Please or to access all these features

Higher education

Talk to other parents whose children are preparing for university on our Higher Education forum.

Oxbridge Maths - is this normal?!

75 replies

VaseOf · 15/11/2026 14:08

DC started this year doing Maths and Stats at a medium to large college. Clearly very able but attended a non-academic comprehensive and didn’t benefit from any extra tuition, and finding they are on the back foot with the workload and difficulty. The tutors encourage the students to discuss their problem sheets amongst themselves, which my YP is super-keen to do as it really helps them to understand. However they have found their maths cohort very reserved, standoffish and not at all willing to discuss things. Will say things like “I’m not sure how to discuss this without giving away the solution”. Is it normal for the students to be so protective and competitive? The tutors advise them to discuss and collaborate, and then write up separately. At this level it’s not like you can ‘copy someone’s answers’ anyway as it will become clear in the tutorial, and ultimately exams, if you have not understood.

I have advised my DC to raise this with their Director of Studies to find out if there are any options for working with students outside their college. And honestly just so they know they are finding things challenging.

Does anyone have experience of whether this is usual? Thanks

OP posts:
poetryandwine · Yesterday 09:07

Strong agree with your edit, @SoftIce . And the AI should be interrogated, as it can make some whopping mistakes. I’ve been told black is white and up is down, luckily I know to interrogate.

(Even OpenAI’s bespoke tool seems to have done this. OpenAI raised expectations concerning some very famous problems, then the papers it dropped provided only partial solutions. It is thought that the original OpenAI papers had mistakes that did not survive the verification process. A few other mistakes in the Big Drop have also been found.)

MFL · Yesterday 09:42

Well even in my little world, I went to a quiz where an answer had relied on AI, and it was wrong. Accurately there was more than one correct answer. It didn’t seem to occur to the question setters to read more informed work on the subject. I set questions in another quiz where the organisers “verified” my answers. They said AI said one of my answers was wrong. It wasn’t.

Aren’t we just getting lazy? I think it must be so hard for universities and AI. It’s seen as a quick fix and even older adults who should know better aren’t querying it.

poetryandwine · Yesterday 10:58

MFL · Yesterday 09:42

Well even in my little world, I went to a quiz where an answer had relied on AI, and it was wrong. Accurately there was more than one correct answer. It didn’t seem to occur to the question setters to read more informed work on the subject. I set questions in another quiz where the organisers “verified” my answers. They said AI said one of my answers was wrong. It wasn’t.

Aren’t we just getting lazy? I think it must be so hard for universities and AI. It’s seen as a quick fix and even older adults who should know better aren’t querying it.

Strongly agree! On the whole students are relying far too much, and too uncritically, on AI. (Like your quizmasters, perhaps)

The Office for Students has just come out with a strong recommendation in favour of a return to exam hall, closed book major assessments for HE. Students are not expected to be pleased, and in truth there is a real loss. Depth assessments and creative assessment tools can capture achievements that traditional exams do not.

However the large majority of students have been abusing AI badly and as AI improves the abuse worsens. I feel badly for the few honest students who will miss out, but I agree with OfS. The majority have brought this upon themselves.

HoppityBun · Yesterday 11:01

I think the key point here is that many, many children, in reality most children, are taught that they can only succeed if someone else loses.

All the research shows that people, countries and businesses thrive by cooperation but these children/ undergraduates are strongly programmed to the contrary. They do not understand the benefits of talking, discussing and cooperating: they do not understand that this is the best way to learn.

I’m sorry that I can’t help you and of course, your priority is supporting your DC..

Malbecfan · Yesterday 13:43

I second the idea of trying to talk to students from other colleges if his own are too introverted. Also, mention it in tutorials. If it is anything like Cambridge NatSci, some supervisions/tutorials have students from different colleges in the same room. If that doesn't work, then go to the DoS but mention the steps he has taken to try to get going.

User11010866 · Yesterday 15:06

HoppityBun · Yesterday 11:01

I think the key point here is that many, many children, in reality most children, are taught that they can only succeed if someone else loses.

All the research shows that people, countries and businesses thrive by cooperation but these children/ undergraduates are strongly programmed to the contrary. They do not understand the benefits of talking, discussing and cooperating: they do not understand that this is the best way to learn.

I’m sorry that I can’t help you and of course, your priority is supporting your DC..

Most YPs probably wouldn't agree with you.
In this particular scenario, given the relatively small cohort within each college, what is there to win or lose? Mathematics is a large university-wide course, with hundreds of students attending the same lectures and sitting the same examinations at the end of the year. I don't see why this should automatically create a protective or competitive atmosphere.
The way students approach their college mates for help or discussion can also make a difference.
Mathematics is a rather special subject. Some students may understand the lectures immediately and start tackling the problem sheets straight away. Others may need to spend hours reviewing and consolidating the lecture material before they can even begin the questions. Everyone has a different learning pace and approach.
Ultimately, students will naturally find study partners whose working styles, personalities and approaches to learning complement their own.

Leavemetonguetied · Yesterday 16:01

MFL · 16/11/2026 10:30

@Leavemetonguetied A big fat fail might concentrate the minds. If something is required, it’s required. Refusing to do something should be a fail. Sorry - harsh - but it’s about standards isn’t it?

Ah but I teach third years. This is the year that fill out the NSS so if I actually failed swathes of them I would be pulled in to explain myself. I would be told not to fail and the fault would be with me for having an assessment they didn't 'like'.

HoppityBun · Yesterday 16:06

User11010866 · Yesterday 15:06

Most YPs probably wouldn't agree with you.
In this particular scenario, given the relatively small cohort within each college, what is there to win or lose? Mathematics is a large university-wide course, with hundreds of students attending the same lectures and sitting the same examinations at the end of the year. I don't see why this should automatically create a protective or competitive atmosphere.
The way students approach their college mates for help or discussion can also make a difference.
Mathematics is a rather special subject. Some students may understand the lectures immediately and start tackling the problem sheets straight away. Others may need to spend hours reviewing and consolidating the lecture material before they can even begin the questions. Everyone has a different learning pace and approach.
Ultimately, students will naturally find study partners whose working styles, personalities and approaches to learning complement their own.

Wouldn’t agree with me about what? The research that shows the benefits of cooperating and how that embed learning?I wouldn’t expect YP to know about that.

The reality is that in order to get their places at Oxford/Cambridge they have had to be highly competitive. That’s been their training.

Woollyguru · Yesterday 16:29

Leavemetonguetied · 16/11/2026 07:49

Oh no we require all that. We have meeting logs, a group contract they have to fulfill and a peer review section of the mark which asks about collaboration and teamwork. And they get marked down on the group work aspect if I can clearly see they've never met or not worked together. But it doesn't stop them doing it.

I also do group discussion in the class and the typical response now is, rather than talk, to open up a shared Google doc and all silently type. If I demand devices are closed I immediately get formal complaints about creating anxiety.

Do you think this is because they lack English speaking skills?

poetryandwine · Yesterday 16:40

Woollyguru · Yesterday 16:29

Do you think this is because they lack English speaking skills?

I will be interested in @Leavemetonguetied ’s answer. However IME a lack of English compounds the problem but isn’t a basic cause.

MFL · Yesterday 18:45

@Leavemetonguetied I don’t wish that on you at all but it’s a fault of expanding HE and lowering standards.

@poetryandwine Maybe we should expect students to do both - you know - as we used to? Closed book and collaboration? It produces a better all round grad I think.

Results show vast numbers of firsts and 2:1s and few 2:2 or lower. Clearly being not good enough isn’t entertained but some students are simply over marked because they cheat.

Rockyroadminibites · Yesterday 19:16

I know quite a few people who studied maths at Oxbridge (across different ages) and they are all autistic. They all have the social communication difficulties that go with this.

The two I know best who went very recently both struggled, especially in first year.

poetryandwine · Yesterday 19:45

MFL · Yesterday 18:45

@Leavemetonguetied I don’t wish that on you at all but it’s a fault of expanding HE and lowering standards.

@poetryandwine Maybe we should expect students to do both - you know - as we used to? Closed book and collaboration? It produces a better all round grad I think.

Results show vast numbers of firsts and 2:1s and few 2:2 or lower. Clearly being not good enough isn’t entertained but some students are simply over marked because they cheat.

We would love to expect both. Most academics agree that learning collaboration is important. As @Leavemetonguetied says, there is so much anxiety or whatever, as well as unauthorised use of AI now, that it is nearly impossible to do this right.

MFL · Yesterday 22:03

So surely the students aren’t meeting the grade criteria and expectations as before? How are employers expected to trust the degrees?

Leavemetonguetied · Yesterday 22:32

poetryandwine · Yesterday 16:40

I will be interested in @Leavemetonguetied ’s answer. However IME a lack of English compounds the problem but isn’t a basic cause.

I teach groups that are 90% international at post-grad level which means language is a problem, ironically less so with live AI translators, but our ug cohorts are mostly English speaking. We have a lot of US students doing gaps from Harvard etc so they are bright, capable. They just don't like speaking to their peers unless it is via a device.

Genevieva · Yesterday 23:10

MFL · 15/11/2026 19:40

I just think it’s the type of person getting into to Oxford now. 20% Sen there and maybe not the breadth of personalities you would have seen 40 years ago. Discussing topics is expected in humanities subjects but mathematicians can just keep themselves to themselves and it suits them to do this. It’s a shame really.

One of the purposes of the Oxbridge interview system is to ensure offers go to people who are going to make the most of the Oxbridge style of teaching and learning. It sounds like this college failed for Maths this year. I have a child studying a STEM degree at an Oxbridge college who is a natural teacher. He was running (teaching) Olympiad classes at school (partly motivated by wanting to participate himself and the school only being willing to supervise the actual Olympiad if there was sufficient interest!). Nevertheless, discussions are meant to be between equals, so it may be frustrating if the OP’s child just doesn’t grasp things the others feel they should.

Hellohelga · Today 08:19

Cambridge mathematicians are notoriously low on social skills with many on the autism spectrum. It will take time to build relationships. Also these are some of the brightest and best in the country who will be struggling themselves with the course content for the first time in their lives, and going into shock at how hard it is and how fast it is taught. It’s a massive step up from A levels, and even more so for a kid who didn’t go to private/grammar. Tell your DS not to be discouraged and to keep working at building relationships. I assume he has a college mentor (father/mother/brother?) that he could seek support from, as well as his course tutors.

MFL · Today 08:37

@Genevieva How can the other students possibly gauge he isn’t at their level? That’s somewhat elitist amongst the elite!

However, as I said earlier I think Send and language are issues here and the interviews will only really rubber stamp excellent test results. They aren’t a great communication test. Yes, they want students who suit their teaching style but that doesn’t extend to talking to peers.

I know 3 Cambridge maths grads. One is a fantastic person, the other two? Sen and non communicators. One unemployed. The other took a year to get a job and does now understand that talking to others is needed so is doing very well. Being a maths genius isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.

Genevieva · Today 09:21

MFL · Today 08:37

@Genevieva How can the other students possibly gauge he isn’t at their level? That’s somewhat elitist amongst the elite!

However, as I said earlier I think Send and language are issues here and the interviews will only really rubber stamp excellent test results. They aren’t a great communication test. Yes, they want students who suit their teaching style but that doesn’t extend to talking to peers.

I know 3 Cambridge maths grads. One is a fantastic person, the other two? Sen and non communicators. One unemployed. The other took a year to get a job and does now understand that talking to others is needed so is doing very well. Being a maths genius isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.

People often make instant / unfair judgements about other people.

I do agree about high levels of neurodivergence at Oxbridge, but not all neurodivergent people are standoffish and unhelpful loners.

poetryandwine · Today 09:50

Genevieva · Today 09:21

People often make instant / unfair judgements about other people.

I do agree about high levels of neurodivergence at Oxbridge, but not all neurodivergent people are standoffish and unhelpful loners.

Very intelligent undergraduates are particularly liable to make snap judgments. Part of the point of a university education is to discourage this.

As I said upthread, helping others (and we really have no idea how strong any of these students are; I do know the large majority are unlikely to appreciate the deeper implications of their problem sets on the first go, but discussion may well elicit deeper understanding) is one of the best things you can do for yourself. In any case only a small proportion of Oxbridge Y1s will be acing their weekly assignments.

‘I don’t know how to discuss this without giving away the solution’ is simply pathetic in the misunderstanding it reveals, and in many cases probably bluster.

OP, @Hellohelga ’s idea to ask a college parent or other student mentor for guidance on this is excellent.

Rockyroadminibites · Today 13:10

Genevieva · Today 09:21

People often make instant / unfair judgements about other people.

I do agree about high levels of neurodivergence at Oxbridge, but not all neurodivergent people are standoffish and unhelpful loners.

High intelligence (Oxbridge) is itself a type of neurodivergence. Autism, however, is defined in part by lack of social skills. Autism and neurodivergence are not synonyms.

Rockyroadminibites · Today 13:17

It can be a shock to students who have gone through school at the top of the school, finding most work they are given very straightforward, to suddenly find themselves very much in the middle or bottom of their group and struggling with the work. It is an adjustment large numbers of Oxbridge students have to make regardless of school type they attended.

Hellohelga · Today 13:31

OP I asked my DS who has been there. He said

Resist using AI as it’s a slippery slope to short cutting without fully understanding. It’s tussling with the problems that develops the required understanding.

Work on a problem for an hour trying one avenue after another. If he’s getting nowhere leave it. Come back the next day for another look with a fresh mind.
If he’s really fumoxed he has a few options.
Email the tutor for a hint
and/or discuss with peers
leave it unattempted or half attempted to discuss in class - students aren’t expected to complete all problems but they are expected to have a go.

Remind him if he passed STEP he’s earned his place and he has the intellectual ability. It’s meant to be hard, everyone will find the same. His peers will open up as time goes by and they get to know each other.

FrancisBlundy · Today 13:42

I had similar experience myself - maths degree at a uni just below COWI. The really able kids were plagued by others to share/explain and I could understand their reluctance (especially as some asking hadn’t put in any leg work themselves). In my second year they streamed tutorial classes somewhat and I had more success as the very able kids got to see that they could learn a little from me (occasionally I had a more concise solution they had overlooked) and that I wasn’t a lazy numpty. I found I had more success by not just asking to see what they had done but to ask for help when I’d reached an impasse. Sometimes I just needed a yes that’s the right approach keep going and sometimes a steer to use a particular technique. Some tutors were good at encouraging collaboration - we always worked thru an unseen problem as a group and he’d get the less able to do an easier bit.

MFL · Today 13:47

@Hellohelga The thread is about inability to discuss with peers because they won’t participate.

Everybody knows discussing with peers is an excellent way of learning and I know it’s encouraged in many schools but some dc aren’t up for it. It’s very sad that this happens. I do wonder if, because some dc are so good at maths, they have been given special consideration at school? In other words, they beaver away alone and are not part of any peer group discussions because they are allowed to opt out. No evidence, but why are some students against working with peers now if they did it in school? It rather suggests they didn’t.

If you were doing labs in an engineering degree, students would work together. Why not maths students?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page