Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

SCD '20 #7: Live from the Tower Ballroom.. umm, Elstree Studios, it's Blackpool Spectacular week!

997 replies

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 21/11/2020 15:15

Previous thread.

OP posts:
ElspethFlashman · 22/11/2020 09:38

I absolutely looooove Clara, but even I could see last night that her footwork went pear shaped and I'm fairly clueless about DAHHHHHNCE.

I thought Ranvir was emotional at the end, not because of Gio but because she knew it wasn't that great on the night. Some of the circles she was tracing were not that circular and some of her flicks were a bit soggy. And she knew it.

But hey, she was saved by the judges massive horn for AT (and Gio) , so who cares??!

SparklingDinosaurs · 22/11/2020 09:43

It was all just a bit odd last night for me.

Maisie / there was clearly an effort to show in vt and dance that’s she’s young and fun. Try to change voters minds on her since she obviously didn’t get many votes last week. I think she’ll be safe this week as her dance was good (well the lifts looked Impressive) and a lot of people will have been shocked she was in dance off last week as would have assumed she was safe from judges points alone so they’ll give her votes now.

Clara - it’s horrible how she’s been treated throughout especially since she’s such a superfan. Maybe they use that to their advantage and through any old crap at her knowing she’ll accept as she loves Strictly so much. Her make up was horrendous and very distracting. Her theme and outfit was hideous. I can’t believe someone thought they were into a winner with chef whites?!

Bill and Oti it was good and nice to watch but a bit forgettable. I much prefer his more energetic dances. We’re enough weeks in where it’s established that he’s a serious contender and not the joke of the series so I think we’re expecting more of him now (not just being impressed because an older overweight man has some decent moves).

JJ arrg I cant say it...it’s wrong to think..okay I’ll admit I just can’t take to him. I don’t enjoy watching him I don’t feel anything for him. Obviously I’m not completely heartless and I do feel uttermost respect and sympathy for what he suffered in marines (was it the marines?). It’s awful it goes without saying and he’s clearly a strong person. I mean I don’t feel anything when he dances. I don’t know what was very hard for him giving his injuries so find it hard to judge whether he’s any good. I also don’t know what he does now and would actually like to know (something charity wise?) Amy just winds me up. I know she’s sweet and lovely but it’s so fake to me. Watch her at the end when they all facing camera - she’s always got a smile fixed on her face. It’s obviously from years of dance comps and is her being professional but I can’t stand it on a reality tv show like this. She showed quite a scarily competitive side with Karim last year too. Her ott reaction to JJ being safe last week was arrrgg and I felt sorry for JJ as he clearly didn’t know what to be doing!! She is far far far too touchy feely with her celebrity too.

NVwls he’s quite nice much more so than I imagined when I heard he was HRVY. I thought he did a decent job.

Ranvir I like her but I’m feeling increasingly awkward watching her. Last week especially. I don’t want to know when they feel uncomfortable and self conscious as it makes me uncomfortable viewing. She’s nice though. I hope she gets a more regular dance next week away from the intense sexy stuff. Gio is quite clever though as think they playing on the strictly gossip of are they / aren’t they at it.

Jamie I just love him. He’s so fun and has no agenda (or that’s way it appears anyway I’ve never seen his own program). He’s just having so much fun and it’s easy to watch and feel happy. I thought the covered his cc week perfectly as he has no sob story or none we’d want to hear about. Focusing on friendship was smart for his cc. Street dancing was amazing and fun. I’m sure actual street dancers would have plenty to say about it but for Strictly it was fun.

Caroline I’m in shock that theme was approved. It’s so dated and blurgh. I have never liked the way she was sleezing on J right from launch show even the opening titles have her fake acting that she’s swooning over him. Oh I know it’s all just for fun etc but if that was say Bill doing that over Oti would it be accepted? Think about that routine with Bill and Oti in Caroline and J positions and I think there would be complaints. But then strictly always seems to allow the young males to be sleezed over (Shirley I’m looking at you!!!) Caroline herself is just irritating. So aware of herself and thinks she’s better than she is. I though she was expecting 9/10 after the comments she got and was disappointed by the 8s and had to quickly put a face on it.

Speaking of scoring though I’m not actually surprised Caroline might have expected 9/10 given the comments she got. The scoring has been that crazy. So many 9s and 10s was hardly any actually deserved. Shirley started off too early dishing them out and they have overscored themselves into an over marking corner. Craig is the only one who gives trustworthy scores now.

Anton was good but he needs to be more concise for me. I liked that he mentioned technical things and his manner is calmer and his very positive too. I’d be happy if he replaces Motsi or even Bruno. To be honest Shirley is becoming an embarrassment these days with her gin induced madness (I’m assuming it’s gin otherwise eeek). Her scoring is excessive and she seems to either love or hate the celebrities (usually young males are very well liked and young females not so much!)

ElspethFlashman · 22/11/2020 09:44

I am starting to really go off JJ.

Or maybe not so much go off HIM as the pass he's getting week after week.

Someone on here said he was a nice man and I'm sure he is. But on Strictly he has shown zero discernable personality other than a) being grateful to the military and b) being grateful to Amy. There's nothing else to say about him.

So to see him getting absolute rhapsodies from the judges for scooting stiffly around the floor with his hand behind his back is tedious.

Amy last night was trying desperately to look animated enough for both of them, it just served to highlight how he was just mouthing the words but serving no actual character whatsoever.

the80sweregreat · 22/11/2020 09:51

Sorry I meant to say ' Amy not Laura. J J 's partner.

SoupDragon · 22/11/2020 09:56

Amy's dress was my favourite last night I think.

JJ is just walking through the steps - there is no joy. I don't feel any joy from Maisie either, just competence.

