Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Who has chosen NOT to medicate their ADHD child?

108 replies

Peekaboooooo · 15/10/2026 07:33

I really want to hear experiences from parents who have chosen NOT to go down the medication route for their child. Forums are filled with stories of medication being amazing for ADHD and don't get me wrong, I know it's been hugely helpful for many children and adults but it would be good to get other experiences.

I'm a primary school teacher and I've taught an increasing number of children medicated for ADHD in recent years. I can clearly see the benefits in the classroom but I also see the side effects - low mood and depression, loss of appetite and weight loss, difficulty sleeping resulting in children coming in late or falling off to sleep in school.

My son is 8 and was diagnosed with ADHD at 6.5. He is textbook ADHD. However, for now, I feel like we are managing his symptoms and behaviour at home and school. It can be hard work but we just don't feel that medication is right yet. We've worked hard on his sleep routine and for a child with ADHD I think we've got it pretty good so don't want to rock the boat there. My son is naturally quite a lanky, thin child and a loss of appetite and weight would be very concerning for his health I feel. He really can't afford to lose weight.

In the future, if things get harder, we wouldn't rule out medication but for now we feel that the negatives would outweigh the positives.

There definitely seems to be a pressure and bias out there now to medicate so please share any non medicated stories. As a balance is always good. Thank you.

OP posts:
TheRealSmurfette · 15/10/2026 20:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Not a reason to medicate a child. Jesus!

yesiknowithasbeendonetodeath · 15/10/2026 20:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What a horrible post

AnonyMumAuDHD · 15/10/2026 21:09

Peekaboooooo · 15/10/2026 19:41

I'm really not anti adhd medication and like I said in the op, it may be needed for my son in the future. However, in general I feel like it's almost expected after a diagnosis. With so many children and adults being diagnosed with ADHD, does everyone need medicating? Obviously depending on severity.

It’s not all or nothing, though? Sometimes when you have a headache you can put up with and push through, other times taking painkillers is the only way to get through the day. You could argue that we should need to take a painkiller, that we should just be able to opt out of work, parenting, commuting, school and go to bed until it passes - but not doing so, pressing on with those things isn’t considered ‘forcing a round peg into a square hole’, is it? It’s regarded as getting on with normal life.

Getting through the school day, however you may feel about the flaws in the system, is an essential part of existing in modern life. Yes, it is a shame it is so rigid and one-size-fits all so that many children struggle [and not just ND kids, I would point out]. But it is the system we have and it prepares children for the world they have to live in when they are adults. So why wouldn’t you add ADHD medication into the mix as readily as you would take calpol or antibiotics - which all work to achieve the same end? Enabling them to function in school?

If taking medication helps a child regulate on high intensity days, and therefore be less burned out and more able to manage the lower intensity days, why wouldn’t you consider taking it in the same way that you might take paracetamol. It’s just an aid.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Dontlletmedownbruce · 15/10/2026 21:25

Dh was very against meds, I was in favour because DS was so difficult. He wasn't too bad at school and was coping with movement breaks but he was masking heavily and difficult at home. He has Autism diagnosis since early years and ADHD since 10. I also was worried about side effects but like any other medication, you don't know if these affect you til you try. Also in some cases the meds are so beneficial that it's worth side effects. Dh wasn't adamant, just leaning that way. It was a moot point cos DS said he would absolutely refuse any medication because there was nothing wrong with him. He also told nothing to the psychologist because she was a 'stupid nosey bitch' apparently. He refuses to acknowledge his autism 'that's just for retards and I'm not one..' so that's what we were up against. So he had no meds, or OT or anything really that would have helped. At 18 now he is mature and says he will self manage for now but will consider medication if he feels he is getting worse. A part of me wishes I had hidden it in his food back then to see but it's done now. He is an A student and an athlete, every minute is accounted for and he has amazing hyperfocus now. He really is a shining example of how to cope without meds, if you see it from his perspective only. He nearly broke me for years with his behaviour though. I know it's not about me but there should be some consideration of the families of sufferers too and whether they would benefit.

CostcoFanofThree · 16/10/2026 02:56

my dd resists medicating my dgs. partially because dgs doesn't like the drugs effects and she's struggling with getting a medication review. but like others, he took it on an irregular basis; not on holidays or weekends, not on school sports days etc.
dgs attends a private school with extra pe provision (morning swim) something mid day and then more after school. he bikes or walks to school. he finds the treadmill and the peloton really beneficial.

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 04:44

I'm curious about why there's such a bias towards medicating ADHD on Mumsnet? Interestingly, I posed the exact same thing on a different forum and got much more balanced views. There's very little about not medicating ADHD in general on Mumsnet. In reality, I know this isn't a true reflection of all ADHD cases but Mumsnet seems very one sided on this one 🤔

OP posts:
StillSpartacus · 16/10/2026 07:45

I think it is important to keep an open mind and to be aware that medication needs can change at different stages of childhood. Remember too that medication is flexible and that stimulants, which are effective in the most people are short acting and don’t need to be taken every day.

Your child’s clinical team are best placed to help, but where appetite is a concern, options like weekend breaks, or not using meds during holidays can be tried. Obviously it’s important to eat breakfast, to try to eat something at lunch and then to eat an evening meal once the medication has worn off. The medication shouldn’t be affecting sleep as even 12 hour formulations will have worn off by bedtime in school age children. Although sleep issues can be a feature in ND children, they are usually due to the condition itself or lifestyle factors, not medication.

Whilst not every child needs medication, as a teacher, you will know the benefits of helping a child access learning once they can concentrate and focus on one thing at once. It’s great for their self esteem too and being more regulated can help them socially. Not being left behind their peers is an additional benefit. I think at an age when they have so much to learn, it can really help to make sure they can.

StillSpartacus · 16/10/2026 08:13

Sorry, another point because this one really, really bugs me. “It will change their personality” no it won’t. The medication is boosting their (low) levels of dopamine
and noradrenaline, not sedating them.

If your child is energetic, bright, creative and fun they will still be all of those things, but having more control can mean using their energy in less risky ways. Having 2 or 3 thoughts in their head instead of 27 means they can concentrate, learn and give free rein to their creativity with impressive results. Being able to think, not be driven by a motor will help their relationships with peers and at home so that they can genuinely find enjoyment and satisfaction with their lives.

I absolutely agree that meds aren’t for everyone, but it’s sad when parents won’t try medicine due to misinformation and understandable fears. It’s the one treatment that is proven to work and is thought to be effective in around 80% of people with ADHD.

WaterlooBridge · 16/10/2026 08:15

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 04:44

I'm curious about why there's such a bias towards medicating ADHD on Mumsnet? Interestingly, I posed the exact same thing on a different forum and got much more balanced views. There's very little about not medicating ADHD in general on Mumsnet. In reality, I know this isn't a true reflection of all ADHD cases but Mumsnet seems very one sided on this one 🤔

You’ve had a quite a number of thoughtful and balanced responses on this thread and your response is to dismiss them as one sided “bias”. It’s not bias, it’s posters actual experiences.

I suppose that should have been clear when you just asked for responses from those who choose not to medicate.

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/10/2026 08:21

ThaneOfGlamis · 15/10/2026 08:11

I refuse to drug my children to make them fit society's expectations. If schools were designed around children's actual development and need to move then there may be less "need" for medication anyway. Plus mine are also autistic, so no medication would changethat.

That said, I am fully supportive of medication if they ever want it in future, or feel it would help them. I wouldn't be at all surprised if it would help for gcse's etc. I am not anti medication, it just needs to be for the right reasons, not drugging children into compliance.

I agree with you to some extent but I think it is more complicated than that. You are right in my view to say that children should not be drugged simply for the convenience of society. So schools should accommode children’s needs with movement breaks etc. This , I’m sure is actually good for all children, ADHD or not. However, ADHD stimulants do have benefits to the patient - for example a child might really want to listen to their maths lesson but find they cannot because their mind keeps wandering no matter how hard they try, so in this case medication might help.

Regarding your comment about drugs not eliminating autism - interestingly, my psychiatrist, who is one of the most experienced specialists in ADHD and autism in the UK, believes that ADHD meds also help with autism. No idea if she is right but given her decades of experience, she could be. She is obviously not saying that it cancels out autism though.

Phineyj · 16/10/2026 08:24

Us. Our DC is 13. I just don't feel she eats or sleeps well enough to put her on a medication that affects appetite and sleeping. She has been on melatonin since 7 and we see a nutritionist.

She's quite able to keep up at school with only half her attention though, otherwise I might feel differently.

If SHE wants to explore medication when she's older I'll support her with that. I'm not anti medication and I know people it works for.

A really good book is A Parents' Guide to ADHD Medication.

Phineyj · 16/10/2026 08:25

Just to add that she almost certainly has RSD and when I have considered medication it's to manage that not for concentration. Because I do worry about her doing something rash when in a state.

Lizzbear · 16/10/2026 08:31

dizzydizzydizzy · 15/10/2026 08:04

I forgot to say - my mood and anxiety are vastly better on ADHD meds. It could be that the kids you know who have problems in that area would actually have much worse problems without them.

Hi Dizzy
I'm about to start titration for ADHD meds. I want one that improves my mood if possible. Regulates it. Which one has helped you please?

Phineyj · 16/10/2026 08:35

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 04:44

I'm curious about why there's such a bias towards medicating ADHD on Mumsnet? Interestingly, I posed the exact same thing on a different forum and got much more balanced views. There's very little about not medicating ADHD in general on Mumsnet. In reality, I know this isn't a true reflection of all ADHD cases but Mumsnet seems very one sided on this one 🤔

Probably because Mumsnet skews towards parents who are really interested in education and careers and who have the money and cultural capital to do something about it.

Although I don't think medication is necessary for my child right now, I have done enough research to know getting it would not be straightforward! Like the rest of it...assessment...diagnosis...support...EHCP...secondary transition...all left up to the parent to actively manage in our stupid system.

Phineyj · 16/10/2026 08:36

StillSpartacus · 16/10/2026 08:13

Sorry, another point because this one really, really bugs me. “It will change their personality” no it won’t. The medication is boosting their (low) levels of dopamine
and noradrenaline, not sedating them.

If your child is energetic, bright, creative and fun they will still be all of those things, but having more control can mean using their energy in less risky ways. Having 2 or 3 thoughts in their head instead of 27 means they can concentrate, learn and give free rein to their creativity with impressive results. Being able to think, not be driven by a motor will help their relationships with peers and at home so that they can genuinely find enjoyment and satisfaction with their lives.

I absolutely agree that meds aren’t for everyone, but it’s sad when parents won’t try medicine due to misinformation and understandable fears. It’s the one treatment that is proven to work and is thought to be effective in around 80% of people with ADHD.

The useful book I mentioned earlier makes it clear that these are very successful medications as medications go.

namechange0998776554799000 · 16/10/2026 08:50

We were advised by CAMHS to try out medication, because often children are ok at primary school but really struggle at secondary and the process of getting onto the right medication (or deciding against it) can take years. We tried it at age 8. The first two types of medication affected sleep & appetite too much, and he wouldn't take the third consistently (ASD/PDA). I'm glad we tried it when we did, so we weren't going into secondary feeling like we'd missed something.

If you're going via CAMHS, the waiting list for medication is likely years rather than months so it's worth considering agreeing to an initial appointment with a prescriber. You can always decide not to go ahead with the medication once you e discussed the pros & cons with a professional.

The first line medication only stays in your system for a matter of hours, so you can decide day by day whether to give it a try and no problem if you try it one day then decide against it the next having said that, my son didn't sleep or eat at all for the whole day - way after the 4 hours it was supposed to be out of the system

Seagulldancing · 16/10/2026 08:57

Peekaboooooo · 16/10/2026 04:44

I'm curious about why there's such a bias towards medicating ADHD on Mumsnet? Interestingly, I posed the exact same thing on a different forum and got much more balanced views. There's very little about not medicating ADHD in general on Mumsnet. In reality, I know this isn't a true reflection of all ADHD cases but Mumsnet seems very one sided on this one 🤔

Look at Mumsnet user surveys for the answer to that question. We tend to be well educated with good careers (which may or may not have survived having children, especially ones with disabilities), which will lean responses towards valuing education and economic independence.

AnonyMumAuDHD · 16/10/2026 09:06

WaterlooBridge · 16/10/2026 08:15

You’ve had a quite a number of thoughtful and balanced responses on this thread and your response is to dismiss them as one sided “bias”. It’s not bias, it’s posters actual experiences.

I suppose that should have been clear when you just asked for responses from those who choose not to medicate.

ETA original reply removed - Sorry was replying to a different post

but you are right - my first reply outlined the impact of my children NOT being medicated until after they turned 18 and highlighted the benefits they gained AFTER we experienced the difference. Thought that might provide balance, but not sure that was what was sought.

AnonyMumAuDHD · 16/10/2026 09:11

Last PP edited a billion times - am in bed with flu/covid or whatever and head like cotton wool!

Branleuse · 16/10/2026 09:11

In my family three of us have a dx of adhd and 2 of us, me and my eldest take medication for it and the other one was prescribed it when at secondary school, but he stopped taking it. He didn't like how it made him feel. I tried to encourage it because it definitely looked to help him focus in my opinion, but he didn't want to and didn't like it.

I think if he/we had persevered with medication and tried different types then we might be in a better position with him now as an adult.
He is actually similar to my nephew with untreated adhd. Overwhelmed life refuser.
My eldest is thriving and has used his medication as a tool to help him hold down a part time job and go to university. It has been fantastically helpful for him.

For me, I find it somewhat helpful.
I had to try a few things to get the right meds for me, and I can only tolerate low doses of short acting medication, as the long acting one affects my sleep. I don't like the one my son takes, as it makes me feel weird and fizzy in my brain.
Higher doses give me anxiety.

I have another relative who doesn't medicate herself but does use a lot of holistic things to manage such as yoga and healthy living.

The problem with medicating younger children I guess is that we rely a lot on how they act or behave with it because they may not be able to accurately describe how they feel or compare their state with or without it.

I would advise you to keep him under his paediatrician as long as possible and keep medication options open, because it is very different to try and get medication for the first time under adult services.

I think there's a lot of stigma about adhd medication and there can be pressure to do things naturally to manage.
In my opinion from my experience, I think that the people I know who medicate, manage better.
It isn't a miracle cure though and it's trial and error, and I think that it is better supported in paediatrics than it is in adult services.

Also you can trial medication and then stop it or change it if you felt it unhelpful or had side effects. It isn't a decision for life

Clonakilla · 16/10/2026 09:19

I’m not at all sure why you’re asking here. What does the treating consultant advise? What did they say when you asked about the balance of risks and benefits?

I can’t imagine that if the paediatrician recommended I use salbutamol to treat my son’s asthma I’d be on here asking random unqualified people if they’d decided not to treat asthma because of the potential side effects of salbutamol.

As an aside - we’d consider a side effect to be extremely common if it affected 10% of people - so 90 % unaffected.

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/10/2026 09:20

Lizzbear · 16/10/2026 08:31

Hi Dizzy
I'm about to start titration for ADHD meds. I want one that improves my mood if possible. Regulates it. Which one has helped you please?

Elvanse (lisdexamfetamine) for me. But go with the one your doctor suggests. DC2 and I have the same psychiatrist and we are on different medications. She said to me something like “Dizzy, my feeling is that lisdexamfetamine will work best for you. However, I am happy for you for you to try a few of DC2’s MPH it you want to see what they we like.” I tried both and her hunch was right.

I also take a very low dose of fluoxetine (ant-depressant). What I found with Elvanse is that it took away my anxiety and then I had a concentrated ‘dose’ of it in the late afternoon/evening when the Elvanse had worn off. The fluoxetine smooths things out and stops that rollercoaster effect.
My anxiety and mood are indeed vastly better than they have been for many years.

Halleluj · 16/10/2026 09:20

dizzydizzydizzy · 15/10/2026 07:49

I’m an adult with ADHD and on the medication. I did try a period without it and I felt terrible without it.

What you say does sound logical and well-considered but I would say that you appear to be assuming that the side affects will happen. The meds have not affected my sleep in any way. For appetite - they stop impulse eating chocolate but I still eat well but I am not skinny and in fact I went to lose a little weight.

These meds have been around for decades and are very effective. I don’t think you have anything much to lose by trying them and potentially a lot to gain from then. Friend’s DD got diagnosed at age 15 and her grades went up almost overnight from GCSE 3s and 4s to 6s and 7s.

I mean yeah they have been around for decades, became common in the 90s. But at the same time I’ve heard a LOT of people who were put on them as kids back then and are now adults say they wish their parents hadn’t done it.

Tricky ground for sure because there’s also people who say they wish their parents had put them on meds but these are usually the same people who only got diagnosed as adults from private clinics and if we’re being brutally honest seem to have jumped on a bandwagon and made it their personality trait.

The meds would make anyone concentrate better even people without adhd, I’m pretty sure they were using them on pilots in World War Two. But you’ve gotta weigh that up with the side effects

AnonyMumAuDHD · 16/10/2026 09:27

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/10/2026 09:20

Elvanse (lisdexamfetamine) for me. But go with the one your doctor suggests. DC2 and I have the same psychiatrist and we are on different medications. She said to me something like “Dizzy, my feeling is that lisdexamfetamine will work best for you. However, I am happy for you for you to try a few of DC2’s MPH it you want to see what they we like.” I tried both and her hunch was right.

I also take a very low dose of fluoxetine (ant-depressant). What I found with Elvanse is that it took away my anxiety and then I had a concentrated ‘dose’ of it in the late afternoon/evening when the Elvanse had worn off. The fluoxetine smooths things out and stops that rollercoaster effect.
My anxiety and mood are indeed vastly better than they have been for many years.

I second this - anxiety was a feature of each of my family’s ADHD, but in my case also affected by stress and the menopause. I was surprised at the lift in mood as it has also meant that although I was on the brink of starting escitalopram, once I had titrated onto Elvanse I didn;t need it any more.

I’m not sure it lifts your mood so much, as corrects the chemicals/helps you manage the ADHD so you stop having a low mood, if that makes sense? (Ie it’s not an active agent in mood control, but is fixing the stuff that is impacting mood, so your body self corrects). That may be clear as mud - no amount of ADHD meds can counter flu!! 😬

LarryUnderwood · 16/10/2026 09:28

It sounds like right now his needs are met and medication is not necessary. My son is on medication, has been since year 6, and it has been the difference between daily disruption at school (and the ensuing drama) and being able to manage in class most of the time. His weight is fine and he hasn't had any issues with mood. But he really really needs it to be able to cope with the demands of school, and as he progresses, to be able to focus at home for revision etc at the weekends (he's in yr 9 so not there yet but it's looming). If your son is managing well without it then that sounds good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread