Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Welcome to the castle - we got fun and games | 2026 Celebrity Traitors Thread 2 [TV Pace]

1000 replies

CaveMum · 02/10/2026 20:38

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5571945-celebrity-traitors-s2?page=1

This is a tv pace thread so make sure you’re up to date with the live broadcast and yes, previous series (regular and celeb) will be discussed!

Please no spoilers if you read them online!

The story so far (as of end of episode 1)

Traitors
Maya Jama
Richard E Grant

Faithful
Bella Ramsey
James Blunt
Jerry Hall
Joanne McNally
Joe Lycett
Julie Hesmondhalgh
King Kenny
Leigh-Anne Pinnock
Michael Sheen
Miranda Hart
Myha’la
Professor Hannah Fry
Rob Beckett
Romesh Ranganathan
Ross Kemp
Sebastian Croft
Sharon Rooney

Potential Recruit/Murder
Amol Rajan
James Acaster

Celebrity Traitors S2 | Mumsnet

Well seeing as I did the threads last year I might as well kick things off again for 2026 now that the first teaser trailer has dropped. If you haven...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5571945-celebrity-traitors-s2?page=1

OP posts:
BobbiBiscuits · 05/10/2026 14:03

ScaredButUnavoidable · 05/10/2026 13:10

🤣🤣🤣

You can just imagine him walking off and wishing good luck to Maya and James without even realising he was saying it!!!

It would be TV GOLD (again) 🤣

That would be amazing.. Or giving them a subtle wink when he thinks no ones looking..

newrubylane · 05/10/2026 14:16

AlwaysExtraHot · 05/10/2026 11:40

Yeah, I don't think REG has ruined this season. Whether deliberately or not, it's put the cat among the pigeons, which is always fun to watch. And they'll just have to keep recruiting and the Faithful will have to keep hunting/guessing. That's fine by me.
I think Hannah going (if she does) will ruin it much more for me!
Ross's tactic was not well thought out in terms of how narrow a murder pool it left, but I think he was terrified that they'd think he was a Traitor, so had to show that he was on the side of the Faithfuls by rescuing them.

But given that Jerry and Hannah were our of the grave before he'd even got started digging, this slightly negates that argument. The Traitors had someone to murder. If it had been a Traitor in that position I'd have taken that opportunity to 'prove' myself a good Faithful too!

I wasn't clear how much the Traitors knew about what the task was going to be. Ross wasnt particularly a smart choice to sabotage a physical task. I didn't quite follow why they selected him?

ThatCyanCat · 05/10/2026 14:17

FallenNight · 05/10/2026 09:58

But its not fair to me! Hannah could be such a good contenstant I want to see more of her! I wouldn't mind if it had been unfair to some of the others 😂

I'd love to be able to watch without knowing who the traitors were. Because we know its so obvious, all confirmation bias. The 'other' theories are clearly lunacy as we know they are wrong, the evidence stands out a mile as we know its correct.

I was wondering if I could some skip all the tower bits and all social media and watch it without knowing who the traitors are so I can play along!

I guess it would increase the costs and everything madly, but I do wonder if there's a market for two versions, one where the viewer knows who they are, and another where they don't. It would be very difficult to know how to do the edit to keep it fair, though.

CaveMum · 05/10/2026 15:25

sherbetlemonade · 05/10/2026 13:05

Fancy having to come up with all these original challenges, and go through them multiple times trying to predict which of umpteen combinations of circumstances might happen to affect the game in unexpected ways. Can't be easy.

Last year Richard Osman said the production team were really surprised by how fast the celebs completed one of the tasks - the one in the cabin where they had to solve puzzles and undo bolts, etc to release keys.

He said the crew normally do the tasks themselves several times to see how long it takes, and then average out the time so they know how long to give the players, with enough of a “will they, won’t they” element added. These tasks are designed to be completed with a minute or less remaining on the clock.

However they hadn’t factored for Nick Mohammed solving all the puzzles in seconds and Joe Marler single-handedly dismantling things faster than they thought possible! They completed the task with about 5 minutes remaining 🤣🤣

OP posts:
sherbetlemonade · 05/10/2026 16:01

newrubylane · 05/10/2026 14:16

But given that Jerry and Hannah were our of the grave before he'd even got started digging, this slightly negates that argument. The Traitors had someone to murder. If it had been a Traitor in that position I'd have taken that opportunity to 'prove' myself a good Faithful too!

I wasn't clear how much the Traitors knew about what the task was going to be. Ross wasnt particularly a smart choice to sabotage a physical task. I didn't quite follow why they selected him?

The Traitors were told to pick one person, but at the time of picking, they didn't know what the challenge would be. Perhaps they chose him to draw attention away from themselves, in the hope that people would suspect he might be a Traitor and had chosen to name himself, which has happened before.

ThatCyanCat · 05/10/2026 16:23

sherbetlemonade · 05/10/2026 16:01

The Traitors were told to pick one person, but at the time of picking, they didn't know what the challenge would be. Perhaps they chose him to draw attention away from themselves, in the hope that people would suspect he might be a Traitor and had chosen to name himself, which has happened before.

Did they not know? They surely must have done, otherwise they wouldn't have had a chance to form any strategy. At the very least they must have been told that whoever they chose would be shielded from murder.

AlwaysExtraHot · 05/10/2026 16:27

ThatCyanCat · 05/10/2026 16:23

Did they not know? They surely must have done, otherwise they wouldn't have had a chance to form any strategy. At the very least they must have been told that whoever they chose would be shielded from murder.

No, they weren't; Claudia just said gnomic things about their decisions being possibly the difference between life and death.

BeaLola · 05/10/2026 16:32

I was idly thinking for season 3, amongst others:

Andy Murray
Idris Elba
Stanley Tucci
Tess Daly
Clive Myrie
Graham Norton
Gabby Logan
Marcus Wareing

AlwaysExtraHot · 05/10/2026 16:37

BeaLola · 05/10/2026 16:32

I was idly thinking for season 3, amongst others:

Andy Murray
Idris Elba
Stanley Tucci
Tess Daly
Clive Myrie
Graham Norton
Gabby Logan
Marcus Wareing

I'd love Andy Murray and Idris Elba. Gabby Logan is dreadful, but (assuming she was a Faithful) I would like it if she got murdered or banished early.
i'd like Jo Brand and/or Fatiha El-Ghorri, and Lucy Worsley.

BeaLola · 05/10/2026 16:40

The reason I picked Gabby is i expect she would be very competitive, a bit marmite to the other contestants

I like the idea of Jo Brand

AlwaysExtraHot · 05/10/2026 16:51

BeaLola · 05/10/2026 16:40

The reason I picked Gabby is i expect she would be very competitive, a bit marmite to the other contestants

I like the idea of Jo Brand

The reason I picked Gabby is i expect she would be very competitive, a bit marmite to the other contestants
I don't disagree she'd be good from a casting POV, I just can't stand her. She was insanely competitive on Strictly and it put me right off her.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 05/10/2026 17:22

ScaredButUnavoidable · 05/10/2026 13:10

🤣🤣🤣

You can just imagine him walking off and wishing good luck to Maya and James without even realising he was saying it!!!

It would be TV GOLD (again) 🤣

IIRC one of the non famous Traitors basically outed the others when he was correctly banished. It was the lovely Welsh fella, I'm going to say Anthony but I could be wrong.

As for Gabby Logan, hopefully she'd be banished/murdered straight away thanks to her uber competitive head girl behaviour. She even does my head in on WILTY, which is just meant to be light entertainment comedy. And don't even get me started on SCD...

BobbiBiscuits · 05/10/2026 17:25

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 05/10/2026 17:22

IIRC one of the non famous Traitors basically outed the others when he was correctly banished. It was the lovely Welsh fella, I'm going to say Anthony but I could be wrong.

As for Gabby Logan, hopefully she'd be banished/murdered straight away thanks to her uber competitive head girl behaviour. She even does my head in on WILTY, which is just meant to be light entertainment comedy. And don't even get me started on SCD...

Uber competitive but never quite head girl, I'd say.. hence the incessant need to win but not quite getting there.

BobbiBiscuits · 05/10/2026 17:35

Jo Brand would be excellent agreed
Andy M -agree
Clive - agree
Graham Norton agree
Thingy's wife on Connect

who else..

Debbie McGee
Any of the Spice Girls
Giles Brandesburton
Any of the current Bake Off presenters
Mel or Sue (old bake off presenters)
Rowan Atkinson

I don't know any 'content creators' or 'You tube' stars, so we'd need some of those too, for the young people

AlwaysExtraHot · 05/10/2026 17:35

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 05/10/2026 17:22

IIRC one of the non famous Traitors basically outed the others when he was correctly banished. It was the lovely Welsh fella, I'm going to say Anthony but I could be wrong.

As for Gabby Logan, hopefully she'd be banished/murdered straight away thanks to her uber competitive head girl behaviour. She even does my head in on WILTY, which is just meant to be light entertainment comedy. And don't even get me started on SCD...

IIRC one of the non famous Traitors basically outed the others when he was correctly banished. It was the lovely Welsh fella, I'm going to say Anthony but I could be wrong.
I don't remember that, but in the first season didn't one Traitor (forgot his name) out Wilf?

AlwaysExtraHot · 05/10/2026 17:37

BobbiBiscuits · 05/10/2026 17:35

Jo Brand would be excellent agreed
Andy M -agree
Clive - agree
Graham Norton agree
Thingy's wife on Connect

who else..

Debbie McGee
Any of the Spice Girls
Giles Brandesburton
Any of the current Bake Off presenters
Mel or Sue (old bake off presenters)
Rowan Atkinson

I don't know any 'content creators' or 'You tube' stars, so we'd need some of those too, for the young people

I think Rowan Atkinson is insanely shy, so I can't imagine him going on it.
Mel G would be good. I can imagine Sue being prickly, for some reason.
Alison Hammond might be a bit much.

MyFreeOpinion · 05/10/2026 17:42

I need to get this off my chest.

I'm really not liking the start of this season.

I've just rewatched the traitor selection, and REG was terrible right off the bat. Grinning a bit too much after Claudia announced that the traitors would recruit another traitor. Rob asked him whether he's happy, and he replied, "how are you feeling?" SURELY someone who wanted to be a traitor THAT MUCH would have already prepared an answer - answering a question with a question sounds defensive. And of course, I don't know what he was thinking when he told Joe he was a traitor – TWICE.

Here is the transcript. The conversation starts with REG speculating that Joe could be a traitor.
REG (to Joe): Or you could be a traitor yeah [Joe says yeah I could] who's just got a shield.
JOE: I could be, but I'm not. I'm a faithful. What are you?
REG (shrugs shoulders): Traitor.
EDITED TO SUGGEST THOSE IN THE ROOM HAVE TAKEN A MOMENT TO LET THIS SINK IN. BUT I THINK THIS IS MANUFACTURED.
JOE: You're what?
REG (lifting glass of wine as though toasting someone): Traitor.
UNKNOWN VOICE: He's a traitor.
JOE: Are you?
REG (shrugging again while drinking): Yeah.
JOE: Right.
MORE EDITING TO SUGGEST SILENCE. AGAIN, I SUSPECT FRANKENBITING.
REG: What's the point in being in the game if you're not?
JAMES BLUNT LAUGHS. REG LAUGHS A LITTLE.
JOE: Right. Ok.
JAMES: It's an interesting angle.
ROB LAUGHS LOUDLY. THERE ARE A FEW OTHER TUTTERS.
JAMES TO REG: You need to be very clear that you're not.
JOE: I'm going to pretend that I didn't hear that. What are you Richard? Faithful.
REG (whispering): Faithful.
THERE IS A BIT OF LAUGHTER AND CHITCHAT.
JOE: I think you've just done something that's never happened in the game.
REG LAUGHS VERY LOUDLY.
ROB Bold strategy.
JOE: It is a bold strategy.

The highlighted text is key. Joe knows EXACTLY what has happened. The scene does not look anything like a failed joke on REG's part. It looks like someone who was too excited with the status of being a traitor to bother to pre-memorise some lines.

REG then hasn't helped himself by over-explaining at the round table. He should have just said, "everyone always says they're a faithful, so I was trying to make everyone laugh", and kept it at that. It's not a great answer, but the response he gave was too long and the whole Spartacus thing was weird.

I imagine that there has been some editing to make it look like the group is thinking seriously about other names. However, even if over half of them voted for someone other than REG, the suspicions are too unfocussed for any one individual to get more votes than REG. It's FPPT, after all.

In the meantime, however, this whole shit show has put the storyline on a terrible trajectory. Everything Hannah said was right – the decisions of the traitors suggest they are on the back foot and trying to deflect attention – which is absolutely accurate. Maya and REG didn't choose James Acaster because he'd make a good traitor, but because of James's firm view that REG is a traitor. I suspect Maya simply didn't have time to realise the best way forward was to feed REG to the wolves. We now have James doing verbal gymnastics in which he tries to both hide the fact he is a traitor AND not lie.

And the grave digging challenge ... surely the producers should have foreseen that it was likely that the celebrities would save one another rather than donate piddling amounts to a charity? Having only two faithfuls to choose from makes for shit TV.

The best thing from now may be for REG to go, and the show essentially reboots with a new (third) traitor who is actually decent ... hopefully with Hannah still in the cast.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 05/10/2026 17:55

AlwaysExtraHot · 05/10/2026 17:35

IIRC one of the non famous Traitors basically outed the others when he was correctly banished. It was the lovely Welsh fella, I'm going to say Anthony but I could be wrong.
I don't remember that, but in the first season didn't one Traitor (forgot his name) out Wilf?

Yes, thats right. I was annoyed about that at the time as I really liked Wilf.
Just had to look up the S2 series and when Ross was banished he hinted very heavily that the nice Welsh man (whose name was Andrew, not Anthony) was also a traitor.

I think that's why the producers stopped them announcing it nearer the end to stop any traitors outing the others in spite.

HildaGribblethwaiteLives · 05/10/2026 18:11

Right, I know it's not my thread and I am definitely not the self-appointed MN police but is there any chance that the posters who want to discuss who should be in the next series of Celebrity Traitors could start their own thread.

