Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Been on the housing 7 years living in overcrowded accomodation-council will not help

486 replies

ByCoralReader · Yesterday 16:25

Ive been on the council housing for 7 years, i share a small bedroom with my daughter who is 9. In a 3 bed house with my mum, brother and his partner. I am unable to work due to disability. I have given a medical letter to the council last year they said they cannot change my band. I recently spoke to a high up person in my council who said i need to do yet another medical assessment. It is killing me to live here mentally and physically. If i go homeless i could end up hundreds of miles away as my area has no "housing" and lose my position on housing. I need serious genuine advice i need my own place for me ans my child we are entitled to a 2 bed. If i went private we would have no money to eat let alone live so this is not an option. Please please help

OP posts:
Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:45

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:42

I would hazard a guess that their sympathy for the OP's predicament stems from a certain familiarity with it.

I would hazard a guess that the sympathy comes from being a conpassionate human being. I sympathise with the OP despite not being directly familiar with it in my own family

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:45

Boreded · Yesterday 23:40

Why the condescension?

Also this poster hasn’t said anything about the OPs circs that led to her getting to being a single mum living with her parents so why are you making scenarios up to tell them?

I wasn’t being condescending - not sure why you jumped to that.

And OP has said she has a 9 year old but has been living with her mum for 7 years - so obviously when her child was 2 her circumstances changed and she had to move in with her mum.

Comeatmeibite · Yesterday 23:45

OrganicDecafEarlGrey · Yesterday 23:16

It's just a total lack of imagination and empathy. So common on Mumsnet.

Surely part of the financial considerations before having children is considering what you wou do if one, or both, parent(s) became ill / disabled... Isn't that what insurance is for? I don't think that takes too much imagination, does it?

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 23:46

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:42

So why are you and other nasty posters judging OP for not having her own accommodation or being disabled and not being able to work.

OP has not had any other children since not having her own home - hardly irresponsible.

She was not living in her mums for the first 2 years of her child’s life, so obviously had somewhere else to live.

I don’t understand the bitchiness towards someone who is simply trying to make a better life for their child.

The number of medical conditions that render you completely unable to work are actually quite low.

There aren't many medical conditions that prevent you from doing any work whatsoever for your entire life.

A point you've conveniently ignored.

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:47

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:41

Hypothetically, what would happen if your DH died unexpectedly after you gave birth, what if your child had severe disabilies, your aging parents suddenly got ill/died, you couldn't manage childcare so couldn't maintain your professional job, you suddenly couldn't afford maintenance of your home or couldn't afford to pay the student loans solo. Life doesnt always go as planned, and my point is life can change in the blink of an eye. Flexing how prepared you are for having children is ignorant and you never know when the rug could get pulled from beneath you. People's circumstances change every day and we don't know if the OP was previously married with a mortgage etc.

Comeatmeibite is hardly 'flexing' by explaining the provisions in place for her family.

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:50

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:42

I would hazard a guess that their sympathy for the OP's predicament stems from a certain familiarity with it.

It comes mainly from not being a miserable bitch.

But apart from that yes I had to flee a DV situation and was homeless and ended up in temporary accommodation with criminals, addicts and peados - something I wouldn’t wish on my worst enemy.

I am in a fortunate position now as I am not disabled, I have my own accommodation and a steady job - but I understand how quickly all of those things can be taken away from me and I would never judge a woman who is in such a disadvantaged situation or think I’m better than her.

HTH

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:50

Comeatmeibite · Yesterday 23:45

Surely part of the financial considerations before having children is considering what you wou do if one, or both, parent(s) became ill / disabled... Isn't that what insurance is for? I don't think that takes too much imagination, does it?

The bar seems to be remarkably low these days. It doesn't take much imagination to ask yourself how you intend to house and provide for a child.

Yet, judging by some of the responses, having made those considerations in advance is now being portrayed as an outrageous display of privilege rather than simple common sense.

Boreded · Yesterday 23:50

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:42

So why are you and other nasty posters judging OP for not having her own accommodation or being disabled and not being able to work.

OP has not had any other children since not having her own home - hardly irresponsible.

She was not living in her mums for the first 2 years of her child’s life, so obviously had somewhere else to live.

I don’t understand the bitchiness towards someone who is simply trying to make a better life for their child.

Woah! Stop right there, I think you’ll find I have told multiple people that the OPs disability is not up for debate and the government accept that she cannot work so they can’t question it.

Get your facts straight before you start accusing me of things that aren’t true thanks. 🙏

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:50

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:47

Comeatmeibite is hardly 'flexing' by explaining the provisions in place for her family.

It is absolutely flexing in the context of the OP's situation- her point is look how prepared me and DH were for saving and planning for our dear child and future child once we had all our money saved and our house and maintenance all in order vs the OP who is single parenting and has to live in the spare room of her mums 3 bed council house. Come on now.

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:53

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:50

It is absolutely flexing in the context of the OP's situation- her point is look how prepared me and DH were for saving and planning for our dear child and future child once we had all our money saved and our house and maintenance all in order vs the OP who is single parenting and has to live in the spare room of her mums 3 bed council house. Come on now.

No.

She was explaining that she made considered, responsible decisions before having a child.

If that reasoning upsets you, that is really your issue, not hers.

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:54

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:50

It comes mainly from not being a miserable bitch.

But apart from that yes I had to flee a DV situation and was homeless and ended up in temporary accommodation with criminals, addicts and peados - something I wouldn’t wish on my worst enemy.

I am in a fortunate position now as I am not disabled, I have my own accommodation and a steady job - but I understand how quickly all of those things can be taken away from me and I would never judge a woman who is in such a disadvantaged situation or think I’m better than her.

HTH

This was your life. Not the OP's

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:54

Boreded · Yesterday 23:50

Woah! Stop right there, I think you’ll find I have told multiple people that the OPs disability is not up for debate and the government accept that she cannot work so they can’t question it.

Get your facts straight before you start accusing me of things that aren’t true thanks. 🙏

A massive part of OPs crappy situation is because she is disabled - she cannot get a job or get a private rental - so by you judging her for not providing her DD with a home of her own, then you are absolutely bringing her disability into it.

How is she supposed to better her or her DDs situation whilst being disabled and not being able to work or get home?

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:56

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:53

No.

She was explaining that she made considered, responsible decisions before having a child.

If that reasoning upsets you, that is really your issue, not hers.

For what reason though? To show the OP how unprepared she was and so she deserves to be in the situation shes in. What was the point in her list of achievements being posted on this thread otherwise?

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:57

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:54

This was your life. Not the OP's

Yes and you questioned why I had sympathy for OP and if I had been in a similar situation (like you can’t have sympathy for others in different situations than you).

Fortunately I haven’t, as I couldn’t imagine being disabled and a single parent with no hope of being able to provide a better life for your child purely because you were unlucky enough to have an injury or illness that affects the rest of your life.

Boreded · Yesterday 23:57

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:45

I would hazard a guess that the sympathy comes from being a conpassionate human being. I sympathise with the OP despite not being directly familiar with it in my own family

You weren’t the poster who was being condescending…the issue was with the previous poster making snide remarks that were not necessary. The previous poster she made them to had not made any rude comments about the OP and had only replied to someone else.

The poster with the condescending remarks has created a narrative, and with regard to me, has even made things up, like claiming I have a problem with the OPs disability when it would only take a quick scroll to see that I told multiple people that it was none of their business and that if the government accept her disability then they have to too. I’ve actually defended the OP and yet this poster has come at me with her comments.

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:58

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Yesterday 23:56

For what reason though? To show the OP how unprepared she was and so she deserves to be in the situation shes in. What was the point in her list of achievements being posted on this thread otherwise?

Do you understand how forums work?

People post opinions, others respond, and disagreement follows.

In that context, the answer is already glaringly obvious.

Comeatmeibite · Yesterday 23:59

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:31

Yes and what happens if their relationship becomes abusive or their DH dies?

Where will they go?

They may have to move back in with parents or get rented accommodation.

Most private LLs don’t accept single parents, especially those on benefits.

It is not OPs fault that she is disabled, nor is it her fault she can’t get a private rental, nor was it her fault that she’s had to share a room for the past 7 years.

Nothing about OP says that she’s irresponsible but some posters have nothing better to do than to try and kick someone when they’re down simply because they’re nasty bullies.

If she was disabled before conceiving then, yes, she should have considered her ability to raise a child. It's harsh but I think every person should consider their ability to raise a child before having one.

If she has since become disabled, then she could (and, in my opinion, should) have taken out insurance to pay out in the instance of illness / disability to ensure her child would be taken care of, financially, should the worst happen. The same applies, if it is her DH who died.

BlueFahrenheit · Today 00:01

Boreded · Yesterday 23:57

You weren’t the poster who was being condescending…the issue was with the previous poster making snide remarks that were not necessary. The previous poster she made them to had not made any rude comments about the OP and had only replied to someone else.

The poster with the condescending remarks has created a narrative, and with regard to me, has even made things up, like claiming I have a problem with the OPs disability when it would only take a quick scroll to see that I told multiple people that it was none of their business and that if the government accept her disability then they have to too. I’ve actually defended the OP and yet this poster has come at me with her comments.

Yes. The pattern has been fairly consistent: accusation first, speculation second, evidence nowhere to be found.

Boreded · Today 00:02

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:54

A massive part of OPs crappy situation is because she is disabled - she cannot get a job or get a private rental - so by you judging her for not providing her DD with a home of her own, then you are absolutely bringing her disability into it.

How is she supposed to better her or her DDs situation whilst being disabled and not being able to work or get home?

I HAVE NOT JUDGED THE OP FOR NOT HAVING HER OWN HOME!!!!!!!

I need you to read this and understand.

I have:

  1. told multiple people off for accusing her of having a fake disability for the benefits
  2. suggested that it is her brother and his partner that should not be living in the house because they can work, that would give her soace

And 3 as a completely totally unrelated note, agreed with a comment someone made about not having children if you can’t afford to house them.

I HAVE NOT SAID: that disabled people should have children if they can’t afford to house them…I was incredibly clear on that.

I HAVE NOT SAID That the Op isn’t disabled. That is other people.

Stop making up lies!

Newbookandcupofcoffee · Today 00:02

BlueFahrenheit · Yesterday 23:58

Do you understand how forums work?

People post opinions, others respond, and disagreement follows.

In that context, the answer is already glaringly obvious.

Hahaha and I am engaging in the forum too, I can point out other people's ignorance or gloating the same way you can reply to me etc. We all know what a forum is lol

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:03

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 23:35

Well done to you both for having good jobs.

I imagine if your DH left you for another woman and then you became disabled and couldn’t work then your lifestyle would look very different than it does today.

It would. If he left me, I would rely on my salary and my savings, that I've put aside (during those 20 years I didn't have a child). If I became disabled, my insurance, which I pay ahead of any luxuries, would pay off my mortgage.

Boreded · Today 00:04

Boreded · Yesterday 22:52

Ffs, my able bodied son took 6 months of searching and searching to finally get a temporary part time job…there may well be something that the op could do, but there are probably thousands of people applying for that same thing. There is a limited supply of jobs out there and it is only going to be harder for those who are disabled

And it is irrelevant whether you think the OP can work, the government accept that she needs benefits.

Edited

@OneHazelBird

See this…

Boreded · Today 00:05

Boreded · Yesterday 22:38

But this person says the reason she doesn’t work is her disability, given we know nothing about herd betting that she can work is ridiculous. She could be a quadraplegic for all we know.

It is a entirely irrelevant whether a poster bets that she could work, the government accept that she can’t and therefore we look at the thread and respond based on what we know, not on whether we want to tie her in with benefits cheats.

@OneHazelBird

and this

BlueFahrenheit · Today 00:05

Boreded · Today 00:02

I HAVE NOT JUDGED THE OP FOR NOT HAVING HER OWN HOME!!!!!!!

I need you to read this and understand.

I have:

  1. told multiple people off for accusing her of having a fake disability for the benefits
  2. suggested that it is her brother and his partner that should not be living in the house because they can work, that would give her soace

And 3 as a completely totally unrelated note, agreed with a comment someone made about not having children if you can’t afford to house them.

I HAVE NOT SAID: that disabled people should have children if they can’t afford to house them…I was incredibly clear on that.

I HAVE NOT SAID That the Op isn’t disabled. That is other people.

Stop making up lies!

Edited

You cannot reason with the unreasonable. When people repeatedly dismiss facts, logic, and evidence in favour of emotion, meaningful discussion becomes impossible.

Comeatmeibite · Today 00:06

Kirbert2 · Yesterday 23:36

It's also possible that OP was in a better situation than she is now when her child was born 9 years ago. Circumstances can change.

I could afford to provide for my child...and then I couldn't. Sometimes everything falls apart and you are left with nothing.

Whilst that is true, too many people don't plan for their circumstances changing.

I saved for 20 years, got myself into a position of being self-sufficient and took out insurance, before having a child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread