Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Great British Sewing Bee 2026 final

108 replies

queenceleste · 14/09/2026 07:35

Is there a new thread somewhere?

I’m excited to see this.

OP posts:
ChapmanFarm · 16/09/2026 11:00

While the transformation winners don't often suit my tastes, I think they have been consistent in the way they have judged them.

Contestants are scored for the transformation and if you make it look very different to the original, you tend to do better than with a well made piece closer to the original (see Rebecca's school dress for best example of this).

I liked Beth's better but she used floaty beach style fabrics which lend themselves to the task but don't necessarily carry the extra points for 'different'. Anna took a heavy duty chair cover and while I wouldn't wear it, she did bring together the horribly clashing components into something cohesive with an interesting shape - and that's what has won on every challenge.

Hedgehogsintheorchard · 16/09/2026 16:09

I think the judges, especially Patrick, had decided from the start that Annawas going to win & it didn’t really matter what she did in the final. All her three garments were weak. The bow tie was too thin, the transformation was just horrible & the mtm was too child’s dress up with the wings very sloppily sewn at their base. Beth should have won.

LongTallTally · 16/09/2026 17:18

Mischance · 16/09/2026 10:05

I agree Beth should have won.

I think Patrick fancied Anna!

This is so unnecessary. There is not a hint of inappropriate tone in Patrick's attitude to the women on sewing bee. It's an accusation often levelled at young women on reality programmes and it's really offensive because it belittles their achievements in a deeply mysogynstic way.

I wanted Beth to win, and if she hadn't messed up the pattern challenge she would have done. No conspiracy theories needed.

Unexpectedlhereagain · 16/09/2026 17:46

Gosh this thread has turned unpleasant.

MaterMoribund · 16/09/2026 17:48

I was really pleased to see Sam (plumber/heating engineer) had started his own clothing business. His makes perhaps didn’t have the Wow! factor that others had but time constraints aside, he was a decent maker.

Agree the win was more valuable to Anna than to Beth.

ChoppyWalters · 16/09/2026 17:52

I enjoyed this series but I think Beth edged Anna out at the end in terms of her makes. She was under the radar for me but she came good last few weeks. But I knew that Anna would win. She was clearly a favourite with the judges for her boldness in design. I think some of Anna’s stuff was amazing, others were what the hell. The last make looked like something a mum would make for the school play. Plus she owed a lot of her inspiration to Westwood, very samey designs. Good series though. Not sure what Emma was doing in the final, the other two were in a different league.

AnnaMagnani · 16/09/2026 19:03

Realised from the story at the end that I've actually seen Emma on stage in opera - she was fabulous.

Beth's dress was amazing, would have liked to see the contortions Patrick and Esme would have gone through to award Anna the win if Beth hadn't messed up the pattern challenge.

Mooselove · 16/09/2026 19:47

AnnaMagnani · 16/09/2026 19:03

Realised from the story at the end that I've actually seen Emma on stage in opera - she was fabulous.

Beth's dress was amazing, would have liked to see the contortions Patrick and Esme would have gone through to award Anna the win if Beth hadn't messed up the pattern challenge.

Well I could not believe the contortions they did to award Anna first place with the transformation. They obviously knew it was hers and purposely gave it first place when it was absolutely awful.

If someone else had made that and thrown pompoms and an enormous flower on it I can just imagine their comments, particularly Esme's

TheFashionDemon · 16/09/2026 21:38

Since the third episode was clear that the judges (especially Patrick Grant) wanted Anna to win (god knows why...). She got many things wrong but it was always labelled like "oh yes, you can get away with it", while others were harshly judged. The last MTM was frankly embarasing. Probably Anna is Patrick's secret daughter or the relative of some big boss in the BBC. Otherwise I can't explain her winning. Beth is the real thing, she really produced a stunning dress and not a Disney's carnival costume like Anna did. Shame. This is a huge let down and takes away from the judges credibility.

Zebracat · 16/09/2026 21:58

I loved Anna and Beth, I really think a joint win would have been the fairest outcome. The transformation decision seemed bizarre. The hideous flower in the middle of Emma’s dress absolutely killed it stone dead. Beth’s was gorgeous. I loved Emma, but that mtm was dreadful, she was out of her depth. Congratulations to all 3, the competition was to a very high standard this year.

Mischance · 16/09/2026 22:08

LongTallTally · 16/09/2026 17:18

This is so unnecessary. There is not a hint of inappropriate tone in Patrick's attitude to the women on sewing bee. It's an accusation often levelled at young women on reality programmes and it's really offensive because it belittles their achievements in a deeply mysogynstic way.

I wanted Beth to win, and if she hadn't messed up the pattern challenge she would have done. No conspiracy theories needed.

Edited

I'm not belittling Anna and her talents. I was just aware of a sparkle in his eye when talking with her and a surfeit of emotion when he talked about her clothing.

I am not suggesting that his judging was biased. Esme was there too.

Binglebong · 16/09/2026 22:35

I loved the idea of the wings but hated their execution. The frames they were on needed to be bigger so the fabric was taut. And the way the orange one was fastened so it had a hollow in the middle was bad. I would love to see her remake it without time constraints as I think it had loads of potential.

Beth's dress was wow.

Fiftyandnotsonifty · 16/09/2026 22:38

It was clear from day one that Anna was going to win she has a rare talent and I hope she fulfils her dream in costume design.

