Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

How do people justify the mass murder of children?

670 replies

cavewoman2026 · 31/10/2026 11:34

Can someone explain this to me in a non emotional way? Like I’m really dense.

Children are innocent and don’t understand the concept of death. In a normal society if somebody murders a child they get locked up. But I see people online who deny or justify the killing of children and I just don’t understand how their brain ends up at that stage.

As a mother and someone who works with children in a school the idea of someone bombing or hurting children genuinely makes me feel faint. I’ll be on playground duty and get horrific intrusive thoughts of the school being bombed and thinking of all our precious children being hurt and society being ah okay well it’s just collateral damage. I truly don’t understand it. Then I bat these thoughts away because I end up feeling confused.

We have seen images of children being ripped apart, being orphaned (I get emotional whenever a child at work asks for their mummy, the idea of an orphaned child being all alone in the world hurts me)and there are people on this site saying hmm not enough, more war! More bombing!

20,000 thousand children have been murdered in Gaza (and 40 Israeli children), how as a society we let this happen? Or justify it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
golosh · 06/11/2026 01:43

nearlylovemyusername · 05/11/2026 21:57

I think that definition of minor depends on culture.
A person caught with weapon in a war zone, where joining armed forces is widely accepted as norm at the age of 15, cannot be considered as a minor unfortunately, but an enemy soldier, so not a regular prisoner, but prisoner of war.
This is horrific, but giving weapons to children is not Israel's fault, there are many issues there, but Israel isn't known for their child soldiers.

Ok so a 15,16,17 year old is an adult.

I presume Israelis would be happy for their 15 year olds to join the IDF: which certainly clears up a lot of confusion for the government I guess.

What about 12,13 and 14 year olds?

Squeezingwildoranges · 06/11/2026 11:49

Here's some quotes from a Reuters article 10 years before Oct 7th happened.

During the 10-year period, an estimated 7,000 Palestinian children aged 12 to 17, but some as young as nine, had been arrested, interrogated and detained, the U.N. report said.

Many are brought in leg chains and shackles before military courts, while youths are held in solitary confinement, sometimes for months, the report said.

It voiced deep concern at the "continuous use of Palestinian children as human shields and informants", saying 14 such cases had been reported between January 2010 and March 2013 alone.

Israeli soldiers had used Palestinian children to enter potentially dangerous buildings before them and to stand in front of military vehicles to deter stone-throwing, it said.

"Almost all those using children as human shields and informants have remained unpunished and the soldiers convicted for having forced at gunpoint a nine-year-old child to search bags suspected of containing explosives only received a suspended sentence of three months and were demoted," it said.

The last paragraph is 'telling' to say the least.

https://www.reuters.com/article/world/palestinian-children-tortured-used-as-shields-by-israel-un-idUSBRE95J0FR/

Squeezingwildoranges · 06/11/2026 12:55

Martymcfly24 · 05/11/2026 19:17

Agree @golosh how can Hamas prove they have disarmed? You just know that no matter what they say another cache will be "found" to halt any progress towards Israel returning one foot of the territory they have annexed.

Israel has publicly declared it is not going to give up the land it has occupied in Lebanon. It has cleared villages and constructed permanent infrastructure. Why on earth would anyone think they would give up an inch of territory in Gaza? Ministers in the Israeli cabinet have repeatedly expressed expansionist desires in the form of the Greater Israel project. It seems clear that talk of ceasefire terms or Hamas disarming is serving as a convenient political distraction, when the long term goal appears to be permanent territorial control.

FacetiousFace · 06/11/2026 14:06

OpheliaWasntMad · 05/11/2026 19:19

“This is not about disarming Hamas to save the world. It is about removing the arabs from the land they are squatting on,”

That’s your opinion. It’s not a fact .

Hamas’ terrorism on October 7th is a fact .
Hamas’ aim is to destroy Israel - that is a fact- they state it themselves.
Another fact Hamas and other terrorist groups are funded by Iran who aim to destroy Israel.

My opinion- I think it’s understandable that Israel want to disarm Hamas. I think many Palestinians would also be glad to see the back of Hamas.

I find it odd that this is a sticking point for you. It would certainly be a challenge to ensure Hamas had disarmed - and it wouldn’t be an easy process - but does anyone think there is an easy way out of this horror?

Hamas’ aim is to destroy Israel - that is a fact- they state it themselves.

And Israels aim is that there will never be a Palestinian state, they believe Palestinian land belongs to Israel - that is a fact - they state it themselves.

It's also a fact that for that land to be Israels they cannot allow Palestinians to stay there. They want Israel to be Jewish majority, if they allow Palestinians to stay there that won't be the case.

How do you think they can achieve their stated aim of making sure that there will never be a Palestine and making Palestine theirs with Palestinians remaining there?

Come on now. Israel have told us what they want, why do so many people act like they haven't heard?

Martymcfly24 · 06/11/2026 17:26

Squeezingwildoranges · 06/11/2026 12:55

Israel has publicly declared it is not going to give up the land it has occupied in Lebanon. It has cleared villages and constructed permanent infrastructure. Why on earth would anyone think they would give up an inch of territory in Gaza? Ministers in the Israeli cabinet have repeatedly expressed expansionist desires in the form of the Greater Israel project. It seems clear that talk of ceasefire terms or Hamas disarming is serving as a convenient political distraction, when the long term goal appears to be permanent territorial control.

Absolutely @Squeezingwildoranges the land has been taken. The demolitions and displacement are taking place, the yellow line is being moved continuously. Hamas disarming is like returning the hostages another distraction to kick the can down the road while stealing land.

OpheliaWasntMad · 06/11/2026 20:30

Martymcfly24 · 06/11/2026 17:26

Absolutely @Squeezingwildoranges the land has been taken. The demolitions and displacement are taking place, the yellow line is being moved continuously. Hamas disarming is like returning the hostages another distraction to kick the can down the road while stealing land.

“Returning the hostages- another distraction”
Really?
How can you think you are a humanitarian if you write or think this?

OpheliaWasntMad · 06/11/2026 20:42

FacetiousFace · 06/11/2026 14:06

Hamas’ aim is to destroy Israel - that is a fact- they state it themselves.

And Israels aim is that there will never be a Palestinian state, they believe Palestinian land belongs to Israel - that is a fact - they state it themselves.

It's also a fact that for that land to be Israels they cannot allow Palestinians to stay there. They want Israel to be Jewish majority, if they allow Palestinians to stay there that won't be the case.

How do you think they can achieve their stated aim of making sure that there will never be a Palestine and making Palestine theirs with Palestinians remaining there?

Come on now. Israel have told us what they want, why do so many people act like they haven't heard?

What’s your solution then? “a land for all” isn’t going to work …

Dassssy · 06/11/2026 21:21

OpheliaWasntMad · 06/11/2026 20:30

“Returning the hostages- another distraction”
Really?
How can you think you are a humanitarian if you write or think this?

A lot of the innocent hostages were also returned dead. Maybe if the focus could be on Hamas disarming like they agreed to. There can't be any continuation of the peace process until they do?

golosh · 07/11/2026 12:16

OpheliaWasntMad · 06/11/2026 20:30

“Returning the hostages- another distraction”
Really?
How can you think you are a humanitarian if you write or think this?

because Bibi never cared about the hostages. The goal is annexation. So saying ‘return the hostages’ is just a distraction from the wider geopolitics. Hamas actually agreed to return all hostages on October 8th, in exchange for no ground assault. Israel refused.

golosh · 07/11/2026 12:25

Dassssy · 06/11/2026 21:21

A lot of the innocent hostages were also returned dead. Maybe if the focus could be on Hamas disarming like they agreed to. There can't be any continuation of the peace process until they do?

A lot of the innocent hostages were killed by Israeli bombs.
When you dump over 600 x 2,000lb bombs (conservative estimate by B’Tselem & FXB Harvard) on an area the size of Birmingham, do you think maybe lots of people might die?

Squeezingwildoranges · 07/11/2026 12:47

OpheliaWasntMad · 06/11/2026 20:42

What’s your solution then? “a land for all” isn’t going to work …

Why are so sure 'A Land for All' won't work. Even the 'Standing Together' movement has now adopted the model. It solves the problem of a Jewish homeland as well as self determination for Palestinians. If you have another solution, I would love to hear it. The two state solution is dead and I don't think that would be a solution anyway as it does nothing to address the antagonism between the two groups. Even if Israel were willing to withdraw to the pre 67 borders it is not feasible that they would be able to extract 750,000 settlers.

GeneralPeter · 07/11/2026 14:30

Squeezingwildoranges · 07/11/2026 12:47

Why are so sure 'A Land for All' won't work. Even the 'Standing Together' movement has now adopted the model. It solves the problem of a Jewish homeland as well as self determination for Palestinians. If you have another solution, I would love to hear it. The two state solution is dead and I don't think that would be a solution anyway as it does nothing to address the antagonism between the two groups. Even if Israel were willing to withdraw to the pre 67 borders it is not feasible that they would be able to extract 750,000 settlers.

It’s not a bad aspiration, but it’s not an alternative to two states, it’s a two-state solution with added complicated features that make it harder to win support for or to implement.

