Actually, it's entirely representative of MN to me.
But, I can say that, having a similar taste in posters as LV/CM obviously does.
Hunker, Cod, Aitch, LL, MP are all posters I admire, am great friends with on and some off board.
They are posters I look at for the fun, witty, intelligent, caring, amusing threads.
They are always on my radar. I guess it depends on who is on your radar. I'd certainly not think twice about an OP that say Soapbox, WWW, Enid etc had started because they arent folk I gravitate towards, lovely as I am sure they all are. They arent really regulars now anyway, AFAIK. Not as much as once was anyway.
I think it's hard to say an article is wrong if it's based on a POV or perspective. It simply doesnt match everyone's interpretation. But, that's exactly what life is like.
Some folk think Maeve Binchy is their kind of story teller, for example. However, she makes me want to eat her books through boredom. It's all about a persons interpretation appealing or not, innit?