Please or to access all these features

Higher education

Talk to other parents whose children are preparing for university on our Higher Education forum.

Oxbridge Maths - is this normal?!

75 replies

VaseOf · 15/11/2026 14:08

DC started this year doing Maths and Stats at a medium to large college. Clearly very able but attended a non-academic comprehensive and didn’t benefit from any extra tuition, and finding they are on the back foot with the workload and difficulty. The tutors encourage the students to discuss their problem sheets amongst themselves, which my YP is super-keen to do as it really helps them to understand. However they have found their maths cohort very reserved, standoffish and not at all willing to discuss things. Will say things like “I’m not sure how to discuss this without giving away the solution”. Is it normal for the students to be so protective and competitive? The tutors advise them to discuss and collaborate, and then write up separately. At this level it’s not like you can ‘copy someone’s answers’ anyway as it will become clear in the tutorial, and ultimately exams, if you have not understood.

I have advised my DC to raise this with their Director of Studies to find out if there are any options for working with students outside their college. And honestly just so they know they are finding things challenging.

Does anyone have experience of whether this is usual? Thanks

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 16/11/2026 11:13

SoftIce · 16/11/2026 10:26

Another idea: I think it would help if tutors actually (forcibly) sat down with groups of pupils at the beginning of the year and demonstrate / model what a good collaborative discussion of maths problems actually looks like. Maybe some students think collaboration = "copying solutions from the best person in the group", but it is not like that at all (at least not for most and hopefully none at Oxford). Maybe if all students understood the process and how much it benefits everyone (including the best students) they would be more willing to engage. If your DC @VaseOf contacts the tutor anyway it may also be worth asking the tutor if they (or an older student or research assistant) would be willing to do something like this (but it needs to be someone who can do this well and draw people out).

Edited

This is much easier to address in a small tutorial than when addressing multiple working groups in a large lecture.

I despise group work except in small, elective advanced courses. Students know each other, they are more mature and relaxed, they want to be there. All of this makes a big difference.

The trend to group work in required early years courses only benefits students in exceptional groups that work properly. These are few and far between. My deep sympathies to @Leavemetonguetied I was removed by request from such a course, my most frustrating experience ever.

OTOH, I can usually create an environment with my personal tutees that says ‘it’s us against the world’ (or the rest of the lecture cohort). Of course my students will have personal friends they work and socialise with, but I circulate an opt-out contact list at our first meeting (with my data filled in). No one has ever opted out and I am not aware of any negative outcomes. I think I would be made quickly aware of any complaints to the School or the Student Reps.

I make it clear that exploiting others is wrong and pointless but seeking and offering good faith help is a win for everyone. It seems to work. On the whole my students do well and seem to enjoy the course.

Gengha · 16/11/2026 11:26

My son started maths not at Oxbridge but another high ranked RG university. The students sound similar to what your son describes. They were not his kind of people at all so he left and started elsewhere somewhere else where he’s much happier. Life’s too short to spend it with wankers where you can avoid it IMO.

Nighttimenoise · 16/11/2026 11:35

This is so sad really, as an employer, we are noticing how poor the new grad's communication skills are, they refuse to Teams people and stick to emails.

justteanbiscuits · 16/11/2026 11:48

Sorry, too slow to edit. But completely misunderstood your post 😣 Sorry! Not enough coffee for today!

MeshMesh · 16/11/2026 12:09

Again, can’t AI help with this stuff and be better at providing help than just another first year undergrad.

SoftIce · 16/11/2026 12:43

@MeshMesh Have you tried it on fairly complex proofs? (I haven't, so can't say, but am a bit skeptical.) But I agree, if he has access to ChatGPT, it is worth a try to discuss problems with it and let it explain what it can to you (basically treat it like another student, don't copy answers).

latetothefisting · 16/11/2026 12:48

MeshMesh · 16/11/2026 12:09

Again, can’t AI help with this stuff and be better at providing help than just another first year undergrad.

but this will just exacerbate the whole wider problem that @Leavemetonguetied has explained.

OP's DC is one of the few kids who actively WANT to collaborate and communicate, something we desperately need in the workforce. It's ridiculous to say 'if you can't beat them, join them,' and tell them to give up the one thing that is most likely to help them (both academically and socially) as well as very likely make them stand out when they come to apply for jobs.

