Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

How do people justify the mass murder of children?

670 replies

cavewoman2026 · 31/10/2026 11:34

Can someone explain this to me in a non emotional way? Like I’m really dense.

Children are innocent and don’t understand the concept of death. In a normal society if somebody murders a child they get locked up. But I see people online who deny or justify the killing of children and I just don’t understand how their brain ends up at that stage.

As a mother and someone who works with children in a school the idea of someone bombing or hurting children genuinely makes me feel faint. I’ll be on playground duty and get horrific intrusive thoughts of the school being bombed and thinking of all our precious children being hurt and society being ah okay well it’s just collateral damage. I truly don’t understand it. Then I bat these thoughts away because I end up feeling confused.

We have seen images of children being ripped apart, being orphaned (I get emotional whenever a child at work asks for their mummy, the idea of an orphaned child being all alone in the world hurts me)and there are people on this site saying hmm not enough, more war! More bombing!

20,000 thousand children have been murdered in Gaza (and 40 Israeli children), how as a society we let this happen? Or justify it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
cavewoman2026 · 08/11/2026 11:05

Gealach · 05/11/2026 22:20

So you do. Ok, I don’t really know what to say to that. Israel has always detained children for as little as throwing stones. They did it before the “war” and they are doing it during the “ceasefire”

How do you think Israeli children should be treated for violent offences in the West Bank?

It’s okay, they’re just showing their blatant racism. A 16 year old isn’t a minor, sure!

OP posts:
Dinnerontheterrace · 08/11/2026 11:08

All this thread has proven to me is that the situation is a zero sum game. No accommodation suggested is ever enough. There is no clever solution.

Palestinians have turned down a two state solution repeatedly. Is it ever good enough. Is there any set of borders the Palestinians would accept, or must the Jews be utterly driven out?

Squeezingwildoranges · 08/11/2026 11:31

Dinnerontheterrace · 08/11/2026 11:08

All this thread has proven to me is that the situation is a zero sum game. No accommodation suggested is ever enough. There is no clever solution.

Palestinians have turned down a two state solution repeatedly. Is it ever good enough. Is there any set of borders the Palestinians would accept, or must the Jews be utterly driven out?

Israel has only ever made disingenuous, performative offers of land to make them look like they are being reasonable to the uninformed eyes of the world. At no point has the leadership been interested in a peaceful solution that allows Palestinians the rights, self determination, and dignity they deserve. Quite the contrary, as we can see in Gaza, the West Bank and southern Lebanon, the intention is, and always has been, permanent territorial expansion and annexation.

PurpleThistle7 · 08/11/2026 11:40

I am aware I was naive to think this was a good place for debate. But it’s telling that even on this app, a place where most people will not be directly affected by anything in the middle east, it’s impossible to agree on anything or to avoid ending up on two different ends of the spectrum. It’s just an impossible situation that requires solutions that are probably going to sound crazy at first.

if we work from things that are impossible and start going backwards then maybe there’s a way out. I want less violence. That will not happen in either the status quo where everyone hates each other forever and periodically loads of people die. It will not happen if either Palestinians are all dead or some new muslim majority is put in charge of a land for all nonsense. So those two options just aren’t workable if you have a goal of fewer deaths.

At this point, it’s hard for me to be a vehement pro current Israeli government supporter. I am and will always be a Zionist, but I can’t say they are doing a great job of it. So what now? Overthrow Netanyahu? Take the land away from everyone? Move the Israelis somewhere else? Move the Palestinians somewhere else? I still haven’t seen anything suggested that isn’t kill all the Israelis or a slightly more subtle version to dismantle Israel (and thus kill the Israelis.).

and to be clear, I wasn’t actually suggesting mass migration to Madagascar for the entire Jewish population. Of course that was a terrible suggestion. But if we start with the understanding that Jews were hated and murdered and attacked long before Israel and will be hated and murdered and attacked whether or not Israel exists then what exactly can anyone on here suggest as a solution if you think a Jewish state is unnecessary. That we all just keep dying until we solve the problem? That we give up being Jewish? That we start fighting for our rights for our ancestral homelands in Iran and Ethiopia and Russia? The Palestinian society at my work says all Jews should leave Israel and move ‘back’ to Poland. And that’s when I knew they had nothing of use to offer as a suggestion.

Ihatetomatoes · 08/11/2026 12:14

PurpleThistle7 · 08/11/2026 11:40

I am aware I was naive to think this was a good place for debate. But it’s telling that even on this app, a place where most people will not be directly affected by anything in the middle east, it’s impossible to agree on anything or to avoid ending up on two different ends of the spectrum. It’s just an impossible situation that requires solutions that are probably going to sound crazy at first.

if we work from things that are impossible and start going backwards then maybe there’s a way out. I want less violence. That will not happen in either the status quo where everyone hates each other forever and periodically loads of people die. It will not happen if either Palestinians are all dead or some new muslim majority is put in charge of a land for all nonsense. So those two options just aren’t workable if you have a goal of fewer deaths.

At this point, it’s hard for me to be a vehement pro current Israeli government supporter. I am and will always be a Zionist, but I can’t say they are doing a great job of it. So what now? Overthrow Netanyahu? Take the land away from everyone? Move the Israelis somewhere else? Move the Palestinians somewhere else? I still haven’t seen anything suggested that isn’t kill all the Israelis or a slightly more subtle version to dismantle Israel (and thus kill the Israelis.).

and to be clear, I wasn’t actually suggesting mass migration to Madagascar for the entire Jewish population. Of course that was a terrible suggestion. But if we start with the understanding that Jews were hated and murdered and attacked long before Israel and will be hated and murdered and attacked whether or not Israel exists then what exactly can anyone on here suggest as a solution if you think a Jewish state is unnecessary. That we all just keep dying until we solve the problem? That we give up being Jewish? That we start fighting for our rights for our ancestral homelands in Iran and Ethiopia and Russia? The Palestinian society at my work says all Jews should leave Israel and move ‘back’ to Poland. And that’s when I knew they had nothing of use to offer as a suggestion.

I think this corner of mumsnet isn't a kind place. Sadly, many only do Israel bad and Palestine good.

I'd avoid it for your mental health.

Best wishes and yes Jewish people should have a homeland.

Some posters don't do understanding, they just want arguments. I wouldn't give them any opportunity.

Dinnerontheterrace · 08/11/2026 12:19

Squeezingwildoranges · 08/11/2026 11:31

Israel has only ever made disingenuous, performative offers of land to make them look like they are being reasonable to the uninformed eyes of the world. At no point has the leadership been interested in a peaceful solution that allows Palestinians the rights, self determination, and dignity they deserve. Quite the contrary, as we can see in Gaza, the West Bank and southern Lebanon, the intention is, and always has been, permanent territorial expansion and annexation.

I don’t believe that is true.

Is any offer from Israel that is less than 100% of everything that the Palestinians want “disingenuous”?

Squeezingwildoranges · 08/11/2026 12:30

Dinnerontheterrace · 08/11/2026 12:19

I don’t believe that is true.

Is any offer from Israel that is less than 100% of everything that the Palestinians want “disingenuous”?

100% of all offers made by Israel have been disingenuous. Even accepting resolution 181 was a ruse as Ben Gurion had no intention of limiting Israeli territory to the partition plan. He openly declared it was merely a stepping stone in order to annex the whole of Palestinian territory.

Dinnerontheterrace · 08/11/2026 12:36

What genuine suggestions have the Palestinians made?

Perhaps I am looking at this from the wrong direction.

cavewoman2026 · 08/11/2026 12:50

Dinnerontheterrace · 08/11/2026 11:08

All this thread has proven to me is that the situation is a zero sum game. No accommodation suggested is ever enough. There is no clever solution.

Palestinians have turned down a two state solution repeatedly. Is it ever good enough. Is there any set of borders the Palestinians would accept, or must the Jews be utterly driven out?

Hard to agree a deal with a gun to your head, please look more into what they ‘rejected’.

OP posts:
cavewoman2026 · 08/11/2026 12:56

PurpleThistle7 · 08/11/2026 11:40

I am aware I was naive to think this was a good place for debate. But it’s telling that even on this app, a place where most people will not be directly affected by anything in the middle east, it’s impossible to agree on anything or to avoid ending up on two different ends of the spectrum. It’s just an impossible situation that requires solutions that are probably going to sound crazy at first.

if we work from things that are impossible and start going backwards then maybe there’s a way out. I want less violence. That will not happen in either the status quo where everyone hates each other forever and periodically loads of people die. It will not happen if either Palestinians are all dead or some new muslim majority is put in charge of a land for all nonsense. So those two options just aren’t workable if you have a goal of fewer deaths.

At this point, it’s hard for me to be a vehement pro current Israeli government supporter. I am and will always be a Zionist, but I can’t say they are doing a great job of it. So what now? Overthrow Netanyahu? Take the land away from everyone? Move the Israelis somewhere else? Move the Palestinians somewhere else? I still haven’t seen anything suggested that isn’t kill all the Israelis or a slightly more subtle version to dismantle Israel (and thus kill the Israelis.).

and to be clear, I wasn’t actually suggesting mass migration to Madagascar for the entire Jewish population. Of course that was a terrible suggestion. But if we start with the understanding that Jews were hated and murdered and attacked long before Israel and will be hated and murdered and attacked whether or not Israel exists then what exactly can anyone on here suggest as a solution if you think a Jewish state is unnecessary. That we all just keep dying until we solve the problem? That we give up being Jewish? That we start fighting for our rights for our ancestral homelands in Iran and Ethiopia and Russia? The Palestinian society at my work says all Jews should leave Israel and move ‘back’ to Poland. And that’s when I knew they had nothing of use to offer as a suggestion.

I don’t think any decent or rational person wants that. Also Israel is an established country and of course Jews deserve their own country but the power lies with Israel. They clearly have not been fair to the Palestinians as we can clearly see from the violence in the West Bank and the continuous land grabbing. Who looks out for the Palestinians? Apart from a small minority of Hamas militants? (Who kill their own people). All these decades of endless violence have only resulted in a paranoid, angry and oppressive Israel and a traumatised Palestinian society. There has to be another way to this tragedy but sadly I do not think the right wing Israeli government in power currently are it.

OP posts:
PurpleThistle7 · 08/11/2026 13:16

cavewoman2026 · 08/11/2026 12:56

I don’t think any decent or rational person wants that. Also Israel is an established country and of course Jews deserve their own country but the power lies with Israel. They clearly have not been fair to the Palestinians as we can clearly see from the violence in the West Bank and the continuous land grabbing. Who looks out for the Palestinians? Apart from a small minority of Hamas militants? (Who kill their own people). All these decades of endless violence have only resulted in a paranoid, angry and oppressive Israel and a traumatised Palestinian society. There has to be another way to this tragedy but sadly I do not think the right wing Israeli government in power currently are it.

Well minus the idea that Israelis are paranoid I don’t really disagree with most of this. We aren’t paranoid because lots of people really do want us dead. Lots of people want Jews dead in general as my kids have now each heard multiple times from classmates, including the most recent experience my son had last week from an older kid telling him Hitler was right.

Agreed there’s no great solution here but if you rule out crazy ideas we are back round in a circle. And there are plenty of people calling for Israel’s destruction so that’s not paranoia either.

Palestinians are in a lose lose scenario right now so we desperately need some creativity.

Squeezingwildoranges · 08/11/2026 13:21

Dinnerontheterrace · 08/11/2026 12:36

What genuine suggestions have the Palestinians made?

Perhaps I am looking at this from the wrong direction.

Have you considered the Oslo accords? Palestinians officially recognised the State of Israel and its right to exist. They laid down arms and the Palestinian Authority actively collaborated with Israeli intelligence, routinely arresting Palestinians wanted by the IDF to maintain security. What did they get in return? A false promise by Israel to work towards a two state solution. Instead they got decades of expanding settlements in the West Bank, a fragmented territory, and a peace process that the current Israeli leadership has openly admitted they had no intention of allowing to succeed.

Dinnerontheterrace · 08/11/2026 13:25

Okay so we are back to criticising what has gone on in the past.

What compromise do you think would work?

Or is it just pick a side, hope your side grinds the other to dust and then justify it?

golosh · 08/11/2026 13:43

cavewoman2026 · 08/11/2026 11:03

Okay day Hamas are gone, what happens to the Palestinian children who have watched their parents murdered? Their land destroyed? Has Israel’s actions made it safe?

nope. unfortunately whats happened to gaza has ensured this conflict goes on for generations.

Squeezingwildoranges · 08/11/2026 14:31

1dayatatime · 07/11/2026 21:11

One small island off Dubai containing a church, a synagogue and a mosque- seriously is that the level of your counter argument.

I'm specifically showing how attitudes and relationships can change. It was not that long ago that if you tried to enter the UAE with an Israeli stamp in your passport, you would not have been allowed entry. In fact, Israeli border guards would stamp a loose piece of paper, on request, instead of a page in a passport for this very reason. If an expat who lived in the UAE tried to bring back clothes from M&S, they would have to cut the label out in order for them not to be confiscated. Now, there is an Israeli embassy, M&S shops and Israelis happily go there on holiday. The point is, relationships can very quickly go from hostile to cooperative.

OpheliaWasntMad · 08/11/2026 17:04

Ihatetomatoes · 08/11/2026 12:14

I think this corner of mumsnet isn't a kind place. Sadly, many only do Israel bad and Palestine good.

I'd avoid it for your mental health.

Best wishes and yes Jewish people should have a homeland.

Some posters don't do understanding, they just want arguments. I wouldn't give them any opportunity.

Edited

I agree. I read your posts about your children’s experiences at school and I’ve noted the lack of empathy from some posters.
I hope you know there are many people like me (not Jewish) who are appalled by the increased antisemitism.
Im not a supporter of Netanyahu in any way but I believe there is a need for a Jewish homeland -and a right to a Jewish homeland - not at the expense of Palestinians- but people can’t USE Palestinians to insist that the only Jewish state in the world is “dismantled”.

OpheliaWasntMad · 08/11/2026 17:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ihatetomatoes · 08/11/2026 22:57

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

FacetiousFace · 09/11/2026 08:31

I'm very skeptical of people who seem to be trying to control this thread and make it into - if you can't solve the almost century long conflict then shut up - on a thread about childrens suffering.

Surely everyone is appalled at the latest scenes coming out of Gaza of children in flooded tents. You think that they deserve better than that. You know that there are over 500 truckloads of shelter material waiting for Israel to approve their entry into Gaza and Israel isn't doing that. Right now these children don't need us in the West to solve the entire conflict, they need dry, warm, shelter. That's something that aid agencies have been trying to provide them with and Israel have not been permitting into Gaza. Sanction the shit out of Israel until they let little children have somewhere dry to sleep. This is the immediate problem not whether people are saying bad things about the country that is refusing to let kids who they have starved and bombed and orphaned have shelter. People should be saying bad things, it's disgusting.

Squeezingwildoranges · 09/11/2026 10:41

FacetiousFace · 09/11/2026 08:31

I'm very skeptical of people who seem to be trying to control this thread and make it into - if you can't solve the almost century long conflict then shut up - on a thread about childrens suffering.

Surely everyone is appalled at the latest scenes coming out of Gaza of children in flooded tents. You think that they deserve better than that. You know that there are over 500 truckloads of shelter material waiting for Israel to approve their entry into Gaza and Israel isn't doing that. Right now these children don't need us in the West to solve the entire conflict, they need dry, warm, shelter. That's something that aid agencies have been trying to provide them with and Israel have not been permitting into Gaza. Sanction the shit out of Israel until they let little children have somewhere dry to sleep. This is the immediate problem not whether people are saying bad things about the country that is refusing to let kids who they have starved and bombed and orphaned have shelter. People should be saying bad things, it's disgusting.

Very well said. I agree completely. Although it is impossible to avoid the feeling that creating these unlivable conditions is tied to the 'voluntary emigration' policies that senior Israeli cabinet ministers have openly declared. When ministers explicitly state they are going to 'encourage' the population to leave Gaza for other countries, restricting basic shelter and aid trucks looks less like a logistical backup and more like a deliberate strategy.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page