@Mywhitedress I know what you mean. I am an honest person in general. And open too. When I first went LC with my family I felt like I was being dishonest, because usually I would tell someone I feel hurt, try to sort the problem out and then move forward etc. but with them, I haven’t. For a while, I felt like it might not be “fair” of me to have decided to limit contact with them without “giving them a chance” to understand why and respond.
But, my dad in particular just uses DARVO, and my mum just responds to anything other than praise as criticism. I can’t have an honest conversation with either of them. My dad will rewrite history, deny things, argue with all logic and what will be the point? My mum will cry and say things like “I must be the worst mother in the world then, why have anything to do with me?” So I’ll feel like I’ve hurt her, even though it would only be me telling her she has hurt me that would lead to all this.
The truth is, I have tried honest. You have tried honest too. It doesn’t work with these people. Through no fault of your own, you can’t have a proper relationship with them. You can only manage the contact. So if you want to know what’s going on with your mum and the only way to get that information out of your sister is by going along with the rules of engagement so to speak, then you’re not really doing anything wrong imo.
If your sister would just be normal, you’d be able to be normal with her. But she’s not. She’s playing some weird game, and unfortunately she holds all the cards. So if you have to have to contact with her, you have to play by the rules of her game. Or stop playing which unfortunately means you’d have to stop having contact. It’s really not fair we get stuck between a rock and a hard place with these people, but that’s where we all are.