MoonJelly · 22/11/2020 09:57

Anton was good but he needs to be more concise for me. I liked that he mentioned technical things and his manner is calmer and his very positive too. I’d be happy if he replaces Motsi or even Bruno. To be honest Shirley is becoming an embarrassment these days with her gin induced madness (I’m assuming it’s gin otherwise eeek). Her scoring is excessive and she seems to either love or hate the celebrities (usually young males are very well liked and young females not so much!)

Agreed. But on that basis wouldn't it make more sense if Shirley were the one to go, with Craig taking over as head Judge?

the80sweregreat · 22/11/2020 10:00

None of them have wowed me this series really. It feels flat and over marked and people look stressed and a bit upset at times. JJ hasn't much personality and if he wasn't a ex marine he might have not done quite as well as he has been.
Maisie tries really hard but been a bit disappointing. Bill is better at the faster uptempo dances.
If Caroline makes the semi final or even the final (!) I will not be happy at all! That routine was so dated.
Craig is the only one being sensible with the marking and comments.

emilybrontescorsett · 22/11/2020 10:03

Dh votes for Bill every week. Will someone please get some scissors to the wire frizz on his head it's bloody awful. Yes, yes I know it's part of his comedy act blah blah blah not it's not fine. He could take somebody's eye out if he spins round too quickly. It also makes him look much older than he is.

I also loved BVB's routine, think him and Karen are a perfect pairing.
I'd like to see more AT, my favourite dance. Less samba it's not good to watch, and waltz.

MoonJelly · 22/11/2020 10:03

Jamie's dance was an excellent illustration of why they need to do something about tightening up on Couple's Choice. If there are no criteria, how is it possible to mark them sensibly? The reality is that if the couple vaguely manage to move in time to the music that seems to be as much as is expected of them. When you compare what is required for a street dance to what is required for something like Foxtrot or Argentine Tango, there is simply no comparison.

emilybrontescorsett · 22/11/2020 10:04

I mean more waltz.

ppeatfruit · 22/11/2020 10:07

Marking my place , this must be the fastest on MN.!!!Thanks Polka Grin I enjoyed it all, I did wonder why Clara was a chef. They drew the short straw this week like Maisie did last week!

the80sweregreat · 22/11/2020 10:09

Jamie's dance reminded me of Chris Ramsey's ' let's get ready to rumble ' one last year! Good fun but easy marks.
Let's see him do a AT or waltz or foxtrot!
What has he got if he gets through?

Summer15coming · 22/11/2020 10:11

It wasn't just Caroline's routine that was dreadful, it was the dancing within it. If you compare the dance technique of Maisie's cha cha to Caroline's, then compare the critiques that they got from the judges - it's just so ridiculous.

the80sweregreat · 22/11/2020 10:15

They seem to like Caroline so much. I'm not sure why and (I know nothing about dance ) but they clearly see lots I don't!

Samcro · 22/11/2020 10:21

we voted for Clara, Bill and JJ
Masie is good but samesy.
CQ I was too distracted by her face pulling

covetingthepreciousthings · 22/11/2020 10:28

I felt really sorry for Clara yesterday, why were they chefs?! Just whyyyyy?!
So bizarre.

I agree with PP about JJ, I can't warm to him at all which is a shame, I don't know if it's just nerves or his general character but I just don't sense that he's getting any enjoyment out of Strictly at all, so for that reason I'd rather he left this weekend than someone like BVB who just beams every time he dances (with his gob open Grin)

I have really enjoyed watching BVB, I'd be quite happy if he made the final tbh, I'd quite like him, Bill & Ranvir in the final, can't remember if it's 3 or 4 person final, so I'd like to throw Clara in there too.

ppeatfruit · 22/11/2020 10:28

Yes Samcro some of the 'acting' that CQ thought was necessary was too much ( licking his arm fgs) But she looked better, she danced better than in her last ones.

BessieSurtees · 22/11/2020 10:32

The scoring is ridiculous. Shirley looks amazing but she is an embarrassment with her comments.

Never thought I'd hear myself say that Craig is the only Judge worth listening too.

I felt Ranvir looked too uncomfortable to give off any passion. Gio can smoulder though, can't he just.

SoupDragon · 22/11/2020 10:35

I've always thought that Craig is the only judge worth listening to. Or rather that he is always worth listening to.

jambeforeclottedcream · 22/11/2020 10:39

It's hard enough to compare a ballroom against a Latin, without throwing a CC into the mix as well.

ABCDay · 22/11/2020 10:51

@the80sweregreat

They seem to like Caroline so much. I'm not sure why and (I know nothing about dance ) but they clearly see lots I don't!
Perhaps she licks their arses when Johannes is away drying his arm.
PimlicoJo · 22/11/2020 11:03

I have always thought Craig is the best judge. He can be quite critical, but it's usually constructive, and he gives praise where it's due. I'm really enjoying the series this year without Bruno. He drove me mad with all that jumping out of his chair.

ElspethFlashman · 22/11/2020 11:06

You know I never EVER thought I'd utter these words but Jamie Laing is an absolute delight.

Wow, 2020 really is Opposite Land, isn't it? Grin

DigOutThoseLemonHandWipes · 22/11/2020 11:08

Caroline's one this week was horrible and a variation of the ones she's worn every week.
Maybe the costume department has a reduced budget this year although I'm sure they work so hard getting it all ready.

I have found lots of the woman have had samey dresses this year. I wondered if it was to reduce contact with the costume department. I feel like they have had a basic shape fitted to them and this is being used to make each week's outfit.

Bluffinwithmymuffin · 22/11/2020 11:12

SoupDragon

My Fantasy Final Free is Bill, Clara and BVB.

Mine would be Nvwls, Clara and BVB. I’ve had enough of Bill...