Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Why white children are not getting into grammar schools

402 replies

deanstreet · 13/02/2026 15:23

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/02/11/why-white-children-are-not-getting-into-grammar-schools/?WT.mc_id=tmgoff_fb_photo_not-getting-into-grammar-schools

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
suburburban · 23/10/2026 14:35

Simonjt · 23/10/2026 05:53

Yes they did, do you really think benefits in the UK were only introduced in 2000?

Not like they are now, I meant in 1900-1908 not say 1990, I know the Liberal Government introduced some under Lloyd George

nondrinker1985 · 25/10/2026 12:52

Breeze67 · 23/10/2026 13:38

Well, I feel like I have said too much, but I just wanted to add two things that people usually overlook.

First, research, especially Annette Lareau's Unequal Childhoods, shows that setting high standards and keeping kids on a structured path is an upper-middle-class thing, whereas the whole "happy childhood, just let them play" mindset is mostly a working-class dynamic, regardless of ethnicity.

Second, immigrant families are not a random mix. Most were already well-educated or had the drive to move abroad in the first place, so comparing them to the local average is not comparing like for like. Immigrants are basically equivalent to the local upper-middle class in terms of values, just with less money. That is why they push for grammar schools, while the local upper-middle class goes down the private school route.

Erm!! This is partly correct but my parents were barely literate and pushed me as it’s an Asian cultural value to the extent they knew education was the start of success for later in life so they wanted us to go to the best school possible. We didn’t have Grammars near us but we did go to a better comp than our local one.

OfferFlow · 25/10/2026 17:49

I think the support given to dc can be overwhelming pushing though. Many white parents just won’t do this. It’s definitely cultural but lots of Asian dc do what their parents want and end up doing the degrees they are told to do. It’s something many white parents don’t do. That’s not yo say they don’t care, they are just not so intense.

This is very true between our family and my DCs best friend, they are Indian background. They’ve had tutoring for years and have eyes set firmly on grammar and if not a scholarship at a private school which means a lot of extra curriculars, their oldest never stops.

Our family on the other hand, we of course value education highly but in a different way, having been to grammar for my own secondary education, I want my children to follow a more rounded education with opportunity for more vocational subjects, something I just didn’t get. I’ve done well in my career but fucked about at uni so nearly didn’t pass. I think some of that was a bit of rebellion!

I also want my children to have a childhood before secondary school and the pressure and additional work for the 11+ just doesn’t sit right with me having been through it. It’s a shame it has to be at this age and not when they’re a little older.

Breeze67 · 25/10/2026 21:52

OfferFlow · 25/10/2026 17:49

I think the support given to dc can be overwhelming pushing though. Many white parents just won’t do this. It’s definitely cultural but lots of Asian dc do what their parents want and end up doing the degrees they are told to do. It’s something many white parents don’t do. That’s not yo say they don’t care, they are just not so intense.

This is very true between our family and my DCs best friend, they are Indian background. They’ve had tutoring for years and have eyes set firmly on grammar and if not a scholarship at a private school which means a lot of extra curriculars, their oldest never stops.

Our family on the other hand, we of course value education highly but in a different way, having been to grammar for my own secondary education, I want my children to follow a more rounded education with opportunity for more vocational subjects, something I just didn’t get. I’ve done well in my career but fucked about at uni so nearly didn’t pass. I think some of that was a bit of rebellion!

I also want my children to have a childhood before secondary school and the pressure and additional work for the 11+ just doesn’t sit right with me having been through it. It’s a shame it has to be at this age and not when they’re a little older.

I want my children to follow a more rounded education with opportunity for more vocational subjects

It is good someone brings up the vocational side of things. Asian parents still lean heavily towards traditional academic routes, as there is a stronger tradition of tying academic qualifications to higher status and better pay back in home countries. So there is definitely a cultural effect at play.
But more importantly for immigrant families, fields like medicine, technology, law, , finance and others with high academic qualifications offer a much more level playing field, are more diverse, and have fewer cultural barriers, whereas jobs in traditional trades or vocational paths rely more on soft skills, local connections, and cultural nuances, where native locals naturally have the upper hand.
I would be cautious about over-generalising cultural differences. I don't think parents in any culture want to rob their child of a happy childhood! In reality, it’s always a tough balancing act, especially coming from an immigrant background where you’re often starting from behind without a built-in safety net. Sometimes kids in such families just have to work that bit harder to bridge the gap and secure their future.
It is easy to polarize academic effort and childhood happiness as if they are opposite extremes, just as it is easy to lean on cultural stereotypes (even if average differences do exist). But it’s really about every family finding their own sweet spot that works best for them.

