I'm totally in the same boat as OP. I want to buy high quality, comfy leather shoes for everyday wear that have a bit of a style quirk or two about them. ie sort of like Campers but not quite as quirky.
I can't find anything in the shops but I highly recommend Clarks Originals, which you can get online. Also there is a brand called Staccato which you can get on a website called shoe-shop.com. If you look under 'casuals' they have great quirky well made flat shoes.
The shoes I love and hope to buy for spring are: www.amazon.co.uk/Clarks-Originals-Imperial-Girl-Leather/dp/B001T327D0/ref=sr_1_8?ie=UTF8&s=apparel&q id=1239032973&sr=1-8
If I'm honest I think the OPs shoes are too earth-mother for me, but maybe with the right clothes they could look great.