Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

How long can people live like this?

513 replies

HoppityBun · 22/10/2026 19:07

This might seem callous, but I don’t mean it to be. The thing is, I’m bewildered about how long elderly, bedbound people in their 90s can continue to exist. I’ve got several relatives in this situation. One I know wishes that she had died several years ago: I know because she says so when her children aren’t around. One of the other others, actually it’s hard to tell but she focusses on the next meal, or tea, or sweets, and seems ok. Has a few UTIs and once had a very low breathing rate but was revived. The other, seems to be ok, but at other time seems to be sad and has twice commented that they “just wanted to be all over“.

They’re all in nursing homes, all mid 90s, all bedbound and I just don’t understand how it is that they continue to survive when they are not eating much and not getting any exercise. This has been going on since 2020 for one of them and 2-4 years for the other two.

It seems extraordinary to me and, to be honest, it’s getting family members down. I suppose it’s anticipatory grief, which we’re all warned against.

I’d be interested to know because the way things are going they could all live for another five or six years it seems to me. Gradually declining and getting thinner and paler, but just sort of existing. I don’t want that for myself and I hardly recognise them when I look at them, for the people they used to be. Has anybody else come across this? It’s particularly extraordinary because they’ve lived lives that I would have thought are contrary to all we told about healthy living. Granted, none of them ever drank or smoked, but none took any exercise that I remember. Yet still they are here.

How can the body go on existing?

OP posts:
Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 09:47

itstooorangeyforcrows · 01/11/2026 22:09

Why do you find that so hard to believe? Elsewhere on this thread you declared that elderly people 'have no quality of life'. If you're so happy to write off the elderly, what makes you so sure a doctor wouldn't make the same decision?

Because I’m talking about me, or people very very close to me, that I know their wishes.

You’re talking like every health care professional is a Shopman, ridiculous!

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 10:14

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 09:47

Because I’m talking about me, or people very very close to me, that I know their wishes.

You’re talking like every health care professional is a Shopman, ridiculous!

Assuming you mean Shipman, nowhere did I say ‘every’ healthcare professional is like that. I think it’s stunningly naive to assume these things don’t go on at all just because you have no personal awareness or experience of them, though.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 10:31

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 10:14

Assuming you mean Shipman, nowhere did I say ‘every’ healthcare professional is like that. I think it’s stunningly naive to assume these things don’t go on at all just because you have no personal awareness or experience of them, though.

And it’s even stranger that you’re saying this nonsense when the state do lot kill peoples off or make the decision.

I too have lived a life and as an older person, with every single one of friends and family having lost their parents, I concur that I have never heard this. You indicating this is common is nothing short of nonsense.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 10:58

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 10:31

And it’s even stranger that you’re saying this nonsense when the state do lot kill peoples off or make the decision.

I too have lived a life and as an older person, with every single one of friends and family having lost their parents, I concur that I have never heard this. You indicating this is common is nothing short of nonsense.

So basically in your world if something has never happened to you or someone you know, it doesn't happen? You're claiming people are never euthanised without consent because you've never heard of it happening? I don't think I'm the one talking nonsense on this thread.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 11:06

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 10:58

So basically in your world if something has never happened to you or someone you know, it doesn't happen? You're claiming people are never euthanised without consent because you've never heard of it happening? I don't think I'm the one talking nonsense on this thread.

No I don’t believe both your parents were killed by doctors administered lethal injections, you yourself only “think” it, as you’ve admitted.

Over active imagination?

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 11:13

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 11:06

No I don’t believe both your parents were killed by doctors administered lethal injections, you yourself only “think” it, as you’ve admitted.

Over active imagination?

You could at least try reading properly. That was a different poster.

NewspaperTaxis · 02/11/2026 11:28

Okay @LazyCrazyAndStupid - but that is also used as an excuse to deny the elderly food or drink, which, of course, is the Liverpool Care Pathway under a different name - or no name. They can dress it up as 'care'.
Then you get into how anyone can determine someone is at the 'end stage' - I mean, my mother went on like this for three years or so but God help you if you're put on their list of people who are about to die. She was downing 300ml of Peach Tea via straw every morning in Ewell's Priory Court Care Home - but I had to do it, the staff were never going to, not in over a year of us begging.

I have informed everyone about this - my local MPs Chris Grayling and now Epsom's Helen Maguire, all Surrey MPs in fact copied in, journalists who specialise in reporting on adult care, many Surrey County councillors - virtually nothing in response, save one councillor offering sympathy but nothing else. You notice that many such as my MP Ms Maguire are quite careful not even to admit to having read it - they want plausible deniability, I assume. Someone from Surrey Police did get in touch months later and very much wanted to discuss it. But I couldn't get past the suspicion it was a way for them to get me to volunteer for an interview without a solicitor present. I would have asked my MP Ms Maguire - for whom I voted - to accompany me but frankly it looks like I can't trust her either!

It's a big thing. But my point is, I sent my evidence out - having taken the issue successfully to the local and national press several times (though only the issue of bad care homes, they will not touch allegations of euthanasia) - I sent the 100-page evidence to over 500 people via email and all I got was that Surrey's Social Services acknowledged that this document had gone around to my MP - and tellingly didn't deny any of the allegations! They're laughing, they don't care.

The person who'd reported it to Surrey Police was from Surrey's Social Services - they're hardly going to dob themselves in it, so I did smell a rat.

Nobody's denied it, nor any court action - so euthanasia is certainly going on in Surrey and anyway, I understand 'passive euthanasia' is not illegal in this country anyway.

NewspaperTaxis · 02/11/2026 11:35

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 11:06

No I don’t believe both your parents were killed by doctors administered lethal injections, you yourself only “think” it, as you’ve admitted.

Over active imagination?

It's true, the other poster was responding in support to my comment.

It's a bit pointless arguing this on the basis that if you haven't seen it yourself, you'd struggle to believe it.

In fairness to @Chickpeacurrywithrice I must be a bit thick because it literally took years for me to consider that what the care homes were doing was deliberate. I just thought they were incompetent or didn't care when they didn't give Mum drink. I never considered it was the Liverpool Care Pathway or notorious end of life care laws passed under NICE. Largely because Mum didn't seem at the end of her life, she had come through a very bad time in hospital after a care home nearly killed her. The only thing putting her at the end of life subsequently was the care home's poor care - deliberate as it turned out.

Surrey's Social Services were steering it all behind the scenes it later emerged via a Subject Access Request to the Council - they were enraged because a) I'd dobbed one of their care homes in Banstead to the press after they nearly killed Mum and b) I'd unwittingly found out about subsequent dehydration programmes going on - but I hadn't realised it was actual policy, so in fact I wasn't going to report that to the press. And in any case, the press I found out won't touch those allegations with a barge pole. Maybe there's the equivalent of a D-notice applied.

If anyone wants a copy of the dossier or report I sent out to everyone, you are welcome to DM me and I'll send you a PDF.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 11:45

NewspaperTaxis · 02/11/2026 11:35

It's true, the other poster was responding in support to my comment.

It's a bit pointless arguing this on the basis that if you haven't seen it yourself, you'd struggle to believe it.

In fairness to @Chickpeacurrywithrice I must be a bit thick because it literally took years for me to consider that what the care homes were doing was deliberate. I just thought they were incompetent or didn't care when they didn't give Mum drink. I never considered it was the Liverpool Care Pathway or notorious end of life care laws passed under NICE. Largely because Mum didn't seem at the end of her life, she had come through a very bad time in hospital after a care home nearly killed her. The only thing putting her at the end of life subsequently was the care home's poor care - deliberate as it turned out.

Surrey's Social Services were steering it all behind the scenes it later emerged via a Subject Access Request to the Council - they were enraged because a) I'd dobbed one of their care homes in Banstead to the press after they nearly killed Mum and b) I'd unwittingly found out about subsequent dehydration programmes going on - but I hadn't realised it was actual policy, so in fact I wasn't going to report that to the press. And in any case, the press I found out won't touch those allegations with a barge pole. Maybe there's the equivalent of a D-notice applied.

If anyone wants a copy of the dossier or report I sent out to everyone, you are welcome to DM me and I'll send you a PDF.

Edited

This is some horrifying stuff, and the saddest thing is it doesn't surprise me at all. This thread got me thinking about the LCP, I know it's supposed to have been withdrawn but having witnessed my dad's and in particular my FIL's passings in hospital, I have suspected ever since that it's still around, just not under that name.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 12:37

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 11:13

You could at least try reading properly. That was a different poster.

Oh I see you just decided the other poster was correct and have no actual reason too! Even worse!

Anyway I shall move on, the only issue being I still think healthcare people over step the mark on keeping people alive.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 12:38

NewspaperTaxis · 02/11/2026 11:35

It's true, the other poster was responding in support to my comment.

It's a bit pointless arguing this on the basis that if you haven't seen it yourself, you'd struggle to believe it.

In fairness to @Chickpeacurrywithrice I must be a bit thick because it literally took years for me to consider that what the care homes were doing was deliberate. I just thought they were incompetent or didn't care when they didn't give Mum drink. I never considered it was the Liverpool Care Pathway or notorious end of life care laws passed under NICE. Largely because Mum didn't seem at the end of her life, she had come through a very bad time in hospital after a care home nearly killed her. The only thing putting her at the end of life subsequently was the care home's poor care - deliberate as it turned out.

Surrey's Social Services were steering it all behind the scenes it later emerged via a Subject Access Request to the Council - they were enraged because a) I'd dobbed one of their care homes in Banstead to the press after they nearly killed Mum and b) I'd unwittingly found out about subsequent dehydration programmes going on - but I hadn't realised it was actual policy, so in fact I wasn't going to report that to the press. And in any case, the press I found out won't touch those allegations with a barge pole. Maybe there's the equivalent of a D-notice applied.

If anyone wants a copy of the dossier or report I sent out to everyone, you are welcome to DM me and I'll send you a PDF.

Edited

I’m not a bit thick at all!

NewspaperTaxis · 02/11/2026 13:17

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 12:38

I’m not a bit thick at all!

@Chickpeacurrywithrice I do think on the evidence of your last few points you don't seem at the races today - I never said you were thick and I didn't phrase it obliquely. I said I was 'thick' - because it took me years to suspect that the day-to-day dehydration of my mother in a care home was actually deliberate.

My point was that, like you, it simply never occurred to me that this was going on. You certainly don't read about these allegations in the press, but then I've noticed that care home scandal stories are very thin on the ground these days, they used not to be, but I think the Covid lockdown shot that fox. That was so awful it became a case of, well, if the State can do that, they can do anything.

Believe it or not I have sympathy with those who have relatives just hanging on for years and there is a checklist where I would agree it is best to pull the plug. a) No chance of recovery, it's a terminal illness b) No friends or family who love them c) Completely ga-ga and doesn't recognise friends or family d) Doesn't enjoy food or music e) In day to day physical pain f) Past a certain age

The State applies that checklist too but is a bit cavalier about it, and runs roughshod over alternative realities or evidence.

But like I say, this is in Surrey, or was, given what I experienced. My mother was pre-Covid, for instance. It may be very different where you live.

Secretseverywhere · 02/11/2026 15:05

HouseBee · 01/11/2026 12:14

I’m going to guess that it depends which world you are inhabiting.

Im chronically ill with an illness that has no treatment. But you not typically die from it. You just have a very bad quality of life for years on end.
Many people in Canada for example are offered no treatment, even for simple pain reduction. It can take months and months to see any consultant. Not working means no support re housing etc…
On the other end, if they want AD, they can see someone in a week. Are approved within a couple of weeks. And quite a few go down that route because theyre let down by the whole system/don’t have a network around them. NOT because they want to die.

Many other stories with ND people, many other illnesses etc….

Also saying ‘it’s only 6% of the deaths so it’s ok’ 😳😳😳

There’s a reason why AD didn’t make it through the system in the U.K.
Until there are proper safeguards for disabled people, people with SN/SEN etc etc… it’s just not acceptable.

Im saying 6% to demonstrate it’s still pretty niche. Far more people would be eligible but even after 20 years ( Netherlands as that is system I am familiar with) it’s still predominantly used by people who are dying with cancer.

Yes there are other cases that are sonetimes oversimplified to a clickbait headline but. I believe the system works to alleviate suffering for those that would choose it.

I was disappointed that assisted dying didn’t go through. Not because I wish to harm anyone else but for me it’d be a comfort to know that I had choices open to me in the future.

I am sorry that you are struggling with your health but at the same time I don’t see why I shouldn’t have a choice just because you don’t want one?

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 15:15

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 02/11/2026 12:37

Oh I see you just decided the other poster was correct and have no actual reason too! Even worse!

Anyway I shall move on, the only issue being I still think healthcare people over step the mark on keeping people alive.

Of course you're going to 'move on', because it's easier than admitting you made a mistake. 😂

If you meant I 'decided the other poster was correct and have no actual reason to', well actually opinion forums do tend to work on the basis of people either agreeing or disagreeing with each other, sorry to break it to you. And plenty of 'actual reasons' have been given on this thread, you just don't want to hear them. That's some industrial-strength denial you've got going on there.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 03/11/2026 04:25

itstooorangeyforcrows · 02/11/2026 15:15

Of course you're going to 'move on', because it's easier than admitting you made a mistake. 😂

If you meant I 'decided the other poster was correct and have no actual reason to', well actually opinion forums do tend to work on the basis of people either agreeing or disagreeing with each other, sorry to break it to you. And plenty of 'actual reasons' have been given on this thread, you just don't want to hear them. That's some industrial-strength denial you've got going on there.

to be clear u don’t think any health professionals are killing elderly patients!

