Please or to access all these features

Scotsnet

Welcome to Scotsnet - discuss all aspects of life in Scotland, including relocating, schools and local areas.

The "independence pact"

260 replies

Sunnnyday · 15/09/2026 23:09

I'm surprised no-one's started a thread on this, so here goes. The leaders of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have signed a Joint Memorandum of Understanding and have called on the UK Government to start preparing for constitutional change.
Listening to the BBC on this, there is currently no majority in favour of splitting from the UK in any of the devolved nations, though Scotland is closer to it than the other two. It's a matter of those who are currently in government being in favour, rather than their populations being in favour. So is this no more than a publicity stunt?
And should any referendum on such a huge issue, which, regardless of your viewpoint, will cause enormous contention, upheaval and disruption over many years, be on a majority vote basis? Have we learnt anything from Brexit?
I'm also confused as to why the leaders of Scotland and Wales are apparently confident that their countries would be swiftly welcomed into the EU, and how they would manage a hard border with England.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Ruttering · 17/09/2026 16:14

The AI challenge is now - the applications are in. The job losses and wage compression in the tech sector are well underway and snow balling. It seems like a much more important opportunity than a ref that isn’t even planned as yet.

Sunnnyday · 18/09/2026 00:43

@Ruttering Can you explain exactly what Scotland has to gain from multiple enormous AI data centres? Apart from a short-term increase in work for construction companies? Why are we being told that it's so vital for Scotland to welcome them? They will do so much damage, ongoing damage, and very few jobs will be created. And they will take resources that people need here, and which are likely to become scarcer in the future (water). It will be awful for the people living near them. It's bound to have an adverse effect on the tourism industry, too. I have done some research online on the benefits of these data centres, and it wasn't at all convincing. (Apparently in theory it could encourage infrastructure development).

OP posts:
Ruttering · 18/09/2026 03:58

I’m unsure too @Sunnnyday i suppose ‘done right’ Scot gov could ensure Scottish firms build them, retain the profits here, that kind of thing.

there are bound to be ideas out there for a better more beneficial model.

OllyBJolly · 18/09/2026 10:01

The "Pact" is window dressing to convince the party's faithful that independence is on the agenda. The SNP have failed spectacularly to move the country towards that. Support for independence has increased since 2014, but confidence in the SNP government has fallen. They have been very lucky to be re-elected and that's largely because the opposition parties are so weak. Their record in Holyrood is just atrocious. Good at handing out freebies, absolutely abysmal on education, health and growing the economy. They have been such a disappointment.

I did vote Yes in 2014 and I am now glad we didn't win. I would still like to see an independent Scotland but until we can drag the Scottish parliament out of student politics level debate, it's not going to happen.

turkeyboots · 18/09/2026 10:10

Northern Ireland doesn't want independence though. Some want to stay in the UK, and some want to join Ireland. Neither is an independence movement and NI would sink like a stone without UK funding (which I believe is higher than Scotlands?).
And both sides have proven to be awful at running a country, with rule from Westminster regularly having to restart to maintain basic governing. Sinn Fein are trying to borrow some respectability from the Scottish and Welsh. The SNP at least has never lead a terrorist movement.

Inverness1900 · 18/09/2026 14:19

Sunnnyday · 15/09/2026 23:09

I'm surprised no-one's started a thread on this, so here goes. The leaders of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have signed a Joint Memorandum of Understanding and have called on the UK Government to start preparing for constitutional change.
Listening to the BBC on this, there is currently no majority in favour of splitting from the UK in any of the devolved nations, though Scotland is closer to it than the other two. It's a matter of those who are currently in government being in favour, rather than their populations being in favour. So is this no more than a publicity stunt?
And should any referendum on such a huge issue, which, regardless of your viewpoint, will cause enormous contention, upheaval and disruption over many years, be on a majority vote basis? Have we learnt anything from Brexit?
I'm also confused as to why the leaders of Scotland and Wales are apparently confident that their countries would be swiftly welcomed into the EU, and how they would manage a hard border with England.

"Listening to the BBC on this, there is currently no majority in favour of splitting from the UK in any of the devolved nations, though Scotland is closer to it than the other two. It's a matter of those who are currently in government being in favour, rather than their populations being in favour. So is this no more than a publicity stunt?"

Support for the union in Scotland is now consistently in the minority. So it would be more accurate to say the unionists are pulling the stunt, if anything, arguing for it.

For five consecutive elections, the SNP have won every Scottish election. When was the last time Labour or the Tories had won five consecutive national elections?

The majority seats are filled by MPs from independence parties. It's at a new record, from this May. So it's still growing in support, even now.