Mischance · 16/09/2026 23:10

Anna does have talent, but if the final is based on that one day rather than over the whole competition I think Beth had the edge.

Passementerie · 16/09/2026 23:20

Mischance · 16/09/2026 23:10

Anna does have talent, but if the final is based on that one day rather than over the whole competition I think Beth had the edge.

But Beth messed up the pattern challenge totally, and came second in the transformation — it really came down to whether her spectacular gala dress could make up for that. I’ve actually preferred Anna’s work throughout, but I did think Beth was going to win for the last couple of weeks, and thought so right up until the result was announced, given how wowed the judges were with her made to measure. (Fabrics aside, I wasn’t crazy about Anna’s crane fly dress. I thought it needed volume and looked rather skimpy.) I’m actually pleased Anna won, but quite surprised.

Agree that Emma got the Met gala brief all wrong!

ALoveOnceNewHasNowGrownOld · 16/09/2026 23:48

@Hedgehogsintheorchard wrote: the mtm was too child’s dress up with the wings very sloppily sewn at their base.

I agree. The wings weren’t an original idea, and were badly done. The structured, supported shoulder/collar on Anna’s dress was clever, though.

Beth’s bow tie wasn’t a disaster, she just missed out a hook (or eye) which would have taken two minutes to sew on if she’d realised in time.

I understand Emma made the yellow bow tie her friend and operatic colleague wore at The last Night of The Proms on Saturday. I suppose they couldn’t say that on Saturday as we hadn’t seen her making one then.

Great British Sewing Bee 2026 final
Halsall · 17/09/2026 09:14

Probably Anna is Patrick's secret daughter or the relative of some big boss in the BBC

I said a while ago on this thread that I knew Anna wasn’t popular on here and was told I was wrong. Since then many of the reactions to her win have proved me right, with comments like the above being frankly ridiculous and unnecessary.

LongTallTally · 17/09/2026 09:37

Mischance · 16/09/2026 22:08

I'm not belittling Anna and her talents. I was just aware of a sparkle in his eye when talking with her and a surfeit of emotion when he talked about her clothing.

I am not suggesting that his judging was biased. Esme was there too.

Thanks @Mischance , I've seen so much of this over the years I probably overreact to it. Your explanation makes sense. There is often a kind of chemistry beween judges, hosts and contestants - I think maybe Nelly and Noel on Bake Off might be an example - which goes beyond "he fancies her".

I am always a bit impatient with crying judges (see also Game Of Wool) because I feel there is only room for one crying judge on Tv and that clearly is Keith Brymer Jones. On the other hand, can you imagine being the contestant that makes Paul Hollywood cry? How many handshakes would that equal?

CleanSkin · 17/09/2026 09:38

Fiftyandnotsonifty · 16/09/2026 22:38

It was clear from day one that Anna was going to win she has a rare talent and I hope she fulfils her dream in costume design.

Fully agree with you.

EnterQueene · 17/09/2026 20:52

I’ve just watched the final. I understand why Anna won but I thought Beth’s dress was so spectacular she should have won.

SleepingisanArt · 17/09/2026 21:28

I think what has really bugged me was all the 'we've never had such talented sewers' - have they forgotten the fabulous Asmaa already (2023 so not decades ago)? Every week she pushed herself and the transformation dress of her final M2M has not been surpassed since in my opinion. Patrick said it was a feat of genius, they also said it was 'out of this world' and 'spellbinding'. I didn't hear any of those comments about Anna's M2M.

I think as viewers some of us felt it was a foregone conclusion who would win this series. There was some very dodgy judging decisions which made me think I was looking at different garments and their decisions were not consistent.

The last series of Pottery Throwdown got a bit of a kicking after the winner was announced as the winning piece had some serious flaws. The judges 'took the whole body of work' into consideration. Not something they'd ever done before and had sent someone home after the semifinal for the exact same issue. You can't treat your viewers with such disdain. I know both are 'just TV programmes' but for weeks we tune in and that loyalty should not be taken for granted.....

itsalltoplayfor · 17/09/2026 21:41

Much as I can see Anna has immense talent I did find all her work had a similar feel to it, generally theatrical steam punk vibes. Beth seemed to have a greater range. So, good for Anna if this now opens up a career in theatrical costume/film work. She deserves to win but it did seem like a foregone conclusion and the judges appeared biased towards her a bit. Maybe if Beth hadn't messed up the bow tie Patrick and Esme couldn't have been so definite.

queenceleste · 17/09/2026 22:09

Asma’s transormation was FANTASTIC- I still think about it…

OP posts:
Agapornis · 18/09/2026 02:26

Seem to recall that previous winners were also judged on growth throughout the season? I think Beth did lots of things new to her very well; Anna stayed well within her comfort zone. Yes Anna can do many versions of a corset, but Beth has range and is technically better.

I think the damselfly dress would have been better in full length with a long thin train - like an actual damselfly abdomen.

(Fwiw Anna said damselflies mate in the air - not really, they attach in the air but then land for the actual mating.)

WeirdyBeardyMarrowBabyLady · 21/09/2026 09:28

queenceleste · 17/09/2026 22:09

Asma’s transormation was FANTASTIC- I still think about it…

She re-shared the ‘reveal’ on an instagram story not that long ago. I replied to say it was prob the greatest stand out Sewing Bee moment for me and she replied to say thank you. I was so happy!!