It is also a less popular than a traditional two-state solution in Israel, and even more so in West Bank and Gaza.

HowtheJetsLag · 07/11/2026 18:36

Squeezingwildoranges · 07/11/2026 12:47

Why are so sure 'A Land for All' won't work. Even the 'Standing Together' movement has now adopted the model. It solves the problem of a Jewish homeland as well as self determination for Palestinians. If you have another solution, I would love to hear it. The two state solution is dead and I don't think that would be a solution anyway as it does nothing to address the antagonism between the two groups. Even if Israel were willing to withdraw to the pre 67 borders it is not feasible that they would be able to extract 750,000 settlers.

How exactly would making Jewish people a tiny minority "solve the problem of a Jewish homeland"? And why the fuck would Israelis agree to it?

Dassssy · 07/11/2026 19:37

Squeezingwildoranges · 07/11/2026 12:47

Why are so sure 'A Land for All' won't work. Even the 'Standing Together' movement has now adopted the model. It solves the problem of a Jewish homeland as well as self determination for Palestinians. If you have another solution, I would love to hear it. The two state solution is dead and I don't think that would be a solution anyway as it does nothing to address the antagonism between the two groups. Even if Israel were willing to withdraw to the pre 67 borders it is not feasible that they would be able to extract 750,000 settlers.

It won't work because it will just become ( another) Muslim majority country which there already are a lot of. We can see how Muslim majority countries treat Jews ( they expelled them and didn't treat them equally to Muslim citizens in lots of middle Eastern countries) so why would this land for all be any different? The need for a Jewish state has never been needed more today since the 2ndWW and if you can't see that I don't know what to tell you. There is ONE Jewish state in the world and over 50 Muslim ones, why do you want the only Jewish state to become predominantly Muslim too?

Squeezingwildoranges · 07/11/2026 19:49

HowtheJetsLag · 07/11/2026 18:36

How exactly would making Jewish people a tiny minority "solve the problem of a Jewish homeland"? And why the fuck would Israelis agree to it?

I’m not sure if you’ve read how the confederation model actually works. It doesn't dissolve the Jewish homeland, it preserves independent sovereignty for both states while allowing freedom of movement. As for why Israelis would consider it, the argument from proponents is that the alternative, continuing the status quo of dispossession, disenfranchisement and worse, is causing a moral dilemma with possible devastating consequences for Israeli society on the international stage. South Africa found itself in a similar dilemma in the 90's. Why the fuck, as you said, would white South Africans have wanted to give blacks equal rights.

Squeezingwildoranges · 07/11/2026 19:51

Dassssy · 07/11/2026 19:37

It won't work because it will just become ( another) Muslim majority country which there already are a lot of. We can see how Muslim majority countries treat Jews ( they expelled them and didn't treat them equally to Muslim citizens in lots of middle Eastern countries) so why would this land for all be any different? The need for a Jewish state has never been needed more today since the 2ndWW and if you can't see that I don't know what to tell you. There is ONE Jewish state in the world and over 50 Muslim ones, why do you want the only Jewish state to become predominantly Muslim too?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abrahamic_Family_House

Abrahamic Family House - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abrahamic_Family_House

Dassssy · 07/11/2026 19:52

Squeezingwildoranges · 07/11/2026 19:49

I’m not sure if you’ve read how the confederation model actually works. It doesn't dissolve the Jewish homeland, it preserves independent sovereignty for both states while allowing freedom of movement. As for why Israelis would consider it, the argument from proponents is that the alternative, continuing the status quo of dispossession, disenfranchisement and worse, is causing a moral dilemma with possible devastating consequences for Israeli society on the international stage. South Africa found itself in a similar dilemma in the 90's. Why the fuck, as you said, would white South Africans have wanted to give blacks equal rights.

Freedom of movement for suicide bombers to blow themselves up wherever they like?? Yeah, I don't think this is a workable solution.

HowtheJetsLag · 07/11/2026 20:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

1dayatatime · 07/11/2026 21:11

Squeezingwildoranges · 07/11/2026 19:51

One small island off Dubai containing a church, a synagogue and a mosque- seriously is that the level of your counter argument.

golosh · 08/11/2026 02:33

Dassssy · 07/11/2026 19:37

It won't work because it will just become ( another) Muslim majority country which there already are a lot of. We can see how Muslim majority countries treat Jews ( they expelled them and didn't treat them equally to Muslim citizens in lots of middle Eastern countries) so why would this land for all be any different? The need for a Jewish state has never been needed more today since the 2ndWW and if you can't see that I don't know what to tell you. There is ONE Jewish state in the world and over 50 Muslim ones, why do you want the only Jewish state to become predominantly Muslim too?

The way you’re putting it, it seems ethnic cleansing is the only solution.

OpheliaWasntMad · 08/11/2026 09:13

golosh · 08/11/2026 02:33

The way you’re putting it, it seems ethnic cleansing is the only solution.

And the way many of you posters put it - it seems as if you want to “dismantle “ the state of Israel ( as a PP put it)

Squeezingwildoranges · 08/11/2026 10:05

golosh · 08/11/2026 02:33

The way you’re putting it, it seems ethnic cleansing is the only solution.

Of course that is the only acceptable solution. It's just that, for obvious reasons, very few are actually willing to state it.

cavewoman2026 · 08/11/2026 10:55

Gealach · 05/11/2026 08:04

@PurpleThistle7 your view is eye opening. You are condoning crimes against humanity. Even though you see that it is a crime, you shrug your shoulders and say oh well, that’s just life. Go find somewhere else to live.

I very much doubt that you would feel like this in every situation. I think it’s because ultimately you think that the feeling of safety of Israelis can come at the expense of Palestinian lives. That their suffering can be treated as an unfortunate but necessary consequence.

it’s a very deep rooted form of racism. you should be celebrating now. Israeli policy has succeeded in the destruction of Gaza - could Oct 7 happen tomorrow again…no it couldn’t, 2 million Palestinians have been sacrificed for that but oh well, that’s life apparently. But you’re not delighted, you feel aggrieved at the global response, confused why they too are not shrugging their shoulders and saying crimes happen every day.

Well said

OP posts:
cavewoman2026 · 08/11/2026 10:59

PurpleThistle7 · 05/11/2026 10:28

No I'm not. I think war is hideous and terrible. But I have yet to hear a single suggestion on how to get out of this situation besides destroying my country and my family and my entire community. What is your actual suggestion here?

I think if the option is 'destroy Israel and kill all the Jews' or 'explore options for a safer and more secure future for Palestinians' - perhaps elsewhere as per literal endless other times in history when people find themselves on the losing side and perhaps value safety over winning then is that a way forward? I was asking people to consider what that 'could' look like.

I also considered what it could look like if we offered the Israelis somewhere else - a long time ago the Jews were offered Madagascar. It didn't really go anywhere but it's an interesting idea - what if somewhere else altogether is actually better for the future survival of my friends and family? This endless cycle of fear and violence over one teeny tiny bit of land can't go on forever, someone needs to stop it - I'm pretty open to whoever comes up with a plan to do that (leaving aside the endless suggestions for the destruction of Israel, I'd quite like that to stop)

Why is it ethnic cleansing to consider options for people living in one war zone but not another? Why is it okay for millions of Ukrainians to leave Ukraine to stay safe but not okay to suggest this might be a way forward for someone else? I think that's really bigoted too - why would you say that Palestinian value their family less than the millions upon millions of refugees over the last 1000s of years?

Given the situation we are facing here, I could find myself needing to run one day. I would 100% prioritise my kids' safety over holding onto the house I own here in the UK - you can have it, my kids and I are going wherever we need to be.

Because Ukrainians can safely leave and come back if the war is over. Palestinians cannot.

There are 8 million displaced Palestinians in the world.

OP posts:
cavewoman2026 · 08/11/2026 11:03

golosh · 05/11/2026 12:53

“Disarmament of Hamas” isn’t even a viable concept. What does it even look like?

The same conversations last year were “just release the hostages and it will all be over”

Israel has committed war crimes.
Israel is under investigation for genocide, with plausible evidence.
Videos of IDF soldiers chanting ‘there is no innocent civilian’
Human rights organisations calling out forced starvation, shooting people queuing for food
Violence of illegal settlers in the West bank
Naza - IDFs own estimates - at least 40,000, mostly children
Israel has bombed Lebanon and Iran
Not allowing foreign journalists into Gaza
Our own, Jewish, Foreign secretary calling this ethnic cleansing.
BILLIONS of dollars of funding for bombs to be dropped on refugee camps, hospitals, schools, universities.
People losing their jobs for speaking out against it. We’re just “Poor Gaza” idiots who don’t know anything, are antisemitic and ‘want the destruction of Israel’. Not even considering that any of the above ought to be called out.

How many videos of dead children have we had to see, only to be told “oh it’s just Pallywood”

The dehumanisation of the Palestinians. I have no words.

And you claim this all going to stop when whatever is left of Hamas “disarms”. What a joke. What an absolute joke.

Okay day Hamas are gone, what happens to the Palestinian children who have watched their parents murdered? Their land destroyed? Has Israel’s actions made it safe?

OP posts: