i also like the Boots natural collection which a PP recommended
current fave is get bent from benefit
the angle of the wand gives brilliant coverage and really lengthens well. Not the best thickener (that is Max Factor 2000 calorie IMO)
no fibres so doesn't irritate my eyes
stays put all day and easy to remove
IIRC it is £16.99
doesn't dry out too quickly
used to love YSL volume effect but dried out and went cloggy v quickly IME