HPFA · 26/10/2026 13:11

Got to laugh at the writer complaining about Oxfordshire not having grammar schools, although in fact they can be accessed in Bucks if you live in some parts of the county.

We do get very slightly worse GCSE results than Bucks which I'm sure has nothing to do
with the fact that any movement of Year 7 kids into Bucks is exclusively of the very academically able whereas movement the other way will be from kids who failed the 11+.

Almost all comps in Oxfordshire range between OK and excellent and we certainly don't need a return to selection.

It can't happen but I'd love to have a law that says any kid who sits the 11+ must attend the nearest secondary modern if they fail. No going private, no hopping over the county border to a comp. If you believe in the selective system you should trust it to decide the right school for your kid, whether it's the grammar or the secondary modern.

Mathsbabe · 26/10/2026 22:50

My children went to a good comp. Both have dyslexia, DD quite badly. In year 10 she was in the top set for Maths and set 6, the bottom set, for English. Because she worked very hard she excelled at maths and passed her English.

nondrinker1985 · 27/10/2026 10:13

White people have cultural and social capital to be more ‘rounded’ immigrant families have to focus on jobs that are higher end in the professions. They don’t have the luxury of a rounded education as such. In saying that you’ll still find plenty more white male surgeons. Nevertheless - education is a way ‘out’ for immigrants or trying to equalize the playing field a little if they can.

you’ll still find generally the most successful immigrants remain whose parents were also of a higher class and educated - those like my family who were lower class farmers - relatively illiterate and poor although Still focus on getting kids educated and may well go into the professions end up investing in property and escaping the professions.

TypicalBlue · 27/10/2026 22:10

HPFA · 26/10/2026 13:11

Got to laugh at the writer complaining about Oxfordshire not having grammar schools, although in fact they can be accessed in Bucks if you live in some parts of the county.

We do get very slightly worse GCSE results than Bucks which I'm sure has nothing to do
with the fact that any movement of Year 7 kids into Bucks is exclusively of the very academically able whereas movement the other way will be from kids who failed the 11+.

Almost all comps in Oxfordshire range between OK and excellent and we certainly don't need a return to selection.

It can't happen but I'd love to have a law that says any kid who sits the 11+ must attend the nearest secondary modern if they fail. No going private, no hopping over the county border to a comp. If you believe in the selective system you should trust it to decide the right school for your kid, whether it's the grammar or the secondary modern.

I know plenty of children in Bucks who travel to Oxford for independent schools that didn’t “fail” the 11+, or even take it for that matter. That would always have been their trajectory. There are hardly any private senior schools in Bucks, particularly for boys.

HPFA · 28/10/2026 09:25

TypicalBlue · 27/10/2026 22:10

I know plenty of children in Bucks who travel to Oxford for independent schools that didn’t “fail” the 11+, or even take it for that matter. That would always have been their trajectory. There are hardly any private senior schools in Bucks, particularly for boys.

That would not affect the official Oxfordshire GCSE results though.

Movement for state schools between Oxfordshire and Bucks is almost certainly due to passing or failing the 11+. I have never heard of a child in Thame who failed the 11+ moving to a Bucks secondary modern.

TypicalBlue · 28/10/2026 12:17

HPFA · 28/10/2026 09:25

That would not affect the official Oxfordshire GCSE results though.

Movement for state schools between Oxfordshire and Bucks is almost certainly due to passing or failing the 11+. I have never heard of a child in Thame who failed the 11+ moving to a Bucks secondary modern.

Fair enough, if the results are separate in terms of state and independent schools. I know of a few young people who achieved high GCSE grades in Oxford schools, who live in Bucks so just wanted to point out it isn’t all one way.

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 06:25

I do wonder if there is some degree of an element of so-called ‘white flight’ at play as well. That is, it could be possible that some white British parents/students are seeing schools with few white British students in them, and thinking, ‘No, that’s not for me. I’d rather be with others from my own ethnic background and culture.’ Could this also be a factor?

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 06:30

In a system that was set up when the country had a different demographic profile.

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 06:37

I work in education, and I think that this is another factor. I have met white British parents who wouldn’t send their bright children to a grammar school or any other type of selective school because they felt that the existence of such schools was morally wrong. In my experience, people from immigrant backgrounds don’t share this attitude.

