Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Monster - The Lizzie Borden Story

74 replies

SmallDFartyCarNRG · 20/09/2026 21:09

I just completely binged this - loved it!
It's rare to find anything with a mix of horror, history and female focus. I really enjoyed the perspectives and felt like I grew a little with the characters each episode. Gory at times but really enjoyed it.

OP posts:
Thecatbeggar · 26/09/2026 05:20

I liked it, it’s ridiculous and so tenuously linked to the actual Lizzie Borden story but I enjoyed it except the Aileen bits, I actually fast forwarded through most of those as found them distracting. Its a shame Sarah Paulson wasn’t cast as Abi Borden because she would’ve had a ball with that role (although Rebecca Hall was really good).

I know he’s not to everyone’s taste but I think if you tune into a Eyan
Murphy show you sort of know what you’re getting.

malloryknox123 · 26/09/2026 06:10

I enjoyed it, quite gory and blood soaked but the acting was brilliant.

I couldn’t help but notice how Bridget resembled Owen Wilson with her orange mullet hair 😂

Outtaxed · 26/09/2026 06:20

I watched this and hated it! Too many episodes. The Aileen sub plot was awful. Got to the end by fast forwarding the last episodes.

Rinoachicken · 27/09/2026 18:04

It was an absolute load of rubbish.

There is no evidence at all of a romantic relationship (or any meaningful relationship!) between lizzie and the housemaid.

Her father killed the birds, not her stepmother. There is no evidence that the stepmother was cruel or abusive in any way and in fact was the only person in the house to call Bridgette (the maid) by her actual name, whereas Lizzie called her Maggie as she saw no reason to learn her name.

The maid never returned to the house in reality and disappeared from history.

There is no evidence that Lizzie was involved with the suffragette movement in any way.

There is no evidence to suggest Eileen Wuornos even knew of Lizzie Borden, never mind idolised her or visited her house.

And for all those saying ‘it was to show how women were treated and what they were pushed to’…what a load of crap. The makers are quick enough to cast the stepmother as a villain who apparently deserves her death - with zero evidence - where’s her sympathetic portrayal? - a woman of who testimony of the time said she was in a transactional marriage with no authority in the house, was well liked by her neighbours and even Bridgette the maid said was very kind.

Lizzie was also well known in her community, holding leadership positions in her church and having an active social life. She was 32 when her parents were murdered. Not some meek little sheltered girl as portrayed. Lizzie and her sister were well known to have resented their father due to his frugality with his great wealth whilst they craved the power and recognition that their family wealth should have afforded them in their community. There were a number of instances of the sisters demanding their ‘fair share’ from their father, with him gifting them property to placate them.

Like a PP said, the story is fascinating enough, and I can understand things being stretched or emphasised for dramatic effect.

At the beginning it says ‘based on true events’. But so much of this was all such a complete load of fantastical made up rubbish with NO basis on even rumour let alone facts.

Ryan Murphy consistently sensationalises, romanticises and glorifies murderers, ignoring the facts to suit whatever twisted narrative he’s selling. Which may be forgivable for instances where everyone involved is long dead, but Dahmers victims families literally BEGGED him not to make that series and he ignored them all, even showing the real Polaroids of the murders.

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 27/09/2026 18:08

Rinoachicken · 27/09/2026 18:04

It was an absolute load of rubbish.

There is no evidence at all of a romantic relationship (or any meaningful relationship!) between lizzie and the housemaid.

Her father killed the birds, not her stepmother. There is no evidence that the stepmother was cruel or abusive in any way and in fact was the only person in the house to call Bridgette (the maid) by her actual name, whereas Lizzie called her Maggie as she saw no reason to learn her name.

The maid never returned to the house in reality and disappeared from history.

There is no evidence that Lizzie was involved with the suffragette movement in any way.

There is no evidence to suggest Eileen Wuornos even knew of Lizzie Borden, never mind idolised her or visited her house.

And for all those saying ‘it was to show how women were treated and what they were pushed to’…what a load of crap. The makers are quick enough to cast the stepmother as a villain who apparently deserves her death - with zero evidence - where’s her sympathetic portrayal? - a woman of who testimony of the time said she was in a transactional marriage with no authority in the house, was well liked by her neighbours and even Bridgette the maid said was very kind.

Lizzie was also well known in her community, holding leadership positions in her church and having an active social life. She was 32 when her parents were murdered. Not some meek little sheltered girl as portrayed. Lizzie and her sister were well known to have resented their father due to his frugality with his great wealth whilst they craved the power and recognition that their family wealth should have afforded them in their community. There were a number of instances of the sisters demanding their ‘fair share’ from their father, with him gifting them property to placate them.

Like a PP said, the story is fascinating enough, and I can understand things being stretched or emphasised for dramatic effect.

At the beginning it says ‘based on true events’. But so much of this was all such a complete load of fantastical made up rubbish with NO basis on even rumour let alone facts.

Ryan Murphy consistently sensationalises, romanticises and glorifies murderers, ignoring the facts to suit whatever twisted narrative he’s selling. Which may be forgivable for instances where everyone involved is long dead, but Dahmers victims families literally BEGGED him not to make that series and he ignored them all, even showing the real Polaroids of the murders.

Chill out! It was a dramatisation, and done in a very quirky entertaining way. Doesn’t have to be accurate. Who ever said it was?

RhannionKPSS · 27/09/2026 18:11

Imo Lizzie did kill her stepmother because she hated Abby because of the property which had been transferred to her by Andrew.

