Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Who has chosen NOT to medicate their ADHD child?

108 replies

Peekaboooooo · 15/10/2026 07:33

I really want to hear experiences from parents who have chosen NOT to go down the medication route for their child. Forums are filled with stories of medication being amazing for ADHD and don't get me wrong, I know it's been hugely helpful for many children and adults but it would be good to get other experiences.

I'm a primary school teacher and I've taught an increasing number of children medicated for ADHD in recent years. I can clearly see the benefits in the classroom but I also see the side effects - low mood and depression, loss of appetite and weight loss, difficulty sleeping resulting in children coming in late or falling off to sleep in school.

My son is 8 and was diagnosed with ADHD at 6.5. He is textbook ADHD. However, for now, I feel like we are managing his symptoms and behaviour at home and school. It can be hard work but we just don't feel that medication is right yet. We've worked hard on his sleep routine and for a child with ADHD I think we've got it pretty good so don't want to rock the boat there. My son is naturally quite a lanky, thin child and a loss of appetite and weight would be very concerning for his health I feel. He really can't afford to lose weight.

In the future, if things get harder, we wouldn't rule out medication but for now we feel that the negatives would outweigh the positives.

There definitely seems to be a pressure and bias out there now to medicate so please share any non medicated stories. As a balance is always good. Thank you.

OP posts:
hooloola · 16/10/2026 09:28

ThaneOfGlamis · 15/10/2026 18:56

Who decides what the correct balance is? If an adhd brain was an evolutionary problem, it would have died out. But it didn't, which makes the issues cultural.

I repeat that I have not said I am against medication where it helps the individual. I am against the push to sameify (possibly made up word) everyone. It does us no benefit as a society to flatten out the diversity that made us great innovators.

Would you say the same about a child who lived with chronic pain regarding pain meds? Some can live with chronic pain using lifestyle modifications. Others can’t and need medication to manage the pain so that they can function and cope with everyday life. How is ADHD medication any different? It’s helping to address issues caused by a physiological issue that impacts on daily functioning and can have a huge physical and psychological toll on a child. Meds aren’t for everyone, but for some they are life changing.

Lizzbear · 16/10/2026 09:29

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/10/2026 09:20

Elvanse (lisdexamfetamine) for me. But go with the one your doctor suggests. DC2 and I have the same psychiatrist and we are on different medications. She said to me something like “Dizzy, my feeling is that lisdexamfetamine will work best for you. However, I am happy for you for you to try a few of DC2’s MPH it you want to see what they we like.” I tried both and her hunch was right.

I also take a very low dose of fluoxetine (ant-depressant). What I found with Elvanse is that it took away my anxiety and then I had a concentrated ‘dose’ of it in the late afternoon/evening when the Elvanse had worn off. The fluoxetine smooths things out and stops that rollercoaster effect.
My anxiety and mood are indeed vastly better than they have been for many years.

Thanks Dizzy
I’m currently on 75mg of venlefaxin for anxiety and depression. I hope the ADHD meds will work alongside it. But will probably try to gradually reduce the venlefaxin if the ADHD meds improve my overall mood.

Halleluj · 16/10/2026 09:32

Seagulldancing · 16/10/2026 08:57

Look at Mumsnet user surveys for the answer to that question. We tend to be well educated with good careers (which may or may not have survived having children, especially ones with disabilities), which will lean responses towards valuing education and economic independence.

I mean that’s a fair point in the same way I’ve seen people push abortion unless they have a perfect career and are 30+ on here. Worth bearing in mind a lot rightly or wrongly value that over everything else on here. ADHD meds will make anyone concentrate better adhd or not there’s a reason they used them on pilots in World War Two. There was also a big thing of students in Asia abusing Ritalin to get better grades

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

hooloola · 16/10/2026 09:36

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 04:44

I'm curious about why there's such a bias towards medicating ADHD on Mumsnet? Interestingly, I posed the exact same thing on a different forum and got much more balanced views. There's very little about not medicating ADHD in general on Mumsnet. In reality, I know this isn't a true reflection of all ADHD cases but Mumsnet seems very one sided on this one 🤔

You asked for opinions. Is it a bias to follow clinical best practice regarding treatment of a condition if the treatment is right for the individual? You can swap ADHD for any other physical/ psychological condition. Would there be the same “bias” there?
You talked in other posts about square pegs in round holes. But don’t you think having brain / mind that is constantly noisy with a million thoughts at once could actually be very challenging to live with?
Medication certainly isn’t for everyone, but the reasons to / to not take it should be based on clinical need / benefits v not rather than a starting point of medication being inherently negative. We don’t think that about insulin, do we?

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 09:39

WaterlooBridge · 16/10/2026 08:15

You’ve had a quite a number of thoughtful and balanced responses on this thread and your response is to dismiss them as one sided “bias”. It’s not bias, it’s posters actual experiences.

I suppose that should have been clear when you just asked for responses from those who choose not to medicate.

However, I did ask to hear from people who have not medicated in my original post.

OP posts:
AnonyMumAuDHD · 16/10/2026 09:43

Halleluj · 16/10/2026 09:32

I mean that’s a fair point in the same way I’ve seen people push abortion unless they have a perfect career and are 30+ on here. Worth bearing in mind a lot rightly or wrongly value that over everything else on here. ADHD meds will make anyone concentrate better adhd or not there’s a reason they used them on pilots in World War Two. There was also a big thing of students in Asia abusing Ritalin to get better grades

There was also a big thing of students in Asia abusing Ritalin to get better grades

Actually I discussed this with my clinician - the view is that taking these meds if you are not ADHD impairs cognitive function and makes you less effective (ie it makes you high). If the cohort of students who are taking it ‘illegally’ are benefiting, then it is actually more likely that that they are in fact undiagnosed ADHD (hence they are struggling and seeking out medicated support). They are inadvertently self medicating for a condition they do actually have.

Halleluj · 16/10/2026 09:47

AnonyMumAuDHD · 16/10/2026 09:43

There was also a big thing of students in Asia abusing Ritalin to get better grades

Actually I discussed this with my clinician - the view is that taking these meds if you are not ADHD impairs cognitive function and makes you less effective (ie it makes you high). If the cohort of students who are taking it ‘illegally’ are benefiting, then it is actually more likely that that they are in fact undiagnosed ADHD (hence they are struggling and seeking out medicated support). They are inadvertently self medicating for a condition they do actually have.

Edited

There’s other clinicians who would disagree. To get high you take more than you would take to concentrate on a task. They were used in World War Two for pilots doing long flights. Did all the pilots have adhd?

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/10/2026 09:57

Halleluj · 16/10/2026 09:20

I mean yeah they have been around for decades, became common in the 90s. But at the same time I’ve heard a LOT of people who were put on them as kids back then and are now adults say they wish their parents hadn’t done it.

Tricky ground for sure because there’s also people who say they wish their parents had put them on meds but these are usually the same people who only got diagnosed as adults from private clinics and if we’re being brutally honest seem to have jumped on a bandwagon and made it their personality trait.

The meds would make anyone concentrate better even people without adhd, I’m pretty sure they were using them on pilots in World War Two. But you’ve gotta weigh that up with the side effects

There has been scientific research on how ADHD meds affect healthy people compared to those with ADHD. It is a lot more complicated than ‘they would make anyone concentrate better’. The very short summary is yes they help anyone’s cognitive abilities but only very mildly with people who don’t have ADHD. In addition, ADHD drugs reduce ADHD symptoms such as impulsivity, inattention and hyperactivity, all of which can be incredibly disruptive.

As for your comment about adults who have made ADHD into their personality. Try to understand how shattering it is to get an ADHD diagnosis as as adult. On the one hand, it is a massive relief - I’m genuinely not bad, lazy, stupid etc - but it usually starts off a kind of grieving process about what could have been. It actually takes a few years to process an ADHD diagnosis because you end up viewing your whole life through a different lens.’It really is a major life event.

As for the people you know who were put on meds as children and are not happy about that in retrospect - reasons will be very individual and I don’t personally know anyone in that position. I’ve no idea whether this is a common experience or not. Perhaps their concerns were ignored at the time? Perhaps they had side effects they didn’t like?

ADHD stimulants are known to be effective. Taking them is a personal decision and not all drugs work for everyone.

ElsaMars · 16/10/2026 10:02

My child isn't on any medication and won't be until they can make the educated decision themselves. The reason I got them diagnosed was partially so that their ADHD and Autism wouldn't be mistaken for something else, like anxiety, depression or a personality disorder. The other reason is that I went through life undiagnosed and it made me feel so different to everyone else. Them having their diagnosis will hopefully help in understanding these feelings.

Halleluj · 16/10/2026 10:07

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/10/2026 09:57

There has been scientific research on how ADHD meds affect healthy people compared to those with ADHD. It is a lot more complicated than ‘they would make anyone concentrate better’. The very short summary is yes they help anyone’s cognitive abilities but only very mildly with people who don’t have ADHD. In addition, ADHD drugs reduce ADHD symptoms such as impulsivity, inattention and hyperactivity, all of which can be incredibly disruptive.

As for your comment about adults who have made ADHD into their personality. Try to understand how shattering it is to get an ADHD diagnosis as as adult. On the one hand, it is a massive relief - I’m genuinely not bad, lazy, stupid etc - but it usually starts off a kind of grieving process about what could have been. It actually takes a few years to process an ADHD diagnosis because you end up viewing your whole life through a different lens.’It really is a major life event.

As for the people you know who were put on meds as children and are not happy about that in retrospect - reasons will be very individual and I don’t personally know anyone in that position. I’ve no idea whether this is a common experience or not. Perhaps their concerns were ignored at the time? Perhaps they had side effects they didn’t like?

ADHD stimulants are known to be effective. Taking them is a personal decision and not all drugs work for everyone.

If you mind me asking how old you are? I’m mid 20s so went to school with and know a lot of people who had adhd and took meds. I guess if you were 40 or 50 that wouldn’t be a common experience (don’t take offence at me assuming you’re older that’s just been my experience of average mumsnet users as a long time lurker)
But yeah a lot had their concerns ignored because they were 7/8/9 years old. I cant blame the parents for that if the doctor told them it was for the best. I’ve always ignored my sons “concerns” about teeth brushing lol

No disrespect meant towards EVERYONE that got a diagnosis as an adult but I know someone like I described who never stops talking about it actually went to school with her where she was well behaved and got good grades (which I’m sure you’ll point out I’m not in her head so shouldnt presume to know anything) I’m not saying every adult diagnosed with adhd is like that though

namechange0998776554799000 · 16/10/2026 10:17

I think the point a lot of people are trying to make, based on their experience, is that if you choose not to medicate but later change your mind it may take a very long time to actually get the medication. So, keeping your options open definitely has its advantages.

As I said before we tried a few options a few years ago but ultimately my son remained unmedicated. Since you asked for 'non medicated stories', my DS hasn't been to school for a year and is a very very bad way. He was at a special school but was completely unable to cope. He is also autistic, so who knows if ADHD medication would have helped if he'd been able to take it, but I certainly can't give you any positive anecdotes.

AnonyMumAuDHD · 16/10/2026 10:22

Halleluj · 16/10/2026 10:07

If you mind me asking how old you are? I’m mid 20s so went to school with and know a lot of people who had adhd and took meds. I guess if you were 40 or 50 that wouldn’t be a common experience (don’t take offence at me assuming you’re older that’s just been my experience of average mumsnet users as a long time lurker)
But yeah a lot had their concerns ignored because they were 7/8/9 years old. I cant blame the parents for that if the doctor told them it was for the best. I’ve always ignored my sons “concerns” about teeth brushing lol

No disrespect meant towards EVERYONE that got a diagnosis as an adult but I know someone like I described who never stops talking about it actually went to school with her where she was well behaved and got good grades (which I’m sure you’ll point out I’m not in her head so shouldnt presume to know anything) I’m not saying every adult diagnosed with adhd is like that though

I’ve posted above about the impact of not taking meds on my kids, but I do actually agree that meds are often prescribed too soon. It is quite clear my DS struggled by y 5/6, as he was allowed to wear noise excluders, was often sat at a desk in the corridor to do ‘quiet’ work or tests without the distraction of others (which in turn meant he was distracting back - but at this stage just the excessive chatting/goofing around). I asked at the time whether we should be seeking a Ed Psych eval - for ADHD/Autism or anything - and the staff laughed and said no, just a chatty child but we’re managing it.

Thing is, even if I had marched him off for diagnosis, I am not sure that i would have opted for meds at that point anyway - because they were adapting the environment and managing it already (without realising what they were managing). For many kids it really is only when they get to secondary school and the content/style/variety and pace of lessons changes, becomes more unrelenting, class sizes become bigger (and change each period if you are streamed), the environment both more rigid and frenetic that having ADHD becomes disabling [for some].

So, whilst I absolutely feel we should be open to offering medicated support once we get to GCSE/exam territory, I do agree that I think we are perhaps too quick for some children to resort to it without looking at other management measures. It needs to be a child centred decision.

NormasArse · 16/10/2026 10:23

We didn’t medicate our DS, but we did manage his diet very carefully, and looked for a school with a heavy sports timetable. He also did a lot of sport outside school. He once told me that the rules in team sports made him feel ‘safe’. He also swam, and ran long distance, but didn’t enjoy that as much.

I have worked with children who I absolutely knew would benefit from medication though. I think it definitely depends on the child.

Fwiw, I wish I’d been medicated for school- my ADHD is inattentive, and I spent so much energy trying to focus that I’d inevitably fall asleep. DS was more impulsive, and our strategy for him seemed to work.

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/10/2026 10:27

Halleluj · 16/10/2026 10:07

If you mind me asking how old you are? I’m mid 20s so went to school with and know a lot of people who had adhd and took meds. I guess if you were 40 or 50 that wouldn’t be a common experience (don’t take offence at me assuming you’re older that’s just been my experience of average mumsnet users as a long time lurker)
But yeah a lot had their concerns ignored because they were 7/8/9 years old. I cant blame the parents for that if the doctor told them it was for the best. I’ve always ignored my sons “concerns” about teeth brushing lol

No disrespect meant towards EVERYONE that got a diagnosis as an adult but I know someone like I described who never stops talking about it actually went to school with her where she was well behaved and got good grades (which I’m sure you’ll point out I’m not in her head so shouldnt presume to know anything) I’m not saying every adult diagnosed with adhd is like that though

Being well behaved at school and having good grades can be perfectly normal witb ADHD, especially girls. I was like that as was DC2. My psychiatrist and my GP both have ADHD. No idea about their behaviour at school but they obviously must have got outstanding grades. This tends to happen with people who are female, very bright, perfectionist and conscientious. And yes I agree, you cannot look in their heads! What is happening is they they are working VERY hard and have all sorts of stressful systems in place to keep them on track. They are often absolutely exhausted on the evenings and weekend due to this. Eventually there is a big risk of crashing and burning - which is what happened to me. I am now too ill to work which my psychiatrist puts down to the stress of living with undiagnosed ADHD and autism and untreated ADHD. And yes, you are right, I am in my 50s.

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 11:30

When my son was diagnosed with ADHD at 6.5, the consultant prescribed medication straight away. No other support, advice, just medication. (That didn't surprise me as I know how shocking the system is in our area. The best support often comes from charities and other agencies outside the NHS in my experience.) Anyway, we weren't going to give the medication to our son but asked our very trusted pharmacist about it, just for his opinion, and he was shocked that a consultant would suggest it at such a young age, with the side effects too.

I've been teaching many years now in primary schools and the amount of children under the age of 10 on medication for adhd now is quite staggering. I've taught children falling off to sleep on their tables because the medication has interfered with sleep. Children who I can honestly say present as depressed, even dark, suicidal thoughts. I've seen the weight loss on some which isn't nice in some cases. I'm talking primary children here, yrs 2, 3, 4. I understand things might be different in secondary as they are more developed, have greater understanding, etc. Obviously there are some primary children who have extreme ADHD and need it for their own safety and that of others in some cases. However, for lesser extremes of ADHD, like my son, I really don't feel it's right to medicate based on what I've seen first hand and his own circumstances. Maybe in the future but not at such a young age.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 16/10/2026 11:54

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 04:44

I'm curious about why there's such a bias towards medicating ADHD on Mumsnet? Interestingly, I posed the exact same thing on a different forum and got much more balanced views. There's very little about not medicating ADHD in general on Mumsnet. In reality, I know this isn't a true reflection of all ADHD cases but Mumsnet seems very one sided on this one 🤔

At least in my case, I am quite passionately pro ADHD medication online because I see a lot of anti-medication sentiment, fears, worries, anxiety, stigma, concerns - and I think as a whole, in general, particularly in the UK/Europe (perhaps it's different in the US?) the feeling is heavily biased against ADHD medication for children, and I think this is unhelpful because it gives parents this impression that it ought to be a last resort, that they have perhaps failed if they can't manage their child's ADHD without medication. I think this is deeply unhelpful and so many parents are putting off medication for longer than they should and the problem is that untreated ADHD left too long can result in a sort of "cascade effect" of problems which medication will not instantly undo.

But the other way around, if you try medication and don't like it, you can literally instantly undo this. They can stop taking it the next day (I would recommend trialling for a couple of weeks but you can genuinely stop at any time.) The risks are extremely low. The benefits are potentially huge. The risks of not medicating can be devastating and people don't consider this enough.

When I pick up my 8yo's medication from the pharmacy, I worry about whether they are judging me. I know this is irrational, that it is their job to dispense medicine.

I am an adult and take medication daily. I probably will always need to. There is some suggestion from research that the earlier children start on ADHD medication, the less likely they are to need it in adulthood. I wouldn't start a child on it who didn't seem to need it at all, but if there is a query about whether it would benefit them, I think the balance SHOULD tip in the direction of trying it out.

Seagulldancing · 16/10/2026 11:57

Unless your primary age child is about to be excluded from school or is very upset and anxious, I agree managing without drugs is worth a go. But puberty is a challenge and things will change then. So having the back up option of medication is useful. As in my PP my ADHDer managed ok with intensive excerise (all self driven) until age 17, but now she won't consider life unmedicated, its really helped her deal with the adult world.

namechange0998776554799000 · 16/10/2026 13:53

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 11:30

When my son was diagnosed with ADHD at 6.5, the consultant prescribed medication straight away. No other support, advice, just medication. (That didn't surprise me as I know how shocking the system is in our area. The best support often comes from charities and other agencies outside the NHS in my experience.) Anyway, we weren't going to give the medication to our son but asked our very trusted pharmacist about it, just for his opinion, and he was shocked that a consultant would suggest it at such a young age, with the side effects too.

I've been teaching many years now in primary schools and the amount of children under the age of 10 on medication for adhd now is quite staggering. I've taught children falling off to sleep on their tables because the medication has interfered with sleep. Children who I can honestly say present as depressed, even dark, suicidal thoughts. I've seen the weight loss on some which isn't nice in some cases. I'm talking primary children here, yrs 2, 3, 4. I understand things might be different in secondary as they are more developed, have greater understanding, etc. Obviously there are some primary children who have extreme ADHD and need it for their own safety and that of others in some cases. However, for lesser extremes of ADHD, like my son, I really don't feel it's right to medicate based on what I've seen first hand and his own circumstances. Maybe in the future but not at such a young age.

Wow I'm surprised by that, our experience was a very slow process with lots of medical checks, discussions etc and no pressure at all to medicate, just lots of information given so we could make an informed decision. It must be very area specific.

StillSpartacus · 16/10/2026 21:55

BertieBotts · 16/10/2026 11:54

At least in my case, I am quite passionately pro ADHD medication online because I see a lot of anti-medication sentiment, fears, worries, anxiety, stigma, concerns - and I think as a whole, in general, particularly in the UK/Europe (perhaps it's different in the US?) the feeling is heavily biased against ADHD medication for children, and I think this is unhelpful because it gives parents this impression that it ought to be a last resort, that they have perhaps failed if they can't manage their child's ADHD without medication. I think this is deeply unhelpful and so many parents are putting off medication for longer than they should and the problem is that untreated ADHD left too long can result in a sort of "cascade effect" of problems which medication will not instantly undo.

But the other way around, if you try medication and don't like it, you can literally instantly undo this. They can stop taking it the next day (I would recommend trialling for a couple of weeks but you can genuinely stop at any time.) The risks are extremely low. The benefits are potentially huge. The risks of not medicating can be devastating and people don't consider this enough.

When I pick up my 8yo's medication from the pharmacy, I worry about whether they are judging me. I know this is irrational, that it is their job to dispense medicine.

I am an adult and take medication daily. I probably will always need to. There is some suggestion from research that the earlier children start on ADHD medication, the less likely they are to need it in adulthood. I wouldn't start a child on it who didn't seem to need it at all, but if there is a query about whether it would benefit them, I think the balance SHOULD tip in the direction of trying it out.

100 % agree with this. If a child can manage with adaptations, and many can in primary, that’s fine. But the move to secondary, with its additional demands, less nurturing environment and a surge of hormones is often a different story.

But some children really need medication to support them to learn in primary and parents shouldn’t be judged for helping them. Enabling a child to learn and keep up with their peers, supports their wider development, not just acquisition of knowledge.

The decision will always be individual based on the needs of the child, but it’s so important to keep an open mind. If a child is struggling and can be helped, why on earth wouldn’t you try?

IAlreadyHadMyCoffee · 17/10/2026 10:13

I'd be very careful starting ADHD meds for those who are also autistic, they'd need more careful monitoring and more likely to experience increase in autism traits. It's also unlikely to work as well for those who have been misdiagnosed with ADHD but have other conditions such as FADS for example.

flumpkeu · 17/10/2026 10:27

IAlreadyHadMyCoffee · 17/10/2026 10:13

I'd be very careful starting ADHD meds for those who are also autistic, they'd need more careful monitoring and more likely to experience increase in autism traits. It's also unlikely to work as well for those who have been misdiagnosed with ADHD but have other conditions such as FADS for example.

Edited

My son is AuADHD and been on meds for over a year, never heard this and have seen no increase in his autistic “traits”. This has never been discussed in our regular medication reviews. Most ADHD people are autistic, even if not diagnosed.

StormGazing · 17/10/2026 10:36

My child is 14 and had been suffering years of crazy brain, frustration leading to self harm, over stimulation, overwhelming periods, the meds have been an absolute game changer for him. He forgot to take them one morning on a weekend and he said how grateful he was to have the meds as he’d forgotten how bad he was without them, so formula it’s a no, he seems stable, his appetite has gone down a little but he’s still has quite a muscular frame and is 6 feet 2 already

IAlreadyHadMyCoffee · 17/10/2026 10:54

flumpkeu · 17/10/2026 10:27

My son is AuADHD and been on meds for over a year, never heard this and have seen no increase in his autistic “traits”. This has never been discussed in our regular medication reviews. Most ADHD people are autistic, even if not diagnosed.

Not a medical journal but it gives the general idea. Same goes for antidepressants when used for autistic patients.

www.additudemag.com/audhd-medication-side-effects/

Trappedinthecastofawhodunnit · 17/10/2026 11:08

flumpkeu · 17/10/2026 10:27

My son is AuADHD and been on meds for over a year, never heard this and have seen no increase in his autistic “traits”. This has never been discussed in our regular medication reviews. Most ADHD people are autistic, even if not diagnosed.

My ds reports increase in his autism traits when he takes adhd meds - he’s an adult and he manages his drugs on a minimum needs basis.

StuntNun · 17/10/2026 12:30

IAlreadyHadMyCoffee · 17/10/2026 10:13

I'd be very careful starting ADHD meds for those who are also autistic, they'd need more careful monitoring and more likely to experience increase in autism traits. It's also unlikely to work as well for those who have been misdiagnosed with ADHD but have other conditions such as FADS for example.

Edited

I’m surprised at this. My autistic son has ADHD and methyphenidate helps enormously with both stimming and with his anxiety.