ItsWoudHaveNotWouldOf · 08/11/2026 06:45

I'd say it's true that other ethnicities work their children harder. I have several selective grammars in my borough and they're extremely heavily dominated by black pupils who bus in from all over, it's been like this for years. My friends DD got a place at an all girls grammar but had a miserable time. The girls formed friend groups from where they lived and she had barely any local friends she could see at weekends.

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 06:47

Right here, there is a cultural difference, and I say that as a white immigrant to this country. Many white working class British families would take exception to the idea that a tree surgeon owning his or her own business is in a lesser career than one which requires a university education (as you refer to people who ‘want more’ for their children).

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 06:48

Do you think that, at some point, people of non-South Asian origin felt that that school was not for them?

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 06:52

I live in a grammar county. State schools are legally forbidden to help students to prepare for the grammar school test.

ChristmasGreyhound · 08/11/2026 06:57

I'm guessing this is very area specific. My dc attend a grammer in Devon and although it is definitely more diverse than the surrounding state schools, the vast majority of the children are white British.

NoisyHiker · 08/11/2026 07:05

I wonder if the attitudes towards white people will change over time.

I've seen quite a few posts where the things being said about white people and white children would be considered dehumanising and racist if said about minorities.

As it is now inevitable that white people will eventually become the minority in the UK (though they are already the minority globally), will people start being more considerate of their predjuces?

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 07:06

Are fun, art, childhood spirit and freedom to relax bad things?

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 07:09

As a person of Eastern European descent from North America who is an immigrant to this country, I can tell you that we are not included in ‘white Brits’ statistics. We usually have to tick ‘White Other’ on forms.

treeowl · 08/11/2026 07:15

QuestioningW · 08/11/2026 06:25

I do wonder if there is some degree of an element of so-called ‘white flight’ at play as well. That is, it could be possible that some white British parents/students are seeing schools with few white British students in them, and thinking, ‘No, that’s not for me. I’d rather be with others from my own ethnic background and culture.’ Could this also be a factor?

I think some just prefer a bigger mix

Stowickthevast · 08/11/2026 10:24

Which posts are you referring to @NoisyHiker ?

CrescentPoppy · 09/11/2026 09:43

deanstreet · 13/02/2026 15:43

To say that grammar schools are competitive would be a gross understatement: with more than 30 candidates for each place at some schools, getting a place for your child now requires military-style levels of strategy and ruthlessness.
There are stories of children as young as six being privately tutored for the 11+ exams, and families applying for schools hundreds of miles away (some as far away as China). The average house price in Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, which is in the catchment area of several outstanding grammar schools, now exceeds £1.1m.

Grammar schools are no longer just about serving local talent; they are a national – and increasingly international – race for an elite educational opportunity. One that is, crucially, free.
Given that a private secondary education now costs on average £150,000, it is unsurprising that parents are planning and paying years in advance to ensure their child can go to an academically selective school.
A consequence of the exclusivity of grammar schools – aside from premium postcodes and pushy parents with pointy elbows – is that they take very few white working-class pupils (or white pupils at all).
For example, one school in north London, which had nearly 3,000 applicants for its 104 places, took only one white British child in 2024-2025. A nearby school has only two white British pupils in a year group of almost 200.
This has been the case for quite some time. A 2016 report by The Sutton Trust found that disadvantaged Indian pupils were four times more likely than disadvantaged white British pupils to attend a grammar school. Disadvantaged Chinese pupils were 15 times more likely to do so.

Some cultures value education more than others
Many have been quick to blame the under-representation of white children in grammar schools on anti-white discrimination, but the idea that entrance is awarded on the basis of some sort of ethnic favouritism is nonsense.

Firstly, grammar schools are often located in quite demographically diverse areas. Secondly, students sit the same test regardless of background. For most schools, there is no pass threshold, so places are simply allocated in descending order of exam mark (although around two thirds of grammar schools have policies prioritising candidates from disadvantaged homes or on free school meals).
Lee Elliot Major, professor of social mobility at the University of Exeter, is right when he says it is “dangerous to compare ethnic groups as if they are like-for-like ... and these differences could be white British pupils being more likely to come from lower-income households and to live in areas where education has not consistently translated into opportunity”.
However, here’s the quiet part said out loud: the ethnic make-up of grammar schools is a reflection of the academic aspirations of different parents, and the fact that some cultures value education and the importance of exam results more than others.

As I have written previously, education is not a zero-sum game, and white working-class students underachieve in spite of others’ progress, not because of it.

