Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Welcome to the castle - we got fun and games | 2026 Celebrity Traitors Thread 2 [TV Pace]

1000 replies

CaveMum · 02/10/2026 20:38

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5571945-celebrity-traitors-s2?page=1

This is a tv pace thread so make sure you’re up to date with the live broadcast and yes, previous series (regular and celeb) will be discussed!

Please no spoilers if you read them online!

The story so far (as of end of episode 1)

Traitors
Maya Jama
Richard E Grant

Faithful
Bella Ramsey
James Blunt
Jerry Hall
Joanne McNally
Joe Lycett
Julie Hesmondhalgh
King Kenny
Leigh-Anne Pinnock
Michael Sheen
Miranda Hart
Myha’la
Professor Hannah Fry
Rob Beckett
Romesh Ranganathan
Ross Kemp
Sebastian Croft
Sharon Rooney

Potential Recruit/Murder
Amol Rajan
James Acaster

Celebrity Traitors S2 | Mumsnet

Well seeing as I did the threads last year I might as well kick things off again for 2026 now that the first teaser trailer has dropped. If you haven...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5571945-celebrity-traitors-s2?page=1

OP posts:
LindorDoubleChoc · 05/10/2026 21:19

HildaGribblethwaiteLives · 05/10/2026 18:11

Right, I know it's not my thread and I am definitely not the self-appointed MN police but is there any chance that the posters who want to discuss who should be in the next series of Celebrity Traitors could start their own thread.

We are only two episodes in to the current series.

As you were.

Agree! There are so many posts on these threads and it takes a lot of filtering to keep up.

BobbiBiscuits · 05/10/2026 21:43

I didn't realise how seriously people take these threads. I thought it was a bit of fun. Silly me!

CatVester · 05/10/2026 21:56

I don't think anyone is taking anything particularly seriously but I agree that it's slightly irritating to have to scroll through a bunch of posts about people who might never be on the programme to get to people discussing the current series.

I think that dream Celeb Traitors contestants would be better as a separate thread.

MyWildOliveGoose · 05/10/2026 22:51

LindorDoubleChoc · 05/10/2026 21:19

Agree! There are so many posts on these threads and it takes a lot of filtering to keep up.

I quickly decided to keep popping in to bookmark this thread, simply to be able to find new posts that might be relevant during show times lol I can’t deal with so many posts 😅

latetothefisting · 05/10/2026 22:53

LindorDoubleChoc · 05/10/2026 21:15

@latetothefisting

Huh? The celebs don't win any money. They are there to win for charity.

Huh? I know it goes to charity but the winners still 'win' the total prize pot at the end, that's literally the whole reason for having tasks that accumulate a set amount of money. At no point did I say they kept it for themselves, not sure why you seem to think I did?

But it's pretty obvious the money is much less of a motivating factor to them than it is to the contestants in the normal version. Both because it's pretty natural to be less invested in giving money to others, no matter how much you support the charity, and because they are generally much better paid anyway. £30k to a normal person could be genuinely lifechanging, but be the equivalent of a few day's work to some of the celebs.

sherbetlemonade · 05/10/2026 23:33

One thing I find pleasing about the British ones is the camera crew's lack of obsession with manicured fingernails. I've watched the last Irish and American series, and long shots of ludicrously long talons were in practically every scene.

NewspaperTaxis · 06/10/2026 04:11

MyFreeOpinion · 05/10/2026 17:42

I need to get this off my chest.

I'm really not liking the start of this season.

I've just rewatched the traitor selection, and REG was terrible right off the bat. Grinning a bit too much after Claudia announced that the traitors would recruit another traitor. Rob asked him whether he's happy, and he replied, "how are you feeling?" SURELY someone who wanted to be a traitor THAT MUCH would have already prepared an answer - answering a question with a question sounds defensive. And of course, I don't know what he was thinking when he told Joe he was a traitor – TWICE.

Here is the transcript. The conversation starts with REG speculating that Joe could be a traitor.
REG (to Joe): Or you could be a traitor yeah [Joe says yeah I could] who's just got a shield.
JOE: I could be, but I'm not. I'm a faithful. What are you?
REG (shrugs shoulders): Traitor.
EDITED TO SUGGEST THOSE IN THE ROOM HAVE TAKEN A MOMENT TO LET THIS SINK IN. BUT I THINK THIS IS MANUFACTURED.
JOE: You're what?
REG (lifting glass of wine as though toasting someone): Traitor.
UNKNOWN VOICE: He's a traitor.
JOE: Are you?
REG (shrugging again while drinking): Yeah.
JOE: Right.
MORE EDITING TO SUGGEST SILENCE. AGAIN, I SUSPECT FRANKENBITING.
REG: What's the point in being in the game if you're not?
JAMES BLUNT LAUGHS. REG LAUGHS A LITTLE.
JOE: Right. Ok.
JAMES: It's an interesting angle.
ROB LAUGHS LOUDLY. THERE ARE A FEW OTHER TUTTERS.
JAMES TO REG: You need to be very clear that you're not.
JOE: I'm going to pretend that I didn't hear that. What are you Richard? Faithful.
REG (whispering): Faithful.
THERE IS A BIT OF LAUGHTER AND CHITCHAT.
JOE: I think you've just done something that's never happened in the game.
REG LAUGHS VERY LOUDLY.
ROB Bold strategy.
JOE: It is a bold strategy.

The highlighted text is key. Joe knows EXACTLY what has happened. The scene does not look anything like a failed joke on REG's part. It looks like someone who was too excited with the status of being a traitor to bother to pre-memorise some lines.

REG then hasn't helped himself by over-explaining at the round table. He should have just said, "everyone always says they're a faithful, so I was trying to make everyone laugh", and kept it at that. It's not a great answer, but the response he gave was too long and the whole Spartacus thing was weird.

I imagine that there has been some editing to make it look like the group is thinking seriously about other names. However, even if over half of them voted for someone other than REG, the suspicions are too unfocussed for any one individual to get more votes than REG. It's FPPT, after all.

In the meantime, however, this whole shit show has put the storyline on a terrible trajectory. Everything Hannah said was right – the decisions of the traitors suggest they are on the back foot and trying to deflect attention – which is absolutely accurate. Maya and REG didn't choose James Acaster because he'd make a good traitor, but because of James's firm view that REG is a traitor. I suspect Maya simply didn't have time to realise the best way forward was to feed REG to the wolves. We now have James doing verbal gymnastics in which he tries to both hide the fact he is a traitor AND not lie.

And the grave digging challenge ... surely the producers should have foreseen that it was likely that the celebrities would save one another rather than donate piddling amounts to a charity? Having only two faithfuls to choose from makes for shit TV.

The best thing from now may be for REG to go, and the show essentially reboots with a new (third) traitor who is actually decent ... hopefully with Hannah still in the cast.

I do agree with this post, aspects of this series are car crash telly. It's down to REG who seems to be the bloke who wants something so much it means he can't have it, like having a crush on a girl who might actually like him but he has to eff it up anyway by not playing it cool or in any way normal.

It would be a bold move on his part if he were able to brazen it out with skill and aplomb, like Richard III wooing the widow over the corpse of the one he'd had murdered near the beginning of Shakespeare's play.

It's been said or suspected that actors would make good traitors but turns out that's not true because they are rubbish without a script; it's like taking away a tradesman's tools. Without a script they tend to ham it up, which is what one of the actors - the Scottish one currently in Ludwig - was accused of in the last Celeb Traitors. Okay, some actors are good at improvising but apparently not here. A brilliant scriptwriter would have been able to dig REG out of the hole he'd made himself but REG certainly can't.

The best 'actors' / traitors are not actually actors but those who are good at thinking on their feet in front of the camera while being themselves, hence the success of Ross and Carr in the last one.

cloudtreecarpet · 06/10/2026 07:18

NewspaperTaxis · 06/10/2026 04:11

I do agree with this post, aspects of this series are car crash telly. It's down to REG who seems to be the bloke who wants something so much it means he can't have it, like having a crush on a girl who might actually like him but he has to eff it up anyway by not playing it cool or in any way normal.

It would be a bold move on his part if he were able to brazen it out with skill and aplomb, like Richard III wooing the widow over the corpse of the one he'd had murdered near the beginning of Shakespeare's play.

It's been said or suspected that actors would make good traitors but turns out that's not true because they are rubbish without a script; it's like taking away a tradesman's tools. Without a script they tend to ham it up, which is what one of the actors - the Scottish one currently in Ludwig - was accused of in the last Celeb Traitors. Okay, some actors are good at improvising but apparently not here. A brilliant scriptwriter would have been able to dig REG out of the hole he'd made himself but REG certainly can't.

The best 'actors' / traitors are not actually actors but those who are good at thinking on their feet in front of the camera while being themselves, hence the success of Ross and Carr in the last one.

Yes, I would say comedians make good traitors because they have to be sharp & quick thinking in their profession plus they can also use humour to distract people.

I agree that actors are not necessarily good at it without the power of a good script and direction.
I would love Romesh to become a traitor; I think he would be brilliant and good to watch.

ThatCyanCat · 06/10/2026 07:28

I was thinking the same thing. Performing a well rehearsed and directed script before an audience that knows you're pretending is really very different to lying and deceiving, as yourself, off the cuff as people try to catch you out. Even impro isn't the same as that. Lots of people enjoy acting because they can be someone else and struggle being themselves.

AlwaysExtraHot · 06/10/2026 08:03

CatVester · 05/10/2026 19:22

I really liked the secret traitor! It was fun to guess. We had a spreadsheet going and everything.

I thought it was patently obvious who it was. Our household guessed pretty much immediately.

AlwaysExtraHot · 06/10/2026 08:04

BobbiBiscuits · 05/10/2026 19:48

Ah yes A Hammond might be a bit much😂. She could even be a bit REG .

Sue? Prickly? Never! 😆

I’ve heard before (I think on here) that Sue P is not particularly nice.

Beachtastic · 06/10/2026 08:31

And do you vow to keep your identity and the identity of your fellow players a secret?

I'm not sure what happened to that vow!

REG is a complete fuck-up, it's such a disappointment. With his Spartacus speech he seemed to be reaching for the spirit of his Hamlet monologue at the end of Withnail, but it was totally incongruous with the situation.

He's such a loose cannon that Maya must surely vote against him if she wants half a chance of staying in the game? Also, he looked a bit pissed off with her for explaining him away as a prancing loony. That doesn't seem to be how he likes to see himself.

Once he's gone, she's stuck with someone who didn't even want to be a traitor.

Hopefully things will improve when they recruit again.

ThatCyanCat · 06/10/2026 08:40

He hadn't made the vow yet at the time he revealed himself.

HeinousBeaker · 06/10/2026 08:41

REG said he was a traitor immediately after the round table where they were chosen, I think? Then the traitors vow comes before the first turret meeting, so he hadn’t done it yet. Still stupid but he didn’t actually break the vow

Beachtastic · 06/10/2026 08:45

ThatCyanCat · 06/10/2026 08:40

He hadn't made the vow yet at the time he revealed himself.

Ah yes that's true! I'd last 3 seconds in the castle 🫣😔😁

ETA: Mind you, you'd think he'd sort of keep it in mind, given that he always wanted to be a traitor!

BobbiBiscuits · 06/10/2026 09:06

AlwaysExtraHot · 06/10/2026 08:03

I thought it was patently obvious who it was. Our household guessed pretty much immediately.

Careful! We're not allowed to talk about past series of traitors or future series of traitors or Irish Traitors or anything else but This Series of traitors! 🤐😆

AlwaysExtraHot · 06/10/2026 09:08

BobbiBiscuits · 06/10/2026 09:06

Careful! We're not allowed to talk about past series of traitors or future series of traitors or Irish Traitors or anything else but This Series of traitors! 🤐😆

I know 😬

saveforthat · 06/10/2026 09:36

ThatCyanCat · 06/10/2026 08:40

He hadn't made the vow yet at the time he revealed himself.

