Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Help - toilet training, should I quit after tough 1st day?

87 replies

SKLM · 14/10/2026 18:54

Hey everyone. Looking for some toilet training advice.

I am worried I have started trying to toilet train my boy who has just turned 2 too soon.

Background - We have had a potty around the house for months but he has still been in nappies. He was sitting on it out of curiosity from time to time and we talked about what it is for. Have talked a lot about wees and poos, he comes into the toilet when either me or my husband are using it and he knows mummy/daddy is having a wee/poo. He goes away discreetly to poo in his nappy. He enjoys washing his hands after nappy changes. He hasn't ever told us he needs a wee or poo or asked us to change his nappy.

So, some good signs I thought. I have a 5 day stretch to start trying to train, and his nursery are also on board. We have read a book about using the potty together and today went nappy free using those pants that hold a bit of urine (not pull ups).

Initially he seemed fine with it, put on the pants, and in the morning when coaxed would sit on his potty and he would help me pull down his pants etc. But he has become quite stressed as the day has gone on.

No success weeing/pooing in the potty. He is only weeing/pooing in the pants and doesn't seem bothered at all that they are wet or able to acknowledge they need changing. We have gone through 8 pairs today. We put a nappy back on for his nap this afternoon, removed it after and put pants back on. We have put a nappy back on now for bed. I was just following guidelines I read on this one.

He is refusing to sit on the potty since about 3pm and has been tearful when we gently coax him and has been saying no potty a lot and pushing it away. We have tried lifting him on a couple of times but he isn't interested. He has been pretty agitated all afternoon, I've noticed he seems pretty fed up and I am guessing it's the change as everything else is normal for him.

Have been suggesting potty every 1-2 hours.

If you have successfully potty trained, does this sound like a typical first day or have we started far too early?

I don't want to distress him at all but equally if this is par for the course I don't want to give up too soon.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
AlwaysPurple · 17/10/2026 10:14

SKLM · 17/10/2026 10:05

Hey guys - update and help required.

So day 3 and today (day 4) me and my husband are starting to think he just isn't ready.

We had some successes on day 2 as I posted. Since he woke up yesterday every single wee has been on the floor, but for about 3 hours in the morning he held everything in and looked uncomfortable until he couldn't hold it anymore. I have done the other bits of the routine - when I notice him weeing, sit him on the potty, explain etc, wash hands. Every time it has been too late and he doesn't need to wee in the potty anymore. He pooped in his nappy during his nap yesterday.

Today - again holding onto his wee since 7am when he woke up but he has had about 400ml of fluid, looks uncomfortable and again won't wee on the potty. Waiting for him to just give in and run off to wee somewhere which is what he did yesterday in the end.

I don't feel like anything is sinking in after 4 days and he just looks totally bemused by the potty and is getting stressed and resisting.

We are thinking it's time to stop this attempt and revisit? Please give me your honest opinions.

That does sound hard going! Could you bear one more day of trying given its the weekend? It does take kids longer than we expect! We didn't get anywhere until day 4 or 5.

Have you tried one of those insert seats on the proper toilet, instead of the potty? Our DD never liked the potty, has never done anything on it bar sit for 3 seconds! Who knows why but we just went with the toilet, less hassle anyway!

Askingforafriendtoday · 17/10/2026 10:41

I would recommend waiting, it worked for mine. As I said, they fetched their own potty, usually took it into the toilet them selves. They were interested, willing, not stressed in anyway. Not in nappies quite some time before nursery aged 3.5. Childminder was on board and delighted before that.

MintTwirl · 17/10/2026 10:54

SKLM · 17/10/2026 10:05

Hey guys - update and help required.

So day 3 and today (day 4) me and my husband are starting to think he just isn't ready.

We had some successes on day 2 as I posted. Since he woke up yesterday every single wee has been on the floor, but for about 3 hours in the morning he held everything in and looked uncomfortable until he couldn't hold it anymore. I have done the other bits of the routine - when I notice him weeing, sit him on the potty, explain etc, wash hands. Every time it has been too late and he doesn't need to wee in the potty anymore. He pooped in his nappy during his nap yesterday.

