Are these sandals nice or horribly unfashionable

[Avocadoo]

I’m 38 and don’t know what’s cool and what’s not.
Are these cool?

https://www.toa.st/products/vibae-leather-fisherman-buckle-sandals-tan?variant=63328347062621&utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=18437612051&dema_id=18437612051&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=18431488314&gclid=CjwKCAjw2rrQBhBuEiwAarLWHWRecndS3uU_tULTAnudbwTzgOBHxmtjuE4OJDxrIyHv-PTgGDQ2XRoCOPcQAvD_BwE

or

https://mamaowl.net/collections/adult-shoes/products/angulus-womens-fisherman-sandal-tan

Those are actually lovely. I might buy to wear with wide leg trousers.
My ankles are too skinny to wear with dresses.

I’m 46 and wouldn’t wear them if you paid me. They just remind me of what a pervy old bloke aged 80 plus would wear in the 70s.

Strong no.

They remind me of my GCSE Latin teacher, but if you like them then wear them.

I love them, but they're not elegant

They look like what a three year old would wear to be honest. And one born in 1965.

They are ugly and very masculine looking.
But if you like them, buy them; it's your feet.

People saying they’re unfashionable have no clue.

Absolutely not

Somebody wore some open toed DM sandals yesterday at a conference with socks.

I think they are cute. I love that style.

my 4 year old grandson has similar

I also have Saltwaters and Birkies (I like Mayari) and if you wear those you can probably also carry off a fisherman sandal vibe

I have these https://www.celticandco.com/product/fishermans-sandal?cat=2139&colour=390&type=1

I walk miles in the summer and half the sandals I see on here just don’t look suitable for walking far.

The first ones are just about ok. The second pair - I think my grandad has an identical pair. He wears them with white socks and knee length shorts in the summer.

But they are fashionable whether you like them or not 🤷‍♀️

Ditto to people saying “don’t wear them with socks” 🤣

The first ones, I have the slip-ons and I wear them around the house and they look great with long, loose trousers. I wear them outside if not walking very far as they are quite wide and slip off-although the strap would stop that. They have a soft sole. Nice summer sandal. I also have the Grenson fisherman’s which I wear a lot too-a bit more refined than the really clumpy ones. I’m 64 if that helps. I got them direct from Vibae rather than Toast as they did an initial discount.

Fashionable doesn't always mean pretty, in fact it's often the opposite. If we wanted pretty we would all still be wearing tea dresses like the 1950s.

Ugly - I’m 62 and wouldn’t wear these 😵‍💫

Imo, they don’t look ugly at all. I have quite broad feet and delicate summer sandals look ridiculous on me. I also like wide, barrel and harem leg trousers and they suit that look very well. If your vibe is slouchy rather than say, Reiss or Jigsaw, they suit it very well.

Depends on your age and style. If you're young, skinny and dress like some sort of Boho intellectual they'll be really trendy. If you're over 50, carrying a bit of weight and look mumsy even when you try hard not to avoid them like the plague. Sadly, I'm in the second group.

I love fisherman's sandals! I think they go with everything. My taste does run fugly in shoes though, I like a "strong look"! But I think these are classic.

"More than half air" 😂😂. Love it

I think we knew the same people (in the 80s/90s) 🤣

Not true at all. It depends on your attitude and how you wear them and with what. I'm 67 and I wear sandals like this.

They remind me of something my 90-year old FIL would wear. With socks. Sorry!