RCMJD or Yehudi Menuhin School

[CURIOUSMIND]

Please give me your comments .
Are they equally hard to get in? Fees to the value? Children's future is brighten up or narrowed down? Or anything else .

'I'm sure there are loads of accountants who wish they were musicians '

That's me!

I would practice hours a day, all the time, everyday.Piano has that wonderful sound that I can't explain how much I love it. My Mother always regreted for not giving me a chance to play when I was little.(We had to travel quite a lot due to the nature of my father's job.)

It 's not the first time I heard prefessional musican don't recomment this career.Me and DH hold the opinion, we don't push DC to be ,but don't stop them to be.

1805,
I asked my Ds1, asked many times .The answer is always yes, brilliant!
I explained to him that you need to practice at least 4 hours a day, everyday! Teachers might be very strict, tell you off! Maybe you are the worst player in the school! You won't be allowed to play hockey anymore!You may go to another country to perform without Mummy for a whole month long!
He still said ,don't worry Mummy.I am not scared.He is 8 1/2 now.

He sounds like a brave little soldier.
Hope to hear how you get on !

As I said upthread, same as Betelgeuse, the background of the BBC young musicians is very varied....

OP, have you looked at Purcell too? Or is it that you live near YM school that is attracting you there? Must admit, YM is lovely, great concert hall, but if he's going to board, you could go further afield

I wouldn't think about boarding no matter what. But we now have an opportunity to move very close to YM .That's part of the reason.

I will have another study of other possibilities.
Thank you to all again.

Oh I see - well YM might be really good as a day school. Best of luck with it!

'ask one of the important/known soloists or teachers to do an informal private audition '
Obviously there are several comments about the importance of bestest teacher.Now I realized this, and started to search for the possbile better teacher.
How can I get to know these high profile musicians? I am nothing to them, but a daydreadming mother.
I found our current piano teacher from musicteachers.co.uk.He is the most expensive one in my area, has got a Doctor degree and is working as head of music in an independent school.
But those famous teachers don't need to register on the website to find a job, do they?

Found loads of wedding pianist on the website,in the same way as a builder, a plumber are trying to sell themselves .Very sad!

High profile musician does not mean good teacher!

Sorry correction - High profile musician does not necessarily mean good teacher. I didn't mean to imply all high profile musicians are rubbish teachers

Dh's worst teacher was when he was at RCM. Playing came naturally to his teacher(big time musician), so he was pretty crap at actually teaching others.

Could have written that in one post - keep sending too early.

How do you know a teacher is a good teacher(for advanced level)?
I can see our current teacher boasted well on the web.He has got some method to improve the weak bit, all worked well .That's I think is important.
Something I dislike about this teacher is he never had any plan for us, terms based on payasyougo. He changed Ds1's interpretation, then may changed all back next week.This happened a couple of times.

You would need a very good teacher to get him through an audition .. Has he done any grades? G5 Distinction is a minimum standard for RCM - having said that exams are not that important , a distinction standard would suggest a descent teacher :).
There is no easy answer of how to find a good teacher - extensive research I would say. Trying to get one from a JD or YM school might be an idea - they have teaching staff lists published. But be prepared to pay accordingly :)

I wouldn't want you to think the only way into RCMJD at age 8 is with already having done loads of grades and to Already be performing at that level - they're not like that. They're looking for potential, and somehow they can spot it, even if you're not yet at that level. (so readers without the grades Already should not be put off!)

Shilke - am wondering when dh was at RCM? Pm me if you want to. Might be being too nosey though - sorry!

1805 - can't remember and he's working tonight. Didn't meet him until after that - I am not a musician! I'll PM you later.

I am running out of breath to read these!
I don't know whereelse can I get so many genuine, valuable, up to date, first hand information in a couple of days only.
Can't thank you enough guys! You rock!