Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

How long can people live like this?

513 replies

HoppityBun · 22/10/2026 19:07

This might seem callous, but I don’t mean it to be. The thing is, I’m bewildered about how long elderly, bedbound people in their 90s can continue to exist. I’ve got several relatives in this situation. One I know wishes that she had died several years ago: I know because she says so when her children aren’t around. One of the other others, actually it’s hard to tell but she focusses on the next meal, or tea, or sweets, and seems ok. Has a few UTIs and once had a very low breathing rate but was revived. The other, seems to be ok, but at other time seems to be sad and has twice commented that they “just wanted to be all over“.

They’re all in nursing homes, all mid 90s, all bedbound and I just don’t understand how it is that they continue to survive when they are not eating much and not getting any exercise. This has been going on since 2020 for one of them and 2-4 years for the other two.

It seems extraordinary to me and, to be honest, it’s getting family members down. I suppose it’s anticipatory grief, which we’re all warned against.

I’d be interested to know because the way things are going they could all live for another five or six years it seems to me. Gradually declining and getting thinner and paler, but just sort of existing. I don’t want that for myself and I hardly recognise them when I look at them, for the people they used to be. Has anybody else come across this? It’s particularly extraordinary because they’ve lived lives that I would have thought are contrary to all we told about healthy living. Granted, none of them ever drank or smoked, but none took any exercise that I remember. Yet still they are here.

How can the body go on existing?

OP posts:
Minasama · 30/10/2026 15:26

I hear you OP - my grandmother was like this from age 90-97, had dementia, just existed. It was heartbreaking. Her heart and lungs were very sound and it was a great shame she lost her cognitive facilities.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/10/2026 16:34

@itstooorangeyforcrows yes I am, and as several posters have subsequently written and I’ve witnessed, these are conversations that need to be had a lot more often. As I wrote, there really are worse things in life than dying. It isn’t like greys anatomy or scrubs.
However, as you are quite right to point out there have been and will continue to be abuses and unfortunately there’s no way around that. As with anything, not just healthcare, people get it wrong, either through ignorance, lack of training, greed annd a whole host of other reasons, abuse of systems does happen. Humans are flawed as are computers and AI. Nothing is perfect. But the current system is not a caring system- and that is implicit surely in the term healthcare?

itstooorangeyforcrows · 30/10/2026 18:14

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/10/2026 16:34

@itstooorangeyforcrows yes I am, and as several posters have subsequently written and I’ve witnessed, these are conversations that need to be had a lot more often. As I wrote, there really are worse things in life than dying. It isn’t like greys anatomy or scrubs.
However, as you are quite right to point out there have been and will continue to be abuses and unfortunately there’s no way around that. As with anything, not just healthcare, people get it wrong, either through ignorance, lack of training, greed annd a whole host of other reasons, abuse of systems does happen. Humans are flawed as are computers and AI. Nothing is perfect. But the current system is not a caring system- and that is implicit surely in the term healthcare?

It's precisely because there will be abuses that there should be boundaries in place that can't be crossed no matter what. And I've no idea why you think I get my views on life and death from the TV, I've been through plenty of things myself that have informed my view on this.

But if you're advocating going against a person's stated wish to continue living, in circumstances where they can be enabled to do so, then I don't see any value in continuing to debate this with you because I will never see things your way.

I really hope you don't work in medicine.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 30/10/2026 18:18

HouseBee · 30/10/2026 14:47

Actually, it’s done more than you think.
Yes it’s a DNR but it could be not giving antibiotics for example.

Few people actually have an idea of what resuscitation entails. In what state people end up in if they survive etc….
And doctors are very reluctant to go into details with the patient (it’s not an easy Discussion to have so it’s often avoided or done badly)

I'm not talking CPR, I understand the realities of that and I agree it's somewhat different in that instance.

Your comment about it being 'done more than you think' doesn't surprise me at all, unfortunately.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/10/2026 18:23

@itstooorangeyforcrows a persons wish to continue to live isn’t always an informed choice nor are some capable of making an informed choice. There will always be abuses. In your world the abuse could well be that someone is kept alive as simply being a heart beat on a machine and nothing more. To me, and a lot of others that action is also something to be considered an abuse. It would also be an abuse to keep someone alive against their express wishes. The has to be an element of care and a middle ground not a one extreme and nothing else to be considered approach.
No I do not know your life experience just as you do not know mine or any other posters on this thread, nor are you even willing to read and understand anyone’s else’s position or legal and moral points.
very sad.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 30/10/2026 18:46

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/10/2026 18:23

@itstooorangeyforcrows a persons wish to continue to live isn’t always an informed choice nor are some capable of making an informed choice. There will always be abuses. In your world the abuse could well be that someone is kept alive as simply being a heart beat on a machine and nothing more. To me, and a lot of others that action is also something to be considered an abuse. It would also be an abuse to keep someone alive against their express wishes. The has to be an element of care and a middle ground not a one extreme and nothing else to be considered approach.
No I do not know your life experience just as you do not know mine or any other posters on this thread, nor are you even willing to read and understand anyone’s else’s position or legal and moral points.
very sad.

I've read and understood everything. I disagree with some of it. Do you normally accuse people of not understanding and being 'sad' when they disagree with you?

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/10/2026 19:08

@itstooorangeyforcrows 🤣. I do call it sad when someone is not even willing to read or listen too and understand anyone’s else’s position or legal and moral points. Especially when there’s more than just one person making the exact same points.

You don’t disagree with some of it. You disagree with all of it. I don’t think you’ve understood anything, rather you are outright slamming all discussion and viewpoints as flat out wrong. But then I also thought you were not going to engage with me again as you -“ don't see any value in continuing to debate this with you because I will never see things your way.” too quote you directly.

Papyrophile · 30/10/2026 20:45

I stand quite firmly on the side of the oldest person in the picture. If they want to continue, That's wonderful. If they prefer the exit route, I agree to that too, but I might need some written and signed authority.

Secretseverywhere · 30/10/2026 21:11

itstooorangeyforcrows · 30/10/2026 15:23

Yes, there has to. But from some of the things that get said on these threads, I always get a horrible feeling that we could end up with scenarios where a person is not ready to die, treatment could give them more time, and they are denied anyway for reasons of expediency, for want of a better word. I think it would be naive to assume that could never happen.

I accept it's not the same thing legally, but I stand by my view that it's just as bad morally.

I do think you’re right that some people will die despite there being some degree of life prolonging treatment available.

There is a line at which point it’s considered futile to continue medical care. The patient is never going to recover and even if every effort was made would continue to deteriorate albeit slower.

For example the patient with MND, he could have been treated with active ventilation but all control would continue to waste away and eventually could cause shut in syndrome. It’s medically futile to put someone on a difficult treatment regimen (requires intensive 24hr care) if all you are doing is prolonging death by a short period.

TiredofMotorways · 30/10/2026 21:21

I haven't read this whole thread but I have certainly encountered elderly people who very clearly and consistently express that they want their miserable life to end. A friend's granny bedbound with an inoperable (she was too frail) broken hip repeatedly askin "why won't you let me die? Please let me die"

And now my own DM saying "I should have died (when she had her disabling stroke), I shouldn't still be here and I don't want to be." It's just awful, she's content enough while we're there but she knows we can't be there all the time. And she knows she has no power at all over her situation.

Keepgettingolder81 · 30/10/2026 21:28

Fashion, get off the thread. You are taking away any decent discussion by deliberately arguing the opposite and trying to bring attention to yourself. Not all threats are for everyone Hun.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 30/10/2026 22:28

Secretseverywhere · 30/10/2026 21:11

I do think you’re right that some people will die despite there being some degree of life prolonging treatment available.

There is a line at which point it’s considered futile to continue medical care. The patient is never going to recover and even if every effort was made would continue to deteriorate albeit slower.

For example the patient with MND, he could have been treated with active ventilation but all control would continue to waste away and eventually could cause shut in syndrome. It’s medically futile to put someone on a difficult treatment regimen (requires intensive 24hr care) if all you are doing is prolonging death by a short period.

See, as much as I would agree that medically there's always a line, a close friend's recent passing from MND was one of the issues that helped to form my view that it must always be up to the person. Early on, this friend was considering the possible need for exit strategies, so to speak, further down the line, but for some reason I don't think even he could understand, as the illness progressed so did his determination to hang on as long as possible. It defied apparent logic, and yet it was his wish and I personally feel it needed to be respected regardless of the eventual outcome. If this had taken place in Canada I feel certain he'd have been encouraged to consider MAID. And given some of the views expressed on this thread, if we end up with a MAID-style system here, it's only a matter of time before people with conditions such as MND are being 'encouraged' to give consent to being killed, perhaps in part as a matter of expediency. It's an awful thought, but sadly I don't think it's an impossible prospect.

Cushionthefloor · 30/10/2026 22:51

TiredofMotorways · 30/10/2026 21:21

I haven't read this whole thread but I have certainly encountered elderly people who very clearly and consistently express that they want their miserable life to end. A friend's granny bedbound with an inoperable (she was too frail) broken hip repeatedly askin "why won't you let me die? Please let me die"

And now my own DM saying "I should have died (when she had her disabling stroke), I shouldn't still be here and I don't want to be." It's just awful, she's content enough while we're there but she knows we can't be there all the time. And she knows she has no power at all over her situation.

My mums cousin begged to die for 5 years - it’s not what anyone wants to hear, we’re all supposed to be grateful for our lives - the reality when you are very old, in pain and not capable of self care is some what different. So few people talk about it but the experience is real and it’s truly awful.

Secretseverywhere · 31/10/2026 00:35

itstooorangeyforcrows · 30/10/2026 22:28

See, as much as I would agree that medically there's always a line, a close friend's recent passing from MND was one of the issues that helped to form my view that it must always be up to the person. Early on, this friend was considering the possible need for exit strategies, so to speak, further down the line, but for some reason I don't think even he could understand, as the illness progressed so did his determination to hang on as long as possible. It defied apparent logic, and yet it was his wish and I personally feel it needed to be respected regardless of the eventual outcome. If this had taken place in Canada I feel certain he'd have been encouraged to consider MAID. And given some of the views expressed on this thread, if we end up with a MAID-style system here, it's only a matter of time before people with conditions such as MND are being 'encouraged' to give consent to being killed, perhaps in part as a matter of expediency. It's an awful thought, but sadly I don't think it's an impossible prospect.

I’ve a lot of Dutch relatives do I think I’m more in favour of assisted dying as I’ve seen how it works firsthand.

I know people are concerned about pressure but the vast majority of deaths 94% in NL / 95% in Canada are not assisted. I’m not denying that there have been troubling cases but I think that if there was widespread pressure those numbers would be higher.

I have relatives who are card carrying members of a society that says they don’t want to be euthanised for any reason as well as those on the other side. I think there is room for both opinions to be mutually respected. Perhaps selfishly I would like assisted dying to be introduced here as I would like a choice not because I want anyone else’s choice to be curtailed.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 31/10/2026 10:12

Secretseverywhere · 31/10/2026 00:35

I’ve a lot of Dutch relatives do I think I’m more in favour of assisted dying as I’ve seen how it works firsthand.

I know people are concerned about pressure but the vast majority of deaths 94% in NL / 95% in Canada are not assisted. I’m not denying that there have been troubling cases but I think that if there was widespread pressure those numbers would be higher.

I have relatives who are card carrying members of a society that says they don’t want to be euthanised for any reason as well as those on the other side. I think there is room for both opinions to be mutually respected. Perhaps selfishly I would like assisted dying to be introduced here as I would like a choice not because I want anyone else’s choice to be curtailed.

I have relatives who are card carrying members of a society that says they don’t want to be euthanised for any reason

I think this is the closest thing we have to a solution, personally.

user47639820987 · 31/10/2026 13:06

‘I would like assisted dying to be introduced here as I would like a choice’
This. When it came to it I might not want to, but it would bring me tremendous comfort to know that I could opt for AD if I wanted to.
I think a lot of people feel the same way- it’d be wonderful to have the option!

Secretseverywhere · 31/10/2026 14:15

user47639820987 · 31/10/2026 13:06

‘I would like assisted dying to be introduced here as I would like a choice’
This. When it came to it I might not want to, but it would bring me tremendous comfort to know that I could opt for AD if I wanted to.
I think a lot of people feel the same way- it’d be wonderful to have the option!

I’d agree, statistically you probably wouldnt use it, only 1 in 20 would, but for me it would provide peace of mind to have the option.

Ved · 31/10/2026 14:53

Keepgettingolder81 · 30/10/2026 21:28

Fashion, get off the thread. You are taking away any decent discussion by deliberately arguing the opposite and trying to bring attention to yourself. Not all threats are for everyone Hun.

Who are you talking to?

NewspaperTaxis · 31/10/2026 23:39

Guess this has been pointed out, but bear in mind if someone is deemed to have lost mental capacity, the decision is not theirs, it's made by the State - and the State saves money from their death.
Losing mental capacity does not mean totally ga-ga, it may just mean they're not conversational, or won't squeeze the doctor's hand when they ask. My mum was deemed to have lost it, but we took her out for the day, she enjoyed her food, music, our company, knew who she, where she was and who we were etc, nonetheless without our consent or knowledge - as we didn't have LPA in Health and Welfare - she was put on end of life care, which meant dehydration in various Surrey care homes. Not sure that's even illegal, but they get away with it.

I have no idea why some people are kept alive in far worse state than my mother though it may be as she had Parkinson's, there is a different kind of decline and their swallow packs up, which may mean they trying to kill her off before that point (we paid for a PEG to be fitted).

I think both Mum and years later Dad were killed off via an injection of something, it was done under our very noses. We didn't give permission but both has lost capacity by that point so...

Cannot square this with other stories of people being allowed to go on forever, though again these other examples, often they are cognisant so that makes it trickier to justify and harder to slip under the radar.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 01/11/2026 00:51

NewspaperTaxis · 31/10/2026 23:39

Guess this has been pointed out, but bear in mind if someone is deemed to have lost mental capacity, the decision is not theirs, it's made by the State - and the State saves money from their death.
Losing mental capacity does not mean totally ga-ga, it may just mean they're not conversational, or won't squeeze the doctor's hand when they ask. My mum was deemed to have lost it, but we took her out for the day, she enjoyed her food, music, our company, knew who she, where she was and who we were etc, nonetheless without our consent or knowledge - as we didn't have LPA in Health and Welfare - she was put on end of life care, which meant dehydration in various Surrey care homes. Not sure that's even illegal, but they get away with it.

I have no idea why some people are kept alive in far worse state than my mother though it may be as she had Parkinson's, there is a different kind of decline and their swallow packs up, which may mean they trying to kill her off before that point (we paid for a PEG to be fitted).

I think both Mum and years later Dad were killed off via an injection of something, it was done under our very noses. We didn't give permission but both has lost capacity by that point so...

Cannot square this with other stories of people being allowed to go on forever, though again these other examples, often they are cognisant so that makes it trickier to justify and harder to slip under the radar.

Edited

Sorry I do not believe that either of your parents were killed off by “an injection”, to happen once would be unbelievable, but both of them?

As previous posters have said, it’s far from what happens in care homes.

SnoringNora · 01/11/2026 10:54

CrazyMidget · 28/10/2026 09:41

Yes, chemo is rough, but then you get better. I know lots of people who had rough chemo but a couple of years on are living great, active lives again.

I’d just love to see the people in their fifties and sixties who are saying they’d have no treatment actually stick to that if diagnosed. Of course they wouldn’t, not as young as that. I also find such statements highly offensive. Both my late parents would have done anything to live longer, so I wish it had happened to the refusing-treatment lot instead of to them.

DM was only 64 when she refused further cancer treatment if you want an example. She had had cancer treatments in her 50s and early 60s with success and there was further treatment on offer to prolong her life for at least a year.

But, it made her feel dreadful. She decided there was no point in living for a year feeling the way she did. So she refused the treatment and died within 6 weeks. In pain and heavily morphined up. 6 weeks of this.

I mean, it meant we could all get to say goodbye but why she couldn’t just have had that extra dose of morphine to help her slip away sooner, I don’t understand. Inhumane. Thank goodness she had capacity to make this decision.

HouseBee · 01/11/2026 12:14

Secretseverywhere · 31/10/2026 00:35

I’ve a lot of Dutch relatives do I think I’m more in favour of assisted dying as I’ve seen how it works firsthand.

I know people are concerned about pressure but the vast majority of deaths 94% in NL / 95% in Canada are not assisted. I’m not denying that there have been troubling cases but I think that if there was widespread pressure those numbers would be higher.

I have relatives who are card carrying members of a society that says they don’t want to be euthanised for any reason as well as those on the other side. I think there is room for both opinions to be mutually respected. Perhaps selfishly I would like assisted dying to be introduced here as I would like a choice not because I want anyone else’s choice to be curtailed.

I’m going to guess that it depends which world you are inhabiting.

Im chronically ill with an illness that has no treatment. But you not typically die from it. You just have a very bad quality of life for years on end.
Many people in Canada for example are offered no treatment, even for simple pain reduction. It can take months and months to see any consultant. Not working means no support re housing etc…
On the other end, if they want AD, they can see someone in a week. Are approved within a couple of weeks. And quite a few go down that route because theyre let down by the whole system/don’t have a network around them. NOT because they want to die.

Many other stories with ND people, many other illnesses etc….

Also saying ‘it’s only 6% of the deaths so it’s ok’ 😳😳😳

There’s a reason why AD didn’t make it through the system in the U.K.
Until there are proper safeguards for disabled people, people with SN/SEN etc etc… it’s just not acceptable.

itstooorangeyforcrows · 01/11/2026 22:09

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 01/11/2026 00:51

Sorry I do not believe that either of your parents were killed off by “an injection”, to happen once would be unbelievable, but both of them?

As previous posters have said, it’s far from what happens in care homes.

Why do you find that so hard to believe? Elsewhere on this thread you declared that elderly people 'have no quality of life'. If you're so happy to write off the elderly, what makes you so sure a doctor wouldn't make the same decision?

NewspaperTaxis · 01/11/2026 23:11

itstooorangeyforcrows · 01/11/2026 22:09

Why do you find that so hard to believe? Elsewhere on this thread you declared that elderly people 'have no quality of life'. If you're so happy to write off the elderly, what makes you so sure a doctor wouldn't make the same decision?

People either believe this or they don't. It's an odd one.

I mentioned this to a bloke doing some sort of inspection of care homes - this was years ago - sort of hesitatingly: 'Erm, they kill them off.' 'Oh, I know that,' he said dismissively. Mentioned it to my neighbour a few doors down. 'Oh, they did that with my father, they put something in his drip, upped the morphine... . He was on his way out anyway, but It was the fact they put one over us, the deceit, that was annoying.'

Some on this thread are happy to believe some residents are kept alive in care homes for financial reasons, but find it hard to believe they might be killed for financial reasons. It does save money, even if the family is self-funding.

There's an organisation called Families Against Involuntary Euthanasia if anyone's interested.

On a more basic note, if your parent has Parkinson's do get their affairs in order, we found lots of uncashed cheques from share dividends, several years old, after Mum had died, some significant sums, not really recoverable. This can also happen if your parent had hoarding tendencies.

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 02/11/2026 09:44

FlyingCatGirl · 23/10/2026 13:26

I suppose an older and frailer person might pass quicker using that method than those people that do hunger strikes for political reasons and seem to go on for a good while - for me it's the thirst i'd dread, being really thirsty drives me mad!

Hi I've done a lot of reading up on this. When elderly patients in "end stage" refuse food and drink it is usually because they genuinely don't feel hunger or thirst and forcing them to eat or drink is actually more unpleasant as their bodies can't cope with it at that stage. It's different to dying of thirst when you are not at the end stage (as your body craves water) and want to drink but can't. I think in palliative care they just wet their lips as dry lips can be unpleasant rather than thirst.