Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

How do people justify the mass murder of children?

670 replies

cavewoman2026 · 31/10/2026 11:34

Can someone explain this to me in a non emotional way? Like I’m really dense.

Children are innocent and don’t understand the concept of death. In a normal society if somebody murders a child they get locked up. But I see people online who deny or justify the killing of children and I just don’t understand how their brain ends up at that stage.

As a mother and someone who works with children in a school the idea of someone bombing or hurting children genuinely makes me feel faint. I’ll be on playground duty and get horrific intrusive thoughts of the school being bombed and thinking of all our precious children being hurt and society being ah okay well it’s just collateral damage. I truly don’t understand it. Then I bat these thoughts away because I end up feeling confused.

We have seen images of children being ripped apart, being orphaned (I get emotional whenever a child at work asks for their mummy, the idea of an orphaned child being all alone in the world hurts me)and there are people on this site saying hmm not enough, more war! More bombing!

20,000 thousand children have been murdered in Gaza (and 40 Israeli children), how as a society we let this happen? Or justify it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:01

GeneralPeter · 31/10/2026 17:59

I think that’s the same issue.

I read the full Amnesty report that made this case (albeit quite old now).

It laid out very soberly the issues and concluded that this is not a genocide unless the word genocide is redefined. They think it should be. I think the word and the concept is too important to do that to for campaigning reasons.

Gaza is a genocide if you redefine genocide, just like abortion is murder if you redefine murder, and transwomen are women if you redefine women.

Regardless of what you think on Gaza, abortion or sex-based rights I think we damage our ability to deal with serious issues and to make good policy if we all just define the words in the way that suits our case.

If you think trans people need more or different rights then make that case plainly. Ditto if you want abortion rights changes. Ditto if you have (entirely understandably) objections to how the Gaza war is being fought.

I can’t believe trans issues are being shoehorned into this. Although it’s Mumsnet so why am I surprised? 😭

GeneralPeter · 31/10/2026 18:05

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:01

I can’t believe trans issues are being shoehorned into this. Although it’s Mumsnet so why am I surprised? 😭

OK — if you don’t like the trans reference, do you think as a general principle that it’s sufficient to redefine words to settle an issue like this?

Or is it more important than that?

AnotherDelphinium · 31/10/2026 18:06

inamarina · 31/10/2026 17:49

Except when it comes to Gaza, it’s not simply ‘BS’, is it?
There is extensive evidence compiled by international bodies and intelligence agencies that shows that children in Gaza have been systematically exposed to anti-Israel and anti-Jewish rhetoric through formal education and media.

Schoolbooks erasing Israel from maps and using conflict to teach basic subjects. Summer camps run by Hamas’s military wing, where they teach children combat tactics. Children’s TV shows using costumed characters to indoctrinate viewers and promote antisemitic tropes.

You can point out extremism among radical Israeli settlers without ignoring the above points.

I don’t think there’s much formal education happening in Gaza, because, you know, the schools have been destroyed. By the Israelis.

I know if someone who I previously had completely neutral feelings about, destroyed my home, shot my dad, bombed my school, made food difficult to buy, I wouldn’t be feeling too neutral anymore. And if I survived, these bias would be passed onto my children, and grandchildren.

So perhaps Israel’s actions over the last few decades is more the reason that they’re pretty despised. Just a guess?

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:06

GeneralPeter · 31/10/2026 18:05

OK — if you don’t like the trans reference, do you think as a general principle that it’s sufficient to redefine words to settle an issue like this?

Or is it more important than that?

Edited

Your posts are so out there that I can’t be bothered addressing them but I’m sure you’ll find someone else to chat to. I don’t have the bandwidth as they say.

inamarina · 31/10/2026 18:07

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 17:58

Do you believe in the Geneva Conventions?

Do you think Hamas believe in it?

GeneralPeter · 31/10/2026 18:09

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:06

Your posts are so out there that I can’t be bothered addressing them but I’m sure you’ll find someone else to chat to. I don’t have the bandwidth as they say.

You could be bothered addressing them.

Just not when you were asked to move beyond a slogan.

The reason I read that massive report, and others, is that I think this is an important issue worth some bandwidth. Do you?

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:13

GeneralPeter · 31/10/2026 18:09

You could be bothered addressing them.

Just not when you were asked to move beyond a slogan.

The reason I read that massive report, and others, is that I think this is an important issue worth some bandwidth. Do you?

You’ve lost me

Octavia64 · 31/10/2026 18:14

Ok I’ll bite.

i’m a parent.

i know very little in detail about the situation in Gaza but yes I believe there are situations where war is justified.

i’m a Christian and there has been significant discussion and thought on this within the Christian tradition over the last couple of thousand years.

in wars, people die. Children die. That is a consequence of them.

in the Christian tradition that doesn’t mean all wars are unjustified.

The classic example given is of a country rebelling against a tyrant.

Ihatetomatoes · 31/10/2026 18:15

PurpleThistle7 · 31/10/2026 12:39

You have a very black and white way of thinking. I would love a world without war. I hate the killing of innocents. I actually hate the killing of anyone, it’s appalling and a stain on humanity.

But the world would be a worse place if Germany had won. There would have been far more deaths of children. 12 million in the camps was just the start, millions of those were children. So the cost of civilian deaths in the bombing of Germany and Japan was a price we paid for ending that war. I wish it had never come to that but if you’re fighting evil, what is the point where you say ‘nevermind, I guess the world should just be destroyed’.

personally, I would say the fight against Hamas and their backers is also a fight against evil. If they win, my world will be destroyed. All of our children will be at risk as the terrorists focus their energy on the rest of the world. So stopping them here and now must be the priority.

I wish Egypt would take refugees. Like you said, many Ukrainians were able to get out and many lives were saved. So many people could go to Egypt and survive but they just won’t let them in. Heartbreaking situation for sure.

Good points.

War is awful. But if you don't fight back then the other kills you and your children. WW's ... should we roll over and give up or fight the enemy that would kill us.

When terrorists invade your country and murder, rape and kidnap your people do you just shrug and say oh well.

I wish no one would start wars, but they do. I wish terrorists wouldn't spend their entire purpose looking for ways to kill, but they do.

Some accountability needs to be laid at the hands of those that start wars or launch terrorism against others too. Be that Germany or Russia or the various civil wars that have raged through the middle east and Northern Africa....Sudan, Yeman etc, don't those children matter too or us it the usual selective outrage. All those children matter too.

Many innocents die on all sides. It's bloody horrific.

When people shout 'globalise the intifada' do they care if innocents die, of course they don't, they are inciting more terror. Yet some of those shouting claim to be on the 'right side'....

If a country launched a war against us now, we wouldn't sit back and do nothing.

Bringing countries together as friends to attempt to prevent war is the way forward. No child in any country deserves war or should be caught up in one.

dairydebris · 31/10/2026 18:16

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 17:58

Do you believe in the Geneva Conventions?

What do you mean do I believe in them?

I believe they exist. I believe they were put in place after the horrors of ww2, to try to mitigate against the likelihood of humans ever doing it again to each other.

I also believe once young men at war have been desensitized to violence, told to kill or be killed, given access to killing technology, force othered the enemy in order to kill them without hesitation, war will inevitably result in horrific human violence no matter the race or ethnicity of the soldier. I believe this ultra violence inflicts violence on the psyche of the killer as well as the killed. I think therefore war should be avoided at almost all costs. I also believe that despite all tje above war is sometimes, rarely, justfifed.

But the moral dilemma of going to war in the knowledge of all that war is... is tricky...

Don't you think war throws up tricky moral questions? Such as, for example, is the murder of children ever justified?

inamarina · 31/10/2026 18:17

AnotherDelphinium · 31/10/2026 18:06

I don’t think there’s much formal education happening in Gaza, because, you know, the schools have been destroyed. By the Israelis.

I know if someone who I previously had completely neutral feelings about, destroyed my home, shot my dad, bombed my school, made food difficult to buy, I wouldn’t be feeling too neutral anymore. And if I survived, these bias would be passed onto my children, and grandchildren.

So perhaps Israel’s actions over the last few decades is more the reason that they’re pretty despised. Just a guess?

I was talking about the education happening before October 7th, I’d think that was pretty obvious.

I know if someone who I previously had completely neutral feelings about, destroyed my home, shot my dad, bombed my school, made food difficult to buy, I wouldn’t be feeling too neutral anymore

So how do you think Israelis feel after October 7th?
You’re talking about Israeli actions over the last decades - do yoi think they were the only aggressors? No attacks from the Palestinian side?

LeavingAtLast · 31/10/2026 18:18

AnotherDelphinium · 31/10/2026 18:06

I don’t think there’s much formal education happening in Gaza, because, you know, the schools have been destroyed. By the Israelis.

I know if someone who I previously had completely neutral feelings about, destroyed my home, shot my dad, bombed my school, made food difficult to buy, I wouldn’t be feeling too neutral anymore. And if I survived, these bias would be passed onto my children, and grandchildren.

So perhaps Israel’s actions over the last few decades is more the reason that they’re pretty despised. Just a guess?

You don’t know much about this conflict do you, beyond the Hamas propaganda you parrot.
Do you know anything about Hamas terrorising their own people? About the number of times they’ve been offered peace and rejected it? About refusing to make peace with Jews because they’re Jews? About the antisemitism within the fabric of Palestinian society that would make Hitler blush?
As for your belief Israelis are deserving of antisemitism- are they the only ethnicity deserving of the racism they face or does that apply to all victims of prejudice in your eyes?

dairydebris · 31/10/2026 18:21

cavewoman2026 · 31/10/2026 17:42

I’m sorry I’m not able to understand the psychology of parents who justify the murder of other people’s children. I just want to know why and how but some posters are helping me understand very quickly.

Go back and look at my thought experiment above then. Would you kill someone else's child to save your own child from being killed?

GeneralPeter · 31/10/2026 18:21

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:13

You’ve lost me

OK, a simpler version:

When you say it's a genocide, what do you mean by the term?

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:24

I’m done here. Nobody has convinced me there’s any justification for this and it’s pointless saying anything else to people who are fine with it.

dairydebris · 31/10/2026 18:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FacetiousFace · 31/10/2026 18:29

drspouse · 31/10/2026 16:35

Do you NOT believe that? Do you not believe there are ANY Hamas bases?
Do you think the Allies should not have bombed Germany? What about refugees, should Britain (let's face it, the only non invaded Ally in Europe) have taken all the German women and children? Because if neighbouring countries are to take refugees they run the same risk of indoctrinated Palestinians destroying their own countries.

Of course I don't believe that there are Hamas bases in every destroyed building! That would be impossible. I don't believe there was Hamas bases in every school, hospital and university in Gaza either. I'm actually really surprised that you think that there was. Why were Israel showing calenders and lying about what they were and using mock ups of Hamas headquaters instead of just showing us the evidence of actual bases?

After world war 2 lots of countries didn't want Jewish people either, some Holocaust survivors were living in refugee camps for years afterwards. It's part of the reason so many moved to Israel and so many Palestinians ended up as refugees. I find it pretty gross when people use the 'nobody wants them argument' as some kind of proof that Palestinians are uniquely awful. It wasn't proof that Jewish people were awful and it isn't proof that Palestinians are.

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Proves my point.

Cheese55 · 31/10/2026 18:32

OneShyPeachShark · 31/10/2026 12:19

She means they’re just not quite as human or as valuable.

She means they are guided by religion in a way that the UK isn't.

dairydebris · 31/10/2026 18:33

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:31

Proves my point.

Nothing to say about my long and thoughtful post about the Geneva Conv? You know the question you asked me? Happy Halloween anyway 👋

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:37

dairydebris · 31/10/2026 18:33

Nothing to say about my long and thoughtful post about the Geneva Conv? You know the question you asked me? Happy Halloween anyway 👋

You didn’t answer my question about why people should leave Gaza and become refugees in another land.

Happy Halloween to you too 👻

MissyB1 · 31/10/2026 18:39

dairydebris · 31/10/2026 18:21

Go back and look at my thought experiment above then. Would you kill someone else's child to save your own child from being killed?

So you believe 20k plus Palestinian children needed to be killed (and presumably need to keep being killed) in order for Israeli children to survive?? No you don’t believe that at all, but you would like others to.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 31/10/2026 18:43

I’m personally sorry at every death in Gaza - all human life has value, not just the children. I blame Hamas for the vast, vast majority of deaths. The idea that any country would allow a terrorist group to continue to run the neighbouring country and use it as a launch pad after the massacre of October 7th is for the birds. Britain, America, France etc would all have done whatever it took to stop them. Nobody started sanctions on the US when they invaded Afghanistan after 9/11 but now there’s some handy Jews to blame it’s suddenly imperative that the world acts.

IMO Hamas leaders knew exactly what they were doing though. They knew thousands of their own would be slaughtered and that millions of useful idiots (plus the antisemites) in the West would place the blame at Israel’s door. I’m only surprised how many have fallen for it tbh.

I do find it interesting how anti-Israel posts flip flop around on something as basic as keeping civilians safe. If they’re moved away from the front lines to a safe place that’s ethnic cleansing and if they’re left in place it’s mass murder. Given that Israel isn’t going to stop until Hamas are completely destroyed, how do you propose to save the human shields?

Cheese55 · 31/10/2026 18:44

LeavingAtLast · 31/10/2026 18:18

You don’t know much about this conflict do you, beyond the Hamas propaganda you parrot.
Do you know anything about Hamas terrorising their own people? About the number of times they’ve been offered peace and rejected it? About refusing to make peace with Jews because they’re Jews? About the antisemitism within the fabric of Palestinian society that would make Hitler blush?
As for your belief Israelis are deserving of antisemitism- are they the only ethnicity deserving of the racism they face or does that apply to all victims of prejudice in your eyes?

How come you know this is Hamas propaganda being parroted but your belief is The Truth?

dairydebris · 31/10/2026 18:49

JaneJeffer · 31/10/2026 18:37

You didn’t answer my question about why people should leave Gaza and become refugees in another land.

Happy Halloween to you too 👻

Sorry I didn't see that.

I don't think they should leave Gaza unless they want to.

I can understand why they'd want to though, oppressed by Hamas and under Israeli fire.

I don't see what thats got to do with the premise of OP.