Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Been on the housing 7 years living in overcrowded accomodation-council will not help

486 replies

ByCoralReader · Yesterday 16:25

Ive been on the council housing for 7 years, i share a small bedroom with my daughter who is 9. In a 3 bed house with my mum, brother and his partner. I am unable to work due to disability. I have given a medical letter to the council last year they said they cannot change my band. I recently spoke to a high up person in my council who said i need to do yet another medical assessment. It is killing me to live here mentally and physically. If i go homeless i could end up hundreds of miles away as my area has no "housing" and lose my position on housing. I need serious genuine advice i need my own place for me ans my child we are entitled to a 2 bed. If i went private we would have no money to eat let alone live so this is not an option. Please please help

OP posts:
Boreded · Today 00:06

Boreded · Yesterday 20:18

FFS…why can’t you just accept that OP is disabled, it isn’t up to you to bet that OP can work.

@OneHazelBird oh look

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:07

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:36

There goes your imagination ...😂

Edited

Thing is, my reality can handle that imagination!

BlueFahrenheit · Today 00:08

Comeatmeibite · Yesterday 23:59

If she was disabled before conceiving then, yes, she should have considered her ability to raise a child. It's harsh but I think every person should consider their ability to raise a child before having one.

If she has since become disabled, then she could (and, in my opinion, should) have taken out insurance to pay out in the instance of illness / disability to ensure her child would be taken care of, financially, should the worst happen. The same applies, if it is her DH who died.

Your approach isn't harsh in the slightest. It's simply logical, methodical, and grounded in the facts presented.

Boreded · Today 00:08

@OneHazelBird
You even reacted to this one…(picture incoming)

BlueFahrenheit · Today 00:10

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:07

Thing is, my reality can handle that imagination!

Now, that's a 'flex' I call 'being prepared' 😎

Something I like!

Boreded · Today 00:10

@OneHazelBird

Been on the housing 7 years living in overcrowded accomodation-council will not help
Comeatmeibite · Today 00:11

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:38

Your conscientious decisions make you responsible parents.

Kudos to you both!

Exactly.

Now, we could have a conversation about why two sensible, straight-A students, with degrees from red-brick universities, and professional jobs, have to wait until they are 40 and 50 to be able to afford their second child, but that's something else. And, you know what, we accept the time we're born into and act accordingly.

Ultimately, we should all make sensible decisions based on our circumstances (even if they seem unfair).

Boreded · Today 00:11

BlueFahrenheit · Today 00:10

Now, that's a 'flex' I call 'being prepared' 😎

Something I like!

Mine too. Insured up the wazoo. 💪

Its not really everyone’s reality though tbf

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:13

Boreded · Yesterday 23:40

Why the condescension?

Also this poster hasn’t said anything about the OPs circs that led to her getting to being a single mum living with her parents so why are you making scenarios up to tell them?

It was a touch, wasn't it!

Again, just a ridiculous affectation of some people to almost mock those who have done the "right" thing.

This person has no idea how either my DH or I got to where we are. We did it because it was the right thing.

pinkdelight · Today 00:15

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:45

I wasn’t being condescending - not sure why you jumped to that.

And OP has said she has a 9 year old but has been living with her mum for 7 years - so obviously when her child was 2 her circumstances changed and she had to move in with her mum.

That’s not obvious though, from the OP. She may have been living with her mum all along but only put her name on the housing list 7 years ago. Maybe because she moved back or maybe because that’s she fell out with the brother or any number of other reasons. We’ve no idea when or if she ever moved out, only that she’s been on the list 7 years.

i still think moving areas makes most sense. It’s way too expensive to stay in that area and the DD can move schools at that age and start over. But if OP stays, a mum and daughter sharing is much better than any other constellation and if teen dd wanting her own room doesn’t motivate OP to move areas to somewhere more sustainable, nor will it move the dial for anyone else to solve the issue. OP could move into her mum’s room and have twin beds so that DD can have her own room.

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:17

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:41

Hypothetically, what would happen if your DH died unexpectedly after you gave birth, what if your child had severe disabilies, your aging parents suddenly got ill/died, you couldn't manage childcare so couldn't maintain your professional job, you suddenly couldn't afford maintenance of your home or couldn't afford to pay the student loans solo. Life doesnt always go as planned, and my point is life can change in the blink of an eye. Flexing how prepared you are for having children is ignorant and you never know when the rug could get pulled from beneath you. People's circumstances change every day and we don't know if the OP was previously married with a mortgage etc.

If DH died, his life insurance would pay off the mortgage and I earn enough to cover everything else. The same is true, vice versa. If we both go, our child's guardians would receive the full whack.

If our child suddenly became disabled, again, insurance would cover a few years for us both to stop work.

If our aging parents died, that would make no difference, save for possible inheritance.

I have literally answered every question.

I completely agree that life can change and the rug can be pulled out from underneath us. We can insure ourselves and save, and that won't always be enough, but I have every scenario you've mentioned covered.

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Today 00:18

You ladies remind me of a scene from Angela's Ashes, where the children are in the street playing and the big matrony woman who has a husband and t comes out to announce to her children all the delicious food they have to come in and eat, purposely gloating towards the children whos father is an alcoholic and they are all starving. The woman gets her joy from announcing their fortune for the benefit of the children who have nothing, schadenfreude.

BlueFahrenheit · Today 00:19

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:11

Exactly.

Now, we could have a conversation about why two sensible, straight-A students, with degrees from red-brick universities, and professional jobs, have to wait until they are 40 and 50 to be able to afford their second child, but that's something else. And, you know what, we accept the time we're born into and act accordingly.

Ultimately, we should all make sensible decisions based on our circumstances (even if they seem unfair).

The dilemma itself is rarely addressed. More often than not, the moment you raise it, you're promptly struck with the "privilege" label for daring to suggest that personal responsibility and planning might be worth discussing.

As you'll quickly discover, a few Benefits Britain crusaders always descend on the thread to shut down any dissenting view. Unless you sing from the approved hymn sheet, you're accused of lacking compassion rather than engaging with the merits of your argument.

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:20

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:47

Comeatmeibite is hardly 'flexing' by explaining the provisions in place for her family.

Who knew it's a flex to be responsible and prepared, hey?

Some people cannot accept that they have, perhaps, not been as responsible as they could have or should have...

Ignasta · Today 00:20

You are unable to work and are disabled - I would stay put with your mum and try to make the best of the housing situation. If you and your DD got a 2 bed, your costs would presumably massively increase and you would still be under stress - it would just be a different kind of stress.

BlueFahrenheit · Today 00:22

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:20

Who knew it's a flex to be responsible and prepared, hey?

Some people cannot accept that they have, perhaps, not been as responsible as they could have or should have...

Well, accountability and truth rattle the reckless 😂

But, hey .... we have 'Benefits' for that.

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Today 00:23

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:20

Who knew it's a flex to be responsible and prepared, hey?

Some people cannot accept that they have, perhaps, not been as responsible as they could have or should have...

Its flexing when you list it on a post of someones misfortune,, for no other purpose than to show how you and your husband made better choices. You added no advice to the OP you just listed why you planned better

Boreded · Today 00:24

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:17

If DH died, his life insurance would pay off the mortgage and I earn enough to cover everything else. The same is true, vice versa. If we both go, our child's guardians would receive the full whack.

If our child suddenly became disabled, again, insurance would cover a few years for us both to stop work.

If our aging parents died, that would make no difference, save for possible inheritance.

I have literally answered every question.

I completely agree that life can change and the rug can be pulled out from underneath us. We can insure ourselves and save, and that won't always be enough, but I have every scenario you've mentioned covered.

Same here…barely pay a penny through work for all of my insurances but they mean I could never be stuck.

The previous poster needs to realise though that this conversation isn’t at OPs expense, it has come from a poster who was throwing out hypothetical situations about what could have happened…

RumPidgeon · Today 00:25

The current housing situation isn’t killing you - please keep some perspective. You have a roof over your head and aren’t separated from your daughter. Yours are wishes - not needs. Speak to the Citizens Advice Bureau by all means but I think it’s correct that you’re not on done sort of emergency housing list. There are people out there who ought to be considered first.

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:26

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:50

It comes mainly from not being a miserable bitch.

But apart from that yes I had to flee a DV situation and was homeless and ended up in temporary accommodation with criminals, addicts and peados - something I wouldn’t wish on my worst enemy.

I am in a fortunate position now as I am not disabled, I have my own accommodation and a steady job - but I understand how quickly all of those things can be taken away from me and I would never judge a woman who is in such a disadvantaged situation or think I’m better than her.

HTH

That is horrendous.

Whilst personal experiences can give one the ability to be empathetic beyond others, in my experience, many people very quickly (and understandably) apply their worst case scenario to whatever situation others find themselves in, when the reality is that the worst case scenario is just that and often won't apply.

That all being said, and as harsh as it sounds, I wouldn't have a child with my DH until I earned as much as him. We have been together for 20 years. I trust him more than myself. He is the best person on the planet. But I felt if I wanted to be a mother, I had to be as responsible as I had ever been, which meant being covered in the instance the worst happened and able to support myself and my unborn child.

I appreciate, with all the planning in the world, sometimes things still won't work out but let's be real about how many people actually plan properly and, instead, go for it with children and then look to others / the state when something goes to shit.

Boreded · Today 00:26

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Today 00:23

Its flexing when you list it on a post of someones misfortune,, for no other purpose than to show how you and your husband made better choices. You added no advice to the OP you just listed why you planned better

again not true. This was in response to an increasingly irrational list of what ifs that were given by another poster…not aimed at OP situation at all

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:28

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:50

The bar seems to be remarkably low these days. It doesn't take much imagination to ask yourself how you intend to house and provide for a child.

Yet, judging by some of the responses, having made those considerations in advance is now being portrayed as an outrageous display of privilege rather than simple common sense.

Or a flex 😏🙄

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Today 00:28

Boreded · Today 00:26

again not true. This was in response to an increasingly irrational list of what ifs that were given by another poster…not aimed at OP situation at all

No, her original and first comment is what I am responding to

TheSnappyBluePoster · Today 00:28

pinkdelight · Today 00:15

That’s not obvious though, from the OP. She may have been living with her mum all along but only put her name on the housing list 7 years ago. Maybe because she moved back or maybe because that’s she fell out with the brother or any number of other reasons. We’ve no idea when or if she ever moved out, only that she’s been on the list 7 years.

i still think moving areas makes most sense. It’s way too expensive to stay in that area and the DD can move schools at that age and start over. But if OP stays, a mum and daughter sharing is much better than any other constellation and if teen dd wanting her own room doesn’t motivate OP to move areas to somewhere more sustainable, nor will it move the dial for anyone else to solve the issue. OP could move into her mum’s room and have twin beds so that DD can have her own room.

OP made the exact same post two years ago, saying she was living with her mum then.

Just like with this thread, she didn't bother coming back when no one could tell her.When she could get her council house of her own.

Whilst here you all are fighting over it.

Edit, to say the tone of her post two years ago suggested she had never moved out of her family home and indeed her dad lived there too.

BlueFahrenheit · Today 00:30

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:56

For what reason though? To show the OP how unprepared she was and so she deserves to be in the situation shes in. What was the point in her list of achievements being posted on this thread otherwise?

Oh, please.

Her response clearly addressed the elaborate scenarios that appeared to be invented, despite little or no evidence to support them.