Today - again holding onto his wee since 7am when he woke up but he has had about 400ml of fluid, looks uncomfortable and again won't wee on the potty. Waiting for him to just give in and run off to wee somewhere which is what he did yesterday in the end.

I don't feel like anything is sinking in after 4 days and he just looks totally bemused by the potty and is getting stressed and resisting.

We are thinking it's time to stop this attempt and revisit? Please give me your honest opinions.

Go with your gut OP, you know your son better than anyone else and if you think it’s time to stop then it’s fine to do so. He is so little you have a long time for it to click into place for him.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

SKLM · 17/10/2026 11:03

Thanks for all the replies so far. It's a hard one isn't it. We don't have friends with toddlers, so no experiences for comparison, it's so helpful hearing from everyone.

We have put some big boy pants back on him for now and loose trousers, going to try sitting him on the potty throughout the day at intervals. We are also spending time out in the garden now doing some water play. He is looking much more relaxed. So we will keep things going today and tomorrow like that and speak to nursery on Monday. We have the weekend so why not use it I figure.

On Monday we will have 5 days of practice and evidence behind us to make a decision about whether or not to delay I think. :)

OP posts:
Oli34 · 17/10/2026 11:07

I would stop OP, you’ve given it a very good attempt but if he’s holding and refusing to go, in my option it’s too soon. I don’t think it should be that stressful, that doesn’t mean he won’t be ready in a couple of months.

Strawberries4days · 17/10/2026 11:12

I would wait a bit and start gradually again. My DD wasn't properly potty trained till she was 3 nearing onto 4. We have tried it throughout the months when she was 2 but had to give it a break because it was upsetting both of us.

If I can remember, we introduced the sticker chart when she was 3 and a kids toilet seat on the toilet with a kids stool of her favourite character. I asked every 1 hour to 2 hours if she needs to go to toilet and bring her with me when I went to the toilet and asked if she would like to try afterwards to see if there was any there.

Somehow worked but not every kid is the same. She still has accidents and I worked with her nursery and try to teach her when her body feels like it's time for the toilet, you go to the loo straight away, not after playing.

It's tough but you will get there. You know you're own child if they're ready. In the end, everyone knows how to use the toilet at some point so don't stress!
Sending good luck and hugs cause there's nothing worst than a crappy panty 😂😅

Strawberries4days · 17/10/2026 11:13

Also to edit I meant to say still had accidents when she was 3/4 not now she's 6, 😅

Mackerelfillets · 17/10/2026 12:04

I wouldnt push on. Leave it a few months. None of mine were ready until 2 and a half and the others were 3. Once they are ready there are only a few accidents. He isnt ready.

PinkWaffleMaker · 17/10/2026 12:11

Days 3 or 4 are always the hardest in my opinion. You’ve seen a glimmer of the fact they can do it but then they don’t.

I would carry on.

I wouldn’t change the method, or if you’ve changed it now stick to it. Changing how you teach him will confuse him and make it harder for him to learn.

Mischance · 17/10/2026 12:16

You've tested the water and found it is freezing!
I would wait a while now if I were you.

AlwaysPurple · 17/10/2026 13:18

If you do decide to pause and try again in a few months, you could try just offering the toilet/potty at convenient times. So we got into the habit of putting DD on the loo first thing in the morning, just before nap and again at bed time. She was in nappies the rest of the time, but helped her get used to the toilet, to the point where she preferred to poop on the loo rather in nappy, and so we didn't have poopy nappies for 2-3 months before we properly started training. But with no pressure.

SKLM · 17/10/2026 16:24

We keep getting signs of progress in between the difficult bits.

So he was holding everything in all morning, and actually he stayed almost completely dry during his nap. We gave him a drink when he woke up, and he walked over and sat on the potty. I said let me help you take your trousers and nappy off, he then sat down and did a big wee. He came off the potty and I asked if he was done, he was dripping a bit still, so he sat back down with a book and had another wee. He as done it one more time this afternoon since.

He was so pleased with himself, big smiles. He proudly put the clean potty insert back in the potty each time. He kept wanting to sit on it again and we said no we think you are done!

It felt to me and my husband that he was much more connected with what was happening and this time and he went on the potty of his own accord.

Fingers crossed! Will keep updating 😂

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread