? I imagine the female crime rates would shoot up. But instead of helping girls men were just churning out useless phrases like ‘not all women, but always a woman’. It’s like idiocracy.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 16:48

Never2many · 02/11/2026 16:43

No but I hate the phrase “when violence against men is equal to that of women I’ll care.” It’s pathetic and hateful.

all violence is wrong. it’s possible to acknowledge that more men are perpitrators of sexual violence than women, but the reality is that female crimes are excused more often than not.

Man murders someone? He was a thug/a bastard/a man what do you expect?

Woman murders someone, including her own children,? “She must have been mentally ill/a victim of a man in some way.”

And let’s not pretend that doesn’t happen because it absolutely does.

In the past few years I’ve seen far more women who have murdered their children than men, and even in the case of men having done it, the woman has been complicit and has more often than not moved him in within five minutes of getting together, then done absolutely nothing to protect her children.

Let’s be honest, there are some heinous individuals out there, more of one sex committing certain crimes does not diminish the guilt of the crimes committed by the other sex, and we need to stop downplaying female crimes because “when as many women do it as men I’ll care.”

Exactly this. And I imagine as the law changes more women will be held to account.

OP posts:
AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 02/11/2026 16:51

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 14:18

I’m more amused that they are talking about the virtues of ChatGPT which falsely said that I persistently talk about this issue when this is my first post and they’ve taken that as gospel.

Are you getting post and thread muddled up? Because you making quite a few posts on this topic here https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5587564-to-feel-uncomfortable-by-these-type-of-posts-as-a-mum-of-a-boy?page=10

Page 10 | To feel uncomfortable by these type of posts as a mum of a boy? | Mumsnet

I follow an influencer on Instagram who has recently had a baby boy and today did a post addressed to ‘girl mums’ about how she was raising her boy wi...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5587564-to-feel-uncomfortable-by-these-type-of-posts-as-a-mum-of-a-boy?page=10

Swipe left for the next trending thread