73 MPs for independence vs 56 MPs for the union, in the Scottish parliament.

In the North of Ireland, support for the union is 50% and declining. It's on a knife-edge.

Currently, in Wales, support for the union is at a 20 point advantage, over support for independence.

Sounds like a done deal, right?

However, in 2014, support for the union had a 50 point edge.

So basically, support for the union, even in Wales, has declined from 50 points ahead, to 20. It's in a similar place to Scotland was about 15 years ago.

All three nations have pro-independence governments. The trend is going away from the union.

Meanwhile, unionists continue to bury their heads in the sand. Which is fine by me, as I support independence.

But they could have chosen to fundamentally reformed the union, to try and save it. Perhaps some sort of federalization,which didn't give England the perpetual ability to dominate the other countries in the union. And give England its own parliament for devolution.

Though personally, I believe many of them would rather lose the union completely, than have to powershare with Wales and Scotland, and the North of Ireland, on equal footing.

Inverness1900 · 18/09/2026 14:29

Meeplemakeglasgow · 16/09/2026 00:30

Without taking any side here I can’t see any scenario where any future referendum will not be decided on a majority basis.

Anything else is immoral, undemocratic and frankly a cheat for those who prefer the status-quo.

As for the pact, I don’t really see how it will help any of the parties as the situations are so different.

Scotland is around 50:50 with support moving based on current events.

If the referendum was ran again during events such as the aftermath of Brexit, Boris scandals or Michelle Mone’s extortion then it would have been a yes vote.

Conversely if it had been ran during the campervan or gender fiascos then it would have been an easy no.

Interestingly, I read recently that if the 2014 ref was restricted to people born in Scotland then it would have been a yes vote on the same percentage as the Brexit one.

No matter what beliefs you have, if a majority of native born Scots wanted to leave then clearly there’s something wrong with the current set-up.

Ireland however is very different, demographic changes mean unionism doesn’t have an automatic majority any more and for the first time both sides are having to campaign on policies without purely being a tribal headcount.

Interestingly many people from traditional unionist backgrounds are now open to a united Ireland with the undecided voters holding the balance.

Sinn Fein holding the 1st Minister position would have been hard to believe even 8 years ago and having spent time there recently there has been a huge shift towards Irish culture.

I genuinely think it is just a matter of time before unification takes place, the GFA was designed for a peaceful transition of power so hopefully it serves it’s purpose.

Wales I have absolutely no idea over but was surprised that PC have so much support.

I think Britain needs to fix the social contracts and binds it once had or there will be change sooner rather than later.

"Scotland is around 50:50 with support moving based on current events.
If the referendum was ran again during events such as the aftermath of Brexit, Boris scandals or Michelle Mone’s extortion then it would have been a yes vote.
Conversely if it had been ran during the campervan or gender fiascos then it would have been an easy no."

Support for the union is now consistently below 50% Independence has the edge. When accounting for DKs, support for independence is roughly 48%. Support for staying in the union is at 44%.

A decade ago, support for the union was almost always above 50%. In the 00s, it was often above 60%. So it's clear which way the trend is going.

I agree with much of what you said though. It is true that the majority of folk born in Scotland voted to leave the UK in 2014.

I'm not arguing that migrants here from rUK or elsewhere shouldn't have a vote. If you contribute to Scotland, you should have a say. But I don't let it be said that Scots ourselves voted to stay in the UK, because it's misleading. The population did, but Scots did not. It would be like if Brexit failed, because EU citizens were allowed to vote (they weren't) and were enough to prevent it, even though the majority of people born in the UK voted to leave it.

We all know that it wouldn't be a settled matter. It might have even driven up support for Brexit, if it was scuppered by votes from EU citizens.

Also, even during the campervan and trans ID period, support for independence didn't fall much. It was barely affected. Maybe 2-3% difference, which is inside the margin of error. It also hasn't affected the movement long-term. Support for the union,, in Scotland, has never been lower than it is at present.

Inverness1900 · 18/09/2026 14:35

Sunnnyday · 16/09/2026 12:46

I have to say, I think the EU (and the world, including Scotland) has enough to be working on at the moment - including now the potential annihilation of the human species by AI, on top of the war in Ukraine, the other ongoing wars, climate change, the loss of the US as a meaningful ally, and everything else. I very much doubt that it would welcome a membership application by Scotland (let alone Wales) with any enthusiasm. And that's even assuming that Scotland would meet the membership criteria.

There will never be a stable/quiet time, based on that logic. Even in 2014 there was plenty of instability and frustrations, and wars.

