Please or to access all these features

News

Russell Brand 🤢🤮 - crunch time

1000 replies

KidsDoBetter · 02/11/2026 11:18

Continuing the docky wock

don’t want to jinx it by referring to potentially Jaily Wail

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Dexternight · 04/11/2026 19:08

After I was on jury service I remembered chatting to the court clerk who told me they knew it would be guilty verdict if the jury came back quick.
Longer deliberations usually meant a non guilty verdict.

Thefrocklady · 04/11/2026 19:14

Bramble26 · 04/11/2026 18:59

I worry he’ll get off as the jury is made up of 8 men to 4 women. You’d think they’d have to have equal numbers in sexual assault / rape cases. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Most of his supporters are women.

LizzieSiddal · 04/11/2026 19:25

SpanishFly · 04/11/2026 18:12

also, I seem to have missed this story.........

The civil lawsuit against Russell Brand and Warner Bros. was filed in November 2023 (under the New York Adult Survivors Act) by an anonymous extra ("Jane Doe") regarding the 2010 film Arthur, and a Manhattan judge recently ruled that Warner Bros. cannot dismiss the case.

  • The Accusations: Jane Doe accuses Russell Brand of appearing intoxicated, exposing himself, and sexually assaulting her in a set bathroom during the filming of Arthur in July 2010, while alleging negligence and enabling behavior by the production companies.
  • The Legal Status: Brand has denied all allegations. In November 2026, a Manhattan judge rejected Warner Bros.' attempt to drop the lawsuit, allowing the case to move forward.

So if he gets found Not Guilty in this trial he has other accusations coming down the line. Good!!

IDasIX · 04/11/2026 19:59

I read today that a woman who worked as an extra on one of his films in the US sued him a few years ago for an assault that was very similar to the oral rape charge in this criminal trial.

I’m not sure what the outcome of that civil case was, but the woman has been given permission to also sue the film studio for their culpability.

KidsDoBetter · 04/11/2026 20:21

Dexternight · 04/11/2026 19:08

After I was on jury service I remembered chatting to the court clerk who told me they knew it would be guilty verdict if the jury came back quick.
Longer deliberations usually meant a non guilty verdict.

In this case at least, the number of separate charges is a factor. It took the judge nearly the whole court day yesterday to do his summing up - so for a jury to take each one, discuss and look through the routes to verdict will in and of itself take some time.

But certainly if we go on into next week without even going back to tell the judge they are majority only - that would worry me.

OP posts:
Picoloangel · 04/11/2026 20:27

I am v sceptical re the whole GOSH thing. I just don’t see that happening at all.

On the subject of expert evidence re reactions to assault etc the Judge will have given a direction re the fact that there is no single way people react. It is not necessary to have expert evidence in relation to this as it is something within the experience and understanding of ordinary people. Expert evidence is usually only called if it is necessary and works generally only if it is something totally beyond common sense or experience eg DNA, cell site, medical, psychiatric.

The vast majority of people are
capable of understanding different reactions and of understanding that what the barristers say is opinion not evidence.

Picoloangel · 04/11/2026 20:32

The jury do not dictate when a majority direction is given; that’s a decision for the Judge. It cannot be given less than 2 hours and 20 minutes after deliberations begin but the longer the case the longer the Judge will usually wait.
I am not so sure that long deliberations = acquittal. Some juries are v focused and fair and want to consider the evidence in detail. They may also be asking questions and sending notes to the Judge - depending on the note these can take some time to deal with.

IDasIX · 04/11/2026 20:36

The Scottish Government tried to introduce juryless trials for rape cases, but had to back down because opposition parties and the legal sector were strong against it.

I understand the reservations to an extent but I don’t think we’ll ever manage to get conviction rates off the floor while we still rely on juries.

A large number of people in the general population are not very bright. It’s apparent on the average Mumsnet thread that a lot of people struggle with basic comprehension, processing, and critical thinking.

AlonsoMosley · 04/11/2026 20:42

CoconutSwirl · 04/11/2026 15:18

But why are all these women laughing along with what he's doing/saying to them😣

But why are all these women laughing along with what he's doing/saying to them😣

Guarantee that most of the sound, lighting, producers etc are men, and note that nobody is stepping in.

The women would be classed as "difficult," "serious," and "humourless" if the don't laugh.

They also recognize that in pushing this far in front of cameras at that point, he could, and probably would, go much further. It would be unpredictable and would more than likely include horrible insults for them, on live TV.

Most of them probably recognized all of the above in one second of thought.

thestepmumspacepodcast · 04/11/2026 21:15

Margaritaaahhh · 04/11/2026 14:58

Just leaving this here.

vile man

KidsDoBetter · 04/11/2026 21:49

Picoloangel · 04/11/2026 20:32

The jury do not dictate when a majority direction is given; that’s a decision for the Judge. It cannot be given less than 2 hours and 20 minutes after deliberations begin but the longer the case the longer the Judge will usually wait.
I am not so sure that long deliberations = acquittal. Some juries are v focused and fair and want to consider the evidence in detail. They may also be asking questions and sending notes to the Judge - depending on the note these can take some time to deal with.

Yes my point was that the jury may tell the judge they can’t reach unanimity.

OP posts:
blankittyblank · 04/11/2026 22:42

Picoloangel · 04/11/2026 20:32

The jury do not dictate when a majority direction is given; that’s a decision for the Judge. It cannot be given less than 2 hours and 20 minutes after deliberations begin but the longer the case the longer the Judge will usually wait.
I am not so sure that long deliberations = acquittal. Some juries are v focused and fair and want to consider the evidence in detail. They may also be asking questions and sending notes to the Judge - depending on the note these can take some time to deal with.

In the podcast I’ve been watching they were taking about how long they expect the jury to take. And they said they expected it to take quite a while, possibly into the end of next week. Due to the number of counts they need to discuss and agree on. So all the teams are probably prepared for it to take a while.

eastegg · 04/11/2026 23:04

One thing I’ve always found barristers agree on is that you cannot draw correlation between length of deliberations and verdict. Everyone finds themselves trying, only to fail. And defendants/police officers/other interested parties always ask ‘is this a good sign?’ hoping for the oracle to give an answer but you can’t! The stock answer when they’re taking a while is ‘well we know they’re thinking about it carefully!’

I definitely don’t agree with the pp’s court clerk who said quick verdicts mean guilty. That’s all I will say.

mids2019 · 04/11/2026 23:21

KidsDoBetter · 04/11/2026 13:31

Sadly I too had experience of a fellow jury member with quite low cognitive ability and a very poor grasp of written English. Combined with an arrogance and dislike of having anything patiently explained to him by anyone (particularly a woman). We had quite a few documents and written items to consider. He really wasn’t equipped for the job and was deeply obstructive. We did finally manage to secure the correct verdict but I did despair rather of the jury system in some ways.

Given the failure rate for GCSE English and general literacy standards by picking 12 random people there is a high chance you will find someone of low cognitive ability who none the less has to be part of the process. Where information is complex then having jurors of low intellect is a particular problem.

I think a minimum academic threshold may help as well as ascertaining whether any jurors have English as a second language as some of the testimony may be misconstrued.

Piglet89 · 04/11/2026 23:23

eastegg · 04/11/2026 23:04

One thing I’ve always found barristers agree on is that you cannot draw correlation between length of deliberations and verdict. Everyone finds themselves trying, only to fail. And defendants/police officers/other interested parties always ask ‘is this a good sign?’ hoping for the oracle to give an answer but you can’t! The stock answer when they’re taking a while is ‘well we know they’re thinking about it carefully!’

I definitely don’t agree with the pp’s court clerk who said quick verdicts mean guilty. That’s all I will say.

L’oeuf de l’est has spoken! That’s really interesting it’s so hard to predict.

Piglet89 · 04/11/2026 23:25

mids2019 · 04/11/2026 23:21

Given the failure rate for GCSE English and general literacy standards by picking 12 random people there is a high chance you will find someone of low cognitive ability who none the less has to be part of the process. Where information is complex then having jurors of low intellect is a particular problem.

I think a minimum academic threshold may help as well as ascertaining whether any jurors have English as a second language as some of the testimony may be misconstrued.

There was also a high level of resentment from some jurors about their valuable time being taken up having to do jury service. I’d say the majority view it as an inconvenience and a chore. The first thought when the summons arrives is “How can I get out of this?!”

TotaleclipseinFrance · 05/11/2026 04:05

IDasIX · 04/11/2026 20:36

The Scottish Government tried to introduce juryless trials for rape cases, but had to back down because opposition parties and the legal sector were strong against it.

I understand the reservations to an extent but I don’t think we’ll ever manage to get conviction rates off the floor while we still rely on juries.

A large number of people in the general population are not very bright. It’s apparent on the average Mumsnet thread that a lot of people struggle with basic comprehension, processing, and critical thinking.

They're absolutely right to be against it.
It's fundamental that a person is tried by their peers.
They've allegedly done something that is against the society in which they live, they get judged by other members of that society.
I get this on a gut level, seems others don't.

The reason conviction rates are low is because in the case of sexual activity between unrelated adults it is entirely legal that they can have it.

The problem, particularly in cases like so-called date rape whereby it is reasonably assumed sexual attraction exists between two people, is proving rape occured.

This is just the way it is. It is unavoidable.

To be frank I wouldn't necessarily trust anybody who wanted to be chosen for a rape trial as I'd suspect they'd be biased either way.
Either because they are on a quest to boost conviction rates or for some perverse reason want to keep them low.

It is perhaps a case of those that want to strongly do something should be the last to be allowed to do it.
If somebody is actively volunteering for a jury, I don't want them on it.

Give me the average 'thicko' any day of the week.

mids2019 · 05/11/2026 05:44

Piglet89 · 04/11/2026 23:25

There was also a high level of resentment from some jurors about their valuable time being taken up having to do jury service. I’d say the majority view it as an inconvenience and a chore. The first thought when the summons arrives is “How can I get out of this?!”

To some extent this is unfortunately understandable. I think you need an understanding employer to fully support a juror even if it is a legal duty. I don't know if an employer is compensated for lack of an employee but I don't think they will be entirely happy with a staffing gap and may approach the employee for a return to work date (?) and I also wonder how much jury service fits in the with any yearly performance appraisal if targets are missed. I work in a medical field and removal of a consultant for a couple of months I would say sadly would have an impact on patient care so I do think this should be a factor when it comes to jury determination. (Ironically the consultants would be excellent jurors imho). I wonder how many middle class professionals can argue their way out of service so that jurys are skewed towards the unemployed and those unable to come out with a plausible reason to avoid the service. Obviously for the self employed it is lack of income and I can fully see a juror wanting to get the service over and done with it they are literally losing cash.

Maybe there is simple boredom to consider when a juror has to contemplate a crime for weeks on end and if the crime is particularly sensitive maybe they don't want to dwell on it for excessive amounts of time for their own mental health ?

Klippin · 05/11/2026 06:49

Do you think he had to say goodbye to his kids every morning and hug them not knowing if it’ll be last time?

How are they even going to explain to them why daddy has gone to jail?

mids2019 · 05/11/2026 06:56

Klippin · 05/11/2026 06:49

Do you think he had to say goodbye to his kids every morning and hug them not knowing if it’ll be last time?

How are they even going to explain to them why daddy has gone to jail?

The question is 'is Daddy going to jail?'. I wonder if the impact on a young family is going to weigh in the jury and it's decisions given that the events took place a couple of decades ago?

KidsDoBetter · 05/11/2026 07:03

mids2019 · 05/11/2026 06:56

The question is 'is Daddy going to jail?'. I wonder if the impact on a young family is going to weigh in the jury and it's decisions given that the events took place a couple of decades ago?

It will certainly be there in their minds, as part of the background seriousness of the charges and your obligation to be “sure” before you deprive anyone of their liberty. Particularly a father of young kids. I’m sure that’s why the surgery GOSH issue was flagged in evidence and the defence’s summing up to ensure the jury all knew he was a father.

But it shouldn’t be a component part of their decision making process. Whether someone now has kids doesn’t affect the evidence as presented, the route to verdict or someone’s ability to be a rapist.

OP posts:
peppapiggg · 05/11/2026 07:31

Had the verdict come back yet? Been following a little bit (mainly just looking at this thread) he always gave me the ick, even at the height of his fame, hated his hair and those stupid skinny jeans

LetsTalkAboutKevinNow · 05/11/2026 07:38

IDasIX · 04/11/2026 20:36

The Scottish Government tried to introduce juryless trials for rape cases, but had to back down because opposition parties and the legal sector were strong against it.

I understand the reservations to an extent but I don’t think we’ll ever manage to get conviction rates off the floor while we still rely on juries.

A large number of people in the general population are not very bright. It’s apparent on the average Mumsnet thread that a lot of people struggle with basic comprehension, processing, and critical thinking.

Also that those same not-the-full-picnic people have ingrained prejudices and preconceptions -like the husband and brother of a pp who told her they would convict him even though they’d not followed any of the case or evidence, on the basis he is obviously a sleazeball…
The defence can argue that there is absolutely no chance a retrial could summon a jury of impartial people after all the podcasts/ and the SM commentary demonstrating the ‘calibre’ of potential jurirs

CoconutSwirl · 05/11/2026 07:38

mids2019 · 05/11/2026 05:44

To some extent this is unfortunately understandable. I think you need an understanding employer to fully support a juror even if it is a legal duty. I don't know if an employer is compensated for lack of an employee but I don't think they will be entirely happy with a staffing gap and may approach the employee for a return to work date (?) and I also wonder how much jury service fits in the with any yearly performance appraisal if targets are missed. I work in a medical field and removal of a consultant for a couple of months I would say sadly would have an impact on patient care so I do think this should be a factor when it comes to jury determination. (Ironically the consultants would be excellent jurors imho). I wonder how many middle class professionals can argue their way out of service so that jurys are skewed towards the unemployed and those unable to come out with a plausible reason to avoid the service. Obviously for the self employed it is lack of income and I can fully see a juror wanting to get the service over and done with it they are literally losing cash.

Maybe there is simple boredom to consider when a juror has to contemplate a crime for weeks on end and if the crime is particularly sensitive maybe they don't want to dwell on it for excessive amounts of time for their own mental health ?

I wonder how many middle class professionals can argue their way out of service so that jurys are skewed towards the unemployed and those unable to come out with a plausible reason to avoid the service.

People can't just argue their way out of service. You can only be excused under specific circumstances and have to provide evidence.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 05/11/2026 07:49

LetsTalkAboutKevinNow · 05/11/2026 07:38

Also that those same not-the-full-picnic people have ingrained prejudices and preconceptions -like the husband and brother of a pp who told her they would convict him even though they’d not followed any of the case or evidence, on the basis he is obviously a sleazeball…
The defence can argue that there is absolutely no chance a retrial could summon a jury of impartial people after all the podcasts/ and the SM commentary demonstrating the ‘calibre’ of potential jurirs

What is this vibe about people who find him not guilty as being thick on this thread?
Self-praise is no recommendation as the saying goes but I know a few people (women actually, feminist and highly-educated - Oxbridge) who cannot be sure of his guilt to the extent he gets found guilty.
They may think that he's guilty but there's doubt.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.