Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

How do people justify the mass murder of children?

670 replies

cavewoman2026 · 31/10/2026 11:34

Can someone explain this to me in a non emotional way? Like I’m really dense.

Children are innocent and don’t understand the concept of death. In a normal society if somebody murders a child they get locked up. But I see people online who deny or justify the killing of children and I just don’t understand how their brain ends up at that stage.

As a mother and someone who works with children in a school the idea of someone bombing or hurting children genuinely makes me feel faint. I’ll be on playground duty and get horrific intrusive thoughts of the school being bombed and thinking of all our precious children being hurt and society being ah okay well it’s just collateral damage. I truly don’t understand it. Then I bat these thoughts away because I end up feeling confused.

We have seen images of children being ripped apart, being orphaned (I get emotional whenever a child at work asks for their mummy, the idea of an orphaned child being all alone in the world hurts me)and there are people on this site saying hmm not enough, more war! More bombing!

20,000 thousand children have been murdered in Gaza (and 40 Israeli children), how as a society we let this happen? Or justify it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
OpheliaWasntMad · 03/11/2026 12:48

Squeezingwildoranges · 03/11/2026 12:26

There is a massive difference between Egypt closing the border and Israel. First off, under international law, Egypt is a sovereign neighbour. It does not occupy Gaza. Egypt restricts the border to keep a specific security threat, as you said, out of its own territory. It is not actively controlling the internal electricity, water, food intake, or fuel levels of the people inside Gaza. It also knows that it cannot unilaterally facilitate the flow of aid into a territory without Israels explicit permission. Egypt also further reinforced the border in 2024 because it very quickly became apparent that Israel's intention was to drive the Palestinians out of Gaza into the Sinai. Regardless of the fact they wouldn't want to be complicit in a crime against humanity in the form of ethnic cleansing, no country could handle 2 million desperate refugees being suddenly thrust upon them. On the other hand, Israel is recognised by the UN as the occupying power because it maintains absolute control over Gaza’s airspace, coastline, maritime waters, population registry, and all other land entry points. With that occupation comes a legal obligation under the Geneva Conventions to ensure the welfare of the civilian population. Conflating a sovereign neighbour protecting its borders with an occupying power maintaining a brutal blockade is a complete false equivalency.

But you’re not addressing the fact that Egypt views Hamas as a dangerous security threat and that is the main reason why it has closed its borders . Or perhaps don’t you agree that Egypt views Hamas as a security threat?

Squeezingwildoranges · 03/11/2026 12:51

OpheliaWasntMad · 03/11/2026 12:48

But you’re not addressing the fact that Egypt views Hamas as a dangerous security threat and that is the main reason why it has closed its borders . Or perhaps don’t you agree that Egypt views Hamas as a security threat?

That is exactly what I said. "Egypt restricts the border to keep a specific security threat, as you said, out of its own territory."

OpheliaWasntMad · 03/11/2026 12:56

Squeezingwildoranges · 03/11/2026 12:51

That is exactly what I said. "Egypt restricts the border to keep a specific security threat, as you said, out of its own territory."

Ok - apologies. I’m reading too quickly.

FacetiousFace · 03/11/2026 14:33

1dayatatime · 03/11/2026 11:53

For the purposes of allowing aid into Gaza and allow those seeking medical treatment to obtain it in Egypt.

It's worth noting that Egypt previously closed and now tightly controls the Rafah border crossing because of its long battle against Islamist militant groups in North Sinai which were operating from Gaza.
Cairo worries that a complete opening of the border completely could allow Hamas militants to enter Egypt and commit further terrorist attacks.

Egypt views Hamas as an offshoot of the Musilm Brotherhood, an Islamist movement that the Egyptian government has outlawed and treats as a severe security threat.

So in short Egypt has closed the border or heavily restricted movements from Gaza to stop terrorist attacks and views Hamas as a dangerous security threat. Egypt also tried to prevent Hamas tunnels into Egypt by flooding them with raw sewage.

But I find it very telling that the Islamo leftists in the West conveniently forget Egypts actions in sealing off Gaza and certainly never criticise Egypt for this .But are quick to criticise Israel for doing exactly the same and for the same reasons. Still as they say "no Jews then no news".