The father came home early due to being unwell and so Lizzie ended up killing him too.

user1471462634 · 27/09/2026 18:45

I thought it was great, although, 6 episodes would have done it. Loved that the Aileen Wournos story was shoehorned in, I thought it worked. Didn't realise it was Sarah Paulson, great performance.

springintospring26 · 27/09/2026 19:02

I thought it was brilliant and actually very emotional during the end scene

fuschiaproudparrot · 27/09/2026 21:10

springintospring26 · 27/09/2026 19:02

I thought it was brilliant and actually very emotional during the end scene

I agree. The execution of Aileen.

Disturbia81 · 27/09/2026 21:11

Absolutely loved it. I love anything he does. Sarah played Aileen so well

Geeseofbeverlyroad · 28/09/2026 22:05

I enjoyed it but totally had to suspend belief as there was so little fact in it.

Jessica Barden as Nance O'Neil was a stand out for me. Also Rebecca Hall looked like she was enjoying her role!

RhannionKPSS · 29/09/2026 10:12

Sarah Paulson was excellent.

Geeseofbeverlyroad · 29/09/2026 10:30

RhannionKPSS · 29/09/2026 10:12

Sarah Paulson was excellent.

Absolutely - she really seemed like Aileen on the Netflix documentary.

giraffesandpigeonstoo · 04/10/2026 05:57

murasaki · 21/09/2026 21:51

Dp is a bit confused as to why they keep inserting Aileen Wuornos into it.

Really?

I thought it was quite obvious.

Aileen was intrigued / inspired / obsessed by Lizzie in the same way that Lizzie was intrigued by the Countess Bathory.*

The thread running through it is loosely the damage that women can do when they are pushed to the brink, often by men.

I do feel it was a theme inserted because the Lizzie story alone wasn’t enough to fill the 8 episodes, but I liked it and thought it worked well. I found the Aileen scenes very emotional, particularly the execution.

Of course, many people will say (and there are a few on this thread who I think would) that there should have been enough of Lizzie’s story to fill 8 episodes, and of course, I’m sure they would have been. But not the way they did it. They set the scene, they showed what her life was like, they had the story with Maggie, they showed the lead up to the murders, the murdere, the aftermath, the trial and her subsequent life. I think it worked quite well having some time given to the countess and Aileen.

*In the show, not in real life.

fuschiaproudparrot · 04/10/2026 06:03

It's also about the " class" of the person - a young lady couldn't be seen as a murderer because of her class. Aileen - well she was considered classless. Time also adds to it - women were seen as pathetic and helpless creatures in Lizzie's day.

AnnWalkersLeftSlipper · 07/10/2026 14:36

Just too unrealistic in my opinion. I agree It's fine to have fun with poetic license, none of us know what happened, we don't know that there wasn't a lesbian affair and it would've been plausible.

But some of it may as well have just been a drama not based on any story at all for how it was just totally made up.

Having said all that, I've not finished it. I will persevere and see if I change my mind!

The worst/funniest part for me was when the maid was 'passing' the foetus as she put it. In reality it would've been much more gory, smelly, and lots of poo and wind.

fuschiaproudparrot · 07/10/2026 21:59

I'm actually thinking about watching it again 😂

locket2009 · 11/10/2026 21:47

It’s absolute drivel first two monsters were food Ed Gein one was okay. This is rubbish if her story was worth telling the tell the story don’t make it into a load of fantasy rubbish

TaraRhu · 11/10/2026 21:55

I had to switch it off I'm afraid. I thought it was so far removed from the real story. The lesbian maid was completely unbelievable. Plus poor Lizzie bordens step mum. There is no evidence to suggest the woman was horrible to Lizzie. think the whole thing was written by a 15 year old boy fantasising about what women do. There is a really interesting story behind this and no need to make it into such a blood bath. The dahmer one was good and I'm disappointed in this.

locket2009 · 11/10/2026 22:25

TaraRhu · 11/10/2026 21:55

I had to switch it off I'm afraid. I thought it was so far removed from the real story. The lesbian maid was completely unbelievable. Plus poor Lizzie bordens step mum. There is no evidence to suggest the woman was horrible to Lizzie. think the whole thing was written by a 15 year old boy fantasising about what women do. There is a really interesting story behind this and no need to make it into such a blood bath. The dahmer one was good and I'm disappointed in this.

Agree. I thought the Ed gein was sensationalism but this just veers too far from the truth. As I said if you’re making money telling the stories of so called monsters then surely their story should be enough without whimsical nonsense

Scorchio84 · 14/10/2026 00:19

Lottapianos · 21/09/2026 15:43

I'm on episode 5. It's absolutely bonkers, very entertaining, great performances, lots of gorgeous locations and costumes. Pretty slow paced and long winded though - I think 6 episodes would have been plenty

I loved the Lizzie Borden story when I was a teenager

Absolutely agree with this, 6 would have been perfect, I liked the contrast between Lizzie, naice, wealthy good girl Vs Aileen, common, poor, bad girl in terms of court appearances & sentencing

Sarah Poulson in the stand as AW deserves an Emmy

I enjoyed it but not as much as Ed Gein, I realize that sounds ghoulish

Scorchio84 · 14/10/2026 00:25

Sparrowsandbudgies · 25/09/2026 08:31

I’m not a fan of Sarah Paulsons Alieen. After seeing Charlize Ts version nothing comes close.

I love Charlize Theron as AW but I think Sarah Poulson comes a very close second in fairness

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 14/10/2026 07:18

locket2009 · 11/10/2026 22:25

Agree. I thought the Ed gein was sensationalism but this just veers too far from the truth. As I said if you’re making money telling the stories of so called monsters then surely their story should be enough without whimsical nonsense

Loved the ‘whimsical nonsense’ !

VenusClapTrap · 16/10/2026 21:24

Mad and over-long but I enjoyed it. The plastic cherry trees that fruited at the same time as blossoming made my teeth itch though. The Aileen scenes confused me at first, but as time went on I got it, and by the end I found her bits really moving. Poulson was incredibly good.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread