Please or to access all these features

Higher education

Talk to other parents whose children are preparing for university on our Higher Education forum.

Oxbridge Maths - is this normal?!

75 replies

VaseOf · 15/11/2026 14:08

DC started this year doing Maths and Stats at a medium to large college. Clearly very able but attended a non-academic comprehensive and didn’t benefit from any extra tuition, and finding they are on the back foot with the workload and difficulty. The tutors encourage the students to discuss their problem sheets amongst themselves, which my YP is super-keen to do as it really helps them to understand. However they have found their maths cohort very reserved, standoffish and not at all willing to discuss things. Will say things like “I’m not sure how to discuss this without giving away the solution”. Is it normal for the students to be so protective and competitive? The tutors advise them to discuss and collaborate, and then write up separately. At this level it’s not like you can ‘copy someone’s answers’ anyway as it will become clear in the tutorial, and ultimately exams, if you have not understood.

I have advised my DC to raise this with their Director of Studies to find out if there are any options for working with students outside their college. And honestly just so they know they are finding things challenging.

Does anyone have experience of whether this is usual? Thanks

OP posts:
Octavia64 · 15/11/2026 14:11

presumably they are in first year.

in my experience as people got further into the course and developed friendships they were more happy to work together and discuss stuff.

this is presumably problem classes rather than lectures.

can he ask his dos if anyone else wants to buddy up with a study partner?

chirrupybird · 15/11/2026 14:14

There was a remedial maths class at my uni, which I had to take even though I had reasonable grades in pure and applied at A level, but it did help get up to speed.

Edit: is there any chance of getting extra support if he is struggling. It does get pretty hard quickly.

PhotoDad · 15/11/2026 14:36

It might take a term or two for other students to open up. It's odd, because it really shouldn't be a competition; it's entirely possible for everyone in a particular college to do well. But maybe some students haven't quite realised that and want to be top dog. Does your YP get along with with their supervision partner(s)?

My DS is a current fresher (STEM but not Maths) and I know he works on problem-sets with his college course-mates. Back in my own day I remember many long, long, sessions with a friend and assorted alcoholic drinks... which probably didn't make the questions easier!

VaseOf · 15/11/2026 14:59

@Octavia64 yes I think they need to raise it with the DOS as they are just finding it very isolating, despite trying really hard to be friendly with everyone.
@chirrupybird there must be some extra support.. they are not very good at asking for help. Pride and all that! But I am reminding them they did a test, and multiple interviews, so must be capable even if it doesn’t feel like it right now.
@PhotoDad what they are telling me is that the other maths students are just quite introverted, and not keen to do anything other than go to lectures, study alone and go to tutorials. They are all perfectly nice people but yes, it seems they are quite competitive. Yes they would love to work with college-mates on the problem sheets, but it doesn’t seem to be working like that. 😞

OP posts:
JanglyBeads · 15/11/2026 15:02

How many other Mathematicians are there in college in his year?

VaseOf · 15/11/2026 15:40

I think around 8 but a few are international students who choose not to mix at all

OP posts:
Flizzy · 15/11/2026 16:13

I did maths and stats at Oxford. We always collaborated, there's nothing to lose by helping people as it's not like it counts towards your marks. Very strange. The international Chinese students had a network across the colleges and years and would have copies of all the answer sheets from people in the years above them. I was friends with a Chinese girl in my college (although they do generally keep themselves to themselves) and sometimes asked her for it.

BreadInCaptivity · 15/11/2026 16:20

Have asked DS (former Oxbridge Maths). He said his cohort was collaborative baring a few exceptions who seemed to think not needing help reflected on their prowess.

Come results time those students didn’t perform as well as those who’d collaborated interestingly.

MargaretThursday · 15/11/2026 18:01

We worked totally together. As in the night before it was due we all got together and discussed every question, with those who understood explaining it to the others -frequently until 2-4am or even later, when we sometimes got rather silly and did things that we wouldn't have done otherwise 😂It helped that we were fairly even in ability but better at different things.
We only twice did an all night and went to breakfast with the rowers at 6am - and then nearly slept through our lectures.