This is Gaza right now. This is where the yellow line is. Israel controls the border to Egypt in Gaza. Israel controls the entire border of Gaza. Egypt can't just open their border and allow Palestinians in they would be shot by Israel the second they approached the yellow line. They can't just pass aid over the border to Palestinians, there are no Palestinians anywhere near the border. Israel have sealed off all of the borders. Don't let any of that get in the way of your rant about Islamo leftists though 🙄

How do people justify the mass murder of children?
1dayatatime · 03/11/2026 16:24

FacetiousFace · 03/11/2026 14:33

This is Gaza right now. This is where the yellow line is. Israel controls the border to Egypt in Gaza. Israel controls the entire border of Gaza. Egypt can't just open their border and allow Palestinians in they would be shot by Israel the second they approached the yellow line. They can't just pass aid over the border to Palestinians, there are no Palestinians anywhere near the border. Israel have sealed off all of the borders. Don't let any of that get in the way of your rant about Islamo leftists though 🙄

This is Gaza right now because there is a war going on.

All this emotion based talk about how Gaza has been blockaded by Israel for years in some form of open air prison conveniently ignores that Israel allowed Gazans to commute to Israel for work whilst Egypt enforced a fortified closed border for security reasons to stop Hamas terrorist attacks in Northern Sinai.

Anyway I'm not as worried about the Islamo leftists as I was. There are a series of major elections next year in Europe that are set to bring in right wing Governments. Then the Islamo leftists will have a lot more to worry about than Gaza.

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2026 16:40

cavewoman2026 · 01/11/2026 18:00

Have you seen the guardian film where they’ve interviewed Israelis on the streets who say all Arabs should be killed?

That doesn’t mean all Israelis think that way!

FacetiousFace · 03/11/2026 16:49

1dayatatime · 03/11/2026 16:24

This is Gaza right now because there is a war going on.

All this emotion based talk about how Gaza has been blockaded by Israel for years in some form of open air prison conveniently ignores that Israel allowed Gazans to commute to Israel for work whilst Egypt enforced a fortified closed border for security reasons to stop Hamas terrorist attacks in Northern Sinai.

Anyway I'm not as worried about the Islamo leftists as I was. There are a series of major elections next year in Europe that are set to bring in right wing Governments. Then the Islamo leftists will have a lot more to worry about than Gaza.

So you acknowledge that the lack of aid now is all on Israel and that there is nothing anyone else can do?

That sounds rather ominous, what will they have to worry about? Surely right wingers think that things will be a lot better with a right wing government so why would anyone have to worry?

Squeezingwildoranges · 03/11/2026 18:01

1dayatatime · 03/11/2026 16:24

This is Gaza right now because there is a war going on.

All this emotion based talk about how Gaza has been blockaded by Israel for years in some form of open air prison conveniently ignores that Israel allowed Gazans to commute to Israel for work whilst Egypt enforced a fortified closed border for security reasons to stop Hamas terrorist attacks in Northern Sinai.

Anyway I'm not as worried about the Islamo leftists as I was. There are a series of major elections next year in Europe that are set to bring in right wing Governments. Then the Islamo leftists will have a lot more to worry about than Gaza.

Less than twenty thousand Gazans could acquire work permits in Israel where they were only allowed to do the most restricted jobs which were exclusively unskilled manual labor in sectors like construction and agriculture. So magnanimous. The only route to the outside world was through Egypt, a foreign country. Yes, there were security restrictions, but nothing like the blatantly brutal blockade Israel, the internationally recognised occupiers, imposed on them.

OpheliaWasntMad · 03/11/2026 19:25

Squeezingwildoranges · 03/11/2026 18:01

Less than twenty thousand Gazans could acquire work permits in Israel where they were only allowed to do the most restricted jobs which were exclusively unskilled manual labor in sectors like construction and agriculture. So magnanimous. The only route to the outside world was through Egypt, a foreign country. Yes, there were security restrictions, but nothing like the blatantly brutal blockade Israel, the internationally recognised occupiers, imposed on them.

I can understand why innocent Palestinians feel aggrieved but I can also understand how Israelis would be very careful about who they give access to and what areas of work …. Given the terrorist threats Israel faces that seems understandable.

Gealach · 03/11/2026 20:16

I feel it’s refreshing that even the most hardline supporters of Israeli policies in Gaza are admitting that there is no ceasefire.

OpheliaWasntMad · 03/11/2026 20:44

Gealach · 03/11/2026 20:16

I feel it’s refreshing that even the most hardline supporters of Israeli policies in Gaza are admitting that there is no ceasefire.

Well I’m sure you know the reasons why this stage of the ceasefire has stalled @Gealach .

“However, getting Israel and Hamas to agree and cooperate on next steps could prove difficult, particularly when it comes to transitioning control of Gaza away from Hamas. Netanyahu has repeatedly said that the next phase should not focus on rebuildingthe enclave, but disarming Hamas and the demilitarization of the Gaza Strip. Meanwhile, Hamas has reaffirmed its “commitment to all the terms of the agreement,” the scope of which included the group’s disarmament, according to the White House. However, as the ceasefire shifted into its second phase in January, Hamas contradicted Washington and said it never agreed to that provision. Several outlets, including the BBC, AFP, and Al-Monitor, also reported recently that Hamas is working to reassert control in areas where its members are present. ”

https://www.cfr.org/articles/guide-trumps-twenty-point-gaza-peace-deal

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c98g1klxnpxo

Three Hamas militants wearing face masks and carrying automatic weapons stand guard on a destroyed street in downtown Gaza.

Hamas is reasserting control in Gaza despite its heavy losses fighting Israel

Gazans say Hamas is again extending its control over security, tax revenue and government services.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c98g1klxnpxo

Gealach · 04/11/2026 07:01

Yes I do @OpheliaWasntMad but the official line is that although the ceasefire is stalled it is holding.

OpheliaWasntMad · 04/11/2026 08:09

Gealach · 04/11/2026 07:01

Yes I do @OpheliaWasntMad but the official line is that although the ceasefire is stalled it is holding.

But Hamas is refusing to disarm - which was supposed to happen in the second stage of the ceasefire. They are actually working to increase control .

“Meanwhile, Hamas has reaffirmed its “commitment to all the terms of the agreement,” the scope of which included the group’s disarmament, according to the White House. However, as the ceasefire shifted into its second phase in January, Hamas contradicted Washington and said it never agreed to that provision.”

So it looks to me as if Hamas is breaking the terms of the ceasefire?

Squeezingwildoranges · 04/11/2026 11:38

OpheliaWasntMad · 03/11/2026 19:25

I can understand why innocent Palestinians feel aggrieved but I can also understand how Israelis would be very careful about who they give access to and what areas of work …. Given the terrorist threats Israel faces that seems understandable.

The problem is that the reasons innocent Palestinians feel aggrieved are inextricably linked to why those security threats exist. If a population is subjected to decades of dispossession, blockade, and military control, a desperate environment is created. While the vast majority simply try to survive, it inevitably breeds extremism and political violence because people feel they have no peaceful avenue left to change their reality. So I will say it again. Do you really think that such a policy will lead to a sustainable or desirable outcome for anyone?

Squeezingwildoranges · 04/11/2026 11:52

OpheliaWasntMad · 04/11/2026 08:09

But Hamas is refusing to disarm - which was supposed to happen in the second stage of the ceasefire. They are actually working to increase control .

“Meanwhile, Hamas has reaffirmed its “commitment to all the terms of the agreement,” the scope of which included the group’s disarmament, according to the White House. However, as the ceasefire shifted into its second phase in January, Hamas contradicted Washington and said it never agreed to that provision.”

So it looks to me as if Hamas is breaking the terms of the ceasefire?

Saying the collective punishment of Gaza is a necessary reaction to Hamas not disarming is a ruse. I'm not saying you are being disingenuous but the Israeli government is. The ultimate objective has always been ethnic cleansing by encouraging 'voluntary' emigration. By deliberately making Gaza unlivable, Israel ensures that Palestinians will have no choice but to flee, achieving the permanent removal of the population under the guise of a security operation.

Gealach · 04/11/2026 12:00

OpheliaWasntMad · 04/11/2026 08:09

But Hamas is refusing to disarm - which was supposed to happen in the second stage of the ceasefire. They are actually working to increase control .

“Meanwhile, Hamas has reaffirmed its “commitment to all the terms of the agreement,” the scope of which included the group’s disarmament, according to the White House. However, as the ceasefire shifted into its second phase in January, Hamas contradicted Washington and said it never agreed to that provision.”

So it looks to me as if Hamas is breaking the terms of the ceasefire?

This is old news. A new road map was released in July. But it’s still stalled.

But my point still stands. The offical line is that the ceasefire is holding but stalled.

I don’t think Hamas are right or just and I’m not sure why you are suggesting that. I just think the humanitarian crisis can be addressed regardless.

Gealach · 04/11/2026 12:14

@OpheliaWasntMad your viewpoint is very odd to me. Do you think that making 2 million people suffer is the only answer? At the time that article the second roadmap was developed Israel controlled 53% of Gaza. Now they control 65% of the strip. They have continued to flatten buildings within this area. I think it is perfectly obvious that they want to push the Palestinians out. And I think they will succeed.

The Palestinians are truly screwed but I don’t think that it will least to lasting peace and security for Israel either. Particularly because its global standing has been so damaged.

It’s all very depressing.

PurpleThistle7 · 04/11/2026 12:32

Squeezingwildoranges · 04/11/2026 11:52

Saying the collective punishment of Gaza is a necessary reaction to Hamas not disarming is a ruse. I'm not saying you are being disingenuous but the Israeli government is. The ultimate objective has always been ethnic cleansing by encouraging 'voluntary' emigration. By deliberately making Gaza unlivable, Israel ensures that Palestinians will have no choice but to flee, achieving the permanent removal of the population under the guise of a security operation.

So basically what happened in the 52 Arab countries to their Jewish populations? And obviously many more through the years. My family was kicked out of Russia in the 1880s, friends of mine were kicked out of Poland or Germany or Iran or Afghanistan. It’s very much part of our story.

Of course this isn’t inherently right, but it’s the culmination of endless not right on both sides. And other countries and organisations weighing in too just to complicate everything.

The concept of owning land forevermore is a bit complicated. Almost all Jewish families were refugees at some point, plenty of others have been forced into this too for all sorts of political or violent reasons.

Were the millions of Ukrainian families (5.6 million people apparently) who fled ethnically cleansed? Should they have stayed? Or were they brave to leave and make a new life?

i have no idea what the solution is and can only hope more clever people do.

Squeezingwildoranges · 04/11/2026 12:41

PurpleThistle7 · 04/11/2026 12:32

So basically what happened in the 52 Arab countries to their Jewish populations? And obviously many more through the years. My family was kicked out of Russia in the 1880s, friends of mine were kicked out of Poland or Germany or Iran or Afghanistan. It’s very much part of our story.

Of course this isn’t inherently right, but it’s the culmination of endless not right on both sides. And other countries and organisations weighing in too just to complicate everything.

The concept of owning land forevermore is a bit complicated. Almost all Jewish families were refugees at some point, plenty of others have been forced into this too for all sorts of political or violent reasons.

Were the millions of Ukrainian families (5.6 million people apparently) who fled ethnically cleansed? Should they have stayed? Or were they brave to leave and make a new life?

i have no idea what the solution is and can only hope more clever people do.

Surely you're not trying to say that what happened to the Jews on a disgusting global scale justifies what is happening to the Palestinians?

OpheliaWasntMad · 04/11/2026 12:47

PurpleThistle7 · 04/11/2026 12:32

So basically what happened in the 52 Arab countries to their Jewish populations? And obviously many more through the years. My family was kicked out of Russia in the 1880s, friends of mine were kicked out of Poland or Germany or Iran or Afghanistan. It’s very much part of our story.

Of course this isn’t inherently right, but it’s the culmination of endless not right on both sides. And other countries and organisations weighing in too just to complicate everything.

The concept of owning land forevermore is a bit complicated. Almost all Jewish families were refugees at some point, plenty of others have been forced into this too for all sorts of political or violent reasons.

Were the millions of Ukrainian families (5.6 million people apparently) who fled ethnically cleansed? Should they have stayed? Or were they brave to leave and make a new life?

i have no idea what the solution is and can only hope more clever people do.

I think you’re right @PurpleThistle7
It’s all more complicated than a binary mumsnet thread can possibly deal with.
As you say “it’s the culmination of endless not right on both sides”
I have no idea what the solution is either. I do know the solution doesn’t lie in demonising the innocent Israelis and innocent Palestinians who just want security and hope for their children.
And the solution doesn’t lie in fanning the flames of global antisemitism. That is just going to make moderate Israelis become more hardline.

OpheliaWasntMad · 04/11/2026 12:50

Squeezingwildoranges · 04/11/2026 12:41

Surely you're not trying to say that what happened to the Jews on a disgusting global scale justifies what is happening to the Palestinians?

I think she was saying something much more nuanced and thoughtful than that. The problem is that these threads ( like X) encourage people to become increasingly extreme as nuanced positions aren’t tolerated. They are pounced on and distorted .

OpheliaWasntMad · 04/11/2026 12:53

Gealach · 04/11/2026 12:14

@OpheliaWasntMad your viewpoint is very odd to me. Do you think that making 2 million people suffer is the only answer? At the time that article the second roadmap was developed Israel controlled 53% of Gaza. Now they control 65% of the strip. They have continued to flatten buildings within this area. I think it is perfectly obvious that they want to push the Palestinians out. And I think they will succeed.

The Palestinians are truly screwed but I don’t think that it will least to lasting peace and security for Israel either. Particularly because its global standing has been so damaged.

It’s all very depressing.

My only point was that the ceasefire has stalled because Hamas won’t disarm.
Where on earth did I say that making 2 million people suffer was the only answer to that?

But I do see the need for Hamas to disarm because I think they are largely responsible for the suffering you refer to.

Squeezingwildoranges · 04/11/2026 13:02

OpheliaWasntMad · 04/11/2026 12:50

I think she was saying something much more nuanced and thoughtful than that. The problem is that these threads ( like X) encourage people to become increasingly extreme as nuanced positions aren’t tolerated. They are pounced on and distorted .

I’m genuinely not trying to distort anything, which is exactly why I asked a direct question. The problem with bringing up historical atrocities committed against Jewish people in a thread about the current displacement of Palestinians is that it naturally raises the question of whether one is being used to justify the other. If that wasn't the intention, I'm happy to be corrected, but it's entirely fair to ask what the relevance of that comparison is meant to be.

PurpleThistle7 · 04/11/2026 13:49

Squeezingwildoranges · 04/11/2026 13:02

I’m genuinely not trying to distort anything, which is exactly why I asked a direct question. The problem with bringing up historical atrocities committed against Jewish people in a thread about the current displacement of Palestinians is that it naturally raises the question of whether one is being used to justify the other. If that wasn't the intention, I'm happy to be corrected, but it's entirely fair to ask what the relevance of that comparison is meant to be.

Actually I was just using my own experience in my family history about being a refugee and thinking about how there are lots of lived experience of refugees in recent and further away history and how the Palestinian refugee situation is the current link in that chain and not that different from the many, many other experiences of people all over the world. The intensity of 'that's my land' is one of the many things that I wonder about in this - on both sides! If someone just said 'nah, what else can the world offer me?' and found something better than this endless arguing and endless violence what could that look like?

There are 0 Jews longing for a return to Russia even though several million of us ran from there in several rounds of mass immigration. There were around 5 million Russian Jews before the 1880s and there are around 80,000 left today. Millions left in the 1880s, another couple million in WW2 and then as many as could went to Israel after 1948. So if where everyone physically is right now is creating more death than life and more pain than joy... what other options can we (collective we - like the whole world) come up with? Surely it can't be right to just spend the next 200 years fighting over a scrap of land until the aliens invade or the sun explodes.

Sometimes I wonder what would have happened if the Jews had taken up the vague offer of Madagascar that was made at some point. I wonder if we would have been left alone or if the terrorists would have just gotten on a boat and come to find us anyway. These are the musings that keep me up at night!

Squeezingwildoranges · 04/11/2026 15:05

PurpleThistle7 · 04/11/2026 13:49

Actually I was just using my own experience in my family history about being a refugee and thinking about how there are lots of lived experience of refugees in recent and further away history and how the Palestinian refugee situation is the current link in that chain and not that different from the many, many other experiences of people all over the world. The intensity of 'that's my land' is one of the many things that I wonder about in this - on both sides! If someone just said 'nah, what else can the world offer me?' and found something better than this endless arguing and endless violence what could that look like?

There are 0 Jews longing for a return to Russia even though several million of us ran from there in several rounds of mass immigration. There were around 5 million Russian Jews before the 1880s and there are around 80,000 left today. Millions left in the 1880s, another couple million in WW2 and then as many as could went to Israel after 1948. So if where everyone physically is right now is creating more death than life and more pain than joy... what other options can we (collective we - like the whole world) come up with? Surely it can't be right to just spend the next 200 years fighting over a scrap of land until the aliens invade or the sun explodes.

Sometimes I wonder what would have happened if the Jews had taken up the vague offer of Madagascar that was made at some point. I wonder if we would have been left alone or if the terrorists would have just gotten on a boat and come to find us anyway. These are the musings that keep me up at night!

Thank you for clarifying, but the comparison with Russian Jews doesn't hold up because there is a fundamental difference between fleeing historical pogroms and the active, engineered displacement happening right now. Suggesting they should just 'find something better' elsewhere shifts the blame onto the victims by implying they are being unreasonable and completely bypasses the issue of international law. Ethnic cleansing is a recognised crime against humanity and cannot be considered as a reasonable lifestyle choice just because it has happened to others in the past.

Swipe left for the next trending thread