I'm sure it would help all the other students as well, if they can't/won't communicate with someone their own age about their shared interest, how on earth will they get through interviews or speak to colleagues?

I'm very far from the expert but my understanding is when you're learning maths at that level it's not just about finding the answers but how you get there, and how that process can be used for other problems, learning how and why you got the wrong answer so you don't make the same mistake again, etc. Otherwise what's the point of them going to uni for three years at all, they could use chat gpt from home and save fifty grand.

MFL · 16/11/2026 13:06

@latetothefisting I agree with others that conversing and discussing with others is vital for students. Keeping yourself to yourself is not what employers value. We are producing automatons but not employable young people who can thoughtfully engage in the workplace.

MeshMesh · 16/11/2026 13:14

latetothefisting · 16/11/2026 12:48

but this will just exacerbate the whole wider problem that @Leavemetonguetied has explained.

OP's DC is one of the few kids who actively WANT to collaborate and communicate, something we desperately need in the workforce. It's ridiculous to say 'if you can't beat them, join them,' and tell them to give up the one thing that is most likely to help them (both academically and socially) as well as very likely make them stand out when they come to apply for jobs.

I'm sure it would help all the other students as well, if they can't/won't communicate with someone their own age about their shared interest, how on earth will they get through interviews or speak to colleagues?

I'm very far from the expert but my understanding is when you're learning maths at that level it's not just about finding the answers but how you get there, and how that process can be used for other problems, learning how and why you got the wrong answer so you don't make the same mistake again, etc. Otherwise what's the point of them going to uni for three years at all, they could use chat gpt from home and save fifty grand.

Edited

AI isn’t just about getting to answers; it can help with all the other stuff you mention too.

Sure, working with other people is great and I’m not suggesting AI is always preferable. But, if the alternative is feeling behind, lost or confused, and so on, it would be silly to not consider how AI can be helpful in the meantime.

There is always going to be an over representation of ‘antisocial’ people with autism in maths cohorts. It comes with the territory.

VaseOf · 16/11/2026 13:22

Thank you to you all for your helpful and supportive comments. It is reassuring to know that what they were hoping would be the case is in fact the ideal, and that they are not being unrealistic in expecting (and looking forward to) these discussions. Indeed at interview they seem to be looking for people who can communicate their maths thinking over Teams (though I am sure some people are admitted based solely on maths genius and not communication!).
@MeshMesh They are au fait with AI but as other posters have explained, I am not sure it is as simple as just finding the answer. They want to be hearing about how others have approached the same problem in different ways and have that camaraderie.
As pointed out upthread, I have myself reassured my DC that when they reach the workplace, collaborative skills are fairly non-negotiable and they will be well placed in this respect.

OP posts:
VaseOf · 16/11/2026 13:23

@MeshMesh we crossed posts - yes good point, that as a stop-gap to help avoid overwhelm and throwing the baby out with the bath water, strategic use of AI could be wise!

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 16/11/2026 13:52

I am Maths adjacent and have been following some of the recent uses of AI in the discipline with interest.

AI is not foolproof and is capable of even quite basic mathematical mistakes. However, so are humans! If DC can come to AI as they would to a human collaboration, asking incremental questions, focusing on understanding and interrogating the machine thoroughly, I think using it intelligently for now is a good idea.

Also, the more the other students see DC doing problems, participating constructively in discussions, etc, the more attractive the idea of studying with them will be to the insecure (and Oxbridge is rife with intellectual insecurity). Obviously DC must obey any honour code about declaring the use of AI (and a good tutor will be able to tell, anyway), but I would not broadcast this use to peers unless it is clearly acceptable, based on the actions of others, to do so.

Best wishes to DC

cupboardoftrouble · 16/11/2026 14:01

I use a variety of AI when I am trying to work out how to help DS with his pure maths (Yr 13) and it is surprisingly good - if you ask the right question. If we just want hints on how to approach a problem, it will give us those hints - or sometimes we ask it to really unpick and explain a concept. But we do that because DS has a disability and doesn't have a cohort of peers to lean on. Would infinitely prefer it if he did! We also use different AI versions for different problem types - MathGPT makes typing in a problem way easier. Would your DS be able to set up a regular meet (same place, same time every week) to discuss the problem sheets - then people can drop in when they want. If it is diarised like that, maybe they will see it as a 'normal' thing to be doing?

SoftIce · 16/11/2026 14:08

@cupboardoftrouble A-level "pure" maths is nothing like degree-level "pure" maths (fortunately or unfortunately, depending on where you are sitting!). A-level "pure" maths is much more like the maths in engineering degrees than the maths in maths degrees.

It is interesting that AI can answer A-level maths questions but then again, these are fairly routine. I'm really doubtful about AI and degree-level maths questions. Maybe someone with access could feed it a STEP paper and see how it does? I'm quite curious now to find out.

irregularegular · 16/11/2026 14:18

I'm an Oxbridge tutor (not Maths). We strongly encourage our students to work together, but some groups have better dynamics than others. It can be hard for students to get out of the competitive "not giving away the solution" mindset. And more introverted students may struggle.

I would suggest that they talk to their tutor/DoS about this, and perhaps the tutor could talk to the group about the benefits of working together and give them a little bit of help organising it. They could reiterate that is is not "cheating" and that even the students who have got further with the problems by themselves will still benefit from explaining it and discussing it with others. I also tell students to give credit on their work where they have received significant help, which again the tutor could reiterate. The tutor might even be willing to set a time and place for students to meet to get them going.

If that fails, could they talk to people from other Colleges in lectures and see if they would be open to meeting up to work together.

SoftIce · 16/11/2026 14:32

OK, I just asked google gemini and it looks like some AI models are very good indeed at proofs. I'd definitely try it @VaseOf - as mentioned by PPs your DC should interrogate the AI very thoroughly to make sure they understand 100% of the problem and the solution, but doing that could actually really improve their mathematical understanding a lot. (Kind of wish this had been available when I was a student, haha.)

Here is Google, if anyone is interested:

Frontier reasoning AI models are very strong at first-year university mathematics, routinely scoring over 90% on standard undergraduate problem sets and solving complex competition proofs. However, their reliability depends heavily on whether a problem is a standard textbook exercise or a novel, multi-step proof without formal verification.

Performance Across First-Year Modules
Calculus, Linear Algebra & Differential Equations: Top models handle almost all standard computational and theoretical problems in these core courses. On the U-MATH university-level benchmark, leading reasoning models achieve over 93% accuracy on text-based undergraduate problems.
Real Analysis & Abstract Algebra (Proofs): Frontier AI excels at standard first-year proofs (such as epsilon-delta limits, continuity, and basic group theory). When paired with formal proof assistants like Lean, systems like AxiomProver and DeepSeek-v3.2-Speciale on MathArena have even achieved top-tier scores on the Putnam Competition, which is far harder than standard first-year exams.
Visual & Diagram-Heavy Problems: Performance drops significantly when questions rely on geometric intuition, phase portraits, or complex diagrams, where accuracy on university benchmarks falls to around 58%. 1]

Key Limitations to Watch Out For
Wordy & Confusing Proofs: Even when an AI reaches the right conclusion, mathematicians note in guides like MIT's guide on AI in mathematics that AI-written proofs are often unnecessarily wordy, poorly structured, or difficult to follow compared to human solutions.
Subtle Logical Gaps: Without a formal verifier like Lean, an AI can occasionally slip in a subtle sign error, assume an unproven edge case, or skip a step that a university marker would penalize.
Impact on Learning: A 2026 study on AI and proof-writing found that while students using AI chatbots scored higher on homework, heavier reliance on AI correlated with lower scores on closed-book exams. Because first-year math is about building your own proof-writing muscle, letting AI write your problem sheets backfires during exams.

MathArena: Evaluating LLMs on Uncontaminated Math Benchmarks

MathArena.ai

MathArena: Evaluating LLMs on Uncontaminated Math Benchmarks

https://matharena.ai/putnam/

OneZanyCat · 16/11/2026 16:55

It maybe worth them joining a university maths society if they want to find other people to discuss maths with - this seems to be one at Oxford https://www.invariants.org.uk/

Its early days and hopefully students they are with will become less reserved - maybe they could suggest a maths group meal out at a pub / restaurant / trip to McDonalds where they could chat to the others and get to know them more. If they are just looking for the social side plus someone to discuss maths with maybe worth approaching other subjects which have a high maths content - Economics / E&M students tend to be sociable and a lot will have Maths and Further Maths and some will have done Maths comps / know other Maths students. Or do they have college parents / know students in the year above, worth asking their advice. And get involved in university wide interest groups. At the start many students will be reserved and needing some courage to go to things. DDs group all work together, do sport together and socialise together and even holidayed together and are very different backgrounds and nationalities so the background and nationality need not be a block.