I don't believe that REG has ever watched a series of Traitors. I am furious that he blurted that out. I don't think it's funny at all. I think he should be removed from the show for breaking the rules (not banished) and Maya allowed to recruit. Then the murder could be cancelled and Hannah saved.

sherbetlemonade · 06/10/2026 09:51

There's going to be egg on some faces. If the ones who think he's a traitor don't vote for him to be banished, they will look like fools when it finally comes out, and the ones who think he's a faithful will look like fools anyway.

Fortuity · 06/10/2026 10:18

B9waiting · 04/10/2026 17:43

What is there to say? Complete background character at this stage & has contributed nothing (as far as we’ve seen).

She contributed that very telling comment that she was sitting beside Richard when traitors were chosen and that he was really elated and excited. I suspect that would have caused him real problems even if he hadn't said he was a traitor.

But I think in general her current strategy is to keep her head down as much as possible.

NewspaperTaxis · 06/10/2026 10:19

Beachtastic · 06/10/2026 08:31

And do you vow to keep your identity and the identity of your fellow players a secret?

I'm not sure what happened to that vow!

REG is a complete fuck-up, it's such a disappointment. With his Spartacus speech he seemed to be reaching for the spirit of his Hamlet monologue at the end of Withnail, but it was totally incongruous with the situation.

He's such a loose cannon that Maya must surely vote against him if she wants half a chance of staying in the game? Also, he looked a bit pissed off with her for explaining him away as a prancing loony. That doesn't seem to be how he likes to see himself.

Once he's gone, she's stuck with someone who didn't even want to be a traitor.

Hopefully things will improve when they recruit again.

Earlier I commented on how REG is the Liz Truss of traitors - goes in with a bold move and completely messes it up, and the above post underlines the last Tory Govt nature of this series, where cabinet posts would be relinquished and a new person appointed within weeks - 'maybe it will work this time', a sort of work in progress while the show is ongoing!

It's slightly compulsive but not for the right reasons!

I don't know if Claudia is really the one who chooses the traitors or if it's done via committee - if she is then maybe Tess was the brains of the operation!

That said, REG was on to something when he said that of the traitors, one is bound to be a comedian - seemingly forgetting that it puts new recruit James Macaster in the frame. But it's true, statistically, one of the traitors will be a person of colour, they wouldn't all be of colour or none of them. Last time it was, a gay guy, a jack the lad, a woman of colour, also gay and the younger generation. All that's being wise after the event, I know. But even so, this stuff doesn't help much at such an early stage of the game as it doesn't narrow it down.

Even if you picked who would be most entertaining as a traitor, you would pick Michael Sheen, Joe Lycitt and one of the young uns probably Bella. I think that would make a better show but... it would be like the last one.

NewspaperTaxis · 06/10/2026 10:36

Will also point out that the new Strictly isn't running that smoothly either so that's two BBC flagship shows in danger of running aground.

In a way, REG has been quite punk. He's done very well out of the BBC's travel shows - there was a good one on the Riviera repeated last week - so if it's a case of 'What has the BBC ever done for me?' he's done pretty well! Talk about biting the hand that feeds you, he goes on their flagship show and totally fucks it up! It commands a sort of respect.

JudgeJ · 06/10/2026 10:39

ScaredButUnavoidable · 05/10/2026 13:10

🤣🤣🤣

You can just imagine him walking off and wishing good luck to Maya and James without even realising he was saying it!!!

It would be TV GOLD (again) 🤣

Even better if he says it to another pair!

OsfameronTanamoril · 06/10/2026 10:40

JudgeJ · 06/10/2026 10:39

Even better if he says it to another pair!

Think he has been cautioned by now.

Fortuity · 06/10/2026 10:48

I don't know if Claudia is really the one who chooses the traitors or if it's done via committee - if she is then maybe Tess was the brains of the operation!

She's said before that the producers choose, though she contributes to the choice.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.