We are only two episodes in to the current series.

As you were.

latetothefisting · 05/10/2026 18:41

LindorDoubleChoc · 05/10/2026 10:01

I don't think this series has got off to a good start, sadly. I'm annoyed Amol was the first one out.

That task was an absolute car crash and WTF, WTAF was Ross Kemp thinking? Is he actually as thick as two short planks? It resulted in hardly any money in the prize pot and only 2 people up for murder, so no real interest or suspense there. If I were playing I'd vote for him just to get him out ... what a pillock. I bet the production team were absolutely groaning.

Also if I were in there, I would definitely have thought REG was double bluffing with his original comment and wouldn't suspect him for one second Grin.

Hannah only let loose at the round table because she knows she's very likely to be be murdered. She's definitely intelligent enough to be more circumspect if she thought she had a long run ahead of her.

I really don't like Julie, she's the only person in there I've taken an unexpected strong dislike to (apart from RK obvs).

huh? I really don't get your rationale, unless it's that you can't think outside of being an audience member rather than putting yourself in the perspective of the players.

The celebs don't really care about the money, it's peanuts to them and they go in knowing they only have a 5% chance of getting it anyway, and an even smaller chance of being the ONLY winner and thus getting the full amount.

They DID care about being buried underground. Notice none of them said 'leave me, get the money,' or even 'leave us to last,' they were all shouting to be dug out asap! leigh-anne and one of the others even said something about being annoyed at him for leaving them until later.

It's not RKs job to build suspense! That's the production team's role.

His primary aim is a) to stay in as long as possible, and b) convince people he's not a traitor so it makes perfect sense to endear himself to as many people as he can by digging them all out. His other aim (as with all of them) will be to maintain/improve their public reputation so they get more bookings in the future. RK's reputation is as a bit of a hard man so going gung ho with the digging and being a team player is exactly what he wants to be doing.

It would have been completely illogical of him to have gone for the money first and risked annoying everyone, and even more so to have only dug some people out and then have to explain why at the RT and inviting suspicion.

WonderfulSmith · 05/10/2026 19:04

celebagent · 05/10/2026 11:59

Two things a) It's a game. Game's are often unfair. You're obviously new to Traitors (fair enough) - many other unfair things have happened over the years, take the seer in season 3 messing up a very good contestant.

And on knowing who the traitors are - season 4 of civilian traitors did this so we did know the identity of one traitor. A producer said they did it precisely because people always made this point. It didn't actually work very well. As others have said the entire fun is in knowing the traitors watching them scheme (usually well but sometimes disastrously) and laughing at other players' usually ludicrously bad attempts to figure them out.

I’d forgotten all about the secret traitor. That was daft.

CatVester · 05/10/2026 19:22

I really liked the secret traitor! It was fun to guess. We had a spreadsheet going and everything.

BobbiBiscuits · 05/10/2026 19:48

AlwaysExtraHot · 05/10/2026 17:37

I think Rowan Atkinson is insanely shy, so I can't imagine him going on it.
Mel G would be good. I can imagine Sue being prickly, for some reason.
Alison Hammond might be a bit much.

Ah yes A Hammond might be a bit much😂. She could even be a bit REG .

Sue? Prickly? Never! 😆

CaveMum · 05/10/2026 20:13

Let’s have a “Celebrity Traitors 3: The Wishlist” thread once this series is over. My own main hope (who was rumoured for S1 but apparently couldn’t take it work) is Bob Mortimer.

OP posts:
LindorDoubleChoc · 05/10/2026 21:15

latetothefisting · 05/10/2026 18:41

huh? I really don't get your rationale, unless it's that you can't think outside of being an audience member rather than putting yourself in the perspective of the players.

The celebs don't really care about the money, it's peanuts to them and they go in knowing they only have a 5% chance of getting it anyway, and an even smaller chance of being the ONLY winner and thus getting the full amount.

They DID care about being buried underground. Notice none of them said 'leave me, get the money,' or even 'leave us to last,' they were all shouting to be dug out asap! leigh-anne and one of the others even said something about being annoyed at him for leaving them until later.

It's not RKs job to build suspense! That's the production team's role.

His primary aim is a) to stay in as long as possible, and b) convince people he's not a traitor so it makes perfect sense to endear himself to as many people as he can by digging them all out. His other aim (as with all of them) will be to maintain/improve their public reputation so they get more bookings in the future. RK's reputation is as a bit of a hard man so going gung ho with the digging and being a team player is exactly what he wants to be doing.

It would have been completely illogical of him to have gone for the money first and risked annoying everyone, and even more so to have only dug some people out and then have to explain why at the RT and inviting suspicion.

Edited

@latetothefisting

Huh? The celebs don't win any money. They are there to win for charity.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread