Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Cockroach Cafe - Autumn

970 replies

rookiemere · 13/09/2026 08:06

A new thread but the same themes, for those of us going through the ongoing challenges of supporting elderly DPs and relatives.
No judgement just support and virtual gins or tea on tap depending on your preferences.

OP posts:
deutschland83 · 16/11/2026 14:18

BestIsWest · 16/11/2026 13:41

I wonder how capacity is decided. I have quite a good relationship with DMs’s GP as DM told the practice she is happy for them to talk to me about anything. We also have both POAs in place. But the GP has asked me more than once if DM has capacity and I’m at a loss as to what the answer is. She certainly doesn’t understand or remember that she has normal pressure Hydrocephalus.

GP has brought up the DNR topic more than once. I’ve tried to discuss with DM but she doesn’t quite get it. DB has said no to it. I don’t understand why as he was there when the paramedics were trying to save DF (we both were, they failed) and I don’t understand why he would want a frail 89 year old to go through that.

We did wills and LPAs for each other during the pandemic but it was a bit of a Fuchs and we probably need to revisit.

At the moment DM knows where she is, her birthday and can talk to the doctors. Therefore she has full capacity.

I asked as I have to live with her decisions.

rookiemere · 16/11/2026 14:20

I think the health POA only really comes into place if the person is deemed to no longer have capacity.
I have said before that doctors seem to struggle with this concept of capacity and tbh I don’t blame them. I presume they went into medicine with some general intent of helping people and capacity discussions seem to be mostly playing God with other people’s lives without a definitive rule book.

The care home have responded quickly to my concerns about the administration of antibiotics but now we seem to be doing the two step around capacity, with me vaguely implying they’re a bit incompetent and them not so subtly suggesting I am trying to bump off my mother.

OP posts:
ElderlyDilemmas · 16/11/2026 14:23

Capacity can be fluctuating though, I did use the health LPA for mum when she was delirious on morphine following an accident after the consultant explained but she was OK again after recovering.

MysterOfwomanY · 16/11/2026 15:02

Capacity can be decision dependent too.
The Court Of Protection cases on https://www.bailii.org/ often have cases where someone can decide some things but not others
You have to understand info and retain it and use it to make your decision, iirc.

British and Irish Legal Information Institute

https://www.bailii.org

GnomeDePlume · 16/11/2026 15:11

DB and I have both LPAs for DM.

DM was formally assessed as having lost capacity when the CH was wanting to put a DOLS in place. DM was frequently trying to escape the CH in her wheelchair declaring she needed to see her DPs/her DH/ her DSis all of whom have long since died.

Up until this point the attitude to capacity by HCPs and the CH depended on what suited their purposes. When it was being decided whether to fit DM with a pacemaker they were happy to accept DM didnt have capacity (I decided against it). At other times the CH nurse has said they will decide on appropriate treatment for DM.

It is all a bit of a mess. The LPA system doesnt seem to be fit for purpose.

bigdogpaws · 16/11/2026 15:41

I agree with @GnomeDePlume that the whole LPA system doesn't seem to be fit for purpose. Personally I think, for everyone's benefit, we could do with a clearer and better understood definition of 'capacity' and perhaps even specific rules for specific common circumstances.

I am in a slightly unusual situation in that Mum has signed a form at her GP that allows them to discuss her medical details with me, but I don't have health LPA. Mum technically has capacity but doesn't, in my opinion, really have the ability to consider the information she's presented with, weigh it up and make an informed decision. My observation is that even with simple decisions like what she wants for lunch (from 2 or 3 options) is difficult for her and her usual response is to either just say the last option she's heard or ask what I think is best. If there was a contentious decision to make I suspect they'd have to try to get her to make a decision and assess whether she has capacity for that decision.

Brother has sole LPA for finance and health. It's a long story, but although I am currently expected to help her with both, and he has as little to do with either as possible, he has persuaded her that this is the best decision. To get the LPA they had to have someone certify that essentially she has capacity, understands what she's doing by appointing LPA and has not been coerced. The person certifying this does not need to have any training or particular knowledge- they asked an old friend of Mums. From conversations I have had with Mum recently I really don't think she has any understanding of what the LPA really means- she just thinks I can carry on as I am at the moment (which requires her to be involved, eg. to authorise payments, sign forms etc). There are many reasons why I think he wanted it this way, but I suspect the main one is that he believes if he has both LPAs he can refuse to agree to her going in to residential care, or to pay for any care, so 'we' will have to look after her until the end.

EmotionalBlackmail · 16/11/2026 16:24

Eclipsing · 16/11/2026 09:58

How many of you have LPoA for health?

I have LPoA set up for myself, and after literally years of bitter arguments, my DM allowed one to be set up for her (it's registered now etc but she hasn't given permission for it to be used and I doubt she ever will - but at least when/if all her marbles do eventually roll away, it's ready!)

But both are for finance only. It seems to me that the health ones are not worth the paper they're written on. An attorney can't insist on particular aspects of healthcare, they can only make known the wishes of the ill person, and that is easily overriden (either deliberately or by default) by medics, nurses and caregivers. And of course, we can make the EPs prior wishes known without a LPoA (with about as much success!)

What are everyone's feelings and impressions on this?

It’s more like being able to consent to your own treatment than anything else. So giving consent for the annual flu/Covid jabs, if they have to have a hospital procedure, that kind of thing.

GnomeDePlume · 16/11/2026 20:50

The problem with this grey situation so many are in is that it is all too easy for the elderly person to be manipulated to give the answer which is wanted by the person doing the asking.

It might be something relatively harmless such as choosing the easiest dinner option. But it might be something significant. One of the nurses at DM's CH was very full of his own importance and insisted that he could help DM to make decisions (this before the DOLS). Thankfully he has now gone.

It feels now that the pendulum has swung too much in the direction of insisting people have capacity to make decisions when they really dont.

The whole system moves far too slowly. It is also very black and white. DB and I are joint for finance. If either of us decides we dont want to do it then the whole POA fails.

MotherOfCatBoy · 16/11/2026 21:15

I have Health and Finance for DPs and am an only child. I persuaded them to do it about 5 years ago using examples of “what if you are in hospital/ have a fever/ get hit by a bus and can’t tell them what you want, or can’t get to the bank?) (At the time they were doing all their banking in person, Barclays have since put paid to that by closing all the branches and now hallelujah it’s online).

They still have capacity. I have registered it with their GP surgery and have found that they will talk to me, and I go to medical appointments with them. Finance has been a bit of a farce as Barclays registered it two different ways for DM and DF so I have a debit card etc for Dad but not Mum (long story), but with online banking we manage. We haven’t really encountered a very serious situation in which to use it yet.

I wonder about situational capacity. To be fair to DM she is reasonably savvy financially and though she’s hopeless with the internet, if I sit with her and do the screen, she is perfectly capable of making decisions about savings etc, and can forward think about interest rates etc. On the other hand she will have the screaming ab dabs about throwing out a piece of rotten veg from the fridge, so go figure…

Exhaustedpickle · 16/11/2026 21:22

My DM has capacity and my siblings and I have health and financial PoA at her request.

@MotherOfCatBoy I have a similar situation - my DM forgot the name of her best friend yesterday but is confident with her finances.

Needmoresleep · 16/11/2026 21:41

I was on the original cockroach thread. We used to discuss "shit-siblings". I certainly had one, who only really surfaced when probate started.

If this is you, you might enjoy:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-X9dxL17t1k&pp=iggCQAE%3D

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?pp=iggCQAE%3D&v=-X9dxL17t1k

FiniteSagacity · 16/11/2026 22:35

Finance LPoA was essential and thank goodness we had the LPoAs in place to work out how to pay for care.

Health LPoA was only helpful a few times. When our Dad couldn’t weigh up the information to consent to a possible surgery -he was being asked for a yes or no and the surgeon patiently explained a few times before involving me - we then decided together that invasive surgery was not in his best interests. It was also helpful to have registered the LPoA with the GP, when approaching EoL I could take responsibility for refusing hospital because we knew he didn’t want to go back.

The hospital said they couldn’t record LPoA anywhere (already next of kin) and just asked me to bring LPoA with me to every appointment. In my experience hospitals are buildings with many very separate departments. Add more than one hospital and NHS trust and you really see how disconnected the NHS is. I was taking the respect/dnar to every appointment too.

Like others here I understand the aims of the MCA but in my experience the constant questioning of capacity does make the wheels turn too slowly - especially when you’re solving yesterday’s problem.

countrygirl99 · 16/11/2026 22:55

I can't work out how to link it but multiple people have sent me a Saturday Night Live you tube called "Sister". If you can find it it will chime with a lot of people on there. It's pretty obvious why people thought of me 😂

BestIsWest · 16/11/2026 23:05

Haha (bitter laughter) @countrygirl99. That is excellent.

Kirschcherries · 16/11/2026 23:13

BestIsWest · 16/11/2026 13:41

I wonder how capacity is decided. I have quite a good relationship with DMs’s GP as DM told the practice she is happy for them to talk to me about anything. We also have both POAs in place. But the GP has asked me more than once if DM has capacity and I’m at a loss as to what the answer is. She certainly doesn’t understand or remember that she has normal pressure Hydrocephalus.

GP has brought up the DNR topic more than once. I’ve tried to discuss with DM but she doesn’t quite get it. DB has said no to it. I don’t understand why as he was there when the paramedics were trying to save DF (we both were, they failed) and I don’t understand why he would want a frail 89 year old to go through that.

We did wills and LPAs for each other during the pandemic but it was a bit of a Fuchs and we probably need to revisit.

The Court of Protection requires a COP3. What we did was engage a solicitor who instructed an independent assessor, who was also a solicitor. The independent solicitor then saw Mum on her own and completed the assessment. This is then passed back to the original solicitor who forwarded the COP3.

WRT finance & property LPA, if it is completed indicating Attorneys can act whilst Donor has capacity that is really helpful. You don’t have to question capacity you get it registered and can start helping asap.

WRT Health & Welfare this requires loss of capacity. Having witnessed a DOLs assessment following the SC judgement if a person can give consent when asked they no longer get a DOLS. It appears it doesn’t matter if they forget a nano second later.

Needmoresleep · 17/11/2026 00:01

countrygirl99 · 16/11/2026 22:55

I can't work out how to link it but multiple people have sent me a Saturday Night Live you tube called "Sister". If you can find it it will chime with a lot of people on there. It's pretty obvious why people thought of me 😂

https://m.youtube.com/watch?pp=iggCQAE%3D&v=-X9dxL17t1k

As above

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?pp=iggCQAE%3D&v=-X9dxL17t1k

GnomeDePlume · 17/11/2026 06:23

Something I worry about with DM is that she may be able to answer yes or no to a question of treatment but she will be answering from a false premis.

She doesnt understand that she is in her 80s and bedbound. To her, if treatment was couched in words of 'getting better and going home' she would agree to it. To her now 'home' is her childhood home where her parents are.

If DB and I said 'no' we would be the monsters trying to kill her.

Decision making ability has to include context.

bigdogpaws · 17/11/2026 08:29

@GnomeDePlume I have similar concerns with my DM. She survived cancer in her 60s, but to do that spent about 2 years having very invasive surgery, chemo etc and generally feeling constantly dreadful. But it have her more than a decade of healthy life afterwards. She keeps asking me when her next cancer screening will be (she had extra screening, plus the standard screening offered to all but this stopped being offered as standard several years ago). I've tried to have a gentle discussion about whether she would actually want to go through all that again at this age but her stock response is 'I would want to do whatever it takes to get better!'. I'm pretty sure that in her mind treatment at 80+ (with dementia and other health problems) would be exactly the same as it was at 60- horrible at the time but necessary for all the good years after. I truly don't think she can understand that in her current situation even if she survived surgery etc it would probably speed up her general decline and mean an even more miserable last few years. I think there's a huge difference between making a decision that others may disagree with and even see as foolish/risky when you have had the opportunity to consider what you are doing, and making a decision that you think is right because you are not able to understand the risks.
I have no reason to believe that Mum has any form of cancer etc, but I fear these discussions have given me a glimpse of what would happen if she developed any physical illness where she/we had to decide whether invasive treatment should be attempted.

rookiemere · 17/11/2026 09:00

Somewhat pyrrhic victory.

After speaking to DMs doctor yesterday and agreeing that she did have capacity to make her own medical decisions, it has been agreed that next time DM is prescribed antibiotics they won’t be repeatedly offered if she refuses.

I am going in today to try and ascertain with her if she genuinely did mean to refuse them, I mean I could be wrong.

Of course who knows what state she’ll be in next time, but she certainly knows how to express displeasure.

The doctor was excellent and we had a very frank conversation.

OP posts:
Seeingadistance · 17/11/2026 09:14

Glad to hear you were able to have a good conversation with a doctor, rookiemere. I imagine that must have been quite cathartic too.

We're still waiting for SLT to come to see DF who can now eat and drink again, slowly. I've just left a message for them. Their recorded message gave me a number to phone if I wanted to speak to an SLT - it was the number I'd just phoned. I've decided I'm going round in enough circles just now without adding another one!

deutschland83 · 17/11/2026 12:48

GnomeDePlume · 17/11/2026 06:23

Something I worry about with DM is that she may be able to answer yes or no to a question of treatment but she will be answering from a false premis.

She doesnt understand that she is in her 80s and bedbound. To her, if treatment was couched in words of 'getting better and going home' she would agree to it. To her now 'home' is her childhood home where her parents are.

If DB and I said 'no' we would be the monsters trying to kill her.

Decision making ability has to include context.

I witnessed this today. DM refused drugs to make her comfortable as she thinks they are trying to sedate her and kill her.

They patiently explained that was not the case, it was to help her and she still refused.

If I had any say, I would have said yes to give her relief and I would have believed the very kind nurse who was being very patient and trying to tell DM she was wrong.

rookiemere · 17/11/2026 12:57

So am actually more confused about DMs capacity and wishes after visiting her. I asked her if she had wanted antibiotics and she pointed fairly unequivocally to the No arrow. But then I managed to decipher on her pad she had written for me that she had a UTI and the antibiotics made her feel better. I then tried to ask if she wanted to feel better but by that stage her attention was wandering and it was impossible to press any further.

So no idea really. DM does like to demonstrate that she has retained medical knowledge so she could be saying that technically that’s what antibiotics are used for, but it’s all very unclear and in the case of doubt then it is absolutely right that she is treated. So perhaps the care home did the right thing treating her. Who can tell.Ironically the ABs seem to have perked her up marvellously and she was asking me to arrange a haircut and a nail trim.

I have decided I have to be more zen about these things, so I have made an appointment with the funeral directors where I can ask heartless fun questions like if we were away on holiday when one of them passes, how long could they keep the body for before the service. I am aware that even asking this makes me sound like an ice cold heartless bitch, maybe I am, who can tell.

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 17/11/2026 13:00

If it helps none of our funerals were less than 3 weeks due to crematorium availability and one was nearer 4 because of BIL being away.

BestIsWest · 17/11/2026 13:34

Our next door neighbour died on the 7th of October and is being buried on Thursday, 19th November due to family travelling and holidays etc.

deutschland83 · 17/11/2026 13:59

It’s three weeks here at the moment for a crematorium slot.