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 03/11/2026 04:26

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 03/11/2026 04:25

to be clear u don’t think any health professionals are killing elderly patients!

Because I don’t think they are being liked by health professionals.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 03/11/2026 09:14

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 03/11/2026 04:25

to be clear u don’t think any health professionals are killing elderly patients!

I've made it perfectly clear in my posts that I believe it does go on.

GnomeDePlume · 04/11/2026 07:20

If there is passive euthenasia available I wish it would get round to my DM.

Yes, you read that right, I want my DM to die.

She has vascular dementia, bedbound, doubly incontinent, doesnt know who she is let alone anyone else. Cant do anything for herself.

UnexpectedlyRetired · 04/11/2026 09:50

@GnomeDePlume I think most of us with elderly relatives who are very sick, in pain, and with no hope of recovery want the end to come quickly. It would be a mercy for them.

If they don't know what's happening to them or around them, then what is their quality of life? And if they do know, that's even worse.

NewspaperTaxis · 04/11/2026 10:40

UnexpectedlyRetired · 04/11/2026 09:50

@GnomeDePlume I think most of us with elderly relatives who are very sick, in pain, and with no hope of recovery want the end to come quickly. It would be a mercy for them.

If they don't know what's happening to them or around them, then what is their quality of life? And if they do know, that's even worse.

The thing is, I don't disagree with this. I'm only against the Assisted Dying bill because I think/know it will be abused. Not everything is a slipper slope, but this looks like the Black Run to me.

When we see what NHS Trusts and County Councils have gotten away with in recent years/decades... they are generally unaccountable and all about the money.

UnexpectedlyRetired · 04/11/2026 10:42

@NewspaperTaxis yes I agree. So I don't know what the answer is.

midnight4 · 04/11/2026 10:50

NewspaperTaxis · 04/11/2026 10:40

The thing is, I don't disagree with this. I'm only against the Assisted Dying bill because I think/know it will be abused. Not everything is a slipper slope, but this looks like the Black Run to me.

When we see what NHS Trusts and County Councils have gotten away with in recent years/decades... they are generally unaccountable and all about the money.

I still think assisted dying and euthanasia are needed.

GnomeDePlume · 04/11/2026 11:09

I think beyond a crrtain point maybe age, maybe capacity related, treatment of disease should stop being the default approach. Immediate comfort should be the default.

Treatment should become 'opt in' rather than 'opt out'. The sprightly 87 year old can say they do want to have the treatment for XYZ and they understand what that will entail.

Looking back at my DM's decline there have been various points where IMO treatment (eg ABs) shouldnt have been given.

We need to be having the conversations with partners, with adult DCs, with older relatives. I am having these conversations with my adult DCs. Maybe I'm strange but I was talking about funerals with DC yesterday, DH and I are thinking about pre-paying.

We all die so we should talk about how we feel about later life care. Better to talk about it when you have time than to be trying to guess what someone would want when you are sat in A&E.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 04/11/2026 17:19

midnight4 · 04/11/2026 10:50

I still think assisted dying and euthanasia are needed.

So, in other words, you want us to legalise both people being able to choose to die, and people being killed against their will. Why not just use those words?

itstooorangeyforcrows · 04/11/2026 17:22

GnomeDePlume · 04/11/2026 11:09

I think beyond a crrtain point maybe age, maybe capacity related, treatment of disease should stop being the default approach. Immediate comfort should be the default.

Treatment should become 'opt in' rather than 'opt out'. The sprightly 87 year old can say they do want to have the treatment for XYZ and they understand what that will entail.

Looking back at my DM's decline there have been various points where IMO treatment (eg ABs) shouldnt have been given.

We need to be having the conversations with partners, with adult DCs, with older relatives. I am having these conversations with my adult DCs. Maybe I'm strange but I was talking about funerals with DC yesterday, DH and I are thinking about pre-paying.

We all die so we should talk about how we feel about later life care. Better to talk about it when you have time than to be trying to guess what someone would want when you are sat in A&E.

You don't think that perhaps 'don't kill me unless I've signed a form expressly permitting it' should be the default, perhaps? 🤔