Inverness1900 · 18/09/2026 14:39

Igneococcus · 16/09/2026 13:56

In regards to the EU, I think its was because it had been regularly stated by the EU administration that they would be welcomed

This will entirely depend on Scotland (or Wales) fulfilling the economic requirements that the EU demands, which looks unlikely, and also committing to the Euro and to becoming part of Schengen.

Yet vastly more likely than we would, rejoin the EU by staying in the UK.
The UK took us out of it, and there's little interest from Labour, let alone the Reform lot, in taking us back in.

That said, I'd support an independent Scotland in or out of the EU. Preferably within it, but Scottish democracy and sovereignty is at the top of my priorities. And before anyone suggest EU nations aren't sovereign, just ask the UK, who were able to leave the EU without once seeking the EU's permission. Something that can't happen in the UK.

It is true that you have to sign up to certain conditions to join the EU, but that's true of any trade agreement, to a varying extent.

Sunnnyday · 18/09/2026 16:04

You're quite right that in the future there will never be a quiet time. You're wrong to suggest that 2014 was comparable to 2026 (did I mention serious warnings of imminent annihilation by AI? War in Europe? Trump dismantling the world order?).

OP posts:
Sunnnyday · 18/09/2026 16:10

@Inverness1900 What do you mean by power-sharing on "an equal footing"? Do you think Northern Ireland should have as big a say as England on issues which affect both, despite the population of England being 30 times larger?

OP posts:
Murley · 18/09/2026 17:32

@Inverness1900 what makes you think the support for Indy is in the majority? Unionist parties got a majority of the vote in the latest Holyrood election and when surveyed Indy isn’t even in the top 5 of Scots political priorities!

Differentforgirls · 18/09/2026 18:54

Sunnnyday · 18/09/2026 16:10

@Inverness1900 What do you mean by power-sharing on "an equal footing"? Do you think Northern Ireland should have as big a say as England on issues which affect both, despite the population of England being 30 times larger?

Therein lies the problem. We had 56 SNP MPs after the referendum. Still had no say.

Differentforgirls · 18/09/2026 18:58

Murley · 18/09/2026 17:32

@Inverness1900 what makes you think the support for Indy is in the majority? Unionist parties got a majority of the vote in the latest Holyrood election and when surveyed Indy isn’t even in the top 5 of Scots political priorities!

Parties other than Labour got the majority of the vote in the last UK election. Labour is in Government.

Plus there is no such thing as a “Unionist” party.

People vote for the party they want to govern for 5 years. However there are Independence supporters in every party.

Test that by having a referendum.

Sunnnyday · 18/09/2026 19:05

Differentforgirls · 18/09/2026 18:54

Therein lies the problem. We had 56 SNP MPs after the referendum. Still had no say.

What do you mean by not having a say? Scotland has MPs at Westminster and has its own devolved parliament which handles most issues - including education, health, transport, planning. It has a hell of a lot more of a say than any non-devolved part of the UK.

OP posts:
Differentforgirls · 18/09/2026 19:20

Sunnnyday · 18/09/2026 19:05

What do you mean by not having a say? Scotland has MPs at Westminster and has its own devolved parliament which handles most issues - including education, health, transport, planning. It has a hell of a lot more of a say than any non-devolved part of the UK.

There is only one non devolved part of the UK. The country with most MPs. They get the biggest say.

Aiming4Optimistic · 18/09/2026 19:48

So England has the largest population and therefore more MPs, which is fair enough. But to mitigate for that, devolution gives more direct control over areas that affect Scotland and Wales, such as health and education. And because England has a bigger population and therefore more taxpayers, it contributes more to the funding of the UK which is then shared, with S & W receiving more than would be raised by their own populations' taxation.
Swings and roundabouts to me .

Murley · 18/09/2026 19:52

Differentforgirls · 18/09/2026 19:20

There is only one non devolved part of the UK. The country with most MPs. They get the biggest say.

Of course they do. They represent the majority of the UK. Thats democracy.

Murley · 18/09/2026 19:58

Aiming4Optimistic · 18/09/2026 19:48

So England has the largest population and therefore more MPs, which is fair enough. But to mitigate for that, devolution gives more direct control over areas that affect Scotland and Wales, such as health and education. And because England has a bigger population and therefore more taxpayers, it contributes more to the funding of the UK which is then shared, with S & W receiving more than would be raised by their own populations' taxation.
Swings and roundabouts to me .

England earns more of the tax take that rUK by dint of it containing the City of London, one of the worlds biggest tax generating focal points. Scotland does ok on its own - out earning per head of population many areas of England, wales and N Ireland, but it spends SO MUCH more than it generates by itself, because it gets a share of the City of London’s riches - which are vast. So yeah Scotland could do ok as a nation, once it has tightened its belt drastically and got over its spending addiction, and fights its way out of debt. Then it might get near meeting EU criteria but it will take decades of austerity, and the EU might not be there in 20 years time.