However I remember a friend at another college saying that it took until the summer term for them to collaborate. They'd done it occasionally, but most of them felt that was cheating, and it was only in the summer term that one mentioned that they'd asked someone else for help, and the tutor had heavily praised them and said that was what studying should be like and they expected them to ask and teach each other.
They then breathed a sigh of relief and collaborated after that.

So it may be that they are feeling it's "cheating".

MFL · 15/11/2026 19:40

I just think it’s the type of person getting into to Oxford now. 20% Sen there and maybe not the breadth of personalities you would have seen 40 years ago. Discussing topics is expected in humanities subjects but mathematicians can just keep themselves to themselves and it suits them to do this. It’s a shame really.

VaseOf · 15/11/2026 21:44

Thanks all. @Flizzy yes that rings through re. the Chinese students who do seem to have a whole life already outside of college apparently. Lucky them!
@MargaretThursday and @BreadInCaptivity sounds like my DC is just unlucky then, and/or people are not yet confident enough with each other to want to get too involved. I guess they are only 5 weeks in. I will continue encouraging them to discuss with the DoS as perhaps he can instigate/encourage some collaboration.

OP posts:
Leavemetonguetied · 15/11/2026 21:51

I'm an academic. I'd say this isn't a maths thing. We find that the more recent UG cohorts just do not communicate. They will talk online and they will sit in a tutorial and whatsapp each other but they won't actually speak out loud. It's very odd and quite sad really. I run a group presentation assessment and in previous years they have come together as a group to plan, develop and then record it on a shared call. Last year most recorded their sections separately and spliced it together so I don't think they ever met in person.

poetryandwine · 15/11/2026 21:53

I put this post to DH. He is a Cambridge Maths alumnus (with a Distinction at Part III)
and Russell Group Maths Professor recently gone emeritus with a number of international esteems.

All of his sympathies and reasoning are with your DC, OP. He is emphatic that learning to explain clearly to others is a hugely important skill in itself and one of the best ways to solidify your own knowledge. (I am also a STEM academic, educated abroad, and agree completely.) He points out that the tutor who wants students to collaborate doesn’t give a damn if someone ‘gives away’ the solution, and anyone bringing this up as a concern misunderstands the nature of tutorials. (They can take credit if they want - it is gauche but accurate, and helps the tutor know how to help the tutees).

I hope that as PP have suggested a lot of this is just shyness and that as the students become more comfortable with each other they will relax. Some may have a history of being taken advantage of academically, so DC could be sensitive to that - if they can show themselves as something of a contributor (which is a very tall order in Y1 at Oxbridge) that might help.

My household is firmly behind DC!

MFL · 15/11/2026 23:27

@Leavemetonguetied So you don’t want evidence of dc meeting and exploring ideas as a group? No wonder employers complain!

SoftIce · 16/11/2026 07:27

I've definitely read this complaint before, on TSR (thestudentroom), years ago, but about Cambridge or Imperial (don't remember which). I don't think it is a new thing or necessarily an Oxbridge thing, though maybe people are happier to collaborate if they ALL think the problems are insanely hard which may be more likely at other universities (such as mine :-)).

Unfortunately, some people think they can only do well if other people do badly.

I think your son should keep signaling that he is willing to collaborate and in the meantime maybe check out TSR - maybe people there can post him to good resources or maybe there are even some other Oxford maths first years on there who would be willing to collaborate. IIRC TSR also has a maths forum but it probably deals more with GCSE/A-level stuff.

Leavemetonguetied · 16/11/2026 07:49

MFL · 15/11/2026 23:27

@Leavemetonguetied So you don’t want evidence of dc meeting and exploring ideas as a group? No wonder employers complain!

Oh no we require all that. We have meeting logs, a group contract they have to fulfill and a peer review section of the mark which asks about collaboration and teamwork. And they get marked down on the group work aspect if I can clearly see they've never met or not worked together. But it doesn't stop them doing it.