poetryandwine · 16/11/2026 17:22

OneZanyCat · 16/11/2026 16:55

It maybe worth them joining a university maths society if they want to find other people to discuss maths with - this seems to be one at Oxford https://www.invariants.org.uk/

Its early days and hopefully students they are with will become less reserved - maybe they could suggest a maths group meal out at a pub / restaurant / trip to McDonalds where they could chat to the others and get to know them more. If they are just looking for the social side plus someone to discuss maths with maybe worth approaching other subjects which have a high maths content - Economics / E&M students tend to be sociable and a lot will have Maths and Further Maths and some will have done Maths comps / know other Maths students. Or do they have college parents / know students in the year above, worth asking their advice. And get involved in university wide interest groups. At the start many students will be reserved and needing some courage to go to things. DDs group all work together, do sport together and socialise together and even holidayed together and are very different backgrounds and nationalities so the background and nationality need not be a block.

Another great idea!

dontrunintothedark · 16/11/2026 17:43

The point isn't about getting to the answers really though. Using AI is just going to entrench the problem. Nobody develops a network, relationships or social, communication and collaboration skills through sitting on their own using a sycophantic robot. Solutions that involve humans would be better.

Octavia64 · 16/11/2026 17:46

AI might cope with standard first year maths it’s unlikely to cope with Oxbridge maths.

my dc who did physics used wolfram alpha.

most AI does not handle maths at all well. This is not likely to be a good use of his time.

MeshMesh · 16/11/2026 18:25

Octavia64 · 16/11/2026 17:46

AI might cope with standard first year maths it’s unlikely to cope with Oxbridge maths.

my dc who did physics used wolfram alpha.

most AI does not handle maths at all well. This is not likely to be a good use of his time.

Ha - I think you’re overestimating the ability of undergraduate maths students.

poetryandwine · 16/11/2026 21:25

Octavia64 · 16/11/2026 17:46

AI might cope with standard first year maths it’s unlikely to cope with Oxbridge maths.

my dc who did physics used wolfram alpha.

most AI does not handle maths at all well. This is not likely to be a good use of his time.

Hi, @Octavia64 . This is a general comment, not just a reply to you. However I suspect this view is shared by many, and not long ago it was correct.

Bespoke AI at least has come along at the speed of light, recently solving notable and even notorious research problems in mathematics and mathematical physics by the hundreds. A number of these have been formally verified and there has been significant media coverage. Early career researchers are clogging up forums wondering whether they should abandon the work they’ve spent a decade or more training for.

(However many of the resulting papers are both obliquely and very badly written. Even when correct, the proofs may be weird. It is clear that many of the papers have not had input from mathematicians. OpenAI has appointed a maths advisory board but does not appear to be taking much advice.)

The question is, then, if bespoke AI is capable of this, what maths can commercial AI now achieve? I would bet that it, too, has come a long way and has probably mastered most of the UG curriculum. Even at Oxbridge.

MFL · 16/11/2026 21:38

So if AI does the grunt work, what’s the point of students studying maths and not getting the additional skills via discussion and group working? What skills are they actually getting? Oh - is it how to use AI?

poetryandwine · 16/11/2026 22:10

MFL · 16/11/2026 21:38

So if AI does the grunt work, what’s the point of students studying maths and not getting the additional skills via discussion and group working? What skills are they actually getting? Oh - is it how to use AI?

Over-reliance - almost any reliance - on AI by undergraduates is not helpful. Carefully calibrated interactions with AI are being suggested as an interim measure that can help OP’s DC learn to discuss maths and gain confidence. It is a beginning, not an end.

Simply asking AI to do your tutorial worksheets is utterly stupid.

SoftIce · Yesterday 06:50

Not to mention that they'd fail their exams quite spectacularly if they didn't put any thought into their interaction with AI.

ETA: Reading and understanding a proof is not enough (in that it will not help you solve other problems). You have to work with it at a deep level. I liked this essay:
https://cognitivemedium.com/srs-mathematics

While searching for the above essay, I stumbled across this one:
https://mikepawliuk.ca/2014/03/31/how-to-read-understand-and-study-proofs/