Differentforgirls · 18/09/2026 21:34

Murley · 18/09/2026 19:52

Of course they do. They represent the majority of the UK. Thats democracy.

Which is why I support Independence

Sunnnyday · 18/09/2026 22:28

Differentforgirls · 18/09/2026 19:20

There is only one non devolved part of the UK. The country with most MPs. They get the biggest say.

How about Cornwall, or North Yorkshire, or Birmingham? They might well love to have the powers the devolved governments have. Do you really think that different parts of England don't have their own distinct personalities and needs? How similar do you think Blackpool is to Cheltenham? Do you think that England is just one big lump where everyone feels as one?
And in fact we often hear that the Highlands don't feel that they're properly represented at Holyrood - they feel that all the attention is on the Central Belt. And Orkney apparently would like to leave Scotland altogether.

People living in Scotland have a say in England, and a very big say in Scotland. That's better than anyone else gets, apart from Wales and Northern Ireland. And Scotland does better than them financially under the Barnet formula.

If you look at what people in Scotland complain about, it's nearly always about the things that the Scottish Government controls. Like the ferries, the state of the roads, being stuck on an NHS waiting list for years, the state of the education system, the lack of regulation on AI data centres (with a recent demonstration at Holyrood). The Scottish government controls almost everything that matters to people. Okay, Scotland isn't responsible for its own defence, so it doesn't control the army, and it doesn't control immigration. Are those things really in the Scottish government's skillset, based on its performance on everything else?

I can't tell you how sick I got of the "sovereignty" argument during Brexit. It's just another word for nationalism. The Scottish version of nationalism is no prettier than the English version, as far as I'm concerned. It's largely about having someone else to blame and someone else to feel superior to. The dishonest tactics that were used to persuade people to vote for Brexit are being used to persuade us to vote for Scottish independence.

We're living in incredibly dangerous times. I don't think that going into many years of self-inflicted disruption, isolation and uncertainty is a great idea right now.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 18/09/2026 23:19

Meeplemakeglasgow · 16/09/2026 10:44

If you’re looking to start a thread bashing independence you’re probably better off just joining another one of the few thousand that are already on here, you’ll have no shortage of contributors to the echo chamber.

Whether you like it or not the debate isn’t going to go away, support for remaining in the uk is now only a majority in the 65+ age groups and 50/50 between 55-64.

Amongst younger people support is massively skewed towards independence.

The issue the the Union has is that traditionally most people tended to move towards the status quo when they got older due to assets built up/pensions, but the younger generations don’t have the same opportunities as previous ones to build this wealth and the generations who were in young/mid-adulthood in 2014 show mode signs of changing their mind.

Outside of the fairly well-off middle classes and certain other communities around central Scotland there aren’t really the cultural links with the rest of the UK that there was when I was young in the 80’s/90’s, demographic/cultural change has made nations that were once reasonably similar seem miles apart.

I travel to London with work regularly and most younger people have no idea about Scotland at all, most didn’t know that part of Ireland was still in the UK (all came up during a strategy meeting), whereas the older ones were much more informed and likely to have family connections to the other nations.

The reality is that Londoners now are much more likely to have cultural ties to places like Nigeria, India and Pakistan than Scotland, to be clear there is nothing wrong with that, that’s where their family ties and backgrounds are from, but why would a young person in Dundee for example feel a cultural connection to London when it is one sided.

'The reality is that Londoners now are much more likely to have cultural ties to places like Nigeria, India and Pakistan than Scotland'

  • what about the rest of England apart from London?
Jane3212 · 18/09/2026 23:30

turkeyboots · 18/09/2026 10:10

Northern Ireland doesn't want independence though. Some want to stay in the UK, and some want to join Ireland. Neither is an independence movement and NI would sink like a stone without UK funding (which I believe is higher than Scotlands?).
And both sides have proven to be awful at running a country, with rule from Westminster regularly having to restart to maintain basic governing. Sinn Fein are trying to borrow some respectability from the Scottish and Welsh. The SNP at least has never lead a terrorist movement.

That's a good point. Reunification is not the same as independence.

Murley · 19/09/2026 06:34

As someone living in Edinburgh I feel very little affiliation with anyone living in the islands, or the likes of Dundee or Glasgow who vote in the incredibly incompetent SNP. Can we please have independence?

Ruttering · 19/09/2026 10:45

It’s a legitimate question in this day and age and with the eu isn’t it - we don’t have a real border, implementing one would cause massive trade friction, what’s to stop further splits?