I need to get this off my chest.
I'm really not liking the start of this season.
I've just rewatched the traitor selection, and REG was terrible right off the bat. Grinning a bit too much after Claudia announced that the traitors would recruit another traitor. Rob asked him whether he's happy, and he replied, "how are you feeling?" SURELY someone who wanted to be a traitor THAT MUCH would have already prepared an answer - answering a question with a question sounds defensive. And of course, I don't know what he was thinking when he told Joe he was a traitor – TWICE.
Here is the transcript. The conversation starts with REG speculating that Joe could be a traitor.
REG (to Joe): Or you could be a traitor yeah [Joe says yeah I could] who's just got a shield.
JOE: I could be, but I'm not. I'm a faithful. What are you?
REG (shrugs shoulders): Traitor.
EDITED TO SUGGEST THOSE IN THE ROOM HAVE TAKEN A MOMENT TO LET THIS SINK IN. BUT I THINK THIS IS MANUFACTURED.
JOE: You're what?
REG (lifting glass of wine as though toasting someone): Traitor.
UNKNOWN VOICE: He's a traitor.
JOE: Are you?
REG (shrugging again while drinking): Yeah.
JOE: Right.
MORE EDITING TO SUGGEST SILENCE. AGAIN, I SUSPECT FRANKENBITING.
REG: What's the point in being in the game if you're not?
JAMES BLUNT LAUGHS. REG LAUGHS A LITTLE.
JOE: Right. Ok.
JAMES: It's an interesting angle.
ROB LAUGHS LOUDLY. THERE ARE A FEW OTHER TUTTERS.
JAMES TO REG: You need to be very clear that you're not.
JOE: I'm going to pretend that I didn't hear that. What are you Richard? Faithful.
REG (whispering): Faithful.
THERE IS A BIT OF LAUGHTER AND CHITCHAT.
JOE: I think you've just done something that's never happened in the game.
REG LAUGHS VERY LOUDLY.
ROB Bold strategy.
JOE: It is a bold strategy.
The highlighted text is key. Joe knows EXACTLY what has happened. The scene does not look anything like a failed joke on REG's part. It looks like someone who was too excited with the status of being a traitor to bother to pre-memorise some lines.
REG then hasn't helped himself by over-explaining at the round table. He should have just said, "everyone always says they're a faithful, so I was trying to make everyone laugh", and kept it at that. It's not a great answer, but the response he gave was too long and the whole Spartacus thing was weird.
I imagine that there has been some editing to make it look like the group is thinking seriously about other names. However, even if over half of them voted for someone other than REG, the suspicions are too unfocussed for any one individual to get more votes than REG. It's FPPT, after all.
In the meantime, however, this whole shit show has put the storyline on a terrible trajectory. Everything Hannah said was right – the decisions of the traitors suggest they are on the back foot and trying to deflect attention – which is absolutely accurate. Maya and REG didn't choose James Acaster because he'd make a good traitor, but because of James's firm view that REG is a traitor. I suspect Maya simply didn't have time to realise the best way forward was to feed REG to the wolves. We now have James doing verbal gymnastics in which he tries to both hide the fact he is a traitor AND not lie.
And the grave digging challenge ... surely the producers should have foreseen that it was likely that the celebrities would save one another rather than donate piddling amounts to a charity? Having only two faithfuls to choose from makes for shit TV.
The best thing from now may be for REG to go, and the show essentially reboots with a new (third) traitor who is actually decent ... hopefully with Hannah still in the cast.