There are too many bright pupils for too few places
If we want to help white working-class pupils, we need to stop blaming hard-working students from other backgrounds, and realise that parental support, engagement and ambition are the distinguishing factors here, not some DEI conspiracy.
To put it simply, white working-class students cannot go to grammar school unless their parents live in the right areas; put them forward for the test, and – with the help of schools – give them appropriate support and encouragement.
As a country, we also need more grammar schools in the first place. There are far too many bright pupils for too few places, all of which are concentrated in a few counties (where I live, in Oxfordshire, there is not a single grammar school).

Grammar schools are oversubscribed because parents are disillusioned with the other, increasingly restricted, choices on offer, caused by successive governments substituting excellence for mediocrity by automatically assuming that “selection by ability is bad”. Yet, in an astonishing rags-to-riches success story, London Academy of Excellence received 60 Oxbridge offers this year.

Finally, we need to acknowledge that certain groups seemingly monopolise grammar schools because parental aspiration is not equal, and grammar school places are not equitable. Our knee-jerk reaction might be to blame these schools’ admissions policies or insist that these schools take more white British children, but we need to encourage ambition, not penalise it.

"This has been the case for quite some time. A 2016 report by The Sutton Trust found that disadvantaged Indian pupils were four times more likely than disadvantaged white British pupils to attend a grammar school. Disadvantaged Chinese pupils were 15 times more likely to do so."

When kids come from disadvantaged backgrounds, none of them really get tutoring or much help at home, so their environments are actually pretty similar. How do you explain a 15-fold difference in those cases?

Well, the 11+ basically acts like an IQ test anyway, and studies show average scores vary a lot by ethnic group. Data from a nationally representative sample of 10-year-old American children shows average IQ scores ordered as follows: Chinese > Indian > White > Black.
https://humanvarieties.org/2023/05/27/iq-scores-by-ethnic-group-in-a-nationally-representative-sample-of-10-year-old-american-children/

Personally, I don't think IQ captures real intelligence. However, the fact remains that IQ is largely innate and hard to change significantly, and there is an undeniable correlation between IQ scores and performance on selective exams.

So unless you use reverse affirmative action—like making it harder for Asian students to get in—their higher test scores, driven largely by higher average IQs, mean they will naturally take up more grammar school places.

IQ scores by ethnic group in a nationally-representative sample of 10-year old American children

Note: We computed these results based on multiple versions of the ABCD data (v2.01 & v3.01) and with different inclusion/exclusion criteria.  I originally posted a version based on the ABCD 2.0…

https://humanvarieties.org/2023/05/27/iq-scores-by-ethnic-group-in-a-nationally-representative-sample-of-10-year-old-american-children/

FlatStanley50 · 11/11/2026 12:46

Elevenseconds · 25/02/2026 07:41

In our town there are three grammars - two single sex (boys, girls), and a co-ed.

The single sex girls school is 60-70% South Asian, in an area where South Asians make up approximately 15% of the population. Genuinely, well done to them and their families for helping their children to achieve the grades.

However, a lot of white families are choosing the co-ed, not because of racism, but for something a bit more complicated. Some white families who have sent their children to the girls' school report that a groundswell of the South Asian girls are not allowed to go into town / have sleepovers / mix outside of school, so it becomes cliquey with the South Asian girls seeing each other within their communities, and then limits the white girls to being friends with the maybe 6 other girls in their class - whom of course they may have very little in common with. Additionally when fallings out naturally occur, there are fewer options to hang out with a different crowd instead.

So it becomes self-perpetuating. Interestingly the co-ed more or less represents the town in terms of ethnic make-up.

I think we must have the same local town. My daughter (white British) has just started at the co-ed and that was definitely one of our considerations. At her primary 6 girls passed the 11+, 4 were white British, 2 south Asian. (Interestingly no boys passed). The Asian girls both chose the girls school while the others have all gone to the co-ed. Both of the Asian girls had a lot more tutoring (one of them in particular was doing 6 hours a day over the summer) and that kind of high pressure, the social life implications you mentioned, and huge emphasis on STEM all put us off the single sex school. We felt the co-ed was more rounded and it offered more performing arts opportunities which was important for my daughter. The cohort at the co-ed is much more diverse - there are still South Asian children amongst many other ethnicities. My daughter had a strong preference and we did feel it was the right choice for her. In her words 'the girl's school wants you to be THE best, co-ed wants you to do YOUR best' and that did feel like the vibe we got from both. We felt in a very lucky position to have the choice of two really good schools. Anyway there are plenty of white British children at the co-ed so I think it depends on area/ school. Obviously this is Bucks rather than a superselective. I don't think there are many working class or underprivileged children of any ethnicity looking at the stats, and from what I can tell so far.