I also do group discussion in the class and the typical response now is, rather than talk, to open up a shared Google doc and all silently type. If I demand devices are closed I immediately get formal complaints about creating anxiety.

poetryandwine · 16/11/2026 07:53

SoftIce · 16/11/2026 07:27

I've definitely read this complaint before, on TSR (thestudentroom), years ago, but about Cambridge or Imperial (don't remember which). I don't think it is a new thing or necessarily an Oxbridge thing, though maybe people are happier to collaborate if they ALL think the problems are insanely hard which may be more likely at other universities (such as mine :-)).

Unfortunately, some people think they can only do well if other people do badly.

I think your son should keep signaling that he is willing to collaborate and in the meantime maybe check out TSR - maybe people there can post him to good resources or maybe there are even some other Oxford maths first years on there who would be willing to collaborate. IIRC TSR also has a maths forum but it probably deals more with GCSE/A-level stuff.

This is a great idea. I hope it works.

MeshMesh · 16/11/2026 08:21

ChatGPT?

dontrunintothedark · 16/11/2026 08:31

Leavemetonguetied · 16/11/2026 07:49

Oh no we require all that. We have meeting logs, a group contract they have to fulfill and a peer review section of the mark which asks about collaboration and teamwork. And they get marked down on the group work aspect if I can clearly see they've never met or not worked together. But it doesn't stop them doing it.

I also do group discussion in the class and the typical response now is, rather than talk, to open up a shared Google doc and all silently type. If I demand devices are closed I immediately get formal complaints about creating anxiety.

Gosh, that's so sad. How are such complaints dealt with?

DonInDisguise · 16/11/2026 08:48

This is really frustrating @VaseOf. I second talking to the one of the college maths tutors about it to see if they can say something to the cohort together. I agree with @Leavemetonguetied though - we're having real problems encouraging communication between students.

I did have this lonely experience with maths at uni (and school) but I thought that had changed.

I also had this experience with my other subject (the one I'm now a specialist in) when people in first year refused to talk to me (a mere woman) about it because 'I'd steal their ideas'.

DonInDisguise · 16/11/2026 08:49

Sometimes college maths lecturers/tutors are rubbish at the communication thing themselves though. And some are great with the students. There is huge variation.

SoftIce · 16/11/2026 10:26

Another idea: I think it would help if tutors actually (forcibly) sat down with groups of pupils at the beginning of the year and demonstrate / model what a good collaborative discussion of maths problems actually looks like. Maybe some students think collaboration = "copying solutions from the best person in the group", but it is not like that at all (at least not for most and hopefully none at Oxford). Maybe if all students understood the process and how much it benefits everyone (including the best students) they would be more willing to engage. If your DC @VaseOf contacts the tutor anyway it may also be worth asking the tutor if they (or an older student or research assistant) would be willing to do something like this (but it needs to be someone who can do this well and draw people out).

MFL · 16/11/2026 10:30

@Leavemetonguetied A big fat fail might concentrate the minds. If something is required, it’s required. Refusing to do something should be a fail. Sorry - harsh - but it’s about standards isn’t it?

justteanbiscuits · 16/11/2026 11:09

My son started doing super curricular maths things in year 10 which helped give him a wider circle to chat maths with. COMPOS was excellent for this. Universities often provide outreach for year 11+ too - such as London Maths Outreach with is Imperial and UCL.

He then also set up the school maths club for his sixth form, and has developed a nice group of maths mates from years 11, 12 and 13 that meet weekly.

PeachTrifle · 16/11/2026 11:12

My ds is an Oxford Maths grad and I would say it is perhaps just early days. I don't think his cohort were perhaps the most socially skilled although ds was lucky to have a nice tutorial partner and it took most of the first year for any friendships to develop. Remember they are all also having to work really hard on their problem sheets and meeting people from other colleges takes time. I would encourage your ds to keep trying, maybe just start with a coffee after lectures, meet a range of students from other